Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“The problem with children these days is that they need a bloody good hiding”

255 replies

TheHeadOfTheHouse · 17/01/2024 13:55

Said by a relative in his 70s.

I’m noticing that the older generation (over 60s) seem to think that although they were beaten to a pulp, they still think this is the correct way to bring children up.

We have Autism and ADHD in our wider family. Older relatives don’t seem to be very tolerant of this and keep implying that the cause of this is too soft parenting.

A relative was having a debate with me the other day saying how parenting was much better in his day, police could hit you, teachers used to cane you etc and how there wasn’t the behaviour that we have these days.

He was very defensive when I told him that I’m very glad all that has been abolished.

“Yeah, but we didn’t have teenagers stabbing each other back then”

Hes one of a few people I’ve come across lately who is all for hitting children.

It seems to be were Autism and ADHD children are concerned that it seems to provoke people saying this

OP posts:
Bootair · 17/01/2024 21:25

Westernesse · 17/01/2024 20:28

What you propose is an absolute charter for the abuse of children.

i do not own my children. I’m not an “authority” over my children. Children are citizens, not possessions and as the most vulnerable in society require protection above all other considerations.

those who seek authority over others are people for the watching.

my own children are taught to challenge any person, child or adult, who tries to exert authority over them. Funnily enough they are well behaved and have zero issues in school or any other setting. They also know I have their back.

But in the case of abuse, the problem isn't the fact that the parent has authority, it's that they're abusing their authority. It's like having a manager. The job role itself isn't a problem, only when it lands in the wrong hands. That doesn't mean we should seek to abolish the role of manager entirely.
That's why safeguarding exists - so we can identify the smaller number of cases where parents are abusing their position, rather than just abolishing the parent-child authority dynamic altogether.
People love to say authority and hierarchy is inherently evil, until they actually experience an anarchic setting where no one knows their place.

Not giving your child clear boundaries, consequences and teaching them how to function in their various roles in society is also neglectful, lazy parenting that sets a child up for a lifetime of mental health problems and dysfunction. If a child isn't taught to believe, on a very basic level, that they shouldn't do what their parents say, then why should they do what a teacher or police officer says?

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 17/01/2024 21:22

Ive worked with so many kids - Guides, summer camps in various forms. In 25 years I've met ONE kid who I thought needed a good hiding. I've no doubt she'll get it one day.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 17/01/2024 21:10

Trinity65 · 17/01/2024 14:37

Oh look ANOTHER ageism thread

Makes a change from the benefit bashing ones I suppose

Ageism is very insulting.
The OP knows her relative thinks the way he does, but it doesn't mean over 60s in general do.

StarDolphins · 17/01/2024 21:04

I’m against smacking & wouldn’t smack my child.

However, all the people I know that got a smack if they were naughty as a kid (including myself, twice) are actually the most respectful & happy people I know.

I also don’t think all the super soft parenting really works ime. Too many disrespectful & arrogant young adults around.

muchalover · 17/01/2024 21:04

I would ask who challenged the status quo so that it is no longer tolerated and is now banned in some places? Clearly it would be older people. Many Victorian's were against it so it's not new.

And every single generation complains about the behaviour of young people. It's a tale as old as time.

MoonWoman69 · 17/01/2024 20:57

Exactly this! You've nailed it!

aliceinanwonderland · 17/01/2024 20:56

CatSighs · 17/01/2024 16:25

I have sometimes wondered something similar myself...I have an autistic DD and we have lots of the related challenges such as school refusal, can't eat with the family because of the noise, too anxious to attend after school clubs etc. We are sympathetic and try to accommodate this to an extent, but sometimes it seems to make things worse...

If the explosion in numbers of children with ASD now is due to better awareness and diagnosis, then presumably there must have been similar numbers of children with what would now be called ASD 40ish years ago. Certainly, Mumsnet seems to be full of middle-aged women who have recently been diagnosed with ASD/ADHD. However, I don't remember kids being on reduced timetables, or children suffering from anxiety, depression, self-harm, gender identity issues (all of which are particularly common in children with ASD). It's not that I don't think many children in the 1980s were neurodivergent (there were lots of kids who were unkindly thought of as weird or odd), but they generally seemed to be able to cope with life in a way that many children (my own DD included) can't now, and I wonder why that is. Could it be something to do with how we raise children now? Is it screentime? Discipline? Perhaps it's connected to more households where both parents work outside of the home? Something about the style of teaching nowadays? These suggestions are just idle musings and I'm not intending to offend anybody, but there has been an enormous change in both how many children are diagnosed with ASD etc and how badly it seems to affect them, and I think it's worth considering why this might be.

As I say, I am the parent of a DC with ASD and I just want to do the best for her...but am sometimes unsure what that looks like.

This is a very interesting observation. I've wondered that too. Maybe life was generally calmer (fewer toys/TV only at certain times/had to sit still in church for an hour everySunday/had to visit Grandma's with nothing to do apart from colouring in and reading). This would be an interesting thread in its own right!

mondaytosunday · 17/01/2024 20:52

There are abusive parents at any age. I'm in my 60s and my parents (if they were alive) would be in their 90s/100s. They never believed in physical punishment, though I believe my father, who was in boarding school in the 1930/40s, said that caning was not uncommon.
I'd say in the 60s and 70s, when I was a kid, smacking was frowned upon.
But a contemporary to me said her left arm was tied behind her back at school as she was left handed - bet those nuns also used a ruler.

alltootired · 17/01/2024 20:44

And I have seen people post about things that happened they saw as normal when they were a child and I was a young adult. Things that if I had known them I would have contacted social services. Some people are not very introspective and accept what happened in their childhood was normal when it was not.

alltootired · 17/01/2024 20:42

The generation who spanked are now in their eighties and older.
Yes younger parents spanked, but parents still spank. There are always parents who will spank even if the wider world does not approve.

Meowandthen · 17/01/2024 20:41

SOME of an older generation. You could have said that rather than the sweeping generalisation.

I am in my 50s, totally against physical punishment but also fed up with soppy, permissive parenting. Lack of boundaries and some firmness is not doing children any favours. Children need to learn that the world doesn’t revolve around them.
.

anicecuppateaa · 17/01/2024 20:39

My very sweet 85 year old nana asked if I give my 1 year old a ‘good old spanking’ at Christmas. I explained that we prefer gentle parenting and I still remember being smacked as a child. She proceeded to recommend I start smacking my 1 and 3 year olds.

Ihaterhymingrabbit · 17/01/2024 20:35

nokidshere · 17/01/2024 14:06

I’m noticing that the older generation (over 60s) seem to think that although they were beaten to a pulp, they still think this is the correct way to bring children up.

No you aren't. You are noticing your relative said it, who's over 70?

I'm over 60, as are many of my friends & relatives, and not one of us thinks that. Get a grip and tell your relative thank goodness it's not that way anymore.

Yep my parents are in their 60s and 70s and would strongly disagree with hitting children. They would never hurt my child.

My 90 year old grandmother wouldn’t have either.

Westernesse · 17/01/2024 20:28

Bootair · 17/01/2024 18:30

"Authoritarian" is such a loaded word with so many connotations. But at the most basic level, parents and other adults such as teachers, police officers etc SHOULD be seen as a clear authority over children, and children should be taught to respect authority. There is nothing wrong with authority systems in and of themselves, and society can only function when we're obedient to all the various authorities that preside over us. I'm obedient to signs that say "no entry", or the hospital matron who tells me I'm not allowed in the nurse staff room, or the police officer who tells me I can't carry a knife on me. Authority can be used badly, of course, but that doesn't mean that on a basic level it's a bad thing. It's very, very important for a safe, harmonious and functional society. Not teaching children that disobedience to authority has consequences (and not always natural consequences, but enforced punishments) is doing them a massive disservice and setting them up to be anxious, chaotic failures.

What you propose is an absolute charter for the abuse of children.

i do not own my children. I’m not an “authority” over my children. Children are citizens, not possessions and as the most vulnerable in society require protection above all other considerations.

those who seek authority over others are people for the watching.

my own children are taught to challenge any person, child or adult, who tries to exert authority over them. Funnily enough they are well behaved and have zero issues in school or any other setting. They also know I have their back.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 17/01/2024 20:20

I’m very glad all that has been abolished.

Which happened because the older generations changed it. Change does not come from the young, it comes because older people change, adapt and accept that things move on.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 17/01/2024 20:18

I’m noticing that the older generation (over 60s) seem to think that although they were beaten to a pulp, they still think this is the correct way to bring children up.

Right. So everyone over 60 was beaten by their parents. And shares their opinions on other peoples parenting freely. And has no empathy, ability to understand special needs, or has never advocated for things to be better for the generation that came after them?

FFS. Stupidest comment I have seen in a long time.

BinkyBeaufort · 17/01/2024 20:16

I'm 70, and would never, did never, smack, hit or otherwise physically abuse my children.
But I was caned, slapped and slippered at junior school. And I couldn't honestly say that it did me no harm, because it did.
So lay off with the casual ageism, thoughtless young idiot.

DewHopper · 17/01/2024 19:45

nokidshere · 17/01/2024 14:06

I’m noticing that the older generation (over 60s) seem to think that although they were beaten to a pulp, they still think this is the correct way to bring children up.

No you aren't. You are noticing your relative said it, who's over 70?

I'm over 60, as are many of my friends & relatives, and not one of us thinks that. Get a grip and tell your relative thank goodness it's not that way anymore.

This.

Mumof2NDers · 17/01/2024 19:35

The needing a good hiding thing…
My DM was in a shop with DSis and my autistic(selective mute) niece. Niece was about 5 and had a meltdown. Lying on the floor arms and legs going, screaming. DSis went to pay for her shopping, DM waited with DN. An elderly woman said to my mum “that child needs a good hard smack”. DM looked her dead in the eye and asked did she want a good hard smack!

CurlewKate · 17/01/2024 19:12

I'm 60, by the way. I was smacked once when I pushed my mother beyond endurance, and she was still apologising for it 40 years later. My father never smacked. I didn't smack my children.

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 17/01/2024 19:11

61 here. Never hit a child in my life and I have 4 children and 3 grandchildren
Please don't generalise because someone in your family thinks this.

CurlewKate · 17/01/2024 19:10

Maybe people should preface any post on here with their ages. I know a LOT of young people who smack....oops, sorry. Tap.

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 17/01/2024 18:48

Oh god, this is still here, MN haven't even edited out the first vitriolic sweeping unintelligent first ramblings ....I despair @Mumsnet I really do. I have tried to raise it with you.

Bootair · 17/01/2024 18:30

Mirrorinthebathroom123 · 17/01/2024 14:03

You can have clear and firm boundaries without resorting to physical assault. Permissive parenting isn’t good for kids but neither is authoritarian. Boundaries can be kept calmly and kindly. (Although we are all human and it’s impossible to do this 100% of the time).

Research shows clear and consistent boundaries delivered in a warm and loving environment is the best. Easy to say. Harder to do!

"Authoritarian" is such a loaded word with so many connotations. But at the most basic level, parents and other adults such as teachers, police officers etc SHOULD be seen as a clear authority over children, and children should be taught to respect authority. There is nothing wrong with authority systems in and of themselves, and society can only function when we're obedient to all the various authorities that preside over us. I'm obedient to signs that say "no entry", or the hospital matron who tells me I'm not allowed in the nurse staff room, or the police officer who tells me I can't carry a knife on me. Authority can be used badly, of course, but that doesn't mean that on a basic level it's a bad thing. It's very, very important for a safe, harmonious and functional society. Not teaching children that disobedience to authority has consequences (and not always natural consequences, but enforced punishments) is doing them a massive disservice and setting them up to be anxious, chaotic failures.

CaptainMyCaptain · 17/01/2024 18:22

CurlewKate · 17/01/2024 17:11

@CaptainMyCaptain "I went to a grammar school but my younger sister went to a secondary modern where the bullying was so bad that she truanted for her last year as she was scared to go in. She left at 15 in 1971 (August birthday)."

So glad you were immune from bullying in your grammar ivory tower....

Any misbehaviour and you were immediately expelled. I had no say in it. I just did my 11 plus and that's where I went. I did experience being spat on when walking home by kids from the other school though. I'm not sure what point you are making really.
My point was that there was bad behaviour in school back then but most left at 15 so it was no longer considered school related.