Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am i being u reasonable not doing dinner for my 18 year old step daughter?

192 replies

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 20:49

Long story short, my 18 year old step daughter of 12 years does nothing, no job no education and doesnt lift a finger around the house. I have 3 other children and another step daughter. They all have their chores i.e unload dishwasher, sweep floor help clean table and they all do it. Thier ages are 4, 5, 6 and 12 they all do there bit, but my 18 year old has not done nothing in over two years. I stopped doing her washing 4 months ago cause i never even got a thank you. She does nothing me and her dad have tried our hardest to support her but she has been so disrespectful and also bullies her younger siblings. I cook our children thier dinner earlier than mine and thier dads and often we offered to her she said "i will eat it later" and then it would go to waste and she would never clean her plate. So now i dont dish her up a plate, i always cook extra anyways but as i dont put it on a plate for her she will cook herself noodles and then go eat her room which she knows she isint aloud to do as she caused a mice problem last year. And as she knows she isint aloud she waits for me and her dad to go to bed. So im sorry if its too much but am i being unreasonable to stop doing her dinners?

OP posts:
BowlOfNoodles · 17/01/2024 10:06

She sounds utterly depressed tbh

sashh · 17/01/2024 08:30

She is crying out for help and at the same time rejecting it.

OP she is in pain, that's obvious.

I'm sorry I can't offer some practical help.

Chocolation · 17/01/2024 08:21

What about art therapy? I wonder if she will engage with that as you mentioned she is fantastic at art and if that might be
a less scary way for her to start processing her feelings rather than sat in front of someone and having to ‘talk’.

Lampzade · 17/01/2024 07:58

Freshstarts24 · 17/01/2024 07:00

The point still stands. It is a form of abuse. If the school were to get wind of this it would be a referral that would be taken quite seriously.

OP all of this to me is screaming a child that has suffered with CSA. I hope I’m wrong.

It is definitely a form of abuse and would definitely be a referral.

Mirrorinthebathroom123 · 17/01/2024 07:36

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 23:42

I just want to say a massive thank you to everyone even the comments i didnt like, you took the time to read and comment and give advice. Its so hard trying to explain everything to strangers and try and do it in a way people will understand but i think this i what ive needed ive read every comment and i know i have done 99% of what people have suggested that is possible. So thank you

I haven’t read everyone’s replies but wanted you to know that from your first couple of posts I thought this sounded like a child with a history of developmental trauma. And then you confirmed it.

Bonding issues between her and her mum (she loved the others more)
alcoholic mum.
relationship with mum fraught
mum died

I would hazard a guess that there is more. The fact that she was so sexualised and at risk of sexual exploitation is often linked to sexual abuse (but can be just the developmental trauma above).

Our early experiences shape our sense of ourselves, others and the world.

She has learned
I am unloveable (even by the one person in the world who is most likely to love me)
Others are unpredictable (mum being an alcoholic - may be volatile relationship before her mum and dad split so may be dad not always emotionally available?)
The world is unpredictable and unsafe (being moved around, mums death)

I would view these behaviours as a kind of ‘push you and keep you away because I’m scared you won’t love me/you’ll leave me. As self neglect because she feels worthless. She is probably drowning out awful feelings by immersing herself in screen use.

Boundaries still matter but she needs you and her dad to hang in there. Maintain that relationship despite her attempts to push you away.

littleblackcat27 · 17/01/2024 07:34

@user1492757084

Nice 'to do' list for the OP but totally unrealistic for this situation.

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 17/01/2024 07:27

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 17/01/2024 07:15

My eldest half sister went through a very similar experience to your SD. Also she was sexually abused and her mum committed suicidal when she was 12. She went on to have multiple problems in her life, alcoholism and died way before her time.

You sound a lot like my parents. The ongoing rhetoric of she’s had multiple counselling sessions, she’s had this opportunity, she’s had that. It’s all so mechanical, clinical and shallow. You’ve let your hurt and your resilience take over in a way you wouldn’t with your own.

I’ll tell you what she hasn’t had, what she desperately needs and what, if she doesn’t get, will lead to a very similar life to my sister’s: unconditional love.

I grew up there being a constant war between my Mum and sister. My Mum constantly saying “she’s had counselling”. But did she ever take her one on one on a day out, no she blames her and was dismissive of her. When she hit the awkward teenage years she didn’t create a bond, just constantly treated her as a dysfunctional burden when her behaviour was crying for help. My Mum said to me when she died “I don’t feel as awful about it as if you or (other sister had died”.

A life of constant rejection from the people who are meant to care for her. Your poor SD. I really hope it’s not too late for you to make amends.

Edited

Another thing my Mum would say is I cooked for her, taught her to read, raised her from a young age, etc. Again quite clinical.

If her personality changed year 7 I wonder if she was groomed or something sinister and she was too vulnerable/no resilience to resist and get help.

Namechangeforthis88 · 17/01/2024 07:24

Apologies if it has been said, but it seems a real possibility that she has been sexually abused at some point. Or at the very least exposed to something very inappropriate.

The vulnerability to grooming, the showing pics of herself and bf to sister (who the hell would do that? Someone who has picked up some odd boundaries and norms).

Hope things improve for everyone.

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 17/01/2024 07:22

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/01/2024 23:01

As a 12 year old she was groomed by adults - she needs help not punishment

Desperate for the one thing she hasn’t had: love and attention.

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 17/01/2024 07:20

Freshstarts24 · 17/01/2024 07:00

The point still stands. It is a form of abuse. If the school were to get wind of this it would be a referral that would be taken quite seriously.

OP all of this to me is screaming a child that has suffered with CSA. I hope I’m wrong.

Agreed. Especially the photo sharing.

LiarLiarKnickersAblaze · 17/01/2024 07:15

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 20:56

Nothing she has no goals or career ambition

My eldest half sister went through a very similar experience to your SD. Also she was sexually abused and her mum committed suicidal when she was 12. She went on to have multiple problems in her life, alcoholism and died way before her time.

You sound a lot like my parents. The ongoing rhetoric of she’s had multiple counselling sessions, she’s had this opportunity, she’s had that. It’s all so mechanical, clinical and shallow. You’ve let your hurt and your resilience take over in a way you wouldn’t with your own.

I’ll tell you what she hasn’t had, what she desperately needs and what, if she doesn’t get, will lead to a very similar life to my sister’s: unconditional love.

I grew up there being a constant war between my Mum and sister. My Mum constantly saying “she’s had counselling”. But did she ever take her one on one on a day out, no she blames her and was dismissive of her. When she hit the awkward teenage years she didn’t create a bond, just constantly treated her as a dysfunctional burden when her behaviour was crying for help. My Mum said to me when she died “I don’t feel as awful about it as if you or (other sister had died”.

A life of constant rejection from the people who are meant to care for her. Your poor SD. I really hope it’s not too late for you to make amends.

Freshstarts24 · 17/01/2024 07:00

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/01/2024 23:02

She did that when she was a child herself

The point still stands. It is a form of abuse. If the school were to get wind of this it would be a referral that would be taken quite seriously.

OP all of this to me is screaming a child that has suffered with CSA. I hope I’m wrong.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/01/2024 06:37

Your dsd is obviously really hurting. I don’t think creating a hard line will help in this situation as there appears to be a lot of trauma and by the sound of it abuse from your stepchildren’s mother. A lot to unpack.

Twelve is an incredibly difficult age to lose one of your parents, especially one you were estranged from. Her younger sister will have taken help as she was devastatingly physically affected, and a child, more malleable at the time.

I also think that you need family therapy even if she won’t engage. And I really hope your family is complete. Having more children when the existing ones were already traumatised will not have been easy on any of the children, including yours.

Wait17 · 17/01/2024 05:35

This!
It's child on child abuse!

Wait17 · 17/01/2024 05:32

Its.called Child on Child abuse and bullying

Lampzade · 17/01/2024 05:14

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Horrible comment
You should be thoroughly ashamed of yourself.
MN at its worst

Nanaof1 · 17/01/2024 04:39

@Natz281092 It sounds like many of the family are hurting. I like the fact that you make enough food, so if your DSD wants to have some, it is available.
As a PP mentioned, maybe let your DH clean out her room of dirty dishes every day so you don't attract insects/mice.
I am heartbroken for all of you, as this must be a tough road to walk. Don't give up on the 18-yr-old. It almost sounds like she is being nasty so that everyone turns against her, when she really wants the opposite. Not sure how to explain it, but it seems she is turning people against her as a self-fulfilling prophecy, because she feels they will at some point anyway, so she'll do it first. Deep down, she is hurt that her DM died before they could fix their relationship, so she is trying to not have relationships with anyone that really loves her.
Keep trying to get her counselling help. Sometimes it takes a while until you find the person you "click with". When/if she finds that person, in time she will start to feel better about herself, which will translate into her feeling better about everyone else close to her.

I also wanted to express to you how sorry I am about the loss of your DD. I cannot imagine your pain or the never-ending heart-ache. I hope you have also gotten some counselling to help with healing.

Keep trying with DSD, continue to fight for her mental health and her self-esteem, as you have been doing. Take care of yourself and your other children, so they can see that you don't give up on any of them.

Nanaof1 · 17/01/2024 04:21

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Maybe you could learn to be human and have empathy instead of delighting over a few misspells. I mean, REALLY?

Three and a half pages of questions and helpful advice and then a "learn to spell then learn to communicate with a child.." post which is not helpful, insightful or of any use to anyone, ever.

Also, the young adult is NOT traumatized by the family situation she is in NOW. But hey, great job of not reading all the posts!

PKNI · 17/01/2024 01:42

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

What a terribly bitchy comment to make! OP, you have such a lot on your plate, please disregard AAT65's nasty remark about learning to spell! AAT65 should be ashamed of themselves! OP, you're doing your best, big hugs. I couldn't read and run, you don't deserve a verbal kicking!

AAT65 · 17/01/2024 01:21

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

BridgetsBigPants · 17/01/2024 01:15

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/01/2024 23:02

She did that when she was a child herself

She was 17. The people defending this are ridiculous. We all know that if it was a 17 year old boy showing those sort of photos to a 10 year old that people would be absolutely disgusted.

tachetastic · 16/01/2024 23:49

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 20:49

Long story short, my 18 year old step daughter of 12 years does nothing, no job no education and doesnt lift a finger around the house. I have 3 other children and another step daughter. They all have their chores i.e unload dishwasher, sweep floor help clean table and they all do it. Thier ages are 4, 5, 6 and 12 they all do there bit, but my 18 year old has not done nothing in over two years. I stopped doing her washing 4 months ago cause i never even got a thank you. She does nothing me and her dad have tried our hardest to support her but she has been so disrespectful and also bullies her younger siblings. I cook our children thier dinner earlier than mine and thier dads and often we offered to her she said "i will eat it later" and then it would go to waste and she would never clean her plate. So now i dont dish her up a plate, i always cook extra anyways but as i dont put it on a plate for her she will cook herself noodles and then go eat her room which she knows she isint aloud to do as she caused a mice problem last year. And as she knows she isint aloud she waits for me and her dad to go to bed. So im sorry if its too much but am i being unreasonable to stop doing her dinners?

Wow!!! Stop, Just stop.

She is 18,

Let her live on Pot Noodles and toast for now. Don't force the argument.

The bullying of the younger siblings would worry me more. If you accommodate her then she needs to back off the rest of the family.

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 23:42

I just want to say a massive thank you to everyone even the comments i didnt like, you took the time to read and comment and give advice. Its so hard trying to explain everything to strangers and try and do it in a way people will understand but i think this i what ive needed ive read every comment and i know i have done 99% of what people have suggested that is possible. So thank you

Kamala Harris Thank You GIF by The Democrats
OP posts:
Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 23:38

anarchicparadise · 16/01/2024 23:34

OP I’m sure you’re doing your best for her.

its difficult to get a full picture/situation from a mumsnet post. Things are so nuanced but honestly well done for helping her as much as you can. None of this sounds easy and I’m sure it takes its toll on you.

I suppose just keep on keeping on, get her the help she needs and look after yourself and your other kids

Thanks 😢 its so hard trying to explain everything to strangers and try and do it in a way people will understand but i think this i what ive need ive read every comment and i know i have done 99% of what people have suggested that is possible.

OP posts:
anarchicparadise · 16/01/2024 23:34

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 23:27

I just want to say we didnt have a choice regarding her savings no matter what we said once she is 18 she has access we could not tell the bank to not give it its all in her name and all she had to do was show i.d to get it. We didnt even know until she already done it

OP I’m sure you’re doing your best for her.

its difficult to get a full picture/situation from a mumsnet post. Things are so nuanced but honestly well done for helping her as much as you can. None of this sounds easy and I’m sure it takes its toll on you.

I suppose just keep on keeping on, get her the help she needs and look after yourself and your other kids