Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think £290 for my prescription is insane?!

338 replies

Justintimeee · 17/01/2024 00:13

Posting here for traffic

I was diagnosed with ADHD 18 months ago and have been receiving monthly medication since.

I have been having follow up zoom calls with my psychiatrist every 6 weeks at a cost of £170. On top of that, to actually have the prescription written is £25 and the meds themselves are £95 so it is a huge cost for me.

The meds have completely turned my life around so I really do not want to go back to life without them.

The issue is, I can no longer afford to pay for the £170 follow ups so regularly. I have asked for a prescription but it has been refused if I don't book a follow up so I am at a loss... I had no idea they were mandatory for me to get medication when I have been diagnosed.

Do I just find another doctor? Is it the same everywhere? I have been refused shared care due to some NHS rules against accepting patients from private ADHD doctors so I don't know what to do.

I am in Essex if it helps.

OP posts:
ApiratesaysYarrr · 17/01/2024 09:20

There are no NHS rules that prevent shared care agreements with the private sector (if you were feeling particularly snarky, you might ask your GP practice to show you evidence of that rule), however many GP practices do not enter into shared care agreements with private providers, and some will not even do shared care with NHS secondary care services.

The key part is that it is a shared care agreement i.e. needs to be agreed by both sides. It's usually for prescribing specialist drugs that fall outside the scope of what is known as GMS (general medical service) which covers what a GP is expected to do.

Those GP practices that don't enter shared care with private sector will cite concerns about the potential quality of private care assessment/providers (many private care providers are of course providing a good, safe service, but not all are: some are run by non-doctors who cannot prescribe themselves, or based outside the UK, and in cases like that the sole responsibility and risk for prescribing is borne by the GP. Even with UK based services, if the patient can no longer afford private care, there is no quick safety net like there is in the NHS - if I dropped dead suddenly/got sacked, my colleagues would be fielding the queries/prescribing/assessments for my patients until they could employ a replacement - that doesn't happen in the private sector. For patients who suddenly stop using private services/service shuts this could mean a period of time where the GP is being asked to prescribe without any specialist support, or for some services potentially there may be no NHS equivalent, so GP prescribing indefinitely, or patient having to stop the medicine and their condition deteriorating.

Even as an NHS consultant, I can't insist that a GP prescribes anything - and the reverse is true.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 17/01/2024 09:20

HoppingPavlova · 17/01/2024 08:58

@bobomomo It's getting ridiculous now with just how low the bar is to get powerful stimulant drugs and nobody really knows the long term side effects

Well, given Ritalin has been taken since the mid 1950’s, I’d say the medical profession has a pretty good grip on this. Nearly 70 years experience with a medicine, which can pretty much also be extended to the class/newcomers of the same class (not all adhd meds belong to the same pharmacologic class though), and you don’t think anyone knows about long term side effects. Really?

I disagree. I think they do know what the drugs do, but don't like to admit thd harm they cause when they go wrong. My neurologist said I needed to actually avoid any medication like ADHD or epilepsy meds as they will make my movement disorder symptoms worse (and these medications are potentially a cause of my movement disorder too, as an adverse effect).

141mum · 17/01/2024 09:18

My GP changes my private scrip to an NHS one, try asking doc, at the end of the day you have already saved NHS money

Knitgoodwoman · 17/01/2024 09:18

Try the GP Op, I’ve recently been referred for an NHS ADHD diagnosis and was told it would take a few months, not years. Got the GP appointment within a few weeks as well.

WaitingForSunnyDaysAgain · 17/01/2024 09:18

I think it's so bloody weird the attitude that people have towards ADHD, as if we are just drug seekers

Accusations of drug seeking is the NHS's latest thing to beat patients up with, regardless of diagnosis. We've had issues with this too.

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 17/01/2024 09:16

TheYearOfSmallThings · 17/01/2024 09:08

Honestly I do think there are private psychiatrists (not all) who will diagnose what they are asked to diagnose, and prescribe what they are asked to prescribe, within reason. That is exactly what they are getting paid to do, and their income would disappear if they didn't dish out diagnoses and prescriptions pretty freely.

The NHS leans too far the other way, but there are risks to both patterns tbh, and one is more fueled by self interest than the other.

Exactly 💯 You said very succinctly what I was trying to say lol 😆

WaitingForSunnyDaysAgain · 17/01/2024 09:13

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 17/01/2024 08:56

Disagree - it was extremely dangerous of her not to fill an existing prescription and leave me without medication that would have needed to be titrated down not just stopped abruptly.

I'm the daughter of a GP - he was horrified, as was the senior partner in my practice. If you are not comfortable because you have zero knowledge of that particular area then pass over to one of others in the practice, don't just refuse.

Consultant was also furious - they ended up getting me an emergency supply - so she wasted huge amounts of time and resources.

Edited

We've had similiar with my son. He has a serious disability, more than one GP has said they aren't comfortable with his meds, one said he didn't need them and he had to miss a few days until we could get hold of his consultant and an emergency prescription. The meds can't be abruptly stopped and it really set him back.
The arrogance of the GP was unbelievable, consultant was furious. It doesn't help that we can't see the same GP twice, so everytime we have to go through the whole rigmarole of explaining why he isn't prescribed x,y,z meds instead. Even had one prescribe a med that had a very dangerous interaction, fortunately the pharmacist caught that.

CharlotteBog · 17/01/2024 09:12

I was diagnosed in the NHS psychiatrist’s waiting room before I had said a word😂

How did they do that?

ForeverDelayedEpiphany · 17/01/2024 09:12

KarenNotAKaren · 17/01/2024 00:42

OP I would suggest watching the Panorama documentary on private ADHD diagnoses and how they’re basically big money making scams. Be very careful, I know the wait is unbearable but a NHS diagnosis is more robust and they aren’t looking to make a monthly profit from you

I agree with this, although i can see both sides of the story too.

My movement disorder called tardive dyskinesia was diagnosed by a private neurologist, who had worked for both the NHS and privately. He said he had seen "hundreds of people who had TD, some of whom were falling off the bed with the symptoms "... yet three of the other neurologists that I saw before my diagnosis (which I actually self diagnosed) were quick to dismiss my movement disorder, and blame it on being their good old "functional neurological disorder", or in other words: a cop-out diagnosis so we don't have to admit these drugs cause harm.

I can very much believe that private psychiatrists are falling over themselves to get more patients and "overdiagnose" conditions like ADHD. Of course, not everyone who genuinely has ADHD will be diagnosed wrongly, and vice versa, and I'm not discredting anyone who suffers from these things.

But I do thing certain conditions and mental health problems have been "medicalised" to the point where we see more people saying "i have a psychological disorder", whereas they are just possibly feeling the range of normal human emotions.

It is a fine line between the two, i guess. The cynic in me says these things are overdiagnosed for a profit, and ego-boost for the doctors. The less cynical side of me can totally understand the frustration of being unwell, with no resources to fall back on easily for support.

Branleuse · 17/01/2024 09:11

Pyramintdreamer · 17/01/2024 02:22

If we take the issue around whether the private doctors are appropriately qualified out of the equation and just look at it from purely ethical grounds then surely if those who can afford the private assessment all decide to pay to do so it alleviates the pressure on the system enabling those who can't afford to pay to also access the assessment more quickly? I think that is the point that's being made? That the huge waiting list is for the assesment and after that it's just the prescription which should be relatively easy to continue on a repeat prescription. I don't see the issue with people paying for private treatment if they can afford to do so unless I'm missing something?

Yeah it's really odd. On one hand they are dismantling and privatising the NHS so that people have huge extended waiting lists, and people are encouraged to pay privately for all sorts of things now, but for ADHD in particular even the fully qualified psychiatrists are apparently just diagnosing anyone with it for a laugh ?

So my psychiatrist who diagnosed me and my son, who works for a private company that we were referred to by NHS. Is she good or bad?

I think it's so bloody weird the attitude that people have towards ADHD, as if we are just drug seekers or trying to excuse our terrible personal flaws and get away with stuff, rather than just trying to lead a normal life as much as possible.
My medication has been life changing for me and my son, ( although not for everyone, my second son is also diagnosed but hates the way medication made him feel so he's decided to not go that route after trying it. My niece said the same - it's not for everyone)

nolongersurprised · 17/01/2024 09:09

That seems very expensive, even for a private script.

In Australia most medications are funded by the government- there’s a list - and it doesn’t matter if they’re prescribed privately or publicly, the cost is the same when you go to the pharmacy.

Under this scheme, for lisdexamfetamine (vyvanse here) the cost is $6.70 if you have a concession card (low income, chronic health issues, older etc), $30 if you don’t, most children with ADHD are eligible for a concession card.

If the medication you want ISN’T covered by the government then you pay full, non subsidised price. For Vyvanse this would happen if you weren’t diagnosed as a child with ADHD and you didn’t fulfil the criteria for a retrospective diagnosis (ie had as a child but not picked up then). Then, the full cost is $95 for a month’s supply. The long-acting methylphenidate types are similar.

If the non-subsidised, full price is $95 of a long-acting stimulant it seems odd that full price in the UK is twice as much.

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 17/01/2024 09:08

HenndigoOZ · 17/01/2024 08:59

Aren’t stimulants controlled medications in the UK? My son doesn’t take them anymore but when he did, his paediatrician had to call a government line and get an authorisation to prescribe for any new medication or dosage change and this authorisation then went on his prescription. So it makes it difficult for an unlicensed and unqualified person to dispense this class of medication. Also, the quantities dispensed were regulated, so you couldn’t get your repeat until the previous bottle was finished, so only every 30 days. I found the process very regulated, compared to other pharmaceuticals. This is in Australia where most ADHD treatment is private. Most specialists who do private also work in the public sector too.

Yes, stimulants are controlled medication in the UK. I have to take my passport in to collect DD's meds, but I don't think any calls are needed to government lines.

Don't have to prove previous ones are finished either - we have long acting for weekdays and short acting for 'as needed' top ups so always have a supply of those that are used infrequently.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 17/01/2024 09:08

Honestly I do think there are private psychiatrists (not all) who will diagnose what they are asked to diagnose, and prescribe what they are asked to prescribe, within reason. That is exactly what they are getting paid to do, and their income would disappear if they didn't dish out diagnoses and prescriptions pretty freely.

The NHS leans too far the other way, but there are risks to both patterns tbh, and one is more fueled by self interest than the other.

CoasttoCoastlines · 17/01/2024 09:08

I'm not sure that discussing personal experiences or the ethics of whether too much prescribing is helpful to the OP.

There is obviously a huge range of personal experiences, across the UK but none of those actually help her because she's already explained what the decision is of her GP.

The only thing she can do is to discuss the financial side and the very frequent reviews with the dr treating her.

If they are aware of her situation they may agree to fewer reviews. They choose how often to do those and they are running a business.

@Justintimeee Contact the dr and tell them you can't afford reviews every 6 weeks, so what can they suggest.

OldTinHat · 17/01/2024 09:07

I had my diagnosis on the NHS last year after an 18 month wait.

Where I live, there's an adult ADHD clinic who send out prescriptions to the local pharmacy (or you can collect directly from the clinic) so you just pay the normal prescription charge - or not if you're exempt.

Is there a facility like this where you live that you could switch to?

HenndigoOZ · 17/01/2024 08:59

KarenNotAKaren · 17/01/2024 08:03

Yeah, except it’s not. Plenty of people happy and willing to use their ‘expertise’ to take advantage of vulnerable people. Snake oil merchants, it’s been happening since humans first set foot on soil!

Aren’t stimulants controlled medications in the UK? My son doesn’t take them anymore but when he did, his paediatrician had to call a government line and get an authorisation to prescribe for any new medication or dosage change and this authorisation then went on his prescription. So it makes it difficult for an unlicensed and unqualified person to dispense this class of medication. Also, the quantities dispensed were regulated, so you couldn’t get your repeat until the previous bottle was finished, so only every 30 days. I found the process very regulated, compared to other pharmaceuticals. This is in Australia where most ADHD treatment is private. Most specialists who do private also work in the public sector too.

HoppingPavlova · 17/01/2024 08:58

@bobomomo It's getting ridiculous now with just how low the bar is to get powerful stimulant drugs and nobody really knows the long term side effects

Well, given Ritalin has been taken since the mid 1950’s, I’d say the medical profession has a pretty good grip on this. Nearly 70 years experience with a medicine, which can pretty much also be extended to the class/newcomers of the same class (not all adhd meds belong to the same pharmacologic class though), and you don’t think anyone knows about long term side effects. Really?

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 17/01/2024 08:56

notmorezoom · 17/01/2024 08:53

It is entirely appropriate for a GP who feels that something is outside of their expertise not to prescribe as the medicolegal liability lies entirely with the person who signs their prescription and patronising comments such as 'well no dea' aren't helpful. Those GPs who will sign anything put in front of them are dangerous.

Disagree - it was extremely dangerous of her not to fill an existing prescription and leave me without medication that would have needed to be titrated down not just stopped abruptly.

I'm the daughter of a GP - he was horrified, as was the senior partner in my practice. If you are not comfortable because you have zero knowledge of that particular area then pass over to one of others in the practice, don't just refuse.

Consultant was also furious - they ended up getting me an emergency supply - so she wasted huge amounts of time and resources.

notmorezoom · 17/01/2024 08:53

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 17/01/2024 08:51

We saw the GP for DD's ADHD referral - he looked at the history (hers and wider family) and the 2-3 year waiting list and strongly advised us to go private if we could possibly afford it and then pop in the forms for shared care.

Diagnosed 2 months later via a former very senior NHS psychiatrist who now has a private practice - took 6 months to get titration right and prescriptions are now passed over to GP and 6 monthly reviews with the private practice.

It's a complete postcode lottery - and down to the views of the individual GP.

I had another GP in the same practice refuse to prescribe medication that my NHS consultant had asked for (for a completely different physical issue) - because she personally didn't approve... despite saying to me "I'm not an expert in this area so I don't feel comfortable" - well, no dear, that's why the prescription has been issued by someone who is an expert. The arrogance was quite something. Happily one of the partners at the surgery was more than happy and did a lot of eye-rolling over the waste of time and resources caused by his colleague's dislike of a particular group of meds that she admitted she knew nothing about.

So well worth shopping around for a more pragmatic GP or GP surgery.

BTW, Right to Choose also a postcode lottery - some areas are no longer allowing this as so many have used it due to the waiting lists.

Edited

It is entirely appropriate for a GP who feels that something is outside of their expertise not to prescribe as the medicolegal liability lies entirely with the person who signs their prescription and patronising comments such as 'well no dea' aren't helpful. Those GPs who will sign anything put in front of them are dangerous.

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 17/01/2024 08:51

We saw the GP for DD's ADHD referral - he looked at the history (hers and wider family) and the 2-3 year waiting list and strongly advised us to go private if we could possibly afford it and then pop in the forms for shared care.

Diagnosed 2 months later via a former very senior NHS psychiatrist who now has a private practice - took 6 months to get titration right and prescriptions are now passed over to GP and 6 monthly reviews with the private practice.

It's a complete postcode lottery - and down to the views of the individual GP.

I had another GP in the same practice refuse to prescribe medication that my NHS consultant had asked for (for a completely different physical issue) - because she personally didn't approve... despite saying to me "I'm not an expert in this area so I don't feel comfortable" - well, no dear, that's why the prescription has been issued by someone who is an expert. The arrogance was quite something. Happily one of the partners at the surgery was more than happy and did a lot of eye-rolling over the waste of time and resources caused by his colleague's dislike of a particular group of meds that she admitted she knew nothing about.

So well worth shopping around for a more pragmatic GP or GP surgery.

BTW, Right to Choose also a postcode lottery - some areas are no longer allowing this as so many have used it due to the waiting lists.

notmorezoom · 17/01/2024 08:42

Justintimeee · 17/01/2024 07:53

Thanks for your responses everyone. I am more annoyed that I keep needing to have these expensive follow ups to be allowed medication... I am happy to pay for my meds and prescription but the excessive follow ups are just too much and so expensive. Staying private, does anyone know of any ADHD clinics that don't require regular follow ups?

how often are the follow-ups? I'd expect every 4-6 weeks when titrating meds, then when stable probably one at 3 months, and then every 6 months long-term.

Hankunamatata · 17/01/2024 08:32

Lots of trusts are refusing adult referrals due to medication shortages and long waiting lists for children to get diagnosis

writingmylifeaway · 17/01/2024 08:30

Did you see the Panorama about private ADHD diagnoses? All about the money they can get from people.

Not saying your diagnosis is incorrect but it's why you can't just move over to NHS as lots of them are wrong!

Yalta · 17/01/2024 08:29

*Willyoujustbequiet · Today 07:38

It's because many private diagnoses are meaningless and not worth the paper they are written on.

I know someone who was repeatedly refused by the NHS who chose to go private and was diagnosed after a 20 minute phone call.

These are controlled drugs that can have serious side effects. I'm not surprised the NHS questions the validity of some private firms.

ADHD, to my knowledge, must have symptoms present from childhood. They do not happen overnight. I would imagine in most cases this would evidence a medical history at the GP which warrants referral to CAMHS. As happened with my dc. Ours were done on the NHS within 4 months. I realise it's a postcode lottery but there is choose and book. I would seek an NHS diagnosis tbh*

I was diagnosed in the NHS psychiatrist’s waiting room before I had said a word😂

I then had to go through the forms I had filled in and at the end I scored 9/9 in both sections.

I always wonder what my life would have been like if someone had just looked at me for a few seconds and realised that something was seriously not right.

It was my dd who came to me with a list of symptoms she had found when she was googling why she did certain things
which others just didn’t do and asked whether I thought the symptoms applied to her now (young adult) and when she was a child.

I looked and said I had all those symptoms even as a child and I don’t have ADHD.
12 weeks later I came out of the psychiatrists office clutching my first prescription of Elvanse 20mg. I would have been diagnosed 4 weeks earlier if I had got round to filling the forms in.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 17/01/2024 08:26

TwiddlingMyToes · 17/01/2024 07:33

My son has ADHD and was diagnosed and is medicated through the NHS. Only he (and many many others around the country) haven't been able to get their meds for months now. According to my GP, this is due to a huge upsurge in private doctors handing out diagnoses and medication, which has resulted in a shortage of meds nationwide.

So while I am kind of sympathetic, it's still also very frustrating for those of us who haven't got a private diagnosis, as apparently the meds are there if you're paying for them!

That's awful for your son, sounds a bit like the difficulty diabetic patients have been having getting their wegovey I think it's due to all the private purchases of it for weight loss?

Swipe left for the next trending thread