Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To never move from my starter home?

59 replies

namechange59482 · 18/01/2024 11:56

We bought our house 6 years ago as a starter home. It's a 3 bedroom terrace with a garden. The third bedroom is a box room so is tiny. Since we have moved in we have had two DC a girl and boy.
It's in a good location for us very close to schools and reasonable distance to both our parents.
With it being an old house there have been a few issues and we have had to spend more than we wanted. We have now discovered another issue which is going to cost us.
I have looked at the market if we ever move we atleast would want 3 reasonable sized rooms and to stay within the area. The issue is whilst we could possibly afford the mortgage of a bigger house it would be our absolute maximum. At the moment we have managed to spend on this house because we have the equity to occasionally borrow abit and also have been able to save. We will definitely need to borrow for this latest issue.
I feel it has come to the point now we either move or spend. I do feel really we have no choice but to stay here. If we choose to sell the buyer would probably try to knock a lot off the price. I'm also concerned if we did move there is no guarantee the new house wouldn't have its own new set of issues.
The thought of how much we have may now spent on this house to move in a few years also seems ridiculous.
Would stay put in these circumstances?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Newestname002 · 19/01/2024 13:27

@namechange59482

My apologies if this has already been answered but do you have the headspace to extend into the loft? If so you'd gain quite a bit more space (extra bedrooms, bathroom/shower rooms, study?).

If that's possibility that might work better for you than effectively starting again elsewhere? 🌹

CartingItAround · 19/01/2024 12:50

When people say teenagers what they actually mean is two adult sized children and their clothing, coats and shoes become adult sized from around 13. As the only female in this house my shoes are a size 5, the men in this house, ie Dh, Ds1 and Ds2 have shoes either sized 10s or size 11s and they have more than one pair each obviously. Your children will need a place to do their homework too so all things considered you have to work out if this house can accommodate that.

We did move when the children were in primary but that was to get into the catchment of a good secondary. We considered the above when moving and chose a house that had space for the children away from us that wasn't their bedrooms.

Even if you never intend to move, keep an eye on the housing market just in case something happens that means you need to move. My friend has a box room for her youngest who is 16, he spends half his life at other people's houses as it is easier to fit 6 man sized children into a bedroom big enough to accommodate them rather than his box room.

idontlikealdi · 19/01/2024 12:34

We are in a similar situation, and decided not to move. The location is perfect for so many reasons and we can't afford to upsize here we would have to move further away from school, DHs job and the train station for when I need to go into London.

We are building a 'garden room' so I can move my office out there and the kids can have a hang out area. they are currently sharing a room as I need an office. They're happy with this for now but I can see that that is going to change soon as they want their privacy. So one of them will have the smaller room which is 10x8.

Jf20 · 19/01/2024 12:30

The issue here is the tiny box room, so someone gets that, and often the youngest gets screwed. For some reason folks think oh the eldest deserves or needs it more, which is silly.

the thing is I’m not sure you can afford to move, that’s the issue. So if you cannot realistically afford it, then stay put.

Tiredalwaystired · 19/01/2024 12:25

Runnerduck34 · 19/01/2024 08:30

I think I would move given that one child has the Box room.
Assuming box room is really small and only big enough for a bed and chest of drawers.
Box rooms aren't really suitable for bedrooms once DC hit school age.
Of course there maybe differ definitions of box rooms!
If you can't afford it it would be different but it does sound like moving is an option so I would look at moving unless you can go up into the loft.

I live in London. Not using the box room as a bedroom is a luxury. Most families I know have children in a box room (if they are lucky enough to even have a box room).

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 19/01/2024 12:04

A friend of mine in a small terrace with a 3rd bedroom like you describe - IIRC only about 8 feet by six, did manage with a son and daughter until they left to go to university - both incidentally to Oxford.
Obviously she’d have loved more space, but it’s a relatively very expensive area so they made it work - I dare say by relentless, regular decluttering.

Crikeyalmighty · 19/01/2024 12:00

@IvorTheEngineDriver a lot of new houses have several bedrooms of that size- and they don't count them as box rooms either !!

IMustDoMoreExercise · 19/01/2024 11:52

BeaRF75 · 18/01/2024 12:02

We never moved from ours - about to hit 35 years here! Paid off the mortgage very early, so money available for holidays, hobbies, investment and early retirement. Never regretted it. When I am on my death bed, I want to remember the interesting things I was able to do, not the fact that I had an extra bedroom/bigger garden/whatever.

I did this too.

I don't see the point of large houses especially with high energy costs.

A lot of people buy large houses because they want to show them off to other people.

Fidgety31 · 19/01/2024 11:44

I hear you saying what you would like but not what is best for the child who gets the box room . Once you are a parent you can’t just go for what you want - there’s always other people to now consider .
if you can’t find a way to make the box room bigger then I would move. Or put yourself in there and let the kid have the bigger room as that’s where they spend all their time .

MRSMTO · 19/01/2024 11:18

Paid £80k for our large 3 bed semi 20 years ago. Our first house. I was 21. Mortgage paid off 3 years ago. It's done how we like it, we like the area, the three bedrooms are big. Would even dream of moving!

IvorTheEngineDriver · 19/01/2024 11:17

Nothing wrong with a box room as a teen bedroom. I was perfectly happy in mine (8' x 10' = 2.4m x 3m) until I finally left home in my early 20s. I'd stay wehere you are if it were me OP.

ActDottie · 19/01/2024 11:13

RuthW · 18/01/2024 12:00

If you like it, stay. A three bed is not a starter home.

This

3 beds is definitely not a starter home

2chocolateoranges · 19/01/2024 11:13

We are still in our first home, it wasn’t the plan but the housing market is ridiculous now, I honestly don’t know how young couples are affording these house prices.

its a 2 bed roomed house which we have partitioned the bigger bedroom which means we have 3 small bedrooms, with one being only big enough for a bed and wardrobe but it works. Kids are both in early 20s and for us it would be too much hassle to move now so we are staying put and upgrading.

once one of the children move out we will be bringing the partition wall down to give us back a bigger bedroom . We like our neighbours, street is quiet and it’s handy for commenting, also means we have extra money for luxuries eg eating out , going on holiday, new cars and we don’t need to worry about paying bills.

also means less to clean!

FrangipaniBlue · 19/01/2024 11:06

We still live in our end terrace "starter home".

It was a 2up/2down and we bought very young (18&19) with the intention of upsizing when we were ready to start a family.

House prices pretty much immediately skyrocketed and although we had a lot of equity, a bigger house was still out of our affordability for a long time because house prices had doubled but our earnings hadn't!

We released some equity and built an extension to mean we now have 3 double bedrooms and a box office.

By the time we were in a position to afford bigger we just thought sod it, there's hardly anything left on our mortgage, our house is big enough for us so why restart another 25+ year mortgage when we can use our spare cash to enjoy our lives and be mortgage free from our 40s!

YogaIsMyCalm · 19/01/2024 11:04

BeaRF75 · 18/01/2024 12:02

We never moved from ours - about to hit 35 years here! Paid off the mortgage very early, so money available for holidays, hobbies, investment and early retirement. Never regretted it. When I am on my death bed, I want to remember the interesting things I was able to do, not the fact that I had an extra bedroom/bigger garden/whatever.

Similar here, albeit only 25 years into our 2 bed starter home and I wouldn't trade a fancier home or additional bedroom for any amount of money. While the additional space would be nice, it's just not worth it, for me anyway.

There's peace of mind not being tied to a huge mortgage and being able to do things in life, as well as meet all the other challenges that life throws at us without having to worry about rising rates. People will view this differently depending on the other demands they have in life though.

I think people want the big forever home these days as their starting position. And I suppose in some cases, depending on where people are based, these days bigger homes might not actually be all that much more expensive compared to flats/smaller houses plus moving expenses. Different times, different expectations too.

Londontown12 · 19/01/2024 10:52

Still in our “starter home “
we bought it 1998
was 2 beds now it’s 3 with bathroom extension conservatory!
Had 2 children both have flown the nest ! And it’s our home ! Mortgage paid off a while ago so more surplus cash makes life more enjoyable ! No worries about money !
it’s a shame more people don’t do it !

LumiB · 19/01/2024 10:45

The house i ended up buying is a 3 bed with garden, pure luck it came on the market when it did as I was really only looking at 2beds I got it because it was only slightly more as in £30k more but being its in London and I'm on my own i figured its a house I could grow into if need be, near schools etc. Or it would be my forever home cos I definitely can't afford to move on just my income alone unless I'm downsizing or moving out of London.

Been over 10yrs now and I still consider it my forever home, id love to have a detached house but can't afford one unless I move way far out but I have great commute times where I am now.

I figure the money I'd have to spend on stamp duty etc I can use to sound proof my house instead. In fact its far cheaper to just adapt my house e.g. sound proofing, extension if need be than to move

WagWoofWalkMeeoow · 19/01/2024 10:27

cadburyegg · 18/01/2024 12:47

Your house sounds lovely. The only issue I would have is that a box room may not be big enough for a teenager. Whether or not it is worth moving for that is up to you.

@cadburyegg it may not be desirable for a teenager, but it IS big enough, they just have to declutter (or have storage elsewhere). My Aunty's house is 2 large doubles & one box room. Due to the layout walls couldn't be moves to spread the space over 3 rooms. My 2 male cousins grew up there & I had the box room (as a young adult) for a couple of years. Perfectly doable.

Summerhillsquare · 19/01/2024 10:25

I wish I had kept my 'starter home'! 2 beds, nice garden, lovely neighbours, all I need really.

StrawberryShortbread2001 · 19/01/2024 10:23

Yes, I'd stay. Can one of your DC have the boxroom as their bedroom? If not you can do what many of us do and give the Dc the bedrooms and sleep downstairs. I only have 2 bedrooms and can't afford to move so I have done that.

WagWoofWalkMeeoow · 19/01/2024 10:19

LightSwerve · 18/01/2024 12:15

If you like your house, the are is good, have good neighbours and have got it how you want it, it seems obvious to stay put. You can change your mind later.

Keep saving and then youhave options later.

@LightSwerve

Not really, no.

shes said this work needs doing now & they'd need to borrow to do it.

so they're looking at either borrowing to do the work or move.

@namechange59482

what is the work that needs doing??

millymae · 19/01/2024 10:05

We have followed my parents who bought their first house in the 70’s and are still living there.
We too have no intention of moving from our first time buyers house as it means that we can now afford to live comfortably in an area that is relatively central with good primary and secondary schools, buy whatever we want within reason, and even save a bit. Coupled with our disinterest in moving up the property ladder is our disinterest in huge fancy cars so outgoings on the cars we run - bought with economy in mind is minimal.
There’s someone on instagram Aliceinscandiland who has done amazing things with her first time buyers house in Cornwall. What she’s done is not for the faint hearted and has been work in progress for a number of years but the article she wrote about why they decided to stay there rather than move is well worth a read.

Annonymiss123 · 19/01/2024 09:23

BeaRF75 · 18/01/2024 12:02

We never moved from ours - about to hit 35 years here! Paid off the mortgage very early, so money available for holidays, hobbies, investment and early retirement. Never regretted it. When I am on my death bed, I want to remember the interesting things I was able to do, not the fact that I had an extra bedroom/bigger garden/whatever.

Snap! ^^This post, word for word. 😀

Windwaysway · 19/01/2024 09:19

BeaRF75 · 18/01/2024 12:02

We never moved from ours - about to hit 35 years here! Paid off the mortgage very early, so money available for holidays, hobbies, investment and early retirement. Never regretted it. When I am on my death bed, I want to remember the interesting things I was able to do, not the fact that I had an extra bedroom/bigger garden/whatever.

I hope this is me in 15 years!

TallulahBetty · 19/01/2024 09:15

We're still in the 2-bed starter home we bought 18 years ago. One child, it suits us.

3-bed is not really a starter home, seeing as the average family have 2 kids.