Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am i being u reasonable not doing dinner for my 18 year old step daughter?

192 replies

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 20:49

Long story short, my 18 year old step daughter of 12 years does nothing, no job no education and doesnt lift a finger around the house. I have 3 other children and another step daughter. They all have their chores i.e unload dishwasher, sweep floor help clean table and they all do it. Thier ages are 4, 5, 6 and 12 they all do there bit, but my 18 year old has not done nothing in over two years. I stopped doing her washing 4 months ago cause i never even got a thank you. She does nothing me and her dad have tried our hardest to support her but she has been so disrespectful and also bullies her younger siblings. I cook our children thier dinner earlier than mine and thier dads and often we offered to her she said "i will eat it later" and then it would go to waste and she would never clean her plate. So now i dont dish her up a plate, i always cook extra anyways but as i dont put it on a plate for her she will cook herself noodles and then go eat her room which she knows she isint aloud to do as she caused a mice problem last year. And as she knows she isint aloud she waits for me and her dad to go to bed. So im sorry if its too much but am i being unreasonable to stop doing her dinners?

OP posts:
JLou08 · 18/01/2024 00:06

There will be a reason she hated her mother and on top of that she lost her after 2 years of not seeing her. Sounds like she hadsexperienced trauma throughout her childhood that will take a long time to heal, unfortunately it may never heal.
You're not being unreasonable though, I would let her know you and her dad love her and want to support her but you also need to have boundaries and need to encourage her independence. You do need to look after yourself otherwise you can't be the best parent for your younger children so I would try and not let it burden you too much.

Tiredmama53 · 17/01/2024 22:01

OP has clearly stated that they've tried to get her help and been to the gp etc and that the girl has refused. You can't force a grown adult into accepting help and at this stage her behaviour is a danger to the other minors in the house. There's only so much that can be done before they need to look at her living somewhere else and personally for me that line would have been drawn when she was showing sexual images to a child or when she was accusing her Dad of abuse or when she herself was physically abusing OP because both of those risk the other children experiencing trauma and they need to be safeguarded. Sorry but she's an adult and isn't the priority here the other children in the house are so I think she needs to be housed elsewhere.

Tiredmama53 · 17/01/2024 21:58

This is obviously so much more than not liking other people's kids. This 'kid' has literally committed a sexual offense against her younger sibling by showing her naked photos of herself and boyfriend that is so beyond inappropriate. No matter how much you like or dislike someone at some point you have to safeguard the other children in the house. This lady also clearly doesn't have any problems with the younger step daughter This isn't a case of an evil step mum and 100 percent a case of this grown adult not child has severe problems that are putting everyone else in the house at risk. Its totally natural to feel the way OP is.

Whyamiherenow · 17/01/2024 20:49

Having read through your comments. It seems you have spent all your energy with no resilience left which sometimes affects our ability to see beyond the short term and look at the bigger picture. Have you thought of something to do for you? To help you? Maybe some help or counselling, someone to talk to who can professionally help you with strategies and techniques? With experience of these sorts of behaviours and situations.

what is the saying? You can’t pour from an empty cup? It sounds like your cup is empty.

I mean this in the nicest possible way because anybody would be exhausted in your situation.

2dogs1braincell · 17/01/2024 20:20

Phwoar, the venom in this thread is unbelievable.

This poor bloody girl, OP you sound like you have absolutely no clue how to handle this situation. She’s clearly struggling with complex trauma and you’re forcing your ideas of what you think is good for her. Get her some proper professional help, I can confidently say as someone who has had CBT that it doesn’t work for everyone and it was more than useless and in fact damaging for me in the end.

She sounds incredibly vulnerable, the fact she is clinging onto boyfriends for dear life would say to me that she is highly co dependant and putting all of her emotional needs on her partner.

There is no excusing her behaviour, but there is a reason and context behind it all.

0MammaBear0 · 17/01/2024 18:28

Mumofferralkid3 · 17/01/2024 11:32

I don't think this is a good response.

She is displaying a lot of self destructive behaviour. Make her homeless and she will be a total lost cause.

Perhaps she doesn't feel worthy of kindness and all your efforts (which I think have been the correct way to treat her) perhaps highlight this. She is obviously in need of help, probably more than you can offer her.

She lost her mum at a pivotal time in her life. Teenage years are the hardest, trying to find identity, navigate becoming a grown up with huge feelings. Perhaps she felt alone a log time before her mum died. The relationship with mum sounds very strained.

I don't know what advice to give but I think kicking her out isn't a good option and might make her believe even more that she isn't worthy of love.

She's already a lost cause. She doesn't want help and she doesn't have any plans for her life. If allowed she will continue living with them indefinitely, how does that help anyone?

LoopyLooooo · 17/01/2024 18:24

Natz281092 · 17/01/2024 11:54

So i wanted to give a sort of update, i contacted her bf to see if he could get her out the house for a couple hours as she hasnt been out in over 4 weeks. She used to stay his all the time but is no longer aloud due to them arguing and her telling his parents to f off. I went in her room this morning probaly too early and she shouted why the f am i talking to her bf i also tried to pick up plates and stuff and she got violent saying "did i give you permission to take those" admittedly i probably said the wrong thing saying she doesnt pay for the plates and then she lashed out hitting me across my face. Her dad was at work at this time my my youngest is still home so i walked away and just rang him. I didnt want my youngest to be aware. Im not sure whats going to happen. I also just wanted to say she has never been SA,D. I just want to say thankyou again to everyone i just dont know what to do anymore.

She sexually abused her younger siblings when she was 17, she's verbally abused her boyfriend's parents and now she's physically assaulted you.

You need her out of the house ASAP, before things get any worse OP.

0MammaBear0 · 17/01/2024 18:23

Natz281092 · 16/01/2024 21:25

She has had multiple counselling sessions even before her mum and she went on camps and had surfing lessons for 12 weeks with them. After her mum she didn't want counselling and tried to persuade her sister not have any as "they are crap" her sister was 9 at the time and did have a good relationship with her mum. We have said on multiple occasions that she needs help as her behaviour has not changed and its now affecting her siblings and her answer is always you cant force me and i dont give a s*it about anyone else. Another note we did get her a docs appointment as i was worried about bipolar or split personality and depression but they said she is fine and just needs someone to talk to. And straight she said no to the doctor.

If you don't do anything and allow her she will stick with you forever making your life hell. You need to kick her out and let her figure her life by herself. Her behaviour is not acceptable

BreatheAndFocus · 17/01/2024 17:49

I’d report that slap to the police; get her somewhere of her own to live; and speak to her GP. They won’t tell you anything but you can tell them your concerns.

You have to think of the effect on your other DC and StepDC, and on you and your DH, of course. It’s not like you haven’t tried to help her. In fact, perhaps she sees your kind help as weakness? If she had to stand on her own two feet maybe she’d be better off.

bear1923 · 17/01/2024 15:11

IkeaMeatballGravy · 17/01/2024 14:40

What is OP supposed to do if SD doesn't bring her plates down? Eat off paper plates and let the mice take over?

There is no excuse for violence, you did nothing to deserve getting slapped. You and your younger DCs have the right to live in a home free of this toxic behaviour. Get your DH to make alternative living arrangements for her, as sad as her backstory is she is not safe to be around young children.

absolutely agree. now she has been physical with you, you're DH needs to intervene ASAP and find her different living arrangements. not okay behaviour with children around, regardless if they were at school at the time. i really feel for you as you said you can't seem to do right from wrong. next time you see her, given she obviously is vulnerable regarding childhood etc, maybe say something like, 'i will support you and will be there for you always, but you don't ever get physical with me again'. leave it at that with her and let DH sort the rest out. you need to distance yourself from it if possible, mentally and physically

Secondstart1001 · 17/01/2024 15:10

@Natz281092 i saw your reply to me and bless you, you are a full time mum and have your hands full. My older daughter suffered a mental breakdown about 2 years ago and her behavior was unbearable as she was violent and agressive especially with me. I persevered with her to continue to look after her at her worst and in way she’s pulled herself up and is 70% better. She also refused therapy and I still think she needs it. That was my way with her however when she was at her dads and she was like this he was tough on her. I am not sure what worked and we still have issues with her but I think try and show her you love her at her worst and I know this is hard as you have all been through so much! And do let the little things slide if you can if not for your own well being x

IkeaMeatballGravy · 17/01/2024 14:40

What is OP supposed to do if SD doesn't bring her plates down? Eat off paper plates and let the mice take over?

There is no excuse for violence, you did nothing to deserve getting slapped. You and your younger DCs have the right to live in a home free of this toxic behaviour. Get your DH to make alternative living arrangements for her, as sad as her backstory is she is not safe to be around young children.

Bellaboo01 · 17/01/2024 14:36

I would still cook her dinner. It sounds like that is the least of your worries with her.
Why doesn't she work?
Why isn't she in Education?
I would perhaps concentrate on that first but, if you are cooking for the whole family then obviously she will feel alienated if you don't for her too. At 18 years old, i can understand that she doesnt want to eat at the same time as her 4,5,6 and 12 year old siblings. You say that you and your H eat later, surely she can just eat with you?

Ganthanga · 17/01/2024 14:28

Are you sure she's not suffering from depression? It sounds as though she's really unhappy and needs a bit of love. Most teenagers are " annoying " but are you sure there's nothing else going on?

Natz281092 · 17/01/2024 14:22

Mirrorinthebathroom123 · 17/01/2024 14:14

You are aggravating the situation. You are understandably frustrated, but going into her private space and interfering in her relationships is not helpful. You have set her up to get dysregulated there. I would be incensed by someone waking me up by having a go at me. The human brain doesn’t finish developing until mid twenties. She’s had a very difficult childhood. I think you need to step back and educate yourself about how to best support her to reach independence but she is very vulnerable.

I didnt go in her room to argue i was going to ask her if she wanted a lift out and to take plates out as thier were loads i know it was early but i did it after school run just after 9. My plate cupboard was pretty mych empty so i need them for tonights dinner. I knocked on her door and only went in when she replied with what do i want. I wasnt interfering i was asking if he could encourage her to go out for a couple of hours so she got some air and some company with someone her age. The way its going im never going to do anything right either too strict, too soft, shes an adult, shes a child honestly im so confused to what im actually meant to be doing especially for everyone saftey now she getting physical.

OP posts:
Mirrorinthebathroom123 · 17/01/2024 14:14

Natz281092 · 17/01/2024 11:54

So i wanted to give a sort of update, i contacted her bf to see if he could get her out the house for a couple hours as she hasnt been out in over 4 weeks. She used to stay his all the time but is no longer aloud due to them arguing and her telling his parents to f off. I went in her room this morning probaly too early and she shouted why the f am i talking to her bf i also tried to pick up plates and stuff and she got violent saying "did i give you permission to take those" admittedly i probably said the wrong thing saying she doesnt pay for the plates and then she lashed out hitting me across my face. Her dad was at work at this time my my youngest is still home so i walked away and just rang him. I didnt want my youngest to be aware. Im not sure whats going to happen. I also just wanted to say she has never been SA,D. I just want to say thankyou again to everyone i just dont know what to do anymore.

You are aggravating the situation. You are understandably frustrated, but going into her private space and interfering in her relationships is not helpful. You have set her up to get dysregulated there. I would be incensed by someone waking me up by having a go at me. The human brain doesn’t finish developing until mid twenties. She’s had a very difficult childhood. I think you need to step back and educate yourself about how to best support her to reach independence but she is very vulnerable.

ReallyAgainReally · 17/01/2024 13:00

Sorry this is hard but I didn't want to read and run.

I see you have a LL so you cannot turn her room into a bedsit. She needs a bedsit as a pp upthread suggested. I agree.

My second choice would be to kindly discuss with her and her dad (all 3 of you) asking HER is she wanted a flat so she lived on her own. See what she says. If she wants it, I would use ALL my money to rent her a place elsewhere. You can always pay for 2 years, after which you give her notice that from the next year (Give her 6 months notice) that she will now need to pay all or half for it. You have to play all these convo by ear whilst sounding her out.

If staying in the house is all you can do and since tough approach has not worked, I would give in and go the softer approach as a pp upthread suggested. Let the father show her how upsetting this is to him. I will tell you, maybe, just maybe, DSD seeing her father struggling could just be what will make her change. I know of many people who changed their bad behaviours towards parents ONLY out of mercy for the parents and parents' suffering- yes mad as it sounds.

She is vulnerable, however she is also an adult and should be able to at least be decent to the family, if nothing else.

Yes, whoever thought giving an 18 yo savings was a good idea is as mad as a bag of frogs- that IS NOT how any 18 yo is treated- never ever; without also making sure she will have access to millions if not billions for the rest of her life!

Woristag · 17/01/2024 12:35

Natz281092 · 17/01/2024 11:54

So i wanted to give a sort of update, i contacted her bf to see if he could get her out the house for a couple hours as she hasnt been out in over 4 weeks. She used to stay his all the time but is no longer aloud due to them arguing and her telling his parents to f off. I went in her room this morning probaly too early and she shouted why the f am i talking to her bf i also tried to pick up plates and stuff and she got violent saying "did i give you permission to take those" admittedly i probably said the wrong thing saying she doesnt pay for the plates and then she lashed out hitting me across my face. Her dad was at work at this time my my youngest is still home so i walked away and just rang him. I didnt want my youngest to be aware. Im not sure whats going to happen. I also just wanted to say she has never been SA,D. I just want to say thankyou again to everyone i just dont know what to do anymore.

I would not live in the same house as someone who physically assaulted me.

The whole dynamic is getting way too toxic and out of hand

Natz281092 · 17/01/2024 11:54

So i wanted to give a sort of update, i contacted her bf to see if he could get her out the house for a couple hours as she hasnt been out in over 4 weeks. She used to stay his all the time but is no longer aloud due to them arguing and her telling his parents to f off. I went in her room this morning probaly too early and she shouted why the f am i talking to her bf i also tried to pick up plates and stuff and she got violent saying "did i give you permission to take those" admittedly i probably said the wrong thing saying she doesnt pay for the plates and then she lashed out hitting me across my face. Her dad was at work at this time my my youngest is still home so i walked away and just rang him. I didnt want my youngest to be aware. Im not sure whats going to happen. I also just wanted to say she has never been SA,D. I just want to say thankyou again to everyone i just dont know what to do anymore.

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 17/01/2024 11:48

Nothankyou22 · 16/01/2024 21:15

Is she depressed? Has she had counselling or support since her mum died.
i get the frustration you’re facing but it seems deeper

This

You can't underestimate the trauma of losing your mother at such a vulnerable age. The poor girl.

I'm not excusing her behaviour but this runs much deeper. She needs support. Unless people have walked in her shoes they can't possibly understand.

bundle · 17/01/2024 11:45

Her behaviour isn’t that unusual for someone her age - it’s annoying but my main concern would be supporting her following the loss of her mum. I can’t imagine how devastating that would be for someone so young, no wonder she has no drive or ambition, especially being the eldest, so much is expected of you. Has she had counselling (or the whole family)?

Mumofferralkid3 · 17/01/2024 11:32

I don't think this is a good response.

She is displaying a lot of self destructive behaviour. Make her homeless and she will be a total lost cause.

Perhaps she doesn't feel worthy of kindness and all your efforts (which I think have been the correct way to treat her) perhaps highlight this. She is obviously in need of help, probably more than you can offer her.

She lost her mum at a pivotal time in her life. Teenage years are the hardest, trying to find identity, navigate becoming a grown up with huge feelings. Perhaps she felt alone a log time before her mum died. The relationship with mum sounds very strained.

I don't know what advice to give but I think kicking her out isn't a good option and might make her believe even more that she isn't worthy of love.

commonsense61 · 17/01/2024 11:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

LokiDoki75 · 17/01/2024 11:07

I see that mum was an alcoholic. Was she drinking before she had the children? I’m just wondering if anyone has ever looked at the possibility that your stepdaughter might have foetal alcohol syndrome? It can affect behaviour. I have an adopted child with FAS and some of these behaviour patterns are sounding quite familiar. It may not be, but it might be worth reading up on just in case.