Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think the terms "neuro diverse" and "neuro typical" will be short lived.

462 replies

theplatformedge · 16/01/2024 08:30

Diversity means "a range of many people or things that are very different from each other" (Oxford learner's dictionary), so the idea that a minority of people are "neuro diverse" and everyone else is "neuro typical" is not only semantically illogical, but also potentially offensive.

We're all different. Some people have traits that make life more difficult for them than others, whether it be ASD, ADHD or a range of other conditions, with spectrums of severity. Telling people that you're neuro-diverse is so vague as to be meaningless, and telling other people they are nero-typical when you have no idea what they're feeling inside is insensitive. Some people get a formal diagnosis for their symptoms, some people self-diagnose and others don't recognise it in themselves. Nobody knows how many people are living with these traits across the population, but the massive increase in diagnostics suggests they're a lot more common than anyone ever thought in the past, and therefore gradually becoming very "typical".

Discuss! 🙂

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
OriginalUsername2 · 16/01/2024 14:10

MyopicBunny · 16/01/2024 12:41

So in your opinion, clinical depression doesn't exist? 🤔

I’m sharing a link to something interesting I read 😐

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 16/01/2024 13:59

alltootired · 16/01/2024 13:03

I am struck once again how little understanding most people have of other disabilities. Mild, moderate and severe are used with other disabilities and chronic illnesses all the time.
I have a mild disability. It still affects me every day and I have been in hospital for treatment. Other mild disabilities can worsen and become moderate or severe.
This is accepted with physical disabilities. And it is quite common for physical disabilities to become much harder to deal with as you age. What a young body can compensate for to some degree, is not possible in an older body.
So when this is widely accepted with physical disabilities why is it seen as threatening with autism, ADHD, etc? Or is it just that people with these have no understanding of other physical disabilities and somehow think they are being insulted?

Because needs change so frequently. Some days, weeks, months you could be low needs and some times you can be high needs.

It's ignorance of the condition that's so frustrating.

CoffeeWithCheese · 16/01/2024 13:59

I'm autistic, one DD is autistic and the other is waiting for diagnosis. We all function "well" in that we're verbal communicators, in mainstream education or professional jobs - societally we're chugging along OK. However, we have various things that we all find challenging, but because we have the cognitive capacity to process these things, develop strategies to mitigate them and generally mask the shit out of the remaining anxiety and overload... our "support needs" in terms of if we had to write a wish list of reasonable adjustments are generally minimal (I think my work adjustments boil down to - "I might have earphones on if it's noisy or I'm particularly overloaded" and "for the love of God can I not have the 5th change in line manager in a year because I'm running low on reserves for processing change without turning into an over anxious wreck").

I may share a diagnosis with someone who has intellectual disabilities, autism and other potential co-morbidities such as ADHD or dyspraxia - but their support needs will be much greater than mine in terms of what they need other people to provide; whatever the system likes to think - we do not function like nice neat tickboxes where "the system says you have autism and you must need this nice easy read document with symbols and pretty pictures instead of words" (which is a personal pet hate of mine since a lot of my work involves developing the bloody easy-reads in the first place) and similar. Basically people are individuals, people may share a diagnosis (which is basically just a checklist of various features they display in the way they process and respond to the world), but they are no more one-size-fits-all than describing "normal" or "typical"... what the fuck is "typical" anyway?!

What does piss me off massively about any discussion on autism (and the articulate section of the autism community in general) is the endless distraction from real issues like discrimination and how we can move to a world which functions better for more people - by fucking arguments over how other people choose to refer to THEIR condition (my autism = if I want to paint it purple, stand it in a corner and call it Dave I can do) and also laying into parents of children who do not communicate verbally and have autism when they dare to advocate for their kids. Yes, not all communication is verbal, and yes, every single individual I meet who does not fully communicate verbally (and I meet a LOT) has their own ways of very very clearly communicating when they're pissed off, or happy, or wanting more chocolate or whatever - but still this communication often needs to be interpreted by someone who knows them very very well - I can write the most superb communication passport in the world, but I will never be able to describe and understand their communication as well as their parents do. I've seen some absolutely vile pile-ons of parents trying to advocate for their autistic children.

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 13:50

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 13:36

For the millionth time, the science around the brain and neurodivergent conditions like ASD is very patchy and still in its infancy in many ways. There simply isn't the certainty in this area that there is with many physical conditions. This doesn't mean that the conditions aren't real and the struggles associated with them aren't real, but we are only really just starting to understand the brain and how ND behaviours are related to this. Developing an accurate diagnostic test for conditions you have limited understanding of is obviously very difficult and currently relies on behavioural tests that are intrinsically less accurate and objective than other tests you can conduct for physical conditions.

In this context, it will of course be controversial to create a binary system where we pretend that people can be definitively ND or NT and nothing in-between. The notion that NT even exists at all is controversial, let alone that everyone must be NT if they don't meet the very specific criteria that is currently favoured for ND conditions. Not to mention that there is no universal definition of which conditions actually fall under the ND banner so who can and can't call themselves ND. The whole concept is obviously deeply flawed and has at its core exclusionary principles. You're in or you're out. If you're in then you can access support and have your needs acknowledged, if you're out then you have a hell of a fight on your hands to be taken seriously.

But when it comes to who needs accommodations and who doesn't of course this is is determined by behavioural tests rather than physical. A blood test isn't going to tell you who needs extra time in their exam or a quieter room to work in. That's always going to be down to the individual's behaviours even if we did develop a diagnostic test.

If you feel you have support needs that aren't being met and you're angry that other people have been able to access accommodations that you would also like - which it sounds like you are - have you taken any practical steps to obtain this support, or even get a diagnosis of your own? Or is this a case of 'I have to struggle so other people should too'?

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 13:48

alltootired · 16/01/2024 13:35

@x2boys I agree with you. Many who say their autism is not a disability would say your son's difficulties are not to do with his autism. As if they are an expert on someone they have not even met. Makes me so angry.
Whether you call it severe or complex autism such children and adults obviously have a different level of care needs. They can not mask.

I think the problem is that as terms are deemed offensive, we lose the language we need to accurately explain the very real differences that exist within an overarching condition.

I read an article recently about a mother favouring the use of the term 'profoundly autistic' to describe her child. Describing her as merely 'autistic' just doesn't cut it when you have people that can function in high power careers with minimal support using this description alongside people that can't talk or go to the toilet. It is helpful for people to be able to use language in a concise and meaningful way to quickly convey the severity of the condition and needs they are actually talking about. This, like many physical disabilities, might fluctuate over time but there still needs to be some, relatively easy way of communicating this.

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 13:36

AloeNora · 16/01/2024 13:21

I should not have to justify the diagnoses given by consultants that my children and I have. They are there to protect them in education, the NHS and other important areas of society. It’s deeply offensive.

Nowhere else in RL do you have to do this. No other disability has to do this.

For the millionth time, the science around the brain and neurodivergent conditions like ASD is very patchy and still in its infancy in many ways. There simply isn't the certainty in this area that there is with many physical conditions. This doesn't mean that the conditions aren't real and the struggles associated with them aren't real, but we are only really just starting to understand the brain and how ND behaviours are related to this. Developing an accurate diagnostic test for conditions you have limited understanding of is obviously very difficult and currently relies on behavioural tests that are intrinsically less accurate and objective than other tests you can conduct for physical conditions.

In this context, it will of course be controversial to create a binary system where we pretend that people can be definitively ND or NT and nothing in-between. The notion that NT even exists at all is controversial, let alone that everyone must be NT if they don't meet the very specific criteria that is currently favoured for ND conditions. Not to mention that there is no universal definition of which conditions actually fall under the ND banner so who can and can't call themselves ND. The whole concept is obviously deeply flawed and has at its core exclusionary principles. You're in or you're out. If you're in then you can access support and have your needs acknowledged, if you're out then you have a hell of a fight on your hands to be taken seriously.

alltootired · 16/01/2024 13:35

@x2boys I agree with you. Many who say their autism is not a disability would say your son's difficulties are not to do with his autism. As if they are an expert on someone they have not even met. Makes me so angry.
Whether you call it severe or complex autism such children and adults obviously have a different level of care needs. They can not mask.

gluggle · 16/01/2024 13:33

CoffeeCantata · 16/01/2024 13:07

ronoi · Today 12:51

@Littlefish

Aspergers has not been a diagnosis for 10 years. Your daughter is autistic.

That's not true. Up until 31 December 2021
it was in the ICD10.

Thank you, ronoi.

My daughter is now 33 and was told on diagnosis some 5 years ago that she was mildly affected by Aspergers. But here I've been rudely told I'm imagining this by more than one angry and aggressive poster.

She's a (mostly) happy, intelligent, highly articulate and sociable person but as a child had a number of sensory issues which we and she only later realised may have been due to autism (not liking cold drinks, loud noises or scratchy clothes, for eg). This was all in the early 90s when all these things were far less in the open. She also has a diagnosis of BPD, which again helped her and us to understand her issues and to give her support.

According to one poster, my daughter deserves sympathy because I'm so ignorant. Well, I did apologise for my (comparative) ignorance at the beginning of my post. I'm not a clinician and I'm not in a profession in which ND matters are discussed, so I am probably not up to speed like some of the posters here. I think that poster's friends and family deserve sympathy for having such a rude and aggressive relation!

Actually my daughter and I get on brilliantly and she would not recognise or agree with that accusation.

I was neither rude nor aggressive to you. Plenty of posters on here have agreed with my reply.

I'm not in a profession in which ND matters are discussed either, but as a parent I make sure I am fully informed about something that affects my child. It's not hard nowadays to bring yourself "up to speed". So please don't feel sorry for my family - I recognised the signs of autism in my DD, I pursued a diagnosis for her, and I work hard every day to try and make her life easier, be her advocate, help her understand herself and give her the best foundation to live with her disability.

SayNoToDoorToDoor · 16/01/2024 13:28

“Except the term was absolutely included up until the end of 2021 in the ICD 10. It doesn't matter what you were told, probably by a clinician who used the DSM at the assessment.”

No Ronoi that was not the case.

Try to find anywhere on the nhs website that refers to an Aspergers diagnosis rather than ASD. You’re not going to be dissuaded other than what you believe so you do you.

x2boys · 16/01/2024 13:25

alltootired · 16/01/2024 13:10

I also find in these discussions non verbal autistic children and adults are usually made invisible. I have seen parents on MN describing their child's difficulties only to be told by a poster who says they are autistic that the difficulties are not due to autism, but a co-morbidity.
Autism can include a child who is non verbal, doubly incontinent, and with little understanding of what is being said to them. However convenient it is for some to pretend that is not the case.

Indeed this is m son although we did manage to toilet train him was ten
He presents as though he has severe learning disabilities but actually who knows maybe it's because his autism is so profound
Children wit such complex needs ,need their parents to speak foe hen because they can't speak for themselves

alltootired · 16/01/2024 13:25

@AloeNora please do not pronounce on other disabilities. You are totally wrong.

ssd · 16/01/2024 13:23

I feckin hate 'discuss'

AloeNora · 16/01/2024 13:21

I should not have to justify the diagnoses given by consultants that my children and I have. They are there to protect them in education, the NHS and other important areas of society. It’s deeply offensive.

Nowhere else in RL do you have to do this. No other disability has to do this.

ronoi · 16/01/2024 13:20

SayNoToDoorToDoor · 16/01/2024 13:17

My son was diagnosed with ASD in 2012 and was also told that he would have been diagnosed with Aspergers but this term was no longer used.

The term was discontinued as a diagnosis to avoid the misconception that Aspergers was a different condition from autism.

Except the term was absolutely included up until the end of 2021 in the ICD 10. It doesn't matter what you were told, probably by a clinician who used the DSM at the assessment.

SayNoToDoorToDoor · 16/01/2024 13:17

My son was diagnosed with ASD in 2012 and was also told that he would have been diagnosed with Aspergers but this term was no longer used.

The term was discontinued as a diagnosis to avoid the misconception that Aspergers was a different condition from autism.

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 13:12

AnonymousMusing · 16/01/2024 12:38

OP, as someone with two neurodiverse conditions, the idea that whether I can describe my reality, as assessed by a psychologist, is up for a cheery debate is deeply offensive.

You wouldn't have a thread stating that "I've got a slight twinge in my knee, therefore we're all a bit physically disabled", so why you (or anyone else) finds it acceptable to discuss neurodiversity in this way is baffling.

Another example of people trying to shut down important and valid discussion. You have two ND diagnosis so feel like you can police all discussion on the NT/ND model presumably because you think it currently works well for you.

Any suggestion that the binary model might not be helpful for others and could lead to some people struggling desperately but not autistic/ADHD/OCD 'enough' for a diagnosis and to be recognised as ND just doesn't concern you. The very patchy science that underlies all of this combined with so much support and help riding on getting an ND diagnosis is a recipe for disaster for those that don't fit into our current neat little definitions.

How on earth you can describe this as some 'cheery' debate puzzles me completely!

alltootired · 16/01/2024 13:10

I also find in these discussions non verbal autistic children and adults are usually made invisible. I have seen parents on MN describing their child's difficulties only to be told by a poster who says they are autistic that the difficulties are not due to autism, but a co-morbidity.
Autism can include a child who is non verbal, doubly incontinent, and with little understanding of what is being said to them. However convenient it is for some to pretend that is not the case.

CoffeeCantata · 16/01/2024 13:07

ronoi · Today 12:51

@Littlefish

Aspergers has not been a diagnosis for 10 years. Your daughter is autistic.

That's not true. Up until 31 December 2021
it was in the ICD10.

Thank you, ronoi.

My daughter is now 33 and was told on diagnosis some 5 years ago that she was mildly affected by Aspergers. But here I've been rudely told I'm imagining this by more than one angry and aggressive poster.

She's a (mostly) happy, intelligent, highly articulate and sociable person but as a child had a number of sensory issues which we and she only later realised may have been due to autism (not liking cold drinks, loud noises or scratchy clothes, for eg). This was all in the early 90s when all these things were far less in the open. She also has a diagnosis of BPD, which again helped her and us to understand her issues and to give her support.

According to one poster, my daughter deserves sympathy because I'm so ignorant. Well, I did apologise for my (comparative) ignorance at the beginning of my post. I'm not a clinician and I'm not in a profession in which ND matters are discussed, so I am probably not up to speed like some of the posters here. I think that poster's friends and family deserve sympathy for having such a rude and aggressive relation!

Actually my daughter and I get on brilliantly and she would not recognise or agree with that accusation.

Spendonsend · 16/01/2024 13:06

I didnt take the op to mean that all the various diagnosis that are covered under neurodiverse didnt exist but more asking whether lumping them all together opposite neurotypical was helpful.

I maybe missed a nuance that everyone else saw.

I dont personally find saying neurodiverse helpful to describe my son. Its vague unbrella term in my mind that doesnt help him get the support he needs.

I can see why others either arent diagnosed yet or dont want to go into their medical history with a stranger might use it.

RainbowZebraWarrior · 16/01/2024 13:05

"This new approach approaches emotional distress for everyone by asking what sources of power you have over you, what resources you have, what happened to you, what meaning did you take from it and what coping mechanisms have you developed"

This is a really dangerous attitude. The point at which most adults seek assessment is because they are not coping. The coping mechanisms have usually long since failed. In order to be considered diagnosis, there has to be a significant impact upon one's life.

A person may cope throughout their 20s, 30s and even later. But continuous burnout leads to poor health, and avoidance is then employed. People start to struggle to socialise, work and function at differnt points. There has to be diagnosis option in order to support and legally protect those who have those significant impacts. Otherwise, what? those of us with Autism just all disappear into the abyss?

Yes, we know that everyone will experience distress in this world at different times of their life. That's entirely understandable. But this article and, therefore, the argument, just doubles down on the 'But we are all a bit like that sometimes' trope.

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 13:04

MyopicBunny · 16/01/2024 12:57

Probably, but there is clearly a valid reason why clinicians are moving away from using it.

Because Hans Asperger was a Nazi who experimented on vulnerable children and condemned the ones he felt less useful to the death camps.

ronoi · 16/01/2024 13:03

MyopicBunny · 16/01/2024 12:57

Probably, but there is clearly a valid reason why clinicians are moving away from using it.

I don't disagree

alltootired · 16/01/2024 13:03

I am struck once again how little understanding most people have of other disabilities. Mild, moderate and severe are used with other disabilities and chronic illnesses all the time.
I have a mild disability. It still affects me every day and I have been in hospital for treatment. Other mild disabilities can worsen and become moderate or severe.
This is accepted with physical disabilities. And it is quite common for physical disabilities to become much harder to deal with as you age. What a young body can compensate for to some degree, is not possible in an older body.
So when this is widely accepted with physical disabilities why is it seen as threatening with autism, ADHD, etc? Or is it just that people with these have no understanding of other physical disabilities and somehow think they are being insulted?

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 13:01

AfterTheSummer · 16/01/2024 10:55

I think people will probably start talking more about specific diagnoses and less about neurodivergence, which is such a broad category that it can be quite unhelpful.

People already do, but it's contextual, surely. Sometimes it's appropriate to speak about your specific diagnosis, sometimes you're making a broader point and it's more relevant to talk about ND people in general. Similar to conversations about race, sometimes you might refer to the BME community in general, sometimes you might talk specifically about Asian people or Black people , or about particular ethnic groups or nationalities. It depends exactly what you're having a conversation about. It's ok and sometimes useful to have a range of terminology available.

lljkk · 16/01/2024 12:57

Language & preferred words change all the time, that's why the terms will be superseded.

The idea that people will stop categorising... neah, that won't happen !

Swipe left for the next trending thread