Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how people can be so stupid to believe the ‘psycho ex’ BS spouted by men?

115 replies

Sunshinemorning · 17/01/2024 11:33

so first of all- yes, sometimes women are at fault in a relationship breakdown and might have been abusive and controlling. But AIBU to think they are the small minority?

It amazes me how many men go on about psycho ex’s, but AIBU to think the people who believe them are just naive? A lot of them are new partners who seem to swallow the narrative- even when they’ve never had first hand evidence of any ‘psycho’ behaviour? Or seem to define ‘psycho behaviour’ as an ex who gets annoyed about flakiness in childcare arrangements.

Full disclosure: I’ve been labelled the ‘psycho ex’ by my ex who was abusive and controlling ( and still is - using childcare arrangements as a means of control).
He has conducted a smear campaign against me - slagging me off and calling me crazy to all his friends and family. He has also accused me of abuse. There are plenty more lies, I’m sure.

what shocks me is the people who seem to believe it. I’m ignored or treated with suspicion by his friends. ( we still live in same small town). His new partner is rude and disrespectful when speaking to me. ( only speak to her cos he has now got her doing his childcare, so she ends up involved in handovers).

Does the penny ever drop?

OP posts:
Mrsm010918 · 17/01/2024 17:43

Psycho here 🙋‍♀️😂

All because I dared to voice an objection to ex moving to other end of the country and leaving me with 100% of childcare with no plans in place for contact.

Further enhanced by the fact I wanted more than 50% of the house in the divorce I'm consideration of this.

Ifhappylittlebluebirdsfly222 · 17/01/2024 16:25

I used to think the same as op until a male relative of mine got involved with a woman who is now a genuine psycho ex. It was lucky my relative could afford a lawyer but I won't say much more.

Obviously there are men who spin things to make the ex look bad but not every time.

SameOldSong · 17/01/2024 15:58

Most women swallow the bullshit version because that version suits them. They don't want their new man on best friend terms with ex, especially if they are insecure.
Personally if l meet a man and he starts going down this road it's a right turn off.
I was speaking to a man recently who had moved to France and opened a guest house. He was quite interesting until he mentioned his "narcissist" ex. That did it for me.

mathanxiety · 17/01/2024 15:52

@mindutopia
The narrative spun by the man who has glommed onto your mother also features money.

He is careful to advertise the fact that he has money for the 'diggers' to dig. He's bigging himself up and dangling the money carrot at the same time that he's admitting the SA.

mathanxiety · 17/01/2024 15:39

The penny rarely drops.

People in general have no idea how abusers behave, and know nothing of the dynamics of abuse. Friends usually only see one side of the abuser.

Women who fall for it are vulnerable to the charm of the narcissistic abuser, and believe they're somehow better than the previous women in their misunderstood prince's life.

Then there is the cultural bias against women, which makes it possible to believe that women are bitter, vengeful, creatures, hell bent on ruining men's lives.

You see that here, in plenty of threads, where women who have been abused advise an OP to start making plans to leave. There are always a few posters who can't see what the problem is and consider it a real humdinger of an insult to accuse those advising ending the relationship of probably being divorced and bitter. It's sad but not surprising.

LavenderHaze19 · 17/01/2024 15:16

One of my friends is recently divorced and on dating websites.

One of her golden rules is that any man who refers to his ex as ‘psycho’, ‘crazy’, ‘bitch’ or similar language goes straight in the bin. At double speed if said ex is the mother of his children.

That’s not to say that women are never at fault for the breakdown of a relationship, but using that kind of language about your ex when dating a new woman is a giant red flag.

WishesPromises · 17/01/2024 14:56

Any divorce lawyer will tell you that ex husbands are always controlling and ex wives are always psychotic.

I think people would have to be very naive not to see through those labels.

Walker1178 · 17/01/2024 14:51

I think there are some couples that just should never have been together and the toxicity of that relationship will filter through to any dealings they have afterwards. The behaviour is very likely to be the product of them both and not as one sided as some like to make out.

On the other hand, I’ve been with my DP for three years, he’s got some annoying traits but is kind, loving, a hard worker and appreciates me and our life. He was with his ex for around 6 mths and they split a good 6mths before we met but she will still talk smack about him and how she is enjoying the single life after being with the worst guy on the planet. She’ll also have a few good digs at her exH who left the scene a very long time ago, no naivety on my part she is simply some kind of psycho

Tandora · 17/01/2024 14:39

It’s always a massive red flag for me when men talk about their “psycho ex”. Basically to me that = misogynist. Unfortunately many women lap it up as they are insecure and also have internalised misogyny. When women post on here about their DP’s awful ex etc, it makes me want to bang my head against a wall. Yes I’m sure there’s a minority of cases where this is true, but in the vast majority it’s just a narrative spin by a nasty , irresponsible man and lapped up by his jealous/ insecure/ desperate to be chosen new partner.

AppleDumplings · 17/01/2024 14:31

I disagree. The post by @SeulementUneFois could have been written by me. My teeny, tiny, butter wouldn't melt in her mouth es SIL was evil. Pure evil. She did unspeakable things to my BIL and no one would ever have believed the 6'2" military man if he had reported it. And she knew it. Female abuse of their partners is more common than people realise.

Ormside · 17/01/2024 14:20

Surely if he's your psycho ex he fooled you at some point too into believing he was a great guy. It's not that difficult to believe others are then sucked in by his bullshit.

LemonLight · 17/01/2024 14:10

Ah I've been there. My ex cheated on me, emotionally blackmailed me, was emotionally and sexually abusive, for four years! and yet, I was labelled the crazy psycho ex because I developed such severe depression and anxiety and dependency that I couldn't function like a normal person. I even developed stress cardiomyopathy, and now have issues with low blood pressure from cardiac weakness. In many ways I felt like I was crazy, Ill never forget the moment when i described how I felt and the relationship to my therapist and she simply said 'so you were abused'. It was such a shock and I'd been so effectively gaslit I never even considered it had been abusive. It took me a lot of therapy, medication and time to get over it. My life has been going pretty well since we finally cut ties though. I hear he's a complete loser so it just goes to show who really had their shhh together.

LenaLamont · 17/01/2024 13:37

The fastest way to put me off a man is to hear him trash talk an ex. Red flags from here to outer space.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 17/01/2024 13:32

I believed my ex that he had a psycho ex. Your question is why... some reflections

  • I was lonely before I met him and he was love bombing me and he just seemed so nice and kind I couldn't imagine him harming anyone but I could imagine people taking advantage of his supposed kindness.
  • the way he described her and her mental health, she reminded me of a colleague who would bully nice people and so I could see how that could happen- it was a plausible story.
  • he had a lot of the 'woke' language and terminologies - he was basically a fake feminist /mysoginist deep down.
  • it was during the pandemic - a lot of people did struggle with their mental health then so it was believable that she'd gone nuts and lashed out at him emotionally.
  • he seemed to have altruistic values and works in a helping profession. I realise now this is about power control and public adoration as he's a narc and he also isn't good enough to get management roles in big private companies. I also realise he probably turned her crazy by constantly gaslighting and dismissing her feelings like he did to me (when I was pregnant).

I am sure I am the crazy ex to his new dates now.

InShockHusbandLeaving · 17/01/2024 13:21

Dotjones · 17/01/2024 11:42

I don't think it's fair to assume it's a "small minority" of cases where the female ex-partner is behaving badly. Often these former relationships were toxic and both parties were at fault, and this toxicity spills over into any contact they have after the relationship ends.

Put another way, me thinking my ex was completely in the wrong doesn't mean that he doesn't believe that I was completely in the wrong. Both positions can be true at the same time because standards of what is right and wrong vary by individual. By MY standards the ex was at fault, by HIS standards I was at fault. The chances are we both are to blame.

Plenty of people who were badly treated in a relationship behave badly themselves when the relationship is over. Someone who complains of having an ex-partner whose behaviour is troublesome or combative might have a genuine complaint even if it was them themselves who was in the wrong whilst the relationship was in progress. The thinking is along the lines of "he cheated on me so I'll make access to our child difficult" - that sort of thing.

TLDR: usually everyone is to blame.

Tell me you’ve never been unfortunate enough to find yourself in relationship with a partner who has a diagnosed personality disorder (in the case of my ex) or an undiagnosed one, without telling me blah blah. My ex was full of stories about his “crazy” ex and doubtless has a fund of similar stories about me, including my drunkenness (I don’t drink and never have), my spendthrift nature (I’ve always had savings, he never has), my bad parenting skills (I’ve moved in with my daughter temporarily at her request to help out with childcare, none of his kids will speak to him after he’s let them down numerous times). So no, it’s not always six of one and half a dozen of the other I’m afraid.

VampireWeekday · 17/01/2024 13:11

Oh also, the casual way these men say it makes me disbelieve them. I am deeply ashamed of having been in an absuive relationship (this is my problem, I know really it wasn't my fault and I feel nothing but admiration and sympathy for other women who have been). But even people who don't feel ashamed in my experience treat it as a serious thing that happened to them, perhaps even a past trauma. They don't casually say "yeah ex was a right dickhead, total psycho" over cocktails.

SquirrelSoShiny · 17/01/2024 13:07

Cheer up, his current partner will at some point be promoted to the next 'crazy ex'.

VampireWeekday · 17/01/2024 13:05

AnneLovesGilbert · 17/01/2024 12:40

You say he was abusive, he says you were. People are choosing who to believe, you’re each telling your side and hoping people you know believe you.

If a woman tells you her male ex is abusive or psycho do you assume she’s lying because only liars claim that, or do you believe her because you think only men can be bad and woman victims?

Actually this is a good test for me. Men who talk about their "psycho ex", "crazy ex" or "narcisist ex" are usually just covering up their own bad expectations or behaviour. Sometimes the wife's actions are totally fabricated. On the other hand, people who talk about being abused are usually telling the truth. If a man told me that he had an abusive ex and could spell out in detail what she would do, I would believe him now, unless given strong evidence to disbelieve.

My ex does the whole psycho ex routine to me, by the way, and did it when we were together. The evidence is made up accusations of hitting him, scratching him and trying to stab him. I've never been in a physical confrontation with him all my life, although he did push me to the ground and into furniture on a few occassions. I once traced down the tiny piece of truth he'd built the stack of lies on. I was holding sauce ready to pour, he aggresively santched it off me and called me a stupid bitch because I was using the wrong pan and I said in frustartion "give it back!" and sort of lightly hit the back of my hand against his arm (he was standing next to me). It was no doubt wrong and I regretted it instantly, but it sure as hell wasn't systematic psycho abusive behaviour, and as someone said upthread perhaps makes more sense against the background of a decade of being sworn at and called names for doing small tasks wrong, like using the wrong pan to cook sauce in.

Lovemusic82 · 17/01/2024 13:04

I think we all learn from our mistakes and we learn more about other peoples behaviours from experiences. When I was younger I stupidly fell for the “ex is crazy” comments. Now I know from experience that it’s a huge red flag, I have also learnt that it’s unlikely for a woman to claim a man is abusive and it not be true, though there are times where it isn’t true but it’s not a risk I am willing to take. I have had some pretty awful relationships but I would never slag a ex off to a new partner.

bobomomo · 17/01/2024 13:04

Funny enough dp has never commented on his ex yet as time has gone on things have slipped out, she was definitely a bit of an odd one. Dsd lives with us (adult so can choose). Polite men don't use derogatory language even if there's negativity!

Whattodo112222 · 17/01/2024 13:03

I was one of these women who fell for my exes lies.. consequently he is now spouting the same bullshit about me too.

I recently sat in court with him whilst he blubbed like a baby, collapsed with emotion in such dramatic fashion. It really was quite something...

All I'll say is, they're believable.. its when the kids believable their lies that's what is hardest to deal with.

bobomomo · 17/01/2024 13:02

It goes both ways, I personally have known women who have pleaded, been conniving, refused to hand over children etc and I've known plenty of men who have refused to pay adequate child maintenance, not seen their kids etc. neither sex are immune from controlling behaviour too. My ex mil only avoided domestic abuse charges because at the time no one thought women were capable, I've seen evidence otherwise and needless to say she never had sole charge of the kids.

LolaSmiles · 17/01/2024 13:01

AnneLovesGilbert

It's not comparable though.

Someone talking about their experience of abuse in a relationship is not the same as the "my ex is crazy, they're such a psycho" lines. There's thread after thread on here where the "my ex is crazy" script has been used.

No sex has a monopoly on poor behaviour in a relationship, but on balance domestic abuse is a male pattern behaviour. Some men are victims of female perpetrators, but that's a minority.

The risk to me listening to a woman outlining her experience with an abusive male ex is not the same level of risk to my safety as entering into a romantic relationship with a man who claims his ex was crazy and psycho.

There are enough men out there who hate their ex, have had awful break ups and had horrible experiences with their ex partners and they still don't use the "ex is crazy, she's so psycho" script. The script is a red flag for me.

therealcookiemonster · 17/01/2024 13:01

'crazy' 'psycho' 'hysterical' 'unstable' all words used to put women 'in their place' and keep them restricted to misogynistic social norms

First they will use it about their ex and then before you know it you are the psycho.

unfortunately in the first throes of love/lust its easy to ignore this name calling especially as we want to minimise our partners' past relationships to feel that this current partnership is 'special'

adollopofthisandthat · 17/01/2024 12:59

I've been/am both - naive and believed him about his previous crazy ex (who was visibly very difficult to a lot of people, which didn't help) and now I'm the new crazy ex...and two people in particular have believed every word he has said about me and no longer want to know me.

He is very, very plausible - sad face, weeping uncontrollably, choking with grief at what has "happened" - and I completely understand why people believe him, as it goes with his other false face, the "gentle, salt-of-the-earth would help anyone what a lovely bloke" demeanour.

It took me many years to work out who he really is, he is that good at hiding it - I think he still thinks I don't know - so however much it hurts I can't blame other people for falling for it; what hurts is that both people had known me well for years, and haven't thought to question his version of events, not so much as a text asking if I'm ok...

So whilst to some extent it's about women being set one against another, from my experience it's simply the efficiency with which an abuser presents his case...