Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's being unreasonable regarding Will

146 replies

Freshpinkroses · 16/01/2024 23:03

Name changed as this could be outing and I'd rather avoid extra tension while trying to figure out what's fair.

So, bit of a background: my husband is 18 years older than me (54) and he has just one older sibling which is brother (66), his brother has 6 children. My husband barely knows his brothers kids and he sees his brother very infrequently (about once every 5 years or so on average).

I'm 36, we have a 4 year old daughter and I'm currently pregnant and due to give birth in September. I have 2 sisters and 2 brothers who my husband and I see every single week, so we're really close (we did have a little fallout this year but everything is good now). Also my sisters each have one child.

The reason for the background is that my husband and I need to write a will, we haven't got one and since we're about to have another child we just feel it's really irresponsible that we don't have this stuff sorted out. We agreed on everything in the Will in the event of either of our deaths as in who we'd make the children's guardian and who would be the trustees etc. What we can't agree on is in the event us and our children died, who our estate would be left to. Even though my husband is older than me, we each bring an almost equal amount to the table (he brings about 20% more than me right now but my earnings are increasing each year so this will level off). The total value of estate is about £3m. He believes most of this should go to his brother and his brothers children??? I can't understand his logic for this and it's really infuriating me as he said himself he wants my sister to be our children's guardian if we were to die, yet he'd want to give his brother almost everything if us and our children were to pass. I personally believe our estate should be divided equally amongst all our brothers and sisters at very least and I'm even willing to flex and let him give his brother 20% more than my siblings. What are your thoughts on this?

YABU- his brother should get majority (roughly 80%)
YANBU - it should be divided close to equally amongst all of the siblings

I welcome any other ideas/thoughts on this.

Thank you in advance!!

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 17/01/2024 11:15

I would be wary of nominating a charity in the disaster clause. They have legal teams who are total vultures.

Friend of the family died and left a similarly sized estate. A clause in the will was siezed upon by the charity's legal team to try and claim that the intended inheritors were excluded so the charity should get the whole estate.

This would have disinherited the family friend's young adult children who were all fit, well and very much alive. Not to mention grieving at tge loss of their parent.

@Freshpinkroses it does sound like your DH has a total blind spot when it comes to his DB. Your wills could stand for 20 years or more. Has your DH considered the inheritance laws where DB currently lives? This could be creating an inheritance nightmare for all involved.

HoHoHoliday · 17/01/2024 10:58

What I would advise is that you drop the discussion for now and agree to revisit it in a year or however long you think appropriate. All it's doing is causing an argument between you and your husband at a time when you should be trying to relax and prepare for a new baby.
The most important provision is what happens to your children in the event of the death of both parents, so as long as you have that sorted the rest can wait. Because, bluntly, if all four of you die then you won't be able to care what happens.

TempleOfBloom · 17/01/2024 10:55

If you all go together your will specifies where your estate goes, and his, his.

So leave all your half to your DSis and he leaves his as he thinks fit.

He can’t control your assets in your will.

HJ40 · 17/01/2024 10:52

DH is totally unreasonable, for all the reasons pp have stated to do with fairness, age, and so on.

It's very important to have a disaster/catastrophe clause, unlikely as it seems. Sometime tragedies happen.

Ironically, what's more like to happen is that (due to the age gap) DH will die before OP. At that point OP inherits everything and would be sensible to update her will.

First beneficiaries would obviously be DC, and GC if there are any by then. The OP can then set her own catastrophe clause, and ENTIRELY EXCLUDE the BIL and his DC should she want to 😂.

If I were the DH, I'd be being a bit more measured in my demands!

Tempnamechng · 17/01/2024 10:45

I think this is far too doom and gloom. You are right to have a solicitor involved, but its so incredibly unlikely that all of you will pass together, so my advice would be to put it out of your head altogether and choose a favourite charity. You are causing yourself unnecessary stress and what if arguments when you are pregnant due to a pessimistic solicitor.

Bellyblueboy · 17/01/2024 10:33

Of course you are right and he is wrong about the will.

I wonder why he is so set on an outcome that is so obviously unfair? Is he generally unreasonable and dismissive of your views? What is your relationship like otherwise - equal?

does he want to play the big man (posthumously!) to his family se they believe the money was all his?

i would find his lack of common sense and fairness a real turn off

Muchof · 17/01/2024 10:14

Aquamarine1029 · 16/01/2024 23:17

Yes, this. This is what I meant to say. I was too hasty and didn't clarify. @Changethetoner is spot on.

Well apart from the fact OP is discussing the scenario of the whole family being wiped out, OP, husband and her children.

LittleOwl153 · 17/01/2024 09:56

I would stop the messing around and say to him, you deal with your 50% as you wish, however my family is getting mine. And be done.

It would however make me relook at anything he was getting if you died first - as he is likely to hand that to his brother rather than your kids or your family by the sounds of things. I'd be making sure your kids got the majority of your 50% if you go first...

SleepingisanArt · 17/01/2024 09:11

We decided to leave everything to charity if that happened - the logic being that our families had their own money so didn't need ours. Children are now adults so it is unlikely that we'll all be wiped out together so they will inherit.

Nazzywish · 17/01/2024 09:05

His approach has no logic to it and is unfair. He's going over the fairness threshold for what exactly? He can't explain it so don't accept it.

Your logic is the correct one and you need to stand firm especially when you've put all your inheritance etc in and it's equally contributed to.

Tinselunderthetv · 17/01/2024 08:44

His brother, due to age would likely end of leaving a load to his DC. Your DH need needs to give his head a wobble. The catastrophe clause is very rarely needed.

We did 50/50 to our families, each choosing where the 50% goes, then plan to forget about it. If we all go at once our family all get something from our hard work. I have purposely not included a toxic sibling in mine.

ManchesterBea · 17/01/2024 08:03

What he wants, and what he can have seem like they are two different things.

Surely you can both just decide what 50% goes to?

Why does he feel like he gets the final say?

And if he doesn't feel like he gets the final say, then, why is it even an issue, you both decide 50%.

EpsilonMaltravers · 17/01/2024 07:53

When we made our wills, in this scenario we each decided where 50% would go to. I chose one of my siblings as that was my preference for my “half” and my DH chose his only sibling for his “half”.

Copasetic · 17/01/2024 07:49

I read up to a point and could see everyone misreading the question and the circumstances. Then I could see it being said that if you all died together then it is assumed the youngest died last and intestacy kicks in and all aunts and uncles are treated equally. I remember many years ago studying probate and learning a long list of the order of relatives that the intestacy rules divided the estate between. At the time relatives of the half blood were not treated the same as relatives of the whole blood. I'm not sure on the situation now but is it possible that the whole estate could go to the husband's brother on the basis that he is of the whole blood?

barkymcbark · 17/01/2024 07:48

You each decide where your own half would go.'surely it's a simple as that. You can leave your half to your sister, and your dh can leave his to his brother or the local cats home

Passingthethyme · 17/01/2024 07:27

Also remember everyone is dead so you won't care anyway. Don't waste too much energy on this

Passingthethyme · 17/01/2024 07:26

HDready · 16/01/2024 23:12

In the event that you and your immediate family all die, I would split 50/50. 50% to your husband’s brother and 50% shared between your 4 siblings. It’s such a remote possibility, it’s really not worth spending much time thinking about.

I'd probably just do this. 50/50 seems fair then you both do with it what you want. I can see your husband POV, if my partner had lots if siblings why should they all get a chunk of my half because there are more of them

user1492757084 · 17/01/2024 07:04

To leave 80% to your DH older brother would be grossly unfair should the following happen ..

You and your husband die so your sister spends ten years raising your children with the help of funds from your estate but also generously donating emotional and physical care.

When one of your children starts to drive both kids have a terrible car accident and both die, too young unfortunately.

The remainder of your estate then goes 80% to the older brother. That seems unfair given that your sister reared your children.

sammylady37 · 17/01/2024 06:10

Aquamarine1029 · 16/01/2024 23:17

Yes, this. This is what I meant to say. I was too hasty and didn't clarify. @Changethetoner is spot on.

Far from being ‘spot on’, that poster and you clearly failed to correctly read and/or comprehend the op.

Zanatdy · 17/01/2024 05:18

Edited original post as misunderstood. Surely you just do 50/50 if he’s insistent this family get the same as yours which is fair. No way should they get most of it

PickledPurplePickle · 17/01/2024 05:15

I’m with you

if you all die, then the estate is split 50:50 ans each half goes to the respective sides

YDHIBU

Nanaof1 · 17/01/2024 05:04

Freshpinkroses · 16/01/2024 23:11

@Enko and @LittleOwl153 sorry I should have stated that his brothers children and my sisters children would be included in the divide of the estate so my husbands side would be getting more than 50% of the entire estate anyway.

Sorry, but in the 1/100M chance that you all die together, the will should give 50% to your siblings and 50% to his siblings. It is your siblings who can give money to their children as they wish. It is ludicrous to even entertain the notion that the brother should get a higher percentage. Your DH is trying to play BMOC by "showing" his brother how important and well-off he is, to the detriment of your family.
Whatever you do, be sure to update the will as needed, as old outdated wills can also be troublesome.
As you are already doing, I am sure, is that if you and your DH die, since your sister would raise the children, the money would go into trust for the children, with an amount to be used for their care by the sister each year, a certain amount for the children to use for university and then they can inherit the remainder at whatever age you think they are most likely ready to be in charge of that amount of money.

SighedAndSmiled · 17/01/2024 04:27

JobMatch3000 · 16/01/2024 23:19

In the event that both me and DH and the DCs all die in an unlikely catastrophic tragic event, our Estate goes to charity.

Well those charity bosses will be happy, in this most unhappy event.
Id rather my family might benefit, even if they were remote relatives, if I had no close family.

I don’t agree with most charities existing though.
Fat cats paying themselves huge salaries from your donations

Anisette · 17/01/2024 03:41

budgiegirl · 17/01/2024 00:01

Take 50% each and decide how you want your half split between your family

OP, given your latest post, then I think this is good advice. You leave your 50% to your siblings and their children, he can leave his 50% just to his brother if he chooses, or split it between his brother and his brothers children. The 80% thing is just odd.

I think you would also have to write in something to protect the money for your siblings in the event that you predecease your husband and your children don't survive you.

Codlingmoths · 17/01/2024 03:26

You don’t have to leave it to the courts, because you write a will with a 30 day clause that says if your husband dies within 30 days your children get it, if they too die within 30 days of you then you wish your entire estate to be divided amongst your siblings. Tell your dh if he wants to give 80% to his brother you’ve never met that is totally unfair to you and your love for your family , he won’t compromise or recognise this so your will gives your estate entirely to your siblings. Or, you could agree something your both happy with, but it’s that or you both put something that makes the other miserable.

its just so self-centred of him that he thinks he gets to decide to hand just about all your joint assets off to his side of the family, I’d be really put off by this. Id say petty things like my sister is coming to tea, I guess since I’m still alive you don’t begrudge her a sandwich?