Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“The problem with children these days is that they need a bloody good hiding”

255 replies

TheHeadOfTheHouse · 17/01/2024 13:55

Said by a relative in his 70s.

I’m noticing that the older generation (over 60s) seem to think that although they were beaten to a pulp, they still think this is the correct way to bring children up.

We have Autism and ADHD in our wider family. Older relatives don’t seem to be very tolerant of this and keep implying that the cause of this is too soft parenting.

A relative was having a debate with me the other day saying how parenting was much better in his day, police could hit you, teachers used to cane you etc and how there wasn’t the behaviour that we have these days.

He was very defensive when I told him that I’m very glad all that has been abolished.

“Yeah, but we didn’t have teenagers stabbing each other back then”

Hes one of a few people I’ve come across lately who is all for hitting children.

It seems to be were Autism and ADHD children are concerned that it seems to provoke people saying this

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TrixieFatell · 18/01/2024 22:38

I do find it tends to be older people that are in favour of smacking in the circles I move in. That there is a lack of respect amongst the younger lot and it's because you can't give them a good hiding. It was a shame they stopped using the cane at school etc etc. However there are a few parents of my age I know too that use smacking as a punishment but oddly enough only when the child is very young and not able to hit them back. One aunt almost had a fit when she found out I was one of those foolish mothers who asked their younger kids consent before washing them.

Why is it extremes of parenting used in these debates. It seems that unless you are hitting your children, you are a parent that just lets their kids do what they want. You can have discipline that doesn't involves physical punishment and can raise lovely respectful children without striking them.

Notanotherbloodynamechange1 · 18/01/2024 22:28

tralalalalalalalal · 18/01/2024 09:18

Oh shutup, no parent is saying that after they refuse food once. Why bother with hyperbole in a debate, it makes you look ridiculous

Is your name supposed to be trolololololololol?

Artemi · 18/01/2024 20:44

Squiblet · 18/01/2024 18:21

I've never met anyone who was occasionally smacked (most of my generation) who is traumatised by it. @Sapphire387

Oddly enough I was just talking to my therapist this morning about how I was smacked occasionally as a child. She made a connection which I had never made myself - that a direct line could be drawn between that and certain patterns of feeling and behaviour that have dogged me all my adult life, and affected my relationships (badly).

She said that it was in fact trauma - not the severe, shell-shock kind, but trauma just the same, in that the fear and anger from those childhood smackings was still within me, unresolved.

I'd never even realised. But it made so much sense.

Yes, my in-laws are genuinely lovely people who thought they were doing the right thing, but my husband was a grouchy little boy sometimes for no apparent reason and in their own words a light smack would "snap him out of it" and they would then have a nice day out rather than a day of arguments and tantrums

However now as a grown man he covers up his emotions and is unable to express anything negative/sad and it's limited our ability to be emotionally intimate to some degree

SweetFemaleAttitude · 18/01/2024 19:26

I’m noticing that the older generation (over 60s) seem to think that although they were beaten to a pulp, they still think this is the correct way to bring children up

I'm noticing ageist idiots with an anecdote of 2 or 3 older people, make sweeping generalisations based on one or two people, who have probably been horrible all their lives, rather than reach a certain age, then suddenly turn into dickheads.

I'm noticing, it makes them look like complete idiots who are a bit hard of thinking.

BertieBotts · 18/01/2024 19:25

alltootired · 18/01/2024 14:44

@BertieBotts there were people at the time highly critical of that book. But there were still a lot of people who had been brought up in a very traditional way and who saw anything to do with babies and children as for women.

You always get forward thinking people who are critical of things - but it was hugely popular, wasn't it? I do think my mum is a bit unusually low-expectations of men and probably always have been, but in general, I feel like it wasn't totally alien in the way it comes across now.

Catsmere · 18/01/2024 19:18

Neurodiversitydoctor · 18/01/2024 19:05

I thi k also possibly male sex is a risk factor.

That would certainly add to it. It was the "key factors" and the usual hint of blaming single mothers that had me rolling my eyes.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 18/01/2024 19:05

Catsmere · 18/01/2024 18:59

Amazing, my father was uninvolved and gone by the time I was eight and I never had incentive to achieve or any ambition, and yet I've never been involved in knife crime, or any crime at all.

I thi k also possibly male sex is a risk factor.

Catsmere · 18/01/2024 18:59

Bootair · 18/01/2024 08:28

Actually, the key factors as to whether a child grows up to get involved in knife crime are 1) absent fathers 2) lack of external motivation and incentive to achieve

Amazing, my father was uninvolved and gone by the time I was eight and I never had incentive to achieve or any ambition, and yet I've never been involved in knife crime, or any crime at all.

Squiblet · 18/01/2024 18:21

I've never met anyone who was occasionally smacked (most of my generation) who is traumatised by it. @Sapphire387

Oddly enough I was just talking to my therapist this morning about how I was smacked occasionally as a child. She made a connection which I had never made myself - that a direct line could be drawn between that and certain patterns of feeling and behaviour that have dogged me all my adult life, and affected my relationships (badly).

She said that it was in fact trauma - not the severe, shell-shock kind, but trauma just the same, in that the fear and anger from those childhood smackings was still within me, unresolved.

I'd never even realised. But it made so much sense.

Cyclebabble · 18/01/2024 17:15

I am now in my fifties so below this generation. I was hit, sometimes beaten by my parents. This was common then. Overall my mum and dad did a good job. However this way of child rearing impacted me as an adult. One thing notable even now is that when I get into any kind of conflict in my head I fear it will turn physical and I become very tense. These disciplinary ways are in the past, had profound implications for recipients and are not for now.

I am a fan of strong discipline for kids and kids knowing consequences. I also think that a lesson from the past is that discipline should be swift and proportionate. What at one stage would have been a quick discussion and quick punishment now can leave children with interventions that last for years. Not sure this is helpful sometimes.

NonPlayerCharacter · 18/01/2024 17:06

MoonWoman69 · 18/01/2024 16:51

It is a shitty technique that is associated with every bad outcome including trauma and reduced intelligence, and smackers themselves have been found as a group to tend towards lower intelligence, which really shouldn't surprise anyone.

What an absolute crock of shit! Lower intelligence? My mum smacked me occasionally, as I have already stated, but unintelligent she was most certainly not! And neither am I from having been smacked! Absolute tripe!

Yes, lower intelligence. I'm not talking about your self reported anecdote, I'm talking about proper research at a class level and yes, parents who hit their kids have been found to score lower on intelligence tests overall than those who don't, and their kids suffer similar effects too.

Rather than railing against the findings, or dismissing them because of your self reported anecdote, you could try not defending the technique. That would be the intelligent thing to do. Hitting doesn't encourage complex thinking, and the Pope is Catholic.

Maddy70 · 18/01/2024 16:52

I kind of see where they're coming from. Times were different most kids were broought up with 2 parents and 1 stayed at home ti look after the chikdren so they had consistent parenting. Now kids (often ) have lax parenting as parents all have to work amd its exhausting dealing with bratty behaviour on top..
Kids have so many differing discipline styles throughout the day now.

Parent gets them up and out then ( 1 set of rules) go to childminder (2nd set of rules) then to school (3rd set of rules) maybe other parent collects from school (4th set of rule) go to grandparents house 5th set of rules

Its tougher to be consistent in these busy times and we have all seen failing gentle parenting im not saying smacking is correct at all but good discipline is definitely necessary

MoonWoman69 · 18/01/2024 16:51

It is a shitty technique that is associated with every bad outcome including trauma and reduced intelligence, and smackers themselves have been found as a group to tend towards lower intelligence, which really shouldn't surprise anyone.

What an absolute crock of shit! Lower intelligence? My mum smacked me occasionally, as I have already stated, but unintelligent she was most certainly not! And neither am I from having been smacked! Absolute tripe!

alltootired · 18/01/2024 16:31

@Strawberrylacess surveys show that a sizeable minority of adults do think it is acceptable for adults to hit other adults in specific circumstances.

alltootired · 18/01/2024 16:29

@BeingATwatItsABingThing so can adults hitting children.

Strawberrylacess · 18/01/2024 16:27

My point wasn't whether or not adults hitting each other happens but that most do not find it acceptable.

I doubt that OPs relative in their 70s would say that statement about an adult.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 18/01/2024 16:19

alltootired · 18/01/2024 16:07

I am not justifying it, but plenty of adults do hit each other. So I am not sure that is a good starting point. Especially as some adults think it is fine to hit other adults in particular circumstances.

And they can rightly be convicted of assault and/or domestic abuse.

alltootired · 18/01/2024 16:07

I am not justifying it, but plenty of adults do hit each other. So I am not sure that is a good starting point. Especially as some adults think it is fine to hit other adults in particular circumstances.

Strawberrylacess · 18/01/2024 15:47

It's not okay to hit an adult if they are annoying me/not listening to me/being a pain so how does anyone justify it towards children?

It's a loss of self control - simple as that.

I was hit occasionally as a child - I suffered (and still relapse if I stop anti depressants) with severe anxiety and OCD. Who knows if there is a relation anywhere.

I think if there is a debate to be had to children being more 'misbehaved' these days it is because everyone is so busy now and people find it easier to let things slide than challenge it.

In some cases it is laziness, in other cases I think it is pure exhaustion and declining mental health in general across the population.

I am not sure what the answer is though - most households now require both parents to work, most can't afford live in help, not everyone has family help (I know I don't, my mum works full time herself and had further children with her second husband, my partners mum also works full time which includes weekends).

Most of us are so burnt out in modern society - it doesn't mean it's fine to allow bad behaviour but I do also appreciate it more now I've had children of my own and am trying to juggle a lot of plates.

NonPlayerCharacter · 18/01/2024 15:30

Sapphire387 · 18/01/2024 15:13

I'm not going to be gaslighted over my own childhood - I know how it was, I know how I feel about it and about my parents. I've read research - perhaps you've read more widely than me, I don't know - and I can't bring myself to get worked up over an occasional smacked bottom.

Going back to the OP about older generation saying the kids need a good hiding... I expect they're just shocked to see the way a lot of kids talk to parents/teachers these days. I don't think beating is the answer, but something has clearly gone wrong somewhere.

Love how a rebuttal on the Internet is gaslighting, and that's somehow worse than assaulting children. And from someone who declared the mental state of all adults you know who were smacked as if you're privy to that information. But you're being gaslit?

Your parents engaged in a technique that is now known to be shit and harmful and is thoroughly rejected by everyone who knows the first thing about it. They may not have known better but you should, and if you wish to reject that knowledge because you can't accept that your parents made a mistake like many others, that does not alter the results of decades of fact finding. Nor does the fact that you personally are not worked up about child assault.

Think what you like about your own childhood, but don't expect to excuse and minimise and defend that shit awful child assault technique in 2024 and not be countered for it. It's not OK.

Sapphire387 · 18/01/2024 15:13

NonPlayerCharacter · 18/01/2024 12:54

I am not ever going to agree to differ with you on this. It is not a matter of opinion. You. Are. Wrong.

The research is done, the stats and facts are in. It is a shitty technique that is associated with every bad outcome including trauma and reduced intelligence, and smackers themselves have been found as a group to tend towards lower intelligence, which really shouldn't surprise anyone. There's no argument about it any more. So when someone comes along insisting that it's fine and dandy when we objectively know that it isn't, one does have to wonder... why?

I've never met anyone who was occasionally smacked (most of my generation) who is traumatised by it.

Well first of all, you don't know this, and again, the research is against you. But have you noticed how often hitters do this? Justify it with "well it didn't cause PTSD"?

Is that the best parenting you aspire to? Your bar must be on the floor.

There's no agreeing to differ when it comes to assaulting children and ignoring decades of sound research because of lazy thinking and an itch for handsiness. I get that you don't want to accept that your parents made a mistake, albeit a common one, but they did. Smacking is shitty parenting and now that we know that, it's arguably worse to defend it now than 30 years ago.

I'm not going to be gaslighted over my own childhood - I know how it was, I know how I feel about it and about my parents. I've read research - perhaps you've read more widely than me, I don't know - and I can't bring myself to get worked up over an occasional smacked bottom.

Going back to the OP about older generation saying the kids need a good hiding... I expect they're just shocked to see the way a lot of kids talk to parents/teachers these days. I don't think beating is the answer, but something has clearly gone wrong somewhere.

alltootired · 18/01/2024 14:46

I think people have higher expectations now because they can divorce more easily. Partly that is about money. It was very hard for women to divorce in the past as most would be left in absolute poverty. But there was also a lot of stigma and judgement. So a lot of people stayed together that would now days divorce.

alltootired · 18/01/2024 14:44

@BertieBotts there were people at the time highly critical of that book. But there were still a lot of people who had been brought up in a very traditional way and who saw anything to do with babies and children as for women.

BertieBotts · 18/01/2024 14:22

Sorry, this is in response to:

the logical conclusion of improved parenting skills over the years would presumably be more secure, productive, mentally healthy adults with good quality relationships?

BertieBotts · 18/01/2024 14:21

Don't you think relationships have improved though? I think people in general have higher expectations from relationships today and they are generally healthier with better communication. Of course there are still gendered divides/expectations/etc today but not as extreme as in past generations, and not as much is excused as "Oh that's just men".

There is this podcast called "If Books Could Kill" and one of the first books they covered was "Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus" - which I remember my mum treating as some kind of vital translation bible to explain men's mysterious behaviour. The book (published in the 90s) opens with an anecdote about a husband who is baffled when his wife is upset with him when she sends him on an errand after she has had a baby and he fails to deliver what she needs. The male hosts of the podcast (2020s) are utterly HORRIFIED at the cluelessness of the man and how he can be so oblivious to his partner's distress, and it does come across to a modern audience as absolutely bizarre - it just wouldn't be a normal relationship scenario today - everyone would be saying "LTB"!