Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“The problem with children these days is that they need a bloody good hiding”

255 replies

TheHeadOfTheHouse · 17/01/2024 13:55

Said by a relative in his 70s.

I’m noticing that the older generation (over 60s) seem to think that although they were beaten to a pulp, they still think this is the correct way to bring children up.

We have Autism and ADHD in our wider family. Older relatives don’t seem to be very tolerant of this and keep implying that the cause of this is too soft parenting.

A relative was having a debate with me the other day saying how parenting was much better in his day, police could hit you, teachers used to cane you etc and how there wasn’t the behaviour that we have these days.

He was very defensive when I told him that I’m very glad all that has been abolished.

“Yeah, but we didn’t have teenagers stabbing each other back then”

Hes one of a few people I’ve come across lately who is all for hitting children.

It seems to be were Autism and ADHD children are concerned that it seems to provoke people saying this

OP posts:
Snugglemonkey · 18/01/2024 09:20

CatSighs · 18/01/2024 01:06

@Snugglemonkey sorry you had such a rough time growing up.

I didn't mean to suggest that no kids in the 1980s had these problems, but that there didn't seem to be so many. I work in a large school where the uniform is a short-sleeved blouse and I see the scars. I can see that there's a much higher % of girls with SH scars now than when I was at school, when it was very rare to see evidence of SH (although I probably wouldn't have been aware of less visible problems like depression, anxiety)

Somebody upthread said that these troubled kids would have been in Borstal etc - yes, I remember Borstal and special schools, but I didn't know anyone who went to one. All my neighbours, my parents' friends, my relatives - their kids went to local mainstream schools, and seemed to get on ok (even the "weird" ones). Now, I would say that about 20- 25% of the families that I know have a child who is EOTAS/EBSA/EHCP/reduced timetable and has severe mental health problems.

It seems that, with all the knowledge we have about ASD etc and the fact that far more children are diagnosed early, should result in better outcomes for these children. But that doesn't appear to be the case. Why isn't early diagnosis and greater awareness leading to better outcomes? Is there something going on that is making things worse for these kids? What can it be?

I think a lot of people who "seemed to get on ok" did not. Hence the mental health crises. Lots of adults carry the wounds of being unsupported.

I do think that self harming is a bit more acceptable now. It is not as necessary to hide it. Noone ever saw cuts on me as I was careful. Even the burns, which were visible and have scarred by hands and arms, were explained as "accidents" while cooking. I pulled out hair and picked my head to bleeding, as it was less visible. Used pins to make tiny marks. All sorts of things to keep it secret. I onewcit was not normal and was terrified I would end up in a mental hospital.

I just do not think you can tell whether people are OK or not. Several girls in my class also struggled with bulimia. Who knows who many also self harmed.

Several younger cousins had early diagnosis of asd and were supported. They are young adults at uni, or in professional careers. They have not had the mental health problems I did. My 20's were a total mess. I am grand now, but I wish that I had received the support they did as it would have saved me so much trauma.

SevenMoon · 18/01/2024 09:19

Testina · 18/01/2024 08:36

Not that OP is coming back to this 🙄 but…

Corporal punishment in schools was abolished by the Education Act (1986).

That doesn’t happen overnight - there’s a few years of legislative process, and before that the social sea change that prompts it.

So the people in their 20s in 1975 are now in their 70s. And that’s generously assuming that change came from the youngest adult generation.

So OP, it wasn’t you that protected children in schools - it’s the age group you’re sweepingly denigrating.

Not all schools, if you were wealthy enough you could still pay a private school to beat your child until 1998.

tralalalalalalalal · 18/01/2024 09:18

Notanotherbloodynamechange1 · 17/01/2024 14:42

I have never and will never hit my DC. But I do agree that for SOME children ruling with fear seems to be the only way. Permissive parenting is rife, lazy bone idle parents who can’t get their own lives in order never mind a child’s. A child only has to turn their nose up at a food one time and “they’ve got sensory issues”. Parents who’s kids can do no wrong.

I 100% agree that all these problems were not around in your relatives day and it does beg the question, why now?

Oh shutup, no parent is saying that after they refuse food once. Why bother with hyperbole in a debate, it makes you look ridiculous

user1492757084 · 18/01/2024 09:04

They are really just expressing their annoyance with some of the behaviours I think, not really wishing to hit the kids.
Children are noisier and naughtier and more rude I notice, though I don't promote hitting I do feel sorry for their parents and wish they'd find successful discipline measures.

I read yesterday that some things, it has been found, do adversely affect many people with ADHD or make their - symptoms worse.

  • screen time and blue light
  • high carb intake
  • caffeine
  • going to bed late
  • phones and addictive games - they steal dopamine
  • getting into arguments or fights because they can get a dopamine hit (start a cycle) and also ruminate on fight.
  • being sedentary - where as exercise is positive
  • taking other suffers medication could have bad effect
  • alcohoism

Modern life does involve interacting with these things more so perhaps that is why more ADHA is being noticed and getting worse.
It would be worthwhile limiting these triggers when managing
ADHD so says Dr Daniel Amen. Old people might not notice the behaviour of ADHD kids so much nor think smacking is the answer.

Whatafustercluck · 18/01/2024 08:47

Bootair · 18/01/2024 08:37

Why on earth would I be suggesting that there is no place for positive guidance and teaching, as well as disciplining bad behaviour?
I'm not saying that you shouldn't teach your children positively why they SHOULD do certain things or have certain attitudes. That's just obvious. I'm just saying that we need to maintain the basic principle of submitting to authorities, whilst also learning about the rare instances in which we should make exceptions for the sake of morality and safety. We needn't throw the baby out with the bathwater.

We teach our children to follow the rules and if they don't believe they're right, work with others to get them changed. That's the fundamental principle of democracy. There have most definitely been occasions where teachers have been wrong at ds's school. We've taught him to politely and respectfully put across his point of view, but accept the outcome may not be the one he wants. Because that is a life skill. If nobody ever challenges authority, nothing will ever change for the better. Look at the Post Office situation for proof of that.

Bbq1 · 18/01/2024 08:43

ChihuahuasREvil · 17/01/2024 16:13

I agree that behaviour amongst kids and teens is pretty poor nowadays, and that parenting seems to be way too permissive, but more violence is hardly the answer. My dad intimidated and assaulted me when I was a kid and it hasn’t made me a better person, it just taught me that aggression and violence is the fallback response. It took me a long time into adulthood and shamefully a little bit into parenthood to unlearn that response.

You're generalising about teens. My son is a teenager and he and all of his friends don't have poor behaviour. Quite the opposite. They ate all at college, work pt too, are very driven and committed to their futures and when they do go out less drink, nobody smokes and thankfully, violence isn't involved. Most teens are quietly getting on with life. It's the minority stabbing people and running wild that we hear about.

Whatafustercluck · 18/01/2024 08:43

NonPlayerCharacter · 18/01/2024 08:36

Erm, actually the default position SHOULD be to do what a teacher or police officer says.

Yes, but it's worth remembering that one reason why our police aren't armed except in particular circumstances is because we are supposed to be "policed by consent".

I do think though that Peelian principle is increasingly redundant in the modern world. I don't support the routine arming of our police officers, but society is now a long way from the days of Robert Peel, for better and for worse.

GintyMcGinty · 18/01/2024 08:43

TheHeadOfTheHouse · 18/01/2024 08:01

Many thanks for all your replies.

i really don’t know anyone that wasn’t smacked who are now in the older generation.

when I was smacked as a child, and I’ve questioned it as an adult, I’ve simply been told everyone did it, it’s what was the norm back then.

seems SpongeBob is alittle over invested in this thread as I’ve woken up to a message accusing me of being a troll 🙄🤔

Have you reflected at all on the feedback regarding your horrible ageism?

Bootair · 18/01/2024 08:37

Feralgremlin · 18/01/2024 07:06

Because you can teach your child to do the right thing because it is morally/ethically/socially the right thing to do, rather than because someone with authority has told them to do it. For example, DS helped to calm down an upset child at school, not because someone told him to, but because he knew it was the right thing to do and would like someone to treat him like that in similar circumstances. He helps at home because he knows it lightens the load for those he loves, and that as a family, we are a team, not because I’ve told him he has to. I have a strong belief that certain types of people are drawn to certain jobs because they like the idea of having authority and power over others (look at the current issues in the Met Police for example) and these are the people we absolutely shouldn’t be following.

I live on the flip side of this PP where I was brought up to obey all authority and it has cost me no end of problems, even to the point that I was too anxious to ask for a second opinion from a different doctor as I viewed the first one as having authority and being right.

Why on earth would I be suggesting that there is no place for positive guidance and teaching, as well as disciplining bad behaviour?
I'm not saying that you shouldn't teach your children positively why they SHOULD do certain things or have certain attitudes. That's just obvious. I'm just saying that we need to maintain the basic principle of submitting to authorities, whilst also learning about the rare instances in which we should make exceptions for the sake of morality and safety. We needn't throw the baby out with the bathwater.

NonPlayerCharacter · 18/01/2024 08:36

Erm, actually the default position SHOULD be to do what a teacher or police officer says.

Yes, but it's worth remembering that one reason why our police aren't armed except in particular circumstances is because we are supposed to be "policed by consent".

Testina · 18/01/2024 08:36

Not that OP is coming back to this 🙄 but…

Corporal punishment in schools was abolished by the Education Act (1986).

That doesn’t happen overnight - there’s a few years of legislative process, and before that the social sea change that prompts it.

So the people in their 20s in 1975 are now in their 70s. And that’s generously assuming that change came from the youngest adult generation.

So OP, it wasn’t you that protected children in schools - it’s the age group you’re sweepingly denigrating.

Bootair · 18/01/2024 08:33

Nestofwalnuts · 18/01/2024 07:15

They shouldn't slavishly do what a teacher or police officer says just because they are in authority. They should only do what someone else says if it is fundamentally good advice. Our job as parents is to teach critical thinking and confidence in their own judgement.

Erm, actually the default position SHOULD be to do what a teacher or police officer says. And it's the loss of this basic expectation that has led to the total change of the dynamic in thr classroom. You can both teach a child when to make exceptions for the sake of morality and safety, and to generally respect service providers who have authority.

Zanatdy · 18/01/2024 08:31

Ignore. I’ve got 2 really well behaved respectful teens and I’ve never laid a finger on them. What they mean is some parents are too soft and let their kids rule the roost and walk all over them. I see it on here and other social media all the time.

WandaWonder · 18/01/2024 08:30

I have never believed in hitting, never hit my child but yes I totally think we have gone too far the other way from

the 'olden days'

Bootair · 18/01/2024 08:30

(obviously not condoning the things you mentioned, which are heinous will invariably mess poor children up in many ways, but if you're talking about knife crime, it's those 2 factors that are the key determinants)

Bootair · 18/01/2024 08:28

happinessischocolate · 17/01/2024 23:01

Violence and stabbings are rarely done by children of parents who brought them up with tolerance and rewards charts.

It's the kids that were smacked, or beaten and locked in cupboards by their parents who then use violence against others.

My step mum said she got smacked as a child and it never harmed her, I replied well it did because it's made you think violence against children is ok.

Actually, the key factors as to whether a child grows up to get involved in knife crime are 1) absent fathers 2) lack of external motivation and incentive to achieve

Callisto72 · 18/01/2024 08:27

Oh for FFS - I'm over 60 and was never beaten to a pulp, nor do I think it's acceptable to hit children. I don't even carry a whip when I'm horse riding.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 18/01/2024 08:25

I’m 75, my late brother and sister born 1936 and 1938 respectively and I can’t recall a time when we were hit or really shouted at. Mum would raise her voice to us but not scream in our faces. My dads raised eyebrows were the scariest thing about him. He’d hear mums raised voice and give us the ‘look’. Nothing ever followed the look, it was an unspoken ‘enough’

SweetChilliChickenWrap · 18/01/2024 08:23

Both my parents came from the silent generation. Both hit me on a regular basis for the slightest misdemeanours, occasionally getting the belt out to give me a good thrashing. My mum totally lost control once and ended up sobbing afterwards, saying sorry over and over. My dad liked having power over me, he was a bully and I was terrified of him.

My mum's dad was a violent bully, my dad's dad wasn't.

I don't think just because my parents were like this that all silent generation people were. Although I do believe it was a lot more prevalent than in any generation since.

Whatafustercluck · 18/01/2024 08:10

My parents and plenty of their friends are 70+ and they've never supported corporal punishment. I was smacked on my bum on two occasions (I was a good kid) by my mum who has regretted it ever since and believes it was a loss of control on her part, rather than an effective consequence for fairly standard child behaviour. My dad has said he believes there was one teacher at his school (Boys school) in particular who likely got a kick out of using the cane on little boys' bottoms.

But. I do think that generation struggles to understand conditions like asd and adhd. Remember that it's only comparatively recently that adhd became known about and for a long time (even now?) people blamed poor parenting and refused to accept that it was a valid neurological condition. Kids back then were 'naughty' and they didn't have the benefit of behavioural psychologists to explain that behaviour is communication and bad behaviour is an indication that something is causing it (whether that's conditions like adhd or life situations).

I had a conversation with my parents recently about this (nephews both have asd and adhd, and dd is undergoing assessment). They're both pretty intelligent people, but both said that it's strange all this wasn't around back in their day. I pointed out that it was, it just wasn't recognised. The kids who struggled were the ones standing in the corner with a 'dunce' label. The kids who struggled likely became the adults who dropped out of society.

AyeRightYeAre · 18/01/2024 08:08

GoingDownLikeBHS · 17/01/2024 14:55

I'm 60+ and I definitely think this is a people in their 70s issue. I have friends over 70 and there seems to be some sort of vague "cut off" age around then when a significant number have very little idea about social norms or schools of thought now; like their opinions were formed in the 1960s and by jingo they're not due for an update any time soon. Or at all.

Obviously, before anyone leaps in, not all over 70 are like this but as a 60 something, I really notice it. I'm just hoping when I get to 70 I am in a like-minded cohort and "we" are more aware, I don't want to be sat in the elderly day centre having tea and cake with people talking about "kids nowadays" (or kids needing to be ruled with fear WTAF?!)

Just as ageist as the OP

NonPlayerCharacter · 18/01/2024 08:06

MoonWoman69 · 18/01/2024 07:35

I don't believe I actually stated that anywhere in my post? I was simply relaying my own experience. But you go on, just assume what my views are! 🙄

"I was smacked as a child, I'm 54 now, but I wasn't "beaten to a pulp" or "battered"! Those are just ridiculous glib statements from people who think a " tap" is bordering on being beaten to a pulp! And it taught me right from wrong. My mum would only smack me if I had done something seriously bad and considering I was quite well behaved usually, that wasn't very often at all. But it was deserved when it happened."

It's known now, of course, that stunted thinking is one of the outcomes of smacking (it's got a hand, ha ha, in literally every bad outcome there is), but the cognitive dissonance still never fails to amaze me. All this text about why hitting children is fine, and the poster still truly thinks she didn't say it.

You can't reason with this. You can only expose it for the benefit of everyone who is still capable of seeing it.

AyeRightYeAre · 18/01/2024 08:03

I’m noticing that the older generation (over 60s) seem to think that although they were beaten to a pulp, they still think this is the correct way to bring children up

We have Autism and ADHD in our wider family. Older relatives don’t seem to be very tolerant of this and keep implying that the cause of this is too soft parenting

I am sorry you have unpleasant relatives.

However that doesn't excuse your nasty ageism.

Sad to see that yet again @MNHQ tolerate these kind of prejudiced and bigoted threads.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 18/01/2024 08:03

MoonWoman69 · 18/01/2024 07:35

I don't believe I actually stated that anywhere in my post? I was simply relaying my own experience. But you go on, just assume what my views are! 🙄

My mum would only smack me if I had done something seriously bad and considering I was quite well behaved usually, that wasn't very often at all. But it was deserved when it happened… I totally despair of modern day, wishy washy parenting… My mum and I were very close and I approved of how she raised me. I see nothing wrong with that at all. The PC brigade have put paid to any semblance of decent parenting.

Whilst you don’t out and out state it, it’s apparent to anyone reading your post that you think violence against children is ok. No child deserves to be abused, no matter how bad their behaviour! That’s not me being PC but me being a decent human who believes children should have as many rights as adults to be safe from harm. If you wouldn’t approve of the same tactics to correct the behaviour of a spouse, elderly person, ND person, colleague, employee… then you shouldn’t be using it against children just because they’re smaller and more vulnerable than adults.

itsgettingweird · 18/01/2024 08:02

I don't agree with resorting to physical punishment.

But then I also agree there's too much permissive parenting nowadays.

Somewhere in the middle where "no" means "no" and consequences are seen as fair would work.

But then again I don't agree with the strictness of some schools either who are trying to rein it back. I was with my friend Friday when she got a call to say her ds was spending a whole day in isolation for making a comment when they were told they had another cover teacher for a week after their teacher left at Christmas. This is their 4th teacher since the start of term.

If we could teach children appropriate ways to communicate and also allow them to have a voice things would be better.

You can have consequences and understanding alongside each other and I think this is what we've lost.