Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how people can be so stupid to believe the ‘psycho ex’ BS spouted by men?

115 replies

Sunshinemorning · 17/01/2024 11:33

so first of all- yes, sometimes women are at fault in a relationship breakdown and might have been abusive and controlling. But AIBU to think they are the small minority?

It amazes me how many men go on about psycho ex’s, but AIBU to think the people who believe them are just naive? A lot of them are new partners who seem to swallow the narrative- even when they’ve never had first hand evidence of any ‘psycho’ behaviour? Or seem to define ‘psycho behaviour’ as an ex who gets annoyed about flakiness in childcare arrangements.

Full disclosure: I’ve been labelled the ‘psycho ex’ by my ex who was abusive and controlling ( and still is - using childcare arrangements as a means of control).
He has conducted a smear campaign against me - slagging me off and calling me crazy to all his friends and family. He has also accused me of abuse. There are plenty more lies, I’m sure.

what shocks me is the people who seem to believe it. I’m ignored or treated with suspicion by his friends. ( we still live in same small town). His new partner is rude and disrespectful when speaking to me. ( only speak to her cos he has now got her doing his childcare, so she ends up involved in handovers).

Does the penny ever drop?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 17/01/2024 22:05

I think it’s the word psycho that’s a particular red flag. Talking about difficult ex is fine- of course women can be difficult and cause problems, even be abusive- but there’s something about the word psycho which tends to tell you that it’s the bloke who was the problem.
I feel the same.
Plenty of men have awful break ups. Plenty of men have been hurt by exes.
Some men have left abusive relationships.
Many will talk about it when needed.
Most don't start their new relationships calling their ex partners crazy or psycho.

There's a certain script that a certain type of man uses with a new relationship that is a huge set of red flags.

Edit to add: On another thread someone used the analogy of a shark cage. Most people have a cage that's good enough to keep the sharks out. Some people, either due to younger experiences, previous abusive relationships, not being shown what a healthy relationship looks like, or other vulnerabilities don't have a very good shark cage at that moment in time.

Men who use the "crazy ex" script will tend to seek out the women who don't have a great shark cage because it gives them a way in, especially if they love bomb and are the model partner. They know exactly what they're doing when they choose new potential partners and they don't tend to pick the women who have obviously good shark cages.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 17/01/2024 20:53

I think it is one of the common assumptions we make to get us through life without being too afraid to step foot outside our door. And it is sometimes hard to truly believe that things can happen until they happen to you - you intellectually know they can happen, but dont really feel it.

Sunshinemorning · 17/01/2024 20:19

@Atethehalloweenchocs i think you are right.

sadly, would include myself in that. Was very naive about my ex when I first met him.

OP posts:
Atethehalloweenchocs · 17/01/2024 20:10

A lot of people feel that they are smarter than they are, and that bad things will not happen to them because of it.

SherbertLemons · 17/01/2024 19:54

I do sometimes think about the fact that somewhere out there my DxH most probably portrays me a the crazy ex wife. I'm far from crazy. I hope the poor women who hear his tales see past the fantasy

Myhubbyisasweetheart · 17/01/2024 19:51

A golden rule is to steer clear of anyone who slanders an ex.

Sunshinemorning · 17/01/2024 19:51

Honeychickpea · 17/01/2024 19:45

Yes, the ex tends to be described as a narcissist, controlling and emotionally abusive instead of psycho when he is male.

I think that ‘narcissistic’ and ‘misogynist’ often get mixed up though. ( though it’s massively narcissistic to think you are superior to another human, without any basis for your belief)

There’s plenty of men who fall into the second category. I’d guess that misogynists probably have a really high chance of divorce , so yes, many divorced men will statistically be misogynistic.

OP posts:
JanglyBeads · 17/01/2024 19:49

qazxc · 17/01/2024 11:43

I think at the beginning the new partners are being love bombed and presented with the perfect partner so they are more inclined to believe the tales of woe of the unfair and unreasonable ex who is stopping them seeing the children, took all the money in the break up, etc,...
Abuser or cock lodgers are also very good at picking partners who are maybe a bit more vulnerable, lonely or naive so that they can get what they want out of them and they will believe the script more readily.
I think as time goes on the reality probably dawns on them, it certainly will when the relationship is over and they are being tarred with the same brush.
You cannot blame the new partners though, they are being conned and manipulated.

This

vivainsomnia · 17/01/2024 19:49

I find both men and women come into the firing line when it comes to being criticised by an ex.
It's not exclusive to one sex

That! The male ex is the abusive ex, the female ex is the psycho ex. Standard.

One trait that attracted me to my OH is that he never put down his ex, and that's despite finding out later that she had cheated on him (and married the guy with whom she's been with over 20 years and still is with). I think it was respectful and showed he'd really moved on. My ex wasn't abusive either.

IncompleteSenten · 17/01/2024 19:47

Ime people believe what they want to believe and will make the most astonishing leaps in order to keep believing it.

Honeychickpea · 17/01/2024 19:45

banjocat · 17/01/2024 11:46

Well 'psycho' is a pretty unhelpful and loaded word.

But a lot of people, male and female, obviously carry a lot of resentment and emotional issues around exes, difficult break ups, even abuse etc., so it's not surprising that ex-partners are often framed in this way.

I know as many women as men who talk this way about their exes.

Yes, the ex tends to be described as a narcissist, controlling and emotionally abusive instead of psycho when he is male.

Whatsgoingonwithmyhead · 17/01/2024 19:41

Yep. Acquaintance of mine tells me about the “psycho ex” wife

Yeah funny she doesn’t like you after you poached her husband who left her with 2 kids under 3……

SouthEastCoast · 17/01/2024 19:41

Yes, I had a close friend who fully believed it but it was clear he had a type and that type was vulnerable

MorrisZapp · 17/01/2024 19:38

You've answered your own question. Your ex was abusive and manipulative so in order to have a relationship with him you must have either tolerated his abuse from the outset, or much more likely believed he was who he said he was when he acted nice when you first met him.

His new partner is no different to you once we're - loved up in a new relationship with a guy who's so lovely anyone who says otherwise must be horrible.

It's a cycle. You're just at different stages.

PuffinJilly · 17/01/2024 19:33

I find both men and women come into the firing line when it comes to being criticised by an ex.
It's not exclusive to one sex.

DeeCeeCherry · 17/01/2024 19:31

To wonder how people can be so stupid to believe the ‘psycho ex’ BS spouted by men?

They believe it because they want to. Never underestimate the pull of wanting a particular man by any means necessary. For these type of women they light up when a man tells them or implies that they're better than his ex. Competitiveness and the heady joy of being seen as 'better than' is another pull.

Personally any man that said that to me 🚩. I read posts on MN by women who are in a tizz over his ex or in a constant battle and I think, how/why? Are you not tired? Dont you like peace? Is a man worth all that? But, they know why so leave them to get on with it, best not to get involved its way too much drama.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 17/01/2024 19:27

I think it’s because socially they have pressure to remain friends with your ex as he’s part of their group so it’s easier for them to just believe him. They only see him on his good days and not under pressure when he’s mean and nasty too.

CeeCeeBloom · 17/01/2024 19:24

YANBU, but my DH did actually have a psycho ex. I was a bit Hmm when he first described her that way early on in our relationship. I thought he was exaggerating, boy was I wrong! 😂Three decades on she's not as psycho anymore, but she certainly has her moments! So much so that DSD limits contact with her so DGD isn't exposed to her nutty behaviour too much.

Sunshinemorning · 17/01/2024 19:09

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 17/01/2024 13:32

I believed my ex that he had a psycho ex. Your question is why... some reflections

  • I was lonely before I met him and he was love bombing me and he just seemed so nice and kind I couldn't imagine him harming anyone but I could imagine people taking advantage of his supposed kindness.
  • the way he described her and her mental health, she reminded me of a colleague who would bully nice people and so I could see how that could happen- it was a plausible story.
  • he had a lot of the 'woke' language and terminologies - he was basically a fake feminist /mysoginist deep down.
  • it was during the pandemic - a lot of people did struggle with their mental health then so it was believable that she'd gone nuts and lashed out at him emotionally.
  • he seemed to have altruistic values and works in a helping profession. I realise now this is about power control and public adoration as he's a narc and he also isn't good enough to get management roles in big private companies. I also realise he probably turned her crazy by constantly gaslighting and dismissing her feelings like he did to me (when I was pregnant).

I am sure I am the crazy ex to his new dates now.

You could be describing my exH!

That is exactly what he is like and I suspect how he talks about me.

in some ways, it’s understandable that the new partner will believe the psycho ex story- they are being love bombed and they love the person.

but it’s some of his friends who knew me that really puzzle me. They spent time with me and knew me ( I think!) to be easy going, kind and supportive while some of them went through difficult times- how can they believe I’m an abusive psycho?

OP posts:
MissersMercer · 17/01/2024 19:05

Yes my ex is the same. That's his reason on why he has not seen our child since he was a toddler. Absolute idiot man.

Sunshinemorning · 17/01/2024 19:02

@TheCadoganArms you are right- there is sometimes poor behaviour on both sides, but I think there is often one partner who is more to blame than the other.

The ‘one is as bad as the other’ argument rarely holds water. If it’s not too much of a stretch- I’ll use the climate change analogy:
the argument of climate change deniers is not equal to those of climate change scientists. Just because people on the side of science get angry at the deniers, it doesn’t mean they are obsessed or crazy!

from my experience, I did everything to have an amicable split. He cheated. I ended it. I still offered to help him decorate his new place so the kids could visit. However, he went nuts at this. He’d take the kids away and not let me see them, or decide he couldn’t take them hours before I was leaving on a business trip. He claimed he was working on that occasion, so I went to his workplace to politely ask if he was there ( never said reason why, and just looked like a wife popping in to drop something with DH). He wasn’t there, so I apologised for the mix up and said his phone wasn’t working and I thought I’d see if he was there.

His version of that story was that I caused a massive scene at his workplace and embarrassed him in front of all his colleagues. I only spoke to the receptionist.

should I have gone? No. But I was at the end of my tether due to a man who was continually hostile and refusing to co-parent effectively. I wouldn’t say I was as bad as the years of abuse and his appalling behaviour after the split.

OP posts:
Sunshinemorning · 17/01/2024 18:46

SeulementUneFois · 17/01/2024 11:50

The problem is that the matter of female on male abuse is taboo.
And hence there are potentially large numbers of such instances which are hidden and stay so forever, due to social conditioning.
Or even when things come out, they are swept under the carpet by friends and family, on both sides.

I'm on the other side of this. My DPs exw violently abused him for over a decade, every couple of weeks, with the kids in the house. I actually know this because I heard her admit it. (DP even has that recorded but noone gives a damn.)
He stayed for the kids. He kept it to himself completely fearing noone would be on his side. (Which ended up happening.)
Two years after they split she assaulted him again, in front of their 10 year old daughter. (All previous violence has been behind closed doors so the kids supposedly didn't know - as if. Remember, this was happening every few weeks )
This time he went to the police, she even couldn't deny it as her daughter was there. She got a slap on the wrist, a caution.

Noone gives a damn. All friends and family don't care about the abuse and stick with her. The kids of course have MH problems but exW is a saint in the eyes of society. Even DPs mum said she didn't want to take sides. When her own son used to be punched in the head for a decade.
(And no for the inevitable question I wasn't the OW, met him years after they split.)

Sorry your DP had to deal with that abuse. And it’s really sad that he isn’t believed.

I think part of the problem is that a lot of abusive men turn things around and say they are the ones being abused. So it makes those who have experience of DA wary. I once spoke to a director of a domestic violence charity and the topic of male victims came up- she was dismissive and implied there was no such thing.

I was pretty shocked tbh, but years later I reflect and think she came to that conclusion because that was the pattern she was seeing play out continually.

It doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen- it’s just rarer.

Some pps have said I only have my example to draw on, but it isn’t. It’s a pattern I see constantly. I’m involved in quite a few single parent groups and I’d say that in the case of bitter acrimonious divorces, it’s the man who is the problem 9 times out of ten.

I also think that almost every one of us has done something that could be called abusive- but it’s the frequency and intent of that behaviour that makes it abuse. For example, when does not talking to your partner become stonewalling?

OP posts:
Sunshinemorning · 17/01/2024 18:14

QueenOfTheLabyrinth · 17/01/2024 12:06

No I disagree, I think it’s more common than you think.

There are literally thread upon threads here from women complaining about “batshit” women be it their DM/MIL, DS/SIL, friend, work colleague etc. These women exist and they don’t suddenly turn into saints in their romantic relationships with men. A lot of the DM / DMIL threads usually feature an enabling FIL who goes along for a quiet life or posters are told they have a DP problem for not putting in boundaries in place with their families. If someone is a problematic person then they will have problems in a

You raise an interesting point- there are a lot of nasty people out there, who also happen to be women. Women are only human after all.

However, I think the ‘psycho ex’ phenomenon is a male one. Behaviour is massively gendered when it comes to divorce. And I think men generally struggle more with break ups than women.

It’s the loss of control over someone where they previously were ‘the man’ of the house.

I also think that it’s also the way men deal with conflict- they want to destroy their opponent.

OP posts:
Peteryourhorseishere · 17/01/2024 17:58

I am the psycho ex! The way my ex husband painted me, you’d think I was the devil.

In realty, I had horrendous PND and he dealt with that (ie ignored it because I was just mental), by shagging prostitutes on work trips. Doesn’t tell people that part.

I used to run a mile from any man who said his ex was nuts.

My now husband only spoke briefly and in good terms about his ex girlfriends. Explained they
had split up because you just don’t see it working long term, or that you’ve changed. He never once spoke badly of them. I liked that.

MaybeTooLate · 17/01/2024 17:54

I think it’s the word psycho that’s a particular red flag. Talking about difficult ex is fine- of course women can be difficult and cause problems, even be abusive- but there’s something about the word psycho which tends to tell you that it’s the bloke who was the problem.