Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we need to find a way to infiltrate the dog cult?

639 replies

dogsdilemma · 17/01/2024 11:53

I'll start by saying I favour cats but love all animals. I don't want a dog just now because I find them tying. Would date someone who had one because, contrary to what I'm about to say, I like them and it wouldn't be my responsibility.

But the obsession drives me nuts. It seems no one can own a dog in a normal way anymore. As in I have a dog, the dog is a pet not a person, dogs aren't god-like solve all creatures, it's fine if not everyone loves my dog as much as me - like I am with my cat.

Someone gets a puppy and I go to their house - all conversation is about the puppy and I'm expected to fuss like they've just given birth. I can't say 'ah I've actually come to catch up with my friend, not have endless chat about the puppy's sleep schedule and whether or not it shat in the house today' because their dogs are their babies, so I should treat them as such.

Instagram accounts for dogs - captions written like 'my mum took me for a walk today, I had so much fun'. Only mildly cringy but wtf? Are you a springer spaniel mother or Katie from uni?

I do an exercise class and the owner has a puppy. She brings him along so he's not home alone. At least 15 minutes of the session I've paid for is always taken up by the hive mind fussing the puppy. Everyone loves dogs so no one minds apparently - except I DO mind. If I say this though I'm gonna be the dick.

I'm OLD, and every other profile says 'must love dogs'. I do love them but don't want one, and if I say this it's like I've confessed to being Hitler in a past life. Cue messages trying to change my mind, as though not being obsessed with dogs is a moral failure. I love my cat but wouldn't rule out someone who doesn't feel the same?

The final nail in the coffin. I've been dating someone new. Had an absolute shitter of a week so far - nothing he can help with, not really serious, just work stuff. His response is 15 pictures of his dog being cute to cheer me up. He's just trying to be nice but I do not get it. I wouldn't expect pictures of my cat to cheer anyone up except, maybe, me. I'm being narky but I actually found it so so irritating and cannot even fake enthusiasm to reply. If I say 'awwww cute, thank you' he'll continue with this approach. If I say 'cute but why would your dog cheer me up ha' I'm gonna look like a knob.

I have no problem with others doing what they want to do but recently it is infiltrating everything. I know there are worse issues but ffs it's so annoying - what is this dog cult and how to we stop it? Can I tell this lovely man I'm dating that I actually have little interest in his dog?!?!?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Fionaville · 17/01/2024 12:53

I love my dog, he's a member of the family. But I fully recognise that he's a dog, not one of the kids.
I don't get the dog cult either. I laugh at some of the antics of 'dog mums' but it doesn't bother me.
Your exercise instructor shouldn't be taking up so much of the class on dog admiration. That's nuts. And I think you're well without yout rights to tell your new chap that his dog won't cheer you up. I told my DH that I didn't like his cat when we met, he just laughed and put it out of the room. I think saying "I'm not a cat/dog lover" is perfectly acceptable.

ZittiEBuoni · 17/01/2024 12:52

And I get what you're saying, OP.

I have a group of old school friends - it was our habit to meet 2/3 times a year for a restaurant meal. Then one of them got a dog and became obsessed with it and now we can only meet for lunches in areas with good dog walking. The dog is cute and well-behaved, no problem with the dog, but I don't particularly want to have to prioritise its needs every time I meet up with this friendship group.

Winnipeggy · 17/01/2024 12:52

I think all that you're saying is reasonable but give your bf a break, I think that's actually quite sweet and obviously coming from a good place. I like a dog but would never want to have one, I have no idea why people with young children would want another tiny needy creature following them around all day.

Ylvamoon · 17/01/2024 12:52

My dog has definitely a Human Soul and should be treated as such!

One can only presume that the Tibetan Terriers bred and kept as companions and watchdogs by the Lamas for over 2,000 years became close companions, particularly since Tibetan Buddhism holds that dogs are the last reincarnation before rebirth as human

https://nationalpurebreddogday.com/the-little-people-dogs/

The "Little People" Dogs

We suppose that entering a monastic life in Tibet was different for each individual, but we came across an account we found fascinating. In every Tibetan family that had five sons or more, one was compelled by law to be a lama, or monk, and this was ne...

https://nationalpurebreddogday.com/the-little-people-dogs

Flamingogirl08 · 17/01/2024 12:51

You are not wrong. I know somebody who refers to her son as her second born as the dog was her first baby. It really is a cult 😆

LilyLemonade · 17/01/2024 12:50

FuzzyPuffling · 17/01/2024 12:28

And then they eat them. 😱

S Korea has just banned eating dogs (with a transition period of several years until full implementation). I think partly because of the rise in keeping them as pets.

ZittiEBuoni · 17/01/2024 12:50

It's about a specific phenomenon in dog ownership, not dogs...

crystaltips77 · 17/01/2024 12:49

@AlwaysGinPlease So you have nothing better to do than post on a thread you find dull?

AlwaysGinPlease · 17/01/2024 12:49

Yet another moaning thread about dogs 🥱

dogsdilemma · 17/01/2024 12:48

I will also add that I feel the same way about people who do this with any pet - not just dogs.
Love cats but cat cafes are a very strange concept to me - I don't need to have a cat that's not mine on my lap whilst I'm eating.

It's only so annoying with dogs because it's literally everywhere in a way that it isn't with other animals - perpetrated by social media I think. Posts like 'I'm sad, send dog pics 😔' 'dogs are better than humans' 'we don't deserve dogs'.
Everyone has just lapped this up and suddenly it's normal to be obsessed, abnormal to be ambivalent or dislike dogs Confused

OP posts:
CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 17/01/2024 12:48

I do an exercise class and the owner has a puppy. She brings him along so he's not home alone. At least 15 minutes of the session I've paid for is always taken up by the hive mind fussing the puppy. Everyone loves dogs so no one minds apparently - except I DO mind. If I say this though I'm gonna be the dick.

This would really annoy me. If it genuinely is 15 mins out of a (presumably) hour(?) long class, where you're not doing anything, that's taking the piss and the instructor should get the class started.

crystaltips77 · 17/01/2024 12:48

I kind of agree OP, I don't mind dogs and have a few in my life via family I am fond of but I think that people using dogs as emotional surrogates is unhealthy and not great for the dog. A vet once told me he feels many dogs now have mental health issues due to being treated at one minute as a beloved indulged child and then next as an animal, loads of dogs have massive anxiety but the owners often don't see it they are so busy getting their own needs met by the animal.

Never forget that dogs are just dogs, they cannot be substitute humans.

Strokethefurrywall · 17/01/2024 12:46

I agree with most of this.

I love dogs, I love all animals. I had 2 dogs. But they were treated like dogs, not mini people.

I didn't have "fur babies", they were left alone for periods of time to entertain themselves, the world didn't revolve around them, and they were trained properly.

I get it, people love their dogs (as well they should!), but the current anthropomorphism of dogs is off the charts in the general population.

I'm not saying people are weird for bringing their dog to places or including them in daily life (I'm glad to see dogs being welcomed in many places), but the "I can't go to a restaurant unless my dog can come too" is a bit nuts.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 17/01/2024 12:46

I don’t get it either OP, I don’t mind dogs, my friends have dogs but they are treated as such, they get a fuss then go and lie down that’s it. I wouldn’t have one as they are too tying, I like my house not smelly and the chance of accidents; we both work out of the house and have kids so don’t want to add any more time intensive things to our life, I like spontaneity and don’t agree with dogs being allowed everywhere.

I also don’t understand all these people who hate kids and love dogs, dogs ain’t going to pay taxes for your elderly care or look after you in your dotage 🤷‍♀️

the problem is there are far too many of them now and mainly owned by irresponsible idiots

thinkfast · 17/01/2024 12:46

I love dogs but I hate dog owners.

I don't understand how they can be so inconsiderate. Took my daughter out for breakfast last weekend. Couple with a large dog sat next to us. They were feeding it herring snacks (which stank). Plus do dogs need constant snacks? They allowed their dog to bother us for our food - it rested its head on our table and panted and drooled when our food arrived. Disgusting. I asked if they could please move their dog away. "Oh a bit of Nutella won't hurt her". Was tempted to reply that it probably wouldn't be good for her, but just said "please move your dog as we can't eat like this". Grrrrrr

fluffyduvetcover · 17/01/2024 12:46

I've had dogs all my adult life. They're my dogs, not my children, nor my fur babies. They're not my life nor my reason for existing or define me. Current dog goes out for walks but I wouldn't dream of taking her out with me in the evening to a friend's for dinner for example.
I don't take photos, I've got no need to, she's with me daily and no one else wants or needs to see photos of my dog.
I love her as I would love any dog who lived within my home for any length of time, but I don't love her as much as my children, Grandchild or parents.
When my favourite dog ever died a couple of years ago, I was so terribly sad and I did cry for some weeks on and off. But the pain subsided, as pain tends to do and was not like the bereavement of a family member.
YANBU OP and what a refreshing thread

TheDogsMother · 17/01/2024 12:45

I was like that until I got mine but without the social media postings. Never ever used the term furbaby though 🤢

We lost our boy in 2020 but I am now a Borrow my Doggy borrower. Love seeing all the dogs in the park.

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/01/2024 12:44

EffieGraysDisappointingWeddingNight · 17/01/2024 12:41

I don't have any pets but I find that cat people wang on about their moggies far more. 'My cat is my benevolent overlord tee hee hee' 'It's my cat's home and I just live in it'

Zzzzzzz.

People anthropomorphising their pets is always tedious and a bit pathetic. It doesn't really matter what species it is. It's just childish.

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/01/2024 12:43

@dogsdilemma

It seems like there can only be 'obsessed' or 'hate dogs' - no in between. And then I get judged for it

This is exactly it: there's no middle ground any more. I completely agree with you.

I actually quite like dogs (though I wouldn't get one mainly because I don't have time). But you're right that everyone seems to have to be at one end of the spectrum or the other. It's no longer possible to be mildly positive but fairly disinterested about them or find them irritating but tolerable. You either have to have your life consumed by them, to the point that you can't talk about anything else, or you have to absolutely hate them and spend your life bitching about them.

To be fair I find the hate for dogs cult as disturbing as the "fur babies" stuff: threads and threads about how people avoid certain parks because of a small risk of a dog jumping up on them. It's so melodramatic and fastidious. Unless you live next to an XL Bully it's perfectly possible to avoid dogs. I find both the wildly exaggerated love and the hate absolutely mystifying. Dogs are animals. Take them or leave them but stop boring the pants off everyone else talking about them.

MrsShortbread · 17/01/2024 12:42

My dog is a dog, I would never consider her my “fur-baby”, she’s a dog. She is not allowed upstairs or on beds/furniture, has no social media, gets no human food treats, is not taken with me to other people’s houses and is always put in a different room immediately if we have visitors at front door (brought back out if visitor happy with that, but expected to behave impeccably). She is very loved by us, but we don’t feel the need to prove that to the world - she knows it.

CharlotteLightandDark · 17/01/2024 12:41

I think anyone who goes on that much about anything lacks a bit of self awareness, whether it’s a child, pet or hobby.

You need to be aware when you’re boring people and that not everyone is as enamoured with whatever it is are you are. It’s not great social skills to bang on and on.

EffieGraysDisappointingWeddingNight · 17/01/2024 12:41

I don't have any pets but I find that cat people wang on about their moggies far more. 'My cat is my benevolent overlord tee hee hee' 'It's my cat's home and I just live in it'

Zzzzzzz.

maudelovesharold · 17/01/2024 12:41

I love my cat but wouldn't rule out someone who doesn't feel the same?

It probably makes me unreasonable, but I definitely would! In my experience, cats seem to trigger a hatred in some people, which dogs rarely do, even in exclusively cat people. I’m definitely a cat person, but I’m, at worst, ambivalent about dogs. I’ve heard some awful, vehement dislike of cats expressed from some people who seem to regard them as akin to vermin.

tinymeteor · 17/01/2024 12:39

Treat it like a filtering system for dating. Would this person want the dog to attend our wedding wearing a bow tie? If so, this is not going to work out.

(I love my dog but he is not my child and nobody who shits in the garden gets a wedding invite, in my book.)

Diamondglintsonsnow · 17/01/2024 12:39

I can’t get on board with what you are saying but then again I am a dog person 😀