Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think the terms "neuro diverse" and "neuro typical" will be short lived.

462 replies

theplatformedge · 16/01/2024 08:30

Diversity means "a range of many people or things that are very different from each other" (Oxford learner's dictionary), so the idea that a minority of people are "neuro diverse" and everyone else is "neuro typical" is not only semantically illogical, but also potentially offensive.

We're all different. Some people have traits that make life more difficult for them than others, whether it be ASD, ADHD or a range of other conditions, with spectrums of severity. Telling people that you're neuro-diverse is so vague as to be meaningless, and telling other people they are nero-typical when you have no idea what they're feeling inside is insensitive. Some people get a formal diagnosis for their symptoms, some people self-diagnose and others don't recognise it in themselves. Nobody knows how many people are living with these traits across the population, but the massive increase in diagnostics suggests they're a lot more common than anyone ever thought in the past, and therefore gradually becoming very "typical".

Discuss! 🙂

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Fionaville · 16/01/2024 12:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I've learnt that you're not allowed to talk like that on MN. You get told off.
Back in the real world though, when you have a group of individuals with high needs, some non verbal, lots in head guards, lots prone to wandering off or approaching people, stimming severely, talking to themselves (echolalia) and who just generally need to be kept safe. The easiest and most efficient way of describing that group, to say a venue you are taking them (to people who don't spend their time being told off 'educated' online) is to say they are autistic and have high needs or they are severely autistic.
If I were to say to somebody that my son is neurodivergent, it really wouldn't reflect the level of support he needs.
As we learn more and more about the human condition, all of the difficulties that come under being ND, it is very presumptions to describe a person as neurotypical.
So, if people want to describe themselves as ND, that's fine by me. Equally if they see themselves as autistic as the people I've described above, thats their choice and I wont argue with them. But not everyone will agree that their needs or autism is as severe. Different labels of severity are needed for different groups.

User542452 · 16/01/2024 12:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MyopicBunny · 16/01/2024 12:09

Jook · 16/01/2024 12:06

I think it’s overused and often not from a diagnosed standpoint which dilutes its meaning for me.

Off topic but my real pet hate of misused labels is narcissistic. Every other annoying DH is apparently a narc!

Edited

How do you know it's overused? Are you a diagnosing clinician?

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 12:08

HellsToilet · 16/01/2024 11:54

Not being diagnosed as ND does not mean you have been diagnosed as NT, nobody has ever been diagnosed as NT and nobody is pushing for binary model as far as I know.

I am sorry for anyone who struggles to function and has no idea why, I was the same for 36 years. Stating that the majority of brains function similarly and deciding to call that neuro-typical is not that same thing as dismissing everyone who doesn't have a ND diagnosis as fine and denying them help. Who thinks we have this power? ND people are some of the most marginalised groups in society so the idea that we are doing the same by pointing out that most people are not like us is borderline offensive.

Of course nobody is diagnosed as NT in the same way that nobody is diagnosed as 'not having cancer' or 'not having heart failure:. The assumption is that if you get checked for a condition and don't meet the criteria then you don't have it. If you don't have a diagnosis for a ND condition then by default you are considered NT. It is absolutely that binary.

You will see time and time again that there is a strong feeling, especially amongst the diagnosed community, that you can't self identify as having a condition no matter how much the traits and symptoms impact your life.

Obviously this would make perfect sense with a physical condition where for example a blood test shows you don't have diabetes. Someone then going on to claim that they dod indeed have the condition would be viewed with a lot of scepticism. But when it comes to my relative who struggles with quite extreme autistic traits but doesn't quite meet the threshold in all areas... I'm not so sure that our science and understanding of the brain is good enough to definitively state he isn't autistic. He wouldn't meet the threshold for any other ND condition so therefore would be considered NT for all intents and purposes. I'm sure you would agree this is wrong and casts doubt on whether the obsession with distinguishing between the 'NT' and 'ND' is massively helpful.

Jook · 16/01/2024 12:06

I think it’s overused and often not from a diagnosed standpoint which dilutes its meaning for me.

Off topic but my real pet hate of misused labels is narcissistic. Every other annoying DH is apparently a narc!

MyopicBunny · 16/01/2024 12:06

I have reported it too but highly doubt it will be removed. It was only yesterday I posted a thread about benefits bashing and ableist bullshit on here, ADHD and ASD seem fair game too on Mumsnet recently and people dont even try to hide their distain, its getting quite vile being on here and reading it all the time.

Exactly right. Nobody has to keep justifying their physical disabilities and the ignorance on MN recently has reached a new high.

www.instagram.com/reel/C0R8x8ssrWY/?igsh=dWg5cGJiZmZjZ3h4

RainbowZebraWarrior · 16/01/2024 12:03

@ronoi I can see it going exactly the same way with my DD in front of my very eyes. It's so difficult.

I'm also in exactly the same position as you personally. In fact I could have written your second paragraph. Sending solidarity.

bobomomo · 16/01/2024 12:02

Agree, drives me a bit mad - everyone seems to be (admittedly self diagnosed) nd these days, and most seem to think they should be given special treatment consequently, I'm sympathetic to those with diagnosed serious issues related to their nd eg those who are autistic and have resulting problems but complaining that her dd should jump the queue into our playgroup because she's neurodivergent (the mum not the child) but on requesting had no formal diagnosis, no social services request etc, that was an hour ago.

We all can struggle with certain things, nd just seems to be fashionable currently. How about accepting everyone is different, everyone has strengths and weaknesses, and restrict diagnosis to those who have significant difficulties resulting from their condition

SpeedyDrama · 16/01/2024 12:02

gluggle · 16/01/2024 11:53

@SpeedyDrama I have been wondering to what extent some responses come down to denial. Especially the "everybody on MN seems to have a child with ASD" type...what exactly are people feeling so threatened by? Why does it piss people off so much that some of us have pursued diagnosis for our children?

Yes it is odd when they get personally offended by perusing a diagnosis, whilst also not wanting to hear terms to overarch our child’s disabilities before getting said diagnosis. With my eldest, he was actually dropped from the paediatrician - it was the school that essentially begged me to fight it (it wasn’t that I disagreed, just felt very deflated for my poor boy). The first paediatrician we saw actually drew a line and said ‘if your son is autistic he’s up here (close to typical) so is there any point?’. By the time he went to ASD panel the level of medical/school/psych evidence given was piles high, a very different story from what that first doctor saw two years previously.

People have no idea the level of work and the years it takes to have autism recognised. In the flip side, same son was diagnosed with ADHD within one appointment after the school filled in some paperwork for the consultant. Both conditions affect my eldest in equal measure but the fight for recognition was like night and day.

TextThumb · 16/01/2024 11:59

Flickersy · 16/01/2024 08:33

Discuss!

Why, what are you gathering responses for?

Ha, I also hate it when posters say ‘discuss’. Like they are giving me my weekend homework to prepare.

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 11:59

RainbowZebraWarrior · 16/01/2024 11:50

Yes, but there aren't threads eveey week questioning the validity or increase in fibromyalgia diagnoses.

That's my point. And I'm sick of it being questioned in this way. Or indeed that you feel that the diagnostic criteria isn't thorough. If you'd been through it, you'd know otherwise.

It just smacks of 'its given out like sweets' and 'we don't believe you'

That's why it's offensive to question and debate it.

I have seen quite a few threads on fibromyalgia but obviously it's a lot less well known than autism so less threads will be created about it.

I didn't say the assessment wasn't thorough, it is extremely thorough and detailed. My argument is that it is fundamentally based on our very patchy understanding of autism and how the brain functions and the way that the assessment is conducted means that it is somewhat subjective. It simply isn't as definitive as undertaking a blood test to check if you have diabetes etc. The fact that the assessment seems so thorough and 'accurate' is what gives a false sense of certainty.

Pugdays · 16/01/2024 11:57

Discuss ..
Yeah I would of done had you not wrote discuss

YuleDragon · 16/01/2024 11:54

funny how a forum for supporting parents is attracting parents who might be seeking support.

People with kids who have disabilities are isolated socially, so we do seek support online, its only natural there would be a wide pool of us here.

HellsToilet · 16/01/2024 11:54

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 11:21

Apologies my rant about shutting down debate wasn't aimed at you. I obviously got a bit carried away.

I never said a typical leg won't cause any issues but the majority of these issues will be related to age or injury. Most young, fit people will not experience day to day problems with their legs in the same way they do their brain. Brains are far more complex and have higher levels of variance than a leg. It is therefore possible using clinical data to label a leg as 'typical' but arguably the same cannot be done with the brain. This is why brain scans can't be used to diagnose many conditions under the ND umbrella.

So where does this leave us? In a world where those struggling with their brains seek out a diagnosis so they can have their struggles acknowledged. Some will meet the criteria for an official diagnosis but some won't. For those that don't, what does it mean to be labelled Neurotypical when their brain won't allow them to function 'normally'? We have such imperfect knowledge on the brain and how it works that it is highly likely that those that don't meet the criteria for a diagnosis today could well do so in a few years time and vice versa. Why are we do keen to push a binary model that implies a level of scientific and medical certainty that we simply don't possess yet?

Not being diagnosed as ND does not mean you have been diagnosed as NT, nobody has ever been diagnosed as NT and nobody is pushing for binary model as far as I know.

I am sorry for anyone who struggles to function and has no idea why, I was the same for 36 years. Stating that the majority of brains function similarly and deciding to call that neuro-typical is not that same thing as dismissing everyone who doesn't have a ND diagnosis as fine and denying them help. Who thinks we have this power? ND people are some of the most marginalised groups in society so the idea that we are doing the same by pointing out that most people are not like us is borderline offensive.

gluggle · 16/01/2024 11:53

@SpeedyDrama I have been wondering to what extent some responses come down to denial. Especially the "everybody on MN seems to have a child with ASD" type...what exactly are people feeling so threatened by? Why does it piss people off so much that some of us have pursued diagnosis for our children?

ronoi · 16/01/2024 11:53

@mamboshirt

Nobody got diagnosed with Asperger's for being 'quirky, with zero issues' though

Gingerkittykat · 16/01/2024 11:51

mamboshirt · 16/01/2024 09:08

There is, it's just gone out of favour as a diagnosis. Trying to lump people who have zero issues ( just a but quirky) with non-verbal people is a massive mistake IMO.

Aspergers was removed from the DSM in 2013 and the ICD10 in Jan 2022 so it is no longer given as a diagnosis, people who would have received a diagnosis of Asperger's before these dates will now be diagnosed with ASD. Some people who were diagnosed with Asperger's before that date still use that term but most now describe themselves as autistic.

RainbowZebraWarrior · 16/01/2024 11:50

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 11:42

I want this thread to stand.

I think you are largely conflating people 'not understanding' with people disagreeing. The reason why there is more controversy and disagreement about ND condition compared to other conditions is because of the way the former is diagnosed and the imperfect science that underpins this. It isn't just ND conditions that have this problem as fibromyalgia is also a very controversial condition for similar reasons.

I don't think the premise of this thread is to undermine the struggles of those with a diagnosis but to question if the NT/ND binary model is diminishing the struggles of those without a formal diagnosis but who struggle with issues related to how their brain is functioning and ND traits everyday. The black and white approach of ND and NT isn't helpful or appropriate for these people and it is not morally wrong to raise this and question the validity of the system that is failing them.

Yes, but there aren't threads eveey week questioning the validity or increase in fibromyalgia diagnoses.

That's my point. And I'm sick of it being questioned in this way. Or indeed that you feel that the diagnostic criteria isn't thorough. If you'd been through it, you'd know otherwise.

It just smacks of 'its given out like sweets' and 'we don't believe you'

That's why it's offensive to question and debate it.

ronoi · 16/01/2024 11:49

@RainbowZebraWarrior

We have the mutism now too. I had to take her out of school 2 years ago and she has only once spoken to someone outside of our family unit since then. She is 14 and cannot go outside alone. Cannot be left at home alone. I have to sit in her bedroom floor at night if she is unsettled. Some days I cannot leave the living room as she needs me by her side. It's hard and intense and the people who suggest mild/moderate/severe labelling don't have a clue. Ironically my son who would have had a 'severe' label when he was 5/6 is now sailing his way though university (albeit living at home with 'mild' support)

As a late diagnosed adult my support needs have grown - years of mental health problems and mis diagnoses tend to do that to you. My life is by far much easier now but only because I make accommodation me and do everything I can to keep demands (outside of parenting) to a minimum. I don't work, I don't socialise, I only go to the same supermarket etc show online for other stuff and I live my wee quiet life. I'm also skint becsue living on disability benefits isn't ideal, especially when most would judge me as 'mildly' autistic and obviously able to work. The pressure of that work is what pushes me into cannot cope mode

SpeedyDrama · 16/01/2024 11:46

anarchicparadise · 16/01/2024 11:39

im sure this person parents their daughter very well.

what an odd and angry response.

It’s an entirely accurate response even if you find it negative. Everything the poster they were replying to was quite worrying for a parent of a sen child to say, like they know very little about the condition despite having a child who has been diagnosed.

Though ‘everyone is a bit autistic’ is usually a side line to ‘but everyone behaves like that’. Usually under it all is huge denial about being autistic themselves (I’m speaking generally not about a singular poster). Or they want there to be such a thing as ‘mild autism’ because they don’t want their child lumped in with autistic kids like mine who are also developmentally delayed.

YuleDragon · 16/01/2024 11:44

my 17 yo sons needs have constantly fluctuated. He has Autism, ADHD, Dyspraxia and hypermobility.

Depending on what day, and what particular diagnosis has the wheel for the day can mean his needs fluctuate significiantly.

Today he is happy, playing on his playstation, all i need do is periodically prompt him to dress, toilet, and come get his food that i've prepared for him to eat. He is calm, happy, chatty and interacting when he's in my company.

He would appear 'low needs' today.

On another day i'm fighting being physically attacked because he can't cope, i'm having to repeat every instruction, he's non verbal, won't eat, hasn't slept, won't get dressed, can't cope with his clothes touching his skin, needs his ear defenders, ticks repeatedly.

Those days he is 'high needs'

But his diagnosis hasn't changed, it's still the same diagnosis as the low needs day.

As i have said, mild/severe autism isn't about how it impacts HIS day. Its a label people who're ignorant insist on sticking on him to do with how they perceive his disabilities when in their company.

Bumpitybumper · 16/01/2024 11:42

RainbowZebraWarrior · 16/01/2024 11:31

Me too. It's a thinly veiled goady thread. Again. 'Discuss' indeed.

The same stereotypes and ignorance is trotted out on every thread, and it's a couple of times a week, now.

No other health conditions are questioned like Autism and other ND umbrella conditions are. Nobody goes around questioning MS diagnoses or other Neurological issues, Diabetes, Heart problems, Liver issues.

To the people who want the thread to stand because 'we should be able to discuss and question these things' Do you not understand how insulting it is to those of us who are diagnosed that you actually feel its OK to want to question it? Constantly. And then still say that you don't understand anyway.

I want this thread to stand.

I think you are largely conflating people 'not understanding' with people disagreeing. The reason why there is more controversy and disagreement about ND condition compared to other conditions is because of the way the former is diagnosed and the imperfect science that underpins this. It isn't just ND conditions that have this problem as fibromyalgia is also a very controversial condition for similar reasons.

I don't think the premise of this thread is to undermine the struggles of those with a diagnosis but to question if the NT/ND binary model is diminishing the struggles of those without a formal diagnosis but who struggle with issues related to how their brain is functioning and ND traits everyday. The black and white approach of ND and NT isn't helpful or appropriate for these people and it is not morally wrong to raise this and question the validity of the system that is failing them.

anarchicparadise · 16/01/2024 11:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

im sure this person parents their daughter very well.

what an odd and angry response.

RainbowZebraWarrior · 16/01/2024 11:38

ronoi · 16/01/2024 11:26

At what age and stage do we categorise?

I just mentioned my DD who would have been placed in the 'mild' box when she was younger. Now at 14? - right in the 'severe'!

Any condition/disability has variables. People can suffer mild/severe effects of the same condition/. They can also change juts like anyone else.

Same with my daughter who is now 12 and we are going through hell trying to get the right support, because the level of understating just isn't there across the board. She has a diagnosis of situational mutism, (as well as Autism) but it's now snowballing as she struggles more and more to cope with life. We now have days on end of her being non verbal.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 16/01/2024 11:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I wrote about this in my response to @LewishamMumNow but I'll cover it again.

People with autism can have interchangeable high support needs and low support needs throughout their entire life.

What people perceive as profound autism is usually high support needs autism with comorbidities such as developmental delays or learning disabilities, ie. The inability to learn to do things like learn to look after themselves either partially or fully, learn academically etc.

Autism alone covers 3 distinct areas of life, with which you have to meet all the criteria in order to receive a diagnosis.

Some people may struggle less due to the way in which they present on the spectrum however that does not mean that they will always struggle less.

Like all people, needs change over the years. People with autism may require more or less support as their needs change.

My son received a very early diagnosis himself as he very obviously presented with high support needs: heavily stimmer, non-verbal, did not respond to name or social cues, couldn't even bear the texture of sensory friendly clothes so spent the first 3 years of his life practically nude. Now he is able to speak, stims less, gets his needs met quicker and can meet his own needs a lot of the time, and is thriving in a mainstream school which I would not have imagined possible a year ago.

I however am almost 30, highly masked as a child, hyperlexic, had less obvious stims and was just deemed hyperactive and quirky, spoke extremely bluntly, scripted, struggled to make friends but I was just called a rude or naughty child, hyperfocused at school, couldn't hack the social requirements of college or university so dropped out, ended up at the job centre, got literally any job I could take which was call centre work, excellent with the structure however unfortunately they can't meet my needs and now I find myself unable to speak some days and am struggling with the long term effects of burnout and am extremely sensitive to all stimuli to the point I will rock back and forth crying and experiencing intense panic attack-like emotions. I can't take wet clothes out of the washing machine, I can't wash my pots, I can't stand the smells of food, lights give me intense headaches, all sounds make my blood curdle and I become extremely aggravated easily.

My support needs are higher than they were when I was my son's age.

So there's no such thing as mild autism. It's all bollocks frankly, and it's all dependent on the support and life experiences available and provided.