Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New partner and parenting

369 replies

Nchange12 · 16/01/2024 16:16

I have 3 teenagers, 18 (Y13), 17 (Y12) and 15 (Y11). I have been seeing someone for about 8 months, he also has 3 teens, 19 (second year of uni), 17 (Y13) and 15 (Y11).
He met my children last month, I told them about the relationship and they asked to meet him. I haven’t met his children, they know about me but don’t want to meet me yet, that’s fine.
The circumstances are different, their mother passed away 7 years ago, he hasn’t had a relationship since, I’m divorced and have a positive relationship with my ex, we don’t really have an arrangement for when the kids are where right now , leave it up to them.

Naturally we discuss the wonders of parenting teenagers. We could say our kids are very different though.
I’ve definitely dealt with more in terms of behaviour (vaping, school avoidance, general boundary pushing) where as he seems to have had very little of this.
Our parenting is remarkably different, I’d say he is stricter but his kids get more, while I’m more relaxed but my kids aren’t spoiled.
Examples

  • His kids were/are expected to get a job as soon as the turn 16 and pay digs accordingly (he says he puts this in savings), I don’t expect my children to work and if they wanted to I wouldn’t take money while they were still in school
  • He bought his older 2 cars for their 17th birthdays - I view this as being spoiled
  • If you walk into his house you wouldn’t think he had children (I’ve been while they’ve been out), everything they own gets kept in their rooms, down to costs and shoes, my house looks like I have teenagers!
  • His kids have a higher chore expectation, including doing all their own washing and cooking once or twice a week (for his middle child this is on top of working 8 hours on Sunday and 4 hours after school one night a week and studying for A-levels), I just expect mine to keep their room clean and help when asked
  • His kids have newer tech, he claims it is an incentive to work harder etc. He says he’d have a no tolerance policy on chat back or rule breaking but he hasn’t dealt with much in the last couple years, if he did all tech would be confiscated immediately and they wouldn’t be allowed out. I don’t take my kids tech regardless, I know I couldn’t be without my phone so why should they be
  • He wouldn’t allow a gap year after sixth form, if they chose to take it he will reduce the funding he offers while at uni, he would support one the year after uni though
  • He expects A and Bs (6-9s) exclusively in GCSEs and A-Levels and provides financial incentives. My kids have yet to achieve an A or B between them and I couldn’t care less - they did their best

I think you get the idea.

To the point, whenever my kids do something a bit silly (vape, get phone taken off them at school, don’t clean their room) and I have a little moan about it to him, he makes it clear he thinks I’m too relaxed, have low/no boundaries and my kids walk right over me. He then reminds me of his straight A, perfect Peter kids, who work and keep the house spotless and never dare to talk back.
All I can think is his kids must be either petrified of stepping out of line or miserable as they never catch a break.

AIBU to want to tell him that half of the reason his kids are like they are is because of their personality and not his stellar parenting and it’s luck of the draw? If I forced my kids to do everything his do they’d be bloody miserable!!
Or am I just a crappy parent who lets her kids run circles around her?

OP posts:
Georgyporky · 16/01/2024 18:09

Don't live together until they've all left home !

PowerhouseOfTheCell · 16/01/2024 18:06

Is it really worth being tit for tat at parenting older teens/ young adults, it's not like they're all under 10 and you're planning on becoming a blended family under one roof.
Just enjoy the adult relationship you have with him, it's still early days, they might be ready to meet you for another year yet!

Hubblebubble · 16/01/2024 17:51

His children have been equipped with life skills (cooking/laundry/cleaning) a work ethic (Saturday and after school jobs) manners and gives extrinsic motivation and high expectations for academic success. Sounds great.

Smallsuitcase · 16/01/2024 17:51

I don’t think his children sound spoilt as, yes, they got cars bought for them at 17, but they work, get good grades and do chores, so they’ve worked hard for the privilege of having a car young.

TheTigerWhoCameToEatMyHusband · 16/01/2024 17:48

He sounds like a good parent, you sound like a pushover

Workawayxx · 16/01/2024 17:45

I don't think we can say who is "right" or "wrong" in terms of your parenting styles. They are just different. I guess if you saw him with his DC you'd have a better understanding of their personalities and relationship. I DO think he is wrong to criticise (implicitly or explicitly) your parenting though. I think it would be impossible to blend in this situation (or in fact, probably any situation with 6 teens!) so if you're happy to just date for the next few years, I'd crack on without mentioning your DC. I'd imagine in practice it'd be very hard to do that though so, for me, this would be the beginning of the end.

Mumsanetta · 16/01/2024 17:42

momonpurpose · 16/01/2024 17:33

I don't understand either. His kids are not vaping or school refusing or having behavior issues. Maybe seeing such respectful kids it's making you feel self conscious about your own?

Quite!

Mumsanetta · 16/01/2024 17:41

I’m not surprised he hasn’t introduced his kids to you or yours yet … He sounds like an excellent parent and his children are a good advert for the benefits of love, boundaries and discipline.

LouOver · 16/01/2024 17:41

This is written from your perspective and he still sounds like the better parent.

Tinkerbyebye · 16/01/2024 17:38

I would be ending it. If he ever moves in your kids would hate it

Crazycatlady79 · 16/01/2024 17:36

You have very different parenting styles, circumstances etc, clearly.

Nope, he shouldn't be critical of your parenting, nor about your teenagers, especially when he's only just met them.

However, some of your observations about his offspring (whom you haven't even met) and the way he parents etc are pretty mean-spirited.

Those children lost their fucking Mum and you seem to somehow been implying that your children have been through more and he hasn't had to deal with what you have etc.

Do you see a future with this man?

Happilyobtuse · 16/01/2024 17:34

He sounds like an amazing parent and reminds me of my own parents who had a very similar parenting style. My siblings and I got driving lessons as soon as we were eligible and cars too. We also worked hard and achieved top grades. Both learned to cook and clean our rooms, do chores etc. as kids.

Honestly I think this sets kids up for life and I follow the same with my own children. Your attitude is doing your children no favours. And honestly you both don’t sound compatible.

momonpurpose · 16/01/2024 17:33

Alwaysalwayscold · 16/01/2024 16:25

I don't understand what you want to criticise him about? His kids clearly have a lot of respect and have been brought up well. Are you jealous or something?

You say he spoils them by buying them a car etc, but then say he's too strict because he makes them earn it by pulling their weight at home. These two things contradict each other.

I don't understand either. His kids are not vaping or school refusing or having behavior issues. Maybe seeing such respectful kids it's making you feel self conscious about your own?

Stressfordays · 16/01/2024 17:23

With all due respect OP, the proof is in the pudding. His kids aren't vaping or getting in trouble at school. You can try and judge him all you want, he is just offering you some advice when you moan about your kids. His way is clearly doing something good.

Oh and buying your kids a car and ensuring they learn to drive at 17 is the best thing you can do as a parent. Gives them so many more opportunities and so much more freedom. I am very grateful my parents did that for me.

DuplicateUserName · 16/01/2024 17:20

He sounds like he's doing a fantastic job.

I don't know why this bothers you, perhaps you could take a look at why it does.

Envy perhaps?

SchoolQuestionnaire · 16/01/2024 17:20

I mean, I’m not really sure about making kids pay board while they are still in education, although I do agree it’s very beneficial for children to have a part time job. I wouldn’t be particularly happy about my kids vaping or not achieving their full potential at school either. To be honest, the main issue here is that you are clearly very different people with different core values and parenting styles. And worse than that you both actively disapprove of each other’s choices. I don’t think this relationship will work long term.

Sunnydays0101 · 16/01/2024 17:19

Do you really think it’s more relaxing for teens to be at home playing video games than out playing sports or out with their friends/boyfriends ?

Reugny · 16/01/2024 17:19

So he gets them to work, pay attention to their grades, do chores around the house, look after their own belongings and buys them a car, yet they are spoilt by him buying them a car?

🙄

IAmAnIdiot123 · 16/01/2024 17:15

I too think his style of parenting sounds good! It is the approach we are taking with our children. My 5 year old helps me do chores, I think it's important for kids to take an active role in maintaining the house

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 16/01/2024 17:15

He sounds very much like the way I was brought up.

His kids do things because that's the way it has always been for them. I knew from a young age, were I to live at home and be working full time, I'd have to contribute to the household. That was an expectation that I knew for years. Unless genuinely ill, I would never not go to school, bunking off was incompressible as was refusing to go. It would not have been tolerated.

You have set expectations very differently so of course your kids would rebel if you asked them to act to the same level as his kids.

My parents bought me a car at 17 as we lived rurally. It was an old banger but they knew as a teen I could not get about without it. They do what he asks, these are their rewards.

spearthatbroc · 16/01/2024 17:15

See how you feel in ten years time OP when your three teens “with not a B between them” and one stricken with anxiety and missing 25% of the school year are fairing in life and how happy and fulfilled they are… compared with his (but i suspect you and he won’t have been in each others lives for a decade at that point anyway)

Sunnydays0101 · 16/01/2024 17:15
  • Good that he’s encouraging a work ethic and paying their way. It balances out being given a car and having latest tech.
  • If he can afford to buy his kids cars, nothing wrong with that. They are studying hard, have part-time jobs, etc. This isn’t spoiling.
  • My house probably looks a little like this. Everything put away. All our coats and shoes are in a cupboard. Personal belongings in our room. Books on bookshelves. School books on their desks.
  • Having set chores encourages a good work ethic and will stand to them in college, when they are sharing houses/flats/living with a partner, etc.
  • Don't know if new tech encourages teens to work harder but their Dad can afford it and they work hard, so what’s the harm.
  • Zero tolerance for back chat - good for him, if his methods work. He’s being firm, not cruel.
  • Lots of kids don’t take gap years.
  • He has high expectations but they wouldn’t get those grades if they weren’t capable. Might some of your children get higher grades if they were encouraged ?

You could say his children have a privileged lifestyle but they have part-time jobs, pay towards their upkeep, help with the running of their home, work hard at school - in all probability, they are well rounded, will all go to Uni and have successful careers.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 16/01/2024 17:13

Sorry, he sounds like he’s doing a great job as a parent (and in my view a better parent). I think his children are going to go a lot further in life.

spriots · 16/01/2024 17:13

Revelwithacause · 16/01/2024 17:10

How can you say his kids are spoiled? They work hard and behave themselves and are rewarded for it.

Yeah that struck me too - being spoiled is more than about money spent on you. His teens sound like they contribute to the household, share the load, cook meals, do laundry etc, it's the OP's teens who sound spoiled to me

jhy · 16/01/2024 17:13

In general men are stricter so given that he's been a single dad for quite a while, it's not surprising. It would be hard to change your parenting skills now, they are too old and won't listen anyway, cause more arguements and more misery for everyone.
Everyone parents in different ways, there's no right or wrong. But it's not nice to criticise either way.