Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say No to this charity BS

343 replies

EffingBirthdays · 16/01/2024 07:34

DS9 and 3 school mates are sharing a birthday party in few days .
I ve made a point to the other mums that we should add a note to what’s app group to kindly bring one present max , absolutely no need for anything more as kids will share

Thats when one of the other mums had the bright idea to donate ALL gifts to kids related charity - apparently her friend did it with her kid and it was massive success all parents were very happy etc

WTAF! Party is not cheap, and how the fuck do I say this to ds?

I don’t mind donating the odd gift but we have more than 40 kids invited, wtaf?

all other 3 mums agreed, wtf do I do? AIBU?

OP posts:
OnaKitchenRoll · 16/01/2024 11:47

'I've been talking to some friends and they were saying how upset they'd be if a gift they bought was donated. How about we do a cash collection with the majority (or whatever fraction you want to say) going to charity and each of the boys getting some money to spend on something they pick'

caringcarer · 16/01/2024 11:47

I'm sorry OP but 4 kids sharing a birthday party is too many. It sounds like it will be a fiasco with the birthday boys annoyed or upset because parents give all their new gifts away and parents of attendees miffed because they chose a thoughtful gift then the intended recipient had it taken away from him to give to charity. I think an individual can make a gift to charity but not force others to do so. I think parents offering their kids gifts away are being mean. They could donate to this charity if they wanted to themselves or indeed give their own gifts away. I'd say no I think my DC would like to keep his birthday gifts but I'll make a charity gift donation myself. Then I'd buy a gift to be donated to said charity.

BusyMummyWrites01 · 16/01/2024 11:44

BodyKeepingScore · 16/01/2024 10:58

Why should I have to choose a gift though that won't go to its intended recipient? I wouldn't attend a party where gifts were just divvied up.

It’s never been an issue at any jointly held birthday my kids were a part of - as guests or the party child - you’re buying a £10 gift for a 9yo (usually books, lego or similar). Think people are being rather precious over this.

caringcarer · 16/01/2024 11:40

EarringsandLipstick · 16/01/2024 08:27

£0.50!!! I mean, I'm all for small gifts but c'mon!

I that is meaner than no gifts at all. 🤣🤣

Growlybear83 · 16/01/2024 11:37

Needmorelego · 16/01/2024 11:05

@BusyMummyWrites01 surely you buy a gift that's something you know the child likes - not something random.
(I mean there is a possibility that the children having a joint party are all obsessed with the same thing - so it doesn't matter which one end up with the Pokémon cards)
It's the buying random gifts attitude I don't get.

I agree. When my daughter was at primary school, it was always part of the party 'routine' to go out and choose a present that we thought the recipient would like, sometimes having asked the child's parent if it was someone my daughter didn't know very well. Parents often asked me what my daughter did and didn't like when I sent out party invitations.

caringcarer · 16/01/2024 11:37

Surely a guest will only be invited by one boy. If each boy has a card and gift table and then at the end of the party the boys can either take all gifts home or choose to donate a few from their pile. I'd suggest this.

HMW1906 · 16/01/2024 11:34

Can you not let them keep some and donate some? Presumably 40 invited so potentially 40 gifts, split between the 4 kids so 10 gifts each,
can’t they keep 5 and donate 5? Thats potentially 20 gifts being donated. That sounds reasonable.

Agree · 16/01/2024 11:33

Should have stayed quiet OP and not decided to start controlling how many gifts people can bring - that bit you in the bum didn't it!?

Anyway I think the whole thing is ludicrous and you're going to have to get brave and say you don't agree you'd like the boys (or at least your boy) to have their presents. Some children / parents will have actually put thought into what they're going to buy. Also what an horrific thing to do to other people's gifts - they're bringing them for the boys not to give to charity.

NEXT TIME (ie not this time) if the mothers prefer donations to charity then you say so in advance - ie. no gifts please, but if you'd like to, our chosen charity is 'local food bank'.

I worry about people who want to control other people to this extent. I really do. It's a pervasive sickness in our society and in women it's frequently explained by chronic codependence.
What other people choose to do is none of your business. You declared a party, people are going to bring gifts. It stops right there. Everything else is uncalled for control freakery.

CharlotteBog · 16/01/2024 11:25

Sod that. I will decide whether I'd like to spend my money on a gift for a birthday child or whether to donate to charity.
I'm all for children learning about giving, humility etc, but their Birthday is not the day to do that. IF your child turns round and says they'd like to give some of their gifts to other people then that's a different matter.

Moier · 16/01/2024 11:22

Never heard such thing.
Having a birthday party and no presents.
Do the boys usually donate to charity?.
My nine year old Grandson would be most upset..
It strange to me to be sharing a party.
Have a table for presents. Ask friends to bring one wrapped present each then the three boys don't know what's in them.. then get them to pick same amount each .

peakygold · 16/01/2024 11:15

"absolutely no need for anything more as kids will share"

So one kid gets the massive Lego set and the next gets a pound shop craft set?

Mariposistaaa · 16/01/2024 11:12

The idea in itself is good - kids have far too much 'stuff' and don't need to be spoilt further. But giving away all the presents is a bit much. Could you get the 3 boys to sit together after the party, and they each get to keep 2 things and give the rest away? And that way they decide who gets what? And they could all go to the shelter/charity and you could take picture of them handing the gifts over so they could feel proud of themselves.

Kit60 · 16/01/2024 11:09

“Hi Mum. While I agree that over 40 gifts per child would be extortionate for the families of children attending and excessive for the boys, I feel like donating all 40 gifts (which we suggested are split between them evenly to save families money) would leave them disappointed as they are still quite young. It is also a very large donation and people have taken the time to select a thoughtful gift for the boys in particular. However, I really like the idea of teaching them the value of their gifts and how fortunate they are. Shall we donate a monetary gift to X children’s charity from us three parents? Alternatively, we could each donate a toy to a children’s bank?”

Brefugee · 16/01/2024 11:05

Snugglemonkey · 16/01/2024 11:02

I would not like this at all. We choose gifts for a recipient, not just to go randomly in a pile.

that's never been my experience. Although the maximum number of kids hosting a joint party, IME, was 3 and 2 were twins.

Basically each child invited 8 other children, and the invitees took a gift for the child that invited them, and a card and something like chocolate for the two others. no fuss, no bother, no gnashing of teeth and wailing.

Needmorelego · 16/01/2024 11:05

@BusyMummyWrites01 surely you buy a gift that's something you know the child likes - not something random.
(I mean there is a possibility that the children having a joint party are all obsessed with the same thing - so it doesn't matter which one end up with the Pokémon cards)
It's the buying random gifts attitude I don't get.

PossumintheHouse · 16/01/2024 11:04

To be honest I think it’s a bit weird for four young children to be sharing a party. Two, yes. But with four the potential for kiddie and parental politics to complicate things is really high - and look what’s happened.
You need to be honest, polite and firm. You’re not comfortable giving all of your son’s gifts to charity. Split the presents between the four and each parent can decide what to do with their pile.

CecilyP · 16/01/2024 11:03

Astonetogo · 16/01/2024 08:43

Well fair enough if you disagree. Although I think most 9 / 10 year old are capable of understanding ‘only one is for you’, just like picking a lucky bag from a shop of a gift from a bran tub! They’ll never know what’s in the other gifts, so no disappointment on what they’ve missed out on.

I don’t think there’s any harm in teaching children that giving to charity is a nice thing to do, especially when so many are struggling at this time. The joy of giving is greater than receiving! At 9 I think they can handle that, although as they are still young and it’s the first time doing it this way it’s reasonable to also sweeten the pill with a treat of a different nature. My opinion.

But it would be a darned sight more efficient for the charities tell guests not to bring gifts and just make a charitable donation instead! Seriously, what a waste of everybody’s time and money!

silverbubbles · 16/01/2024 11:03

Just ignore the mum who has said this.
You have already asked for 1 present max. no need to do anything else.

Frangipanyoul8r · 16/01/2024 11:02

Just say you realise you overstepped making present suggestions to try and be helpful - and that parents can feel free to do as they wish. Say you are sure any presents the children receive on their birthdays will be greatly appreciated and you didn’t mean to suggest that the children receive no presents at all as naturally this would lead to disappointment and upset.

Snugglemonkey · 16/01/2024 11:02

BusyMummyWrites01 · 16/01/2024 10:52

Ps some people seem to be confused - when you have joint/multiple child party birthday, the idea is that each attendee brings one present only that goes into the pot, so to speak. The 20 or so gifts are then shared equally, so each birthday child gets 5-8 gifts. There won’t be ‘160 parcels of tat’. It’s usually a ‘whole class’ thing, not a parting with a zillion guests/gifts.

I would not like this at all. We choose gifts for a recipient, not just to go randomly in a pile.

Snowdogsmitten · 16/01/2024 11:00

What about the kids choose 2/3 presents each and they donate the rest? I mean, it could be a total
disaster if they choose shit ones, which could be a possibility if the guests know they’re being donated anyway…

Nonman23 · 16/01/2024 10:59

At our school joint parties, we just put a pound in a card for each child - saves a lot of hassle and money. Every child then has around 25-30 pounds (depending on how many children from the class attend the party) to buy something.

BodyKeepingScore · 16/01/2024 10:58

BusyMummyWrites01 · 16/01/2024 10:52

Ps some people seem to be confused - when you have joint/multiple child party birthday, the idea is that each attendee brings one present only that goes into the pot, so to speak. The 20 or so gifts are then shared equally, so each birthday child gets 5-8 gifts. There won’t be ‘160 parcels of tat’. It’s usually a ‘whole class’ thing, not a parting with a zillion guests/gifts.

Why should I have to choose a gift though that won't go to its intended recipient? I wouldn't attend a party where gifts were just divvied up.

Almahart · 16/01/2024 10:56

What do the children say?!

BodyKeepingScore · 16/01/2024 10:56

I would be really displeased if one of my child's friends threw a party and in order for my child to attend I was expected to buy gifts for each child whose party it was. It would actually stop me from going.

Swipe left for the next trending thread