Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think the terms "neuro diverse" and "neuro typical" will be short lived.

462 replies

theplatformedge · 16/01/2024 08:30

Diversity means "a range of many people or things that are very different from each other" (Oxford learner's dictionary), so the idea that a minority of people are "neuro diverse" and everyone else is "neuro typical" is not only semantically illogical, but also potentially offensive.

We're all different. Some people have traits that make life more difficult for them than others, whether it be ASD, ADHD or a range of other conditions, with spectrums of severity. Telling people that you're neuro-diverse is so vague as to be meaningless, and telling other people they are nero-typical when you have no idea what they're feeling inside is insensitive. Some people get a formal diagnosis for their symptoms, some people self-diagnose and others don't recognise it in themselves. Nobody knows how many people are living with these traits across the population, but the massive increase in diagnostics suggests they're a lot more common than anyone ever thought in the past, and therefore gradually becoming very "typical".

Discuss! 🙂

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Blomh · 16/01/2024 15:39

Why have an ND and NT distinction when very few people would be considered truly NT?
That’s simply not true. The vast majority of people are NT. Obviously not identical but their abilities fall within a certain acceptable range. People who are ND fall very far outside that range.

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 15:28

I don't know about other workplaces since I've worked in the same company for 20 years, but where I work it pretty much is the case that how your condition affects your role is what matters for accommodations. It's all individual anyway and would be based on a conversation with occupational health. I don't think anywhere offers accommodation purely on the basis of diagnosis, ie if you have autism you get XYZ accommodation, nothing more nothing less, never mind whether you do or don't need it.

My workplace also specifies you don't need a diagnosis to ask for accommodations as they recognise getting a diagnosis isn't always straightforward and waiting lists are long. I don't know how typical that is but I think that should be universal.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 16/01/2024 15:26

alltootired · 16/01/2024 15:04

People with cancer will also say what stage the cancer is. It is graded.

Cancer is a broad catchall for a number of different kinds of cancer.

Also it's a progressive disease. It has to be graded, because you access different treatments at each stage and have a varying chance of overcoming the disease.

Autism isn't a disease.

Apples to oranges on that one.

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 15:24

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 15:12

In terms of what we were talking about though, getting accommodations in the workplace or wherever, anxiety disorders don't need to come with a diagnosis of neurodivergence to be considered for accommodation in their own right.

No, but the people that I was referring to in that conversation had traits of anxiety rather than a full blown anxiety disorder. I was using them as an example alongside other 'NT' friends with OCD type behaviours etc to make the point that ND traits are rife and some have a huge impact on people's day to day lives. Why have an ND and NT distinction when very few people would be considered truly NT? Why imply it's black and white when it isn't?

I sometimes wonder why this is so badly received on MN because inevitably these threads attract a lot of people with ASD and this can be associated with quite rigid thinking. They have been told they are emphatically ND and this differentiates them from everyone else. I can imagine it's quite distressing to have this questioned and for posters to raise the grey areas and uncertainty that exists. I do sympathise with this but I blame the system for giving them false certainty when the science isn't there to substantiate this.

user1497207191 · 16/01/2024 15:18

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 15:12

In terms of what we were talking about though, getting accommodations in the workplace or wherever, anxiety disorders don't need to come with a diagnosis of neurodivergence to be considered for accommodation in their own right.

I think there should be more flexibility in workplaces for everyone, not just for those with a formal diagnosis. And accommodations should be based more on the issue and duties etc rather, i.e. a kind of "fit note" basis where it's not the diagnosis that grants accommodations, but how the condition affects the person, given their role. I think what I'm saying is that we need workplaces (and I suppose all educational institutions too) to have a culture of flexibility for everyone and end the "one size fits all" approach. If we could change the culture, people wouldn't need to jump through hoops to get a formal diagnosis and that would also relieve pressure on healthcare workers.

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 15:12

In terms of what we were talking about though, getting accommodations in the workplace or wherever, anxiety disorders don't need to come with a diagnosis of neurodivergence to be considered for accommodation in their own right.

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 15:07

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 14:57

I haven't ever seen someone claim to be neurodiverse purely on the basis of having an anxiety disorder.

Some experts believe it is a form of ND as it can stem from differences in the brain's structure and also because it can have a genetic link and other elements similar to other conditions under the ND umbrella. It can also be co-morbid with other ND conditions so it's a complex picture.

Whether anxiety and OCD will come to be as universally accepted as ND conditions like ASD and ADHD remains to be seen but it's clear this area is still evolving and there is every chance we will see further, even bigger changes in the future as our science improves and we understand the brain better.

Spendonsend · 16/01/2024 15:07

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 14:57

I haven't ever seen someone claim to be neurodiverse purely on the basis of having an anxiety disorder.

Have a look at some of the graphics out there shoewng neurodiversity. The ones used by charities or in training. They do vary a lot. Some have a few conditions in them. But others are really broad. Anxiety is in quite a few of them. Ive seen them with epilepsy in too.

alltootired · 16/01/2024 15:04

People with cancer will also say what stage the cancer is. It is graded.

x2boys · 16/01/2024 15:00

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 14:35

Things like anxiety, OCD etc aren't ND traits though, they are symptoms which other conditons can also share. I wouldn't say someone with an anxiety order was neurodiverse on that basis, though clearly they have a real condition they need support with. Neurotypical doesn't mean "normal" as such and it doesn't mean someone can't have another mental or physical illness while still being neurotypical.

I absolutely get what people say about ND or autism being umbrella terms, but it's worth considering we use umbrella terms for lots of other conditions as well and it doesn't seem to provoke the same reaction. If I say I'm a cancer patient that's also an umbrella term - cancer isn't one condition, and the effect, impact, prognosis etc varies vastly according to type of cancer and the individual. We talk about people having auto-immune conditions or eating disorders or heart disease or being hard of hearing - all of these are umbrella terms. The actual diagnosis will vary as will the impact on the individual. But we'd never say you shouldn't ever use those terms, we recognise they're useful sometimes. Because being neurodiverse can be invisible I think it gets targeted as do mental illnesses. Just because you can't see someone is struggling doesn't mean they aren't.

That said I do agree workplaces should be vastly more accomodating of individual needs, workstyles etc without the need of a diagnosis. But there's a difference between say having a preference for a quiet space and having a need for one or you simply won't cope.

True but cancer patients don't tend to think they have the authority on all types of cancer / treatments etc unlike Some people with autism
Nor would you get a cancer paitient telling the parent of a child with cancer t
They have no right to talk about cancer in negative terms because it doesn't affect hem personally unlike some people with autism
My oldest son was diagnosed with Diabetes last year I'm on various face book groups for Diabetes ,and there is just not same arguing in those groups unllke there are for some autism groups I have Been.in

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 14:57

I haven't ever seen someone claim to be neurodiverse purely on the basis of having an anxiety disorder.

alltootired · 16/01/2024 14:56

@Jimmyneutronsforehead it was an easy example. But plenty of people are born with physical disabilities.
Mild, moderate and severe are shorthand used for all physical disabilities. But are a big no no when it comes to neurodiversity.
I think it just makes those with profound autism invisible.

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 14:53

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 14:35

Things like anxiety, OCD etc aren't ND traits though, they are symptoms which other conditons can also share. I wouldn't say someone with an anxiety order was neurodiverse on that basis, though clearly they have a real condition they need support with. Neurotypical doesn't mean "normal" as such and it doesn't mean someone can't have another mental or physical illness while still being neurotypical.

I absolutely get what people say about ND or autism being umbrella terms, but it's worth considering we use umbrella terms for lots of other conditions as well and it doesn't seem to provoke the same reaction. If I say I'm a cancer patient that's also an umbrella term - cancer isn't one condition, and the effect, impact, prognosis etc varies vastly according to type of cancer and the individual. We talk about people having auto-immune conditions or eating disorders or heart disease or being hard of hearing - all of these are umbrella terms. The actual diagnosis will vary as will the impact on the individual. But we'd never say you shouldn't ever use those terms, we recognise they're useful sometimes. Because being neurodiverse can be invisible I think it gets targeted as do mental illnesses. Just because you can't see someone is struggling doesn't mean they aren't.

That said I do agree workplaces should be vastly more accomodating of individual needs, workstyles etc without the need of a diagnosis. But there's a difference between say having a preference for a quiet space and having a need for one or you simply won't cope.

OCD and anxiety are absolutely considered ND conditions under some definitions. This is part of the problem, there isn't a definitive list of conditions that are accepted as ND in the first place. We then can't really define with any real certainty what tips someone from being NT with traits of a ND condition to being considered ND. The diagnosis process isn't accurate enough to do this and isn't really capable of dealing with those suffering greatly with ND traits but don't fit neatly into an accepted diagnosis. It is totally possible and common for someone who doesn't quite meet the threshold for a condition to suffer more with their traits than someone that has been diagnosed with the condition. The binary NT/ND system just has no space for this kind of scenario or any other complexity.

This is all exacerbated by the false certainty that exists around the NT/ND distinction that makes each side suspicious of the other. It's all 'othering' and very black and white when the science is super grey. So whilst I accept that it can be a useful umbrella term to raise visibility etc, I think on balance it does more harm than good.

I agree with you on your last point and the need to identify how necessary each accommodation is at an individual level irrespective of diagnosis. If someone literally cannot focus on an open plan office for example then they should be allowed to work elsewhere whether they have a formal diagnosis of an ND condition or not.

gamerchick · 16/01/2024 14:47

ssd · 16/01/2024 13:23

I feckin hate 'discuss'

It made me laugh. OP is here effectively telling people to change their language and ends it by using language everyone hates.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 16/01/2024 14:45

alltootired · 16/01/2024 14:28

@Jimmyneutronsforehead If you have mild arthritis the impact will vary day by day. In cold weather you will struggle more. You will struggle more on some days when you have tasks that are more challenging with your arthritis.
But it will still be mild arthritis.

Well, the way I see it is you're either arthritic, or you're not, but you might have lower support needs for your arthritis than other people who have arthritis, and even your needs may change.

You don't get Joe Bloggs telling you "every ones a little bit arthritic though aren't they", or "oh I think I've got arthritis because (insert this very human behaviour here) but we all are a little bit aren't we?"

Because terms like that aren't helpful.

So what you're saying is that you do have arthritis, however you can recognise that on some days, your arthritis affects you more than it does others.

It's very binary as to whether you have the condition or not, but your support needs or how it affects you can operate on a spectrum.

However autism, unlike arthritis, isn't necessarily something that gets worse with age. It can absolutely remain high needs throughout your entire life, but it isn't an inevitability for every one like it is with those with an autoimmune condition, it's a neurodivergence instead.

It might be a helpful way of getting your point across to someone in a shortened and roundabout way that you've got mild arthritis, but the fact is, you've just got arthritis. And those that don't have arthritis, don't.

alltootired · 16/01/2024 14:37

@Jimmyneutronsforehead that is the same for any disability. Physical disabilities are still described as mild, moderate or severe.

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 14:35

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 14:11

I think this is probably the crux of the issue for many.

There are very many people with ND traits that wouldn't meet the threshold for a formal diagnosis and yet would benefit greatly from accommodations being made and support being available in specific areas. The problem is that the system relies on the majority being NT and coping with the 'standard' provision to allow the ND/NT model to exist. Accommodations and support are therefore only made available to those with a formal diagnosis and nothing is afforded to everyone else irrespective of the level of need they may have. The fact that the diagnosis is based on incomplete science and an imperfect diagnostic process just adds to the problems of having such a binary system.

My anger isn't on my behalf but on behalf of family members and others that I know. A specific family member did pursue an ASD diagnosis and didn't meet the threshold despite having pretty extreme symptoms in some areas of their life. I simply don't accept that they are NT. I actually see ND traits in most people I know and many suffer to the point where it really impacts their day to day life (anxiety, OCD type behaviour, impulsive behaviour). They wouldn't meet the threshold for a diagnosis but they could definitely do with some support in specific areas and some of they behaviour would be considered incompatible with what people would consider a NT person to be.

Things like anxiety, OCD etc aren't ND traits though, they are symptoms which other conditons can also share. I wouldn't say someone with an anxiety order was neurodiverse on that basis, though clearly they have a real condition they need support with. Neurotypical doesn't mean "normal" as such and it doesn't mean someone can't have another mental or physical illness while still being neurotypical.

I absolutely get what people say about ND or autism being umbrella terms, but it's worth considering we use umbrella terms for lots of other conditions as well and it doesn't seem to provoke the same reaction. If I say I'm a cancer patient that's also an umbrella term - cancer isn't one condition, and the effect, impact, prognosis etc varies vastly according to type of cancer and the individual. We talk about people having auto-immune conditions or eating disorders or heart disease or being hard of hearing - all of these are umbrella terms. The actual diagnosis will vary as will the impact on the individual. But we'd never say you shouldn't ever use those terms, we recognise they're useful sometimes. Because being neurodiverse can be invisible I think it gets targeted as do mental illnesses. Just because you can't see someone is struggling doesn't mean they aren't.

That said I do agree workplaces should be vastly more accomodating of individual needs, workstyles etc without the need of a diagnosis. But there's a difference between say having a preference for a quiet space and having a need for one or you simply won't cope.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 16/01/2024 14:30

x2boys · 16/01/2024 14:13

For some they don't my son has high needs for every aspect of is daily living his needs won't ever change .

Yes, it's true some people will remain high needs all of their life, but needs will still change for many. It has for me, going from low to high needs and for my son who was very high needs, who now has differing needs in different environments but his support needs have decreased.

Some people will also remain on the lower end of the spectrum for support needs.

There are a lot of factors that go into it, such as other comorbidities, and environmental factors, and no one autistic person is the same as the next.

x2boys · 16/01/2024 14:28

itsmyp4rty · 16/01/2024 14:21

I completely disagree OP. ND just covers a number of diagnoses that anyone might have a combination of. People only talk about NT in terms of ND IME, it's just used to differentiate when you're talking about both sorts of people. If you don't find the terms useful though just don't use them. No one is forcing you to.

It's the same with a lot of terms. Some people don't like the term ASD because they don't see it as a disorder or don't like the term disorder and prefer ASC. I use ASD because it doesn't bother me and it's more widely understood. That doesn't mean that other people have to use it though.

My DS has a diagnosis of Aspergers. I use the term Asperger's all the time because that is his diagnosis. If other people are offended I don't care. No one is calling for BMW to change it's name because of it's association with the Nazis.

I also don't understand the argument that autistic needs change and so everyone should be lumped in under one term - to me there needs to be some variation in an ASD diagnosis. Yes my DS may have varying needs in what he can cope with day to day - but he's never going to be locked in his own world and not be able to communicate at all. He might struggle at university but he's still going to be able to get there. I think lumping everyone in together doesn't help anyone and actually there should be more variation in diagnosis to reflect the diversity, not less. Otherwise people know of one autistic child/person and think they know them all.

Just use the terms that suit you and stop implying that most people are a bit ND when 80-85% of the population are estimated to be NT.

Edited

I agree with you it does both our sons a disservice to lump them together when their needs are so vastly different.

alltootired · 16/01/2024 14:28

@Jimmyneutronsforehead If you have mild arthritis the impact will vary day by day. In cold weather you will struggle more. You will struggle more on some days when you have tasks that are more challenging with your arthritis.
But it will still be mild arthritis.

alltootired · 16/01/2024 14:25

@Jimmyneutronsforehead who do you think that is any different from other disabilities?

itsmyp4rty · 16/01/2024 14:21

I completely disagree OP. ND just covers a number of diagnoses that anyone might have a combination of. People only talk about NT in terms of ND IME, it's just used to differentiate when you're talking about both sorts of people. If you don't find the terms useful though just don't use them. No one is forcing you to.

It's the same with a lot of terms. Some people don't like the term ASD because they don't see it as a disorder or don't like the term disorder and prefer ASC. I use ASD because it doesn't bother me and it's more widely understood. That doesn't mean that other people have to use it though.

My DS has a diagnosis of Aspergers. I use the term Asperger's all the time because that is his diagnosis. If other people are offended I don't care. No one is calling for BMW to change it's name because of it's association with the Nazis.

I also don't understand the argument that autistic needs change and so everyone should be lumped in under one term - to me there needs to be some variation in an ASD diagnosis. Yes my DS may have varying needs in what he can cope with day to day - but he's never going to be locked in his own world and not be able to communicate at all. He might struggle at university but he's still going to be able to get there. I think lumping everyone in together doesn't help anyone and actually there should be more variation in diagnosis to reflect the diversity, not less. Otherwise people know of one autistic child/person and think they know them all.

Just use the terms that suit you and stop implying that most people are a bit ND when 80-85% of the population are estimated to be NT.

x2boys · 16/01/2024 14:13

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 16/01/2024 13:59

Because needs change so frequently. Some days, weeks, months you could be low needs and some times you can be high needs.

It's ignorance of the condition that's so frustrating.

For some they don't my son has high needs for every aspect of is daily living his needs won't ever change .

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 14:11

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 13:50

But when it comes to who needs accommodations and who doesn't of course this is is determined by behavioural tests rather than physical. A blood test isn't going to tell you who needs extra time in their exam or a quieter room to work in. That's always going to be down to the individual's behaviours even if we did develop a diagnostic test.

If you feel you have support needs that aren't being met and you're angry that other people have been able to access accommodations that you would also like - which it sounds like you are - have you taken any practical steps to obtain this support, or even get a diagnosis of your own? Or is this a case of 'I have to struggle so other people should too'?

I think this is probably the crux of the issue for many.

There are very many people with ND traits that wouldn't meet the threshold for a formal diagnosis and yet would benefit greatly from accommodations being made and support being available in specific areas. The problem is that the system relies on the majority being NT and coping with the 'standard' provision to allow the ND/NT model to exist. Accommodations and support are therefore only made available to those with a formal diagnosis and nothing is afforded to everyone else irrespective of the level of need they may have. The fact that the diagnosis is based on incomplete science and an imperfect diagnostic process just adds to the problems of having such a binary system.

My anger isn't on my behalf but on behalf of family members and others that I know. A specific family member did pursue an ASD diagnosis and didn't meet the threshold despite having pretty extreme symptoms in some areas of their life. I simply don't accept that they are NT. I actually see ND traits in most people I know and many suffer to the point where it really impacts their day to day life (anxiety, OCD type behaviour, impulsive behaviour). They wouldn't meet the threshold for a diagnosis but they could definitely do with some support in specific areas and some of they behaviour would be considered incompatible with what people would consider a NT person to be.

ronoi · 16/01/2024 14:10

SayNoToDoorToDoor · 16/01/2024 13:28

“Except the term was absolutely included up until the end of 2021 in the ICD 10. It doesn't matter what you were told, probably by a clinician who used the DSM at the assessment.”

No Ronoi that was not the case.

Try to find anywhere on the nhs website that refers to an Aspergers diagnosis rather than ASD. You’re not going to be dissuaded other than what you believe so you do you.

Nothing to do with the NHS website 

Asperger's WAS included in the ICD 10 and valid as a diagnosis until December 2021.

That is a fact, not a belief.