Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think the terms "neuro diverse" and "neuro typical" will be short lived.

462 replies

theplatformedge · 16/01/2024 08:30

Diversity means "a range of many people or things that are very different from each other" (Oxford learner's dictionary), so the idea that a minority of people are "neuro diverse" and everyone else is "neuro typical" is not only semantically illogical, but also potentially offensive.

We're all different. Some people have traits that make life more difficult for them than others, whether it be ASD, ADHD or a range of other conditions, with spectrums of severity. Telling people that you're neuro-diverse is so vague as to be meaningless, and telling other people they are nero-typical when you have no idea what they're feeling inside is insensitive. Some people get a formal diagnosis for their symptoms, some people self-diagnose and others don't recognise it in themselves. Nobody knows how many people are living with these traits across the population, but the massive increase in diagnostics suggests they're a lot more common than anyone ever thought in the past, and therefore gradually becoming very "typical".

Discuss! 🙂

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
DyslexicPoster · 17/01/2024 08:34

maddening · 17/01/2024 07:33

Personality and personal identity has nothing to do with neuro diversity though. It doesn't mean your thinking and cognitive processes are any different to anyone else and "from what you have seen" means nothing - your judgement and perception of other people gives you no insight whatsoever to their cognitive processes and internal thoughts.

I haven't said I am ND. Or NT. Im just saying I dont think, i think like most people and i dont even rememberwhat i was talking about now.

I'm a hoarder. That's a DSM condition. So i probably do think like most people. However i am guessing from mu pov I do not think like most people. Maybe I do. Hoarding is a compulsive repetitive thing. Maybe it's not part of my personality either.

If I was a serial murderer I could be fairly sure I wasn't thinking like most people.

So if we micro direct it. My childten has Autism and other SEN. I do not.

I would explain my children as having SEN as they have ehcps so legally they do have SEN as there's argument to be had. They go to a SEN school too. So I'd say they are ND

I am like the vast majority of the population. I am NT.

Maybe OP is correct. I'd hate to have to have to justify either their sen. To justify why they have ASD.

Flensburg · 17/01/2024 08:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Groundhoghcg · 17/01/2024 08:25

They are very helpful words if you live, know or work with people with ASD/LD/mental health problems. They are not helpful if we say "everyone is ND" because while we are all different this isn't the point or what ND means. Neurotypical replaces 'normal' or 'not disabled' which both have obvious problems. My sister is severely autistic and I often found myself saying I'm normal, I'm the normal one. It's rubbish and ND/NT work much better.

People with ADHD or ASD can find that the world isn't designed with their needs in mind, it's an easy shorthand to say "sorry these bright lights/queuing system/exam set up/party/loud noise may not work for me" and explain the adaptions people use or need.

'Additional needs' works fairly well for children but can be patronising for adults who for the most part will have their own plans and set ups for navigating life.

As for severe/mild autism.. come on. Some people with ASD (my sister) are non verbal, need 24/7 care, can't manage lots of aspects of life. Some people like my dad have ASD and have full time jobs, children, social lives.. his ASD is real and massively affects him but is objectively mild on the spectrum.

We do need words to describe things and while it's important to be sensitive it can't all be focused on validating feelings.

Daftasabroom · 17/01/2024 08:07

LewishamMumNow · 16/01/2024 22:50

I'm saying it's mild for autism because sadly it is. The condition can get really serious. It would probably be better for Aspergers to still be in wider use - that way people with the difficulties you describe could have severe Aspergers, or just Aspergers if you prefer. But within the spectrum of autism, someone with the level of functionality you describe, though clearly very significant in their own right, is still only mildly autistic, simply because of how severe it gets.
Some conditions are more severe than others eg mild autism is still way more of an interference in normal day to day living than severe dyslexia would be.

mild autism is still way more of an interference in normal day to day living than severe dyslexia would be.

That is completely wrong on so many levels, you really have absolutely no idea what you're talking about.

Daftasabroom · 17/01/2024 07:54

@ronoi the autistic spectrum doesn't place people in order of severity

Not people but traits, but that's pretty much exactly what it does,

maddening · 17/01/2024 07:33

DyslexicPoster · 16/01/2024 23:22

I'm not referring to my dyslexia. I'm talking personality. Of course I can't be sure the majority of people don't think like me, but from what I see, I can be reasonably certain they don't.

I don't define myself as dyslexic. But I had to change my username because I got pissed off with fuckers impling I'm as thick as shit picking apart my spelling. You can be dyslexic and very strange indeed just like you can be non dyslexic and very strange. I'm a programmer and lots of my fellow programmers are dyslexic so that's pretty standard in my world. None of them are strange ( to me).

Personality and personal identity has nothing to do with neuro diversity though. It doesn't mean your thinking and cognitive processes are any different to anyone else and "from what you have seen" means nothing - your judgement and perception of other people gives you no insight whatsoever to their cognitive processes and internal thoughts.

Daftasabroom · 17/01/2024 07:31

YourTruthorMine · 16/01/2024 19:20

Well as I believe autism and ADHD are the same thing anyway, it doesn't really make much difference to me. Science will catch up eventually.

Science will catch up with your beliefs?

firef1y · 17/01/2024 07:18

PaperSheet · 16/01/2024 22:06

To the people that are dead against using the words mild or severe etc, surely you've just moved the same word to in front of "mental impairment" or "learning difficulties" etc?
So what used to be people saying my child has severe autism, you now want people to say my child has autism with severe mental impairment.
Surely the word severe is still in there so surely that's still admitting they ARE more severely affected whichever way you look at it?

But my child does have autism and mod/severe LD.
If he didn't have the autism he would still be significantly disabled by his LD and vice versa.
One of his brothers has autism and mod ld again with out one he'd still have the other.
Another has autism without any LD. Still autistic and very much affected despite being far more verbal and able in other ways, still very much disabled.
In fact I'd go as far as to say that the child without LD is, in some ways more affected by his autism. 7 school days in to the new term and we've had school refusal for 6 of those days and I've only got him in school for 4 days. His older brother "looks" disabled and despite being older people make far more allowances when he exhibits behaviour that stems from the autism. With the younger one, he doesn't look disabled, so he gets the stares, the comments, people telling him he's a bit boy so why can't he walk in a noisy room. Etc etc.
I actually have 6 children all of which are neuro-divergent. 4 have an autism dx, 1 has an ADHD/dyspraxia dx, and one is waiting for a dx most likely ASD/PDD. All bar the youngest have other difficulties, 1 is in a wheelchair due to hypermobility that is often co-morbid with ASD. Another has a rare.form of CP and is visibly disabled.
They are, however, all autistic and every aspect of their (and our) lives are affected by that autism, very often severely impacted, despite any verbal or learning ability

TheOriginalEmu · 17/01/2024 03:41

CoffeeCantata · 16/01/2024 08:51

I confess to being pretty ignorant on the subject of Neurodiversity (except for what I read on MN), but the more I think about it, the more I'm coming to the conclusion that we're ALL ND, really. Not being facetious - we're all on some kind of spectrum. My adult daughter has very mild Aspergers and knowing that has helped us to understand some of her challenging behaviours.

I think they ought to be replaced as our understanding increases and I would imagine it'd be hard to find someone who would declare themselves Neurotypical!

I'm sure I'm not alone here in realising that I and practically every one of my friends and family exhibit some form of ND. But mildy - and if it's mild, I think you just have to get on with life in the knowledge that most people have some issues in this way. But understanding these conditions is helpful in allowing people to modify their own behaviour. Eg if you realise you have an organisational problem (like my eternally unpunctual sister) then you can acknowledge that and find strategies to help.

In order to get a diagnosis of any neurodivergence, it MUST impact your life in a daily and chronic basis in a negative way. Showing a behaviour that might be a clue towards ND does not mean you have a mild dose of it, it means you are NT with a quirk that is not affecting your life in an adverse way significatly. So no we aren’t ‘all’ a bit ND

TempestTost · 17/01/2024 02:04

It's not surprising "diversity" has morphed in the same way too, people think it means "different from the norm".

I don't know why some are so convinced there aren't people who are scammers and fad followers about this stuff. They exist about everything else and are surprisingly plentiful.

theplatformedge · 16/01/2024 23:40

Exactly @EverySporkIsSacred . The term neurodiversity was originally coined to reflect the full range of the population, not just those with a nameable condition (whether formally diagnosed or not). But it has morphed.

OP posts:
EverySporkIsSacred · 16/01/2024 23:28

Haven't read full thread but neurodiversity by definition (probably) includes ALL "neurotypes".
There are as many different neurotypes as there are personalities (because everything is a spectrum of differing traits/charactaristics/ways our brains work).
Collections of some neurological characteristics have been named (eg. Dyslexia, Autism) in an attempt to fit people who are struggling with modern expectations into nice neat categories (presumably so they can be offered accomodations) but have you ever heard the saying "when you've met one person with autism, you've met one person with autism"? That's because even within the different categories there's so much diversity that no two collections of traits look exactly alike.
How well do you know yourself? Are you sure you don't fit into one of the boxes? Is there another box people are calling neurotypical? Are the boxes even real?

DyslexicPoster · 16/01/2024 23:22

maddening · 16/01/2024 22:11

How do you know you don't think like the majority- how do you think the majority do think? Is that humans globally or locally?

I am dyslexic, with a diagnosis- I don't think I think any differently and even if I do it has no actual impact to me and those around me. Apparently dyslexia makes me nd - I think it is a meaningless term as it tells you nothing about me if I tell you that - it could mean anything.

I'm not referring to my dyslexia. I'm talking personality. Of course I can't be sure the majority of people don't think like me, but from what I see, I can be reasonably certain they don't.

I don't define myself as dyslexic. But I had to change my username because I got pissed off with fuckers impling I'm as thick as shit picking apart my spelling. You can be dyslexic and very strange indeed just like you can be non dyslexic and very strange. I'm a programmer and lots of my fellow programmers are dyslexic so that's pretty standard in my world. None of them are strange ( to me).

Fionaville · 16/01/2024 23:18

So we mustn't use 'severe autism' because the 'severe' part is actual related to a severe mental impairment?
Some of the severe difficulties I would list are part of the classic autism diagnosis. Such as persistent echolalia which can last for hours and cause individuals to be completely oblivious to their surroundings with excessive stimming, running and bouncing, that again can last for hours and can cause injury. These are just a couple of the examples of classic autism that would be called severe autism, alongside other behaviours. It's wrong to say that these behaviours aren't related to autism and should be classed as 'autism with something else'

SpeedyDrama · 16/01/2024 23:04

LewishamMumNow · 16/01/2024 22:50

I'm saying it's mild for autism because sadly it is. The condition can get really serious. It would probably be better for Aspergers to still be in wider use - that way people with the difficulties you describe could have severe Aspergers, or just Aspergers if you prefer. But within the spectrum of autism, someone with the level of functionality you describe, though clearly very significant in their own right, is still only mildly autistic, simply because of how severe it gets.
Some conditions are more severe than others eg mild autism is still way more of an interference in normal day to day living than severe dyslexia would be.

You’re still missing the point and I’m not sure if you have the comprehension to understand. Autism can be a fluctuating condition, some like your brother may always need high care/support but that doesn’t mean that his obvious care needs is comparable to someone else with autism and their high needs. Whether they’re in a ‘functional’ aspect or not. Undermining autism as mild causes a far greater likelihood of masking until a breakdown in comparison to recognition of constant high care needs (which can absolutely fluctuate as well).

I can only put my experience out there, but of my two sons with ASD, it is my ‘Asperger’s’ presenting child I am more concerned about in the long term. Because though my other son with severe delays certainly has bad days and meltdowns from lack of understanding, he generally seems quite happy in his own world. My eldest seems terrified of the world he’s expected to fit into, and the consequences of him having a bad day because the mask slipped are far less understanding that of a child who presents with high delays. It’s easy to see how undiagnosed or those seen as ‘high functioning’ end up in catastrophe as adults - it comes from the idea that their disability is mild rather than see how all the smaller difficulties end up in a huge breakdown.

Alicewinn · 16/01/2024 23:00

fottfsofawygtfosm · 16/01/2024 09:12

Using the term neurodiverse/neurodivergent also means you’re giving a fast explanation to people - I’d rather not stand in a supermarket and apologise for taking longer and say, ‘I’ve got complex PTSD, panic disorder, dyspraxia and OCD’ - saying, ‘I’m neurodivergent, can you give me 5 minutes’ generally means people understand faster. I honestly think there should be an advertising campaign on it, but that’s by the by.

Self diagnosis is an interesting issue and debate, a lot of women especially probably do fit the criteria for a diagnosis of autism but were overlooked in school - and now adept at masking and able to compensate - and so never diagnosed formally.

There is the trend almost of diagnosis by tiktok (etc) wherein a minority of people will almost collect labels (interestingly there’s also a correlation with people who identify as being ‘gender fluid’ etc) but that’s a different debate, although also very interesting. You see it on online survey data that the respondents tend not to be truly representative of normal demographics… Rather than condemn its more interesting to consider why people feel the need to be different, or to find an identity and belonging, and why that sense of identity can only be achieved through for example, stacking up psychiatric labels. It’s probably disordered behaviour in and of itself.

I’m doing this (studying neurodiversity movement) as part of my degree/dissertation so could talk about this all day.

That’s really an interesting point.
Neurodiverse + gender fluid definitely seems to be a thing
I wonder if some presentations of ADHD are actually early childhood trauma causing dissociation / spacing out / lack of attention. Have wondered that about myself but think I have both !!

LewishamMumNow · 16/01/2024 22:58

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow But it still doesn't make it severe autism. Surely you know there are people who can't talk or understand anything and spend their lives waving their hands and bodies around? That is severe autism.
Your daughters' difficulties are clearly severe, but cannot be severe autism. I wish you both well.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/01/2024 22:56

LewishamMumNow · 16/01/2024 22:07

Don't get this. Simply pointing out that if you can read, write, hold a job, attend a mainstream school then you don't have severe autism. That doesn't mean you don't have difficulties, milder autism, a disability, or anything else.

My daughter attended mainstream school until 16. She then could no longer go due to severe autistic burnout. ie she masked all her life. Where would that leave her? She’s been out of school since April.

LewishamMumNow · 16/01/2024 22:50

I'm saying it's mild for autism because sadly it is. The condition can get really serious. It would probably be better for Aspergers to still be in wider use - that way people with the difficulties you describe could have severe Aspergers, or just Aspergers if you prefer. But within the spectrum of autism, someone with the level of functionality you describe, though clearly very significant in their own right, is still only mildly autistic, simply because of how severe it gets.
Some conditions are more severe than others eg mild autism is still way more of an interference in normal day to day living than severe dyslexia would be.

SpeedyDrama · 16/01/2024 22:35

LewishamMumNow · 16/01/2024 22:15

WTF! It's okay to use the term "severe autism" but not "mild autism"?? Is this for real?!

Yes, because there isn’t such a thing as mild when it comes to a disability that impairs day to day functioning regardless of how severe it can present. Even in ‘high functioning’ form, ASD can severely affect a person simply because of societal expectations of functioning typically.

It is draining just to meet basic expectations of how to function like a typical person, to meet the right social cues, think about a conversation before you have it, hope you’re making the right amount of eye contact, the anxiety thinking about previous conversations, not knowing if you missed marks, not understanding when you’ve missed them and why someone is currently angry with you, thinking something is angry with you when they’ve simply had a bad day. Overthinking into the early hours. This isn’t adding in sensory issues, going to the shops, they’re bright, loud, there’s a kid screaming 5 aisle down and you can’t focus on what you need to do, they’ve moved things around and now your routine is out of order, if you forget something you have to go through all this again later, the cashier is making small talk, you haven’t prepared for this, it’s loud and your head is in white noise, you hope half smiling and hope you’re not missing important information. You go home and do nothing because an hour’s shop has wiped you for the day.

And that’s a moment in a day of a ‘high functioning’ autistic person who’s ’managing day to day’ stuff, never mind the overwhelming life admin of paying bills and running a home, going to work. If that wall of text sent you a bit spinning, then imagine what it’s like simply trying to wade through life like running through mud and someone saying your condition is ‘mild’.

Updownleftandright · 16/01/2024 22:34

I have a child with asd and complex needs. I think neirodivergent is helpful as it reminds some ignorant people that the behaviour stems from brain development and isn't just behavioural. It's very general though. My son has very low levels of functioning and just saying someone is neurodiverse is a bit too broad and down plays how affected he is. I think we do need to label functioning.

PaperSheet · 16/01/2024 22:33

alltootired · 16/01/2024 22:22

@AloeNora you are the one denying the behaviour that we are saying makes it severe autism is autism. You are saying it is learning difficulties. You are wrong.

This is the thing years ago when people thought of autism they thought of non verbal children and adults needing round the clock care. Or on a "milder" end of the scale you'd think of people like Dustin Hoffman in Rainman.
But over the years the term autism seems to have come to mean something totally different. Those presenting the "old way" now apparently don't just have autism. They have learning difficulties or mental impairments on top. "Newer" autism seems to be where people claim things like it being a superpower etc.
It seems like eventually those with "old fashioned autism" will end up having a totally different diagnosis. Because people want to put the emphasis on "mental impairments or learning difficulties" rather than the autism itself causing issues.

AloeNora · 16/01/2024 22:26

You are wrong about how my children diagnosis.. So there you go maybe posters shouldn’t comment and dictate how others they’ve never met are diagnosed particularly when they are not qualified to do so. You are not my childrens’ diagnostician.

alltootired · 16/01/2024 22:22

@AloeNora you are the one denying the behaviour that we are saying makes it severe autism is autism. You are saying it is learning difficulties. You are wrong.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 16/01/2024 22:22

LewishamMumNow · 16/01/2024 22:07

Don't get this. Simply pointing out that if you can read, write, hold a job, attend a mainstream school then you don't have severe autism. That doesn't mean you don't have difficulties, milder autism, a disability, or anything else.

That's simply untrue though.

I am a high needs individual who is autistic, I require daily support and cannot do many tasks that a NT adult can, yet I can read, write, hold a job albeit with various instances of absence and attended mainstream school. I then recently experienced a true autistic burnout and lost my ability to do many things, including speaking.

Your brother sounds like he is also very high needs and has been for a very long time and sounds very likely he will continue to be but it also sounds like your brother may have other comorbidities in addition to his autism.

It's really offensive that you're trying to tell people who have significantly high needs with which their daily lives are impacted, find society disabling, and require intense support that they have "mild" autism.

Other people having high needs does not take away from your brother having high needs that are different, or prolonged.

Other people presenting differently again does not impact your brother.