Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am i being u reasonable not doing dinner for my 18 year old step daughter?

192 replies

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 20:49

Long story short, my 18 year old step daughter of 12 years does nothing, no job no education and doesnt lift a finger around the house. I have 3 other children and another step daughter. They all have their chores i.e unload dishwasher, sweep floor help clean table and they all do it. Thier ages are 4, 5, 6 and 12 they all do there bit, but my 18 year old has not done nothing in over two years. I stopped doing her washing 4 months ago cause i never even got a thank you. She does nothing me and her dad have tried our hardest to support her but she has been so disrespectful and also bullies her younger siblings. I cook our children thier dinner earlier than mine and thier dads and often we offered to her she said "i will eat it later" and then it would go to waste and she would never clean her plate. So now i dont dish her up a plate, i always cook extra anyways but as i dont put it on a plate for her she will cook herself noodles and then go eat her room which she knows she isint aloud to do as she caused a mice problem last year. And as she knows she isint aloud she waits for me and her dad to go to bed. So im sorry if its too much but am i being unreasonable to stop doing her dinners?

OP posts:
Mountainclimber2024 · 16/01/2024 22:52

I would worry when the money runs out as if she has no access to money it may escalate.

How did she do in her GCSE’s or high school equivalent if you are not in the UK?

Pussygaloregalapagos · 16/01/2024 22:48

This is a sad story. It sounds Lile you are trying but not much working yet. Keep trying. Keep showing up and modelling good behaviour to her. There is a world of pain for her to get through but what would really help would be a sense of purpose. If she has money could it go towards a healing type holiday for say her and her sister?

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 22:47

MercanDede · 16/01/2024 22:42

That doesn’t add up. The 12yr old was 10yrs old when this happened, but the just turned 18yr old was 17yrs old? Whatever. She was a child, she’s not culpable. And it doesn’t make her into a child abuser ffs

I never called her a abuser

OP posts:
Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 22:46

Spomsored · 16/01/2024 22:37

It's obvious you're struggling but so is she. And she has been troubled and unhappy since before she was a teenager. You need some conversations with her and her father about what she wants from life - her savings won't last forever. This isn't something which will be sorted with one chat either. When she says "Throw me out and I'll get a council house" calmly help her to investigate social housing in your area - how they're allocated, waiting lists, costs, where young single people are temporarily housed. Presumably she is coping with her own laundry since you stopped doing it, so congratulate her if that's the case. It's not much but better than nothing. If she ever returns a cup to the kitchen or rinses her plate say thanks, I know it's the least she can do but you need to find something she's not doing wrong. And she needs therapy/counselling because she can't do this alone (probably her sister does too or will do in the future).

She can't endanger your other children though so it's a difficult path to tread

Edited

Everything you put is spot on i have done her washing she takes it to her boyfriend and his mum washes it. We have lived in our house for nearly a year with be a year in feb and she has never washed a plated or cup. Her sister does do counselling for her mum and she was burned over 40% of her body in her mums care at the age of 7. Her sister bullys her for this. Her scars and the fact "she cant wear shorts of skirts coz boys with be disgusted " so yer i am struggling and her dad is even more. Its makes me more upset seeing him trying and trying and then he breaks down

OP posts:
MercanDede · 16/01/2024 22:42

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 22:38

Sorry should i have put her birth date she has turned 18 in the past 2 months

That doesn’t add up. The 12yr old was 10yrs old when this happened, but the just turned 18yr old was 17yrs old? Whatever. She was a child, she’s not culpable. And it doesn’t make her into a child abuser ffs

MercanDede · 16/01/2024 22:40

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 22:33

She just turned 17 and she only had the printer for 2 weeks (bday presents) and the boy she was with was just 16 they where together 6 months nd she is older

As she was a child, it’s not prosecutable as child abuse. Because children are presumed to not know they are doing something wrong when it comes to sharing photos of themselves. It’s a stretch for posters to say she is not safe to be around her sister based on this.

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 22:38

MercanDede · 16/01/2024 22:35

Then how is the 10yr old now a 12yr old if this happened when she was 17 and she is 18 now?

Sorry should i have put her birth date she has turned 18 in the past 2 months

OP posts:
Mountainclimber2024 · 16/01/2024 22:37

How much money did she get when she turned 18? Is it likely to runout? If yes when?

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 22:37

Sorry should i have put her birth date she has turned 18 in the past 2 months

OP posts:
Spomsored · 16/01/2024 22:37

It's obvious you're struggling but so is she. And she has been troubled and unhappy since before she was a teenager. You need some conversations with her and her father about what she wants from life - her savings won't last forever. This isn't something which will be sorted with one chat either. When she says "Throw me out and I'll get a council house" calmly help her to investigate social housing in your area - how they're allocated, waiting lists, costs, where young single people are temporarily housed. Presumably she is coping with her own laundry since you stopped doing it, so congratulate her if that's the case. It's not much but better than nothing. If she ever returns a cup to the kitchen or rinses her plate say thanks, I know it's the least she can do but you need to find something she's not doing wrong. And she needs therapy/counselling because she can't do this alone (probably her sister does too or will do in the future).

She can't endanger your other children though so it's a difficult path to tread

MercanDede · 16/01/2024 22:35

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 22:33

She just turned 17 and she only had the printer for 2 weeks (bday presents) and the boy she was with was just 16 they where together 6 months nd she is older

Then how is the 10yr old now a 12yr old if this happened when she was 17 and she is 18 now?

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 22:33

MercanDede · 16/01/2024 22:11

And showing them naked boyfriend/girlfriend photos is abuse.
No it’s not. The photos might be evidence of the step DD being sexually abused/raped though as they are at least two years old from the OP’s chronology. She could have been 16, or under 16 at the time of the sex in the photos.

Edited

She just turned 17 and she only had the printer for 2 weeks (bday presents) and the boy she was with was just 16 they where together 6 months nd she is older

OP posts:
MercanDede · 16/01/2024 22:32

Wait17 · 16/01/2024 22:25

Showing naked pictures to a 10 year old is a form of sexual abuse so it's child abuse. For that alone she needs to leave because the younger siblings are not safe around her. If one of the siblings says anything at school, then your children will be considered to have suffered child abuse

She did it when she was 16!! And the photos could have been of her being underage (being raped).

You don’t ignore something that happened two years ago and then kick them out as soon as they are 18.

I am wondering why you are so concerned about a 10yr old seeing photos of nudity but not about the potentially underage girl that was in the photos, naked, and presumably having sex.

How is she not safe around younger siblings? She was the girl in the photo that was at a maximum barely 16, potentially younger. She was the victim. She is not an abuser.

Azerothi · 16/01/2024 22:29

If you stopped doing her washing simply because (in your own words) she didn't thank you, I think you are being far too harsh. Is the 12 year old her full sister?

When you started dating this man when this 12 year old child was a newborn what did you think was going to happen? And, yes I think you are out of order to stop making her (18 year old) meals. She needs support and kindness, although I think you and your boyfriend/her father have left it far too late.

MercanDede · 16/01/2024 22:29

I am sorry for your loss, losing a child is a completely different kettle of fish, unique in its pain and agony.

Would she go back to art college? She must want something, even if it is not to be miserable. If she has buy in and some control over her future she will not fight and refuse you and her Dad every step of the way.

An alcoholic mum that neglects you and plays favourites is abusive btw. It doesn’t sound as horrific as the abuse you suffered, but it’s on the scale.

She was telling her sister her truth. Yes it’s not what you think her sister should hear, but you can’t really punish a child that is hurting for being honest. That would be a good moment to tell both of them yes therapy can be crap. It doesn’t always get it right, that’s why you have to not give up on it. It’s the same with medication for mental illness, different ones work for different people.

There is no reason why dishes would be in a room for a month. That’s what a depressed person ends up doing, dad should be stepping up and going in and getting the dishes out once a day. She needs support, not punishment.

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 22:27

Andthereyougo · 16/01/2024 22:18

It must be tempting to tell her to move out but I’d really fear for her safety. She would be really vulnerable to abuse as she’d be desperate for love.
Only suggestion I can make is having you and her dad chat to her with no other kids in the house. Point out she’s 18, technically an adult, time to step up now and work. Can you make her room into a bed sit? No cooking facilities ( could have her own kettle, mini fridge ) but maybe a small sofa? https://www.amazon.co.uk/OFCASA-Portable-Bedrooms-Thermoelectric-Refrigerator/dp/B09W8W4PRT/ref=asc_df_B09W8W4PRT/?tag=googshopuk-21&linkCode=df0&hvadid=641814015358&hvpos=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=6870201380546781019&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=c&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9045798&hvtargid=pla-2005580674220&psc=1&mcid=0a16a7801f06368eb24e82f3c1223def
You could have a behavioural agreement — she gets the better room/fridge etc.. she steps up with chores and no bullying of younger ones.

If she won’t accept counselling you can’t force her but always keep that as an option. I know a counsellor specialising in bereavement and she’s said that even if children have counselling after bereavement it frequently comes back “to bite them on the bum” in teenage years.

Edited

Thanks for your comment she has a fridge and kettle 18th bday presents. We are quite lucky were we live as we all have double rooms with ensuites so they are all "better" rooms. Also just to add she does have her own money as when she turned 18 she got her savings that me, her dad and grandparents set up for her.

OP posts:
Wait17 · 16/01/2024 22:25

Showing naked pictures to a 10 year old is a form of sexual abuse so it's child abuse. For that alone she needs to leave because the younger siblings are not safe around her. If one of the siblings says anything at school, then your children will be considered to have suffered child abuse

Doggymummar · 16/01/2024 22:24

Thus girl is crying out for help, 😞

Lightermoon · 16/01/2024 22:23

i would think she is rebelling because she is unhappy but doesn’t know how to grieve. Have you contacted grief charities. Is there a plan for job/college. I think it’s hard but putting to many rules in place is going to make her rebel more. If she is happy to cook her own food I would say that’s ok. But maybe a couple of times a week she needs to eat with you. Can you speak to her and involve her with plans so they don’t seem like rules? Maybe try contacting the school nursing team for your area they should be up to 19. Hopefully they could help. Also if possible can your husband make time with her alone even once a week, it sounds like she needs it.

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/01/2024 22:22

I volunteered for a while in a youth offenders unit. And I've worked extensively with offenders in the past. Almost every one has a couple of things. Over and over you see it. Witnessing violence and/or a significant bereavement at a young age.

You cannot overstate this troubled relationship with a mother who then died. It's bone deep pain.

You need family therapy even if she won't attend.

Ghentsummer · 16/01/2024 22:22

So she was 6 and her sister just a baby when you started a relationship with her dad? That could itself be quite traumatic depending onthe circumstances of him leaving the family home. Then she was treated badly by her mum so she moved to her dad's and refused to see her mum around age 11. At age 12 she was groomed by paedophiles and your husband's response was just to confiscate her phone. At 13 her mum died and her dad had a newborn, a baby and a toddler with you so how much parenting did she actually get at a time when she needed it most?

Her behaviour is horrible but she has been severely let down by the adults in her life. Is it really that surprising she's traumatised?

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 22:21

MercanDede · 16/01/2024 22:02

YANBU to not cook your 18yo step DD dinner because she doesn’t want it anyway.

YABU for the rest of it.

Let her eat in her room. If you’re worried about mice, ask her to return her dishes to the sink before bed. Dirty dishes in her room attracting mice is partially because she is trying to avoid being confronted about eating in her room or making her own food. Just unclench a bit.

Her mum died 4 years ago and you say she refused to see her the last 2 years of her mum’s life. You say she hated her mum. Going on a limb here, was her mum abusive? This will make her grief that much more complex and hard to process. She is allowed to think the therapy she got was “crap” because some therapy and therapist are in fact crap some are worse than crap.

Where is her dad in all of this? Why is your step DD welfare seemingly all on you?

I don’t know why either of you expected her to be able to concentrate on GCSEs, A levels or working.

This barely adult needs help. I see she refused help, well how many times has her Dad tried to find someone she could talk to? Has he got support from charities, from young people’s services? Has he validated that the therapy she did get was crap, but to keep looking because the reality is therapy is hit or miss until you find what works?

Please do not punish an already traumatised teenager. Her mum dying four years ago probably still feels like yesterday to her. Have you lost your mum yet? Talk to other teens who lose a parent young, it’s not the same as being 45+ and a parent dying. It’s much much worse.

Hi, im sorry i know im the one that has been writing all this byt her dad is very much involved and does the heaving lifting im the support to back him. She has been offered so many different things with all different types of social, counselling, doctors, group's she was even offered her favourite teacher to talk to at anytime and she took advantage and would go see them during maths which she hated. There is a lot with her mum but she wanst abusive but was an alcoholic "who loved her other two children more" which i know is absolutely heart breaking and my god i know my SD has been through it. But she has made the choice to refuse every bit of help we offer to the point we have had to ask previous boyfriends parents for help and her boyfriends but she is abusive and controlling over them. Just to add she good an amazing grade in art and a great one in english but she has never had ambitions or goals she got offered a spot at a art college and turned it down coz it was too far away from her boyfriend of 3 weeks. I havent lost my mum i dont think anyway i havent seen her since i was 14 coz she tried k*lling me. I do know what loss is i lost my 1st daughter. Also have asked her to bring plates out and she doesnt until its too late i.e ive gone to get them after a month or we have ants and mice. I understand she might think all the help she had was crap but to say it to your little sister whos mum it was also that died and make her feel it wont help her.

OP posts:
MercanDede · 16/01/2024 22:21

PerfectTravelTote · 16/01/2024 22:19

She sounds deeply troubled. I think I'd let the dinners and chores slide and and try to tackle the bigger issues. I'm not convinced that tough love is the way to go here.

Same here. She may think her life is derailed so what is the point. Instead of telling her do this, do that, you’re an adult get a job. Ask her what she wants what dreams she still has and try and support her towards them. It’s not too late to go back to school or to try different therapy.

PerfectTravelTote · 16/01/2024 22:19

She sounds deeply troubled. I think I'd let the dinners and chores slide and and try to tackle the bigger issues. I'm not convinced that tough love is the way to go here.

Andthereyougo · 16/01/2024 22:18

It must be tempting to tell her to move out but I’d really fear for her safety. She would be really vulnerable to abuse as she’d be desperate for love.
Only suggestion I can make is having you and her dad chat to her with no other kids in the house. Point out she’s 18, technically an adult, time to step up now and work. Can you make her room into a bed sit? No cooking facilities ( could have her own kettle, mini fridge ) but maybe a small sofa? https://www.amazon.co.uk/OFCASA-Portable-Bedrooms-Thermoelectric-Refrigerator/dp/B09W8W4PRT/ref=asc_df_B09W8W4PRT/?tag=googshopuk-21&linkCode=df0&hvadid=641814015358&hvpos=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=6870201380546781019&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=c&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9045798&hvtargid=pla-2005580674220&psc=1&mcid=0a16a7801f06368eb24e82f3c1223def
You could have a behavioural agreement — she gets the better room/fridge etc.. she steps up with chores and no bullying of younger ones.

If she won’t accept counselling you can’t force her but always keep that as an option. I know a counsellor specialising in bereavement and she’s said that even if children have counselling after bereavement it frequently comes back “to bite them on the bum” in teenage years.

Swipe left for the next trending thread