Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say No to this charity BS

343 replies

EffingBirthdays · 16/01/2024 07:34

DS9 and 3 school mates are sharing a birthday party in few days .
I ve made a point to the other mums that we should add a note to what’s app group to kindly bring one present max , absolutely no need for anything more as kids will share

Thats when one of the other mums had the bright idea to donate ALL gifts to kids related charity - apparently her friend did it with her kid and it was massive success all parents were very happy etc

WTAF! Party is not cheap, and how the fuck do I say this to ds?

I don’t mind donating the odd gift but we have more than 40 kids invited, wtaf?

all other 3 mums agreed, wtf do I do? AIBU?

OP posts:
hellsBells246 · 16/01/2024 12:47

I'd just say no, you already donate to charity and you don't think it's right that you make the decision to donate your ds's birthday gifts, which he was looking forward to receiving.

Katisha · 16/01/2024 12:47

Bet the other mums want to say something too but dont have the courage

Handsnotwands · 16/01/2024 12:43

this is the kind of move that kids will be recounting in therapy 20 years later "and on my birthday they took all my presents and gave them away before i'd even opened them"

Needmorelego · 16/01/2024 12:38

@LessonsInPhysics that's a good point about who they are intending to donate them too.
We've just had Christmas where charities such as the Salvation Army do toy collections which are distributed via (I assume) social services who will have knowledge of who could receive them.
This is always a big volunteer task - collecting, sorting and distributing. It's usually only done at Christmas because it's a big task.
The rest of the year charities don't have the storage space for loads of stuff so they can't take random donations.
I would really really want to know exactly where they were planning on donating.
There's an awful lot of misguided charity giving out there like a random bloke filling a van with toys to drive to Ukraine but doesn't have a collection point in Ukraine that they are actually heading to so they end up dumped.

artimesiasfootsteps · 16/01/2024 12:13

I think it's a bit much to put the pressure on to donate gifts to others...

I went to a public school on scholarship, so the gifts I received at my birthday parties were often pretty ££££ but my mother would encourage me to choose 4-5 gifts to keep and then we would donate the others to a local women's refuge where children arrived with nothing, which my mother's friend ran.

It was a good lesson in though I was the girl in my class with the least, I was still very middle class and better off than many.

However she didn't make do it, the givers didn't know and I had joint birthday parties occasionally and the other girl presumably kept all her gifts, I had no idea and didn't care tbh......

So in a roundabout way, I can see the parents are trying to eliminate waste, do a nice thing etc, but I think it should really be done on an individual basis. If they are doing that, they should really let parents know it will be a toy drive for charity so they can regift things that maybe wouldn't suit the birthday children ie barbies etc, but would for a children's hospital charity, that way they don't have to buy more plastic tat in a col crisis.

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 12:13

Bit of a pickle that it's so close to the party.

I totally understand where you were coming from with one gift each, you can't reasonably suggest attendees bring four presents, and your DCs don't need 40 presents each. I do think it's a bit of a minefield making sure all DCs then get equal presents of equal quality/value (value to them, I mean, not monetary value).

The charity thing might have been ok if announced sooner - people needed to know this before they went shopping so they could buy accordingly. Likewise DCs will now have expectations of presents which will be dashed.

The everyone gives money in a pot which is then split, but again too late to organise this now when people will have already shopped.

Given it's so close to the party you're going to have to stick with whatever the guests have already been told to expect really. And if the other parents want to donate some or all of their DC's haul, that's their choice, but I wouldn't advertise it to the gift givers at this point or they'll feel rejected.

GreatGateauxsby · 16/01/2024 12:13

Why don’t you go for a halfway house…?

“The charity idea is great! But the boys might be disappointed with no gifts… what does everyone think about a compromise?
guests bring 1 gift max, the boys pick 2 gifts or so (like a lucky dip!) and we donate the remaining 30 / 32”

babyproblems · 16/01/2024 12:12

Both the charity and the sharing presents are terrible ideas. People buy gifts with the person in mind! Not a lucky dip type present. It’s up to each boy whether they want to donate anything.

JollyJanuary · 16/01/2024 12:12

I'd be properly hacked off at buying and wrapping presents for these children based on what i think they'd want to receive and then having them given away. So rude and so unpleasant for the children. I give to charity and this is not a way that i'd want to support a charity. I bet the charity would much rather the cash than a zillion plastic toys. Joyless and inefficient.

Petrine · 16/01/2024 12:09

How would giving all the gifts away work in practice?

So, at the party there's a whole pile of gifts - does someone then come over and sweep all those gifts into a bin bag or similar, put it in the boot of their car and drive to the nearest charity shop?

OP you say the children's parents were pleased with what happened at their give everything to charity party but I can't help thinking that those children wouldn't have been in the least bit happy with it. I think it's cruel and unnecessary.

LessonsInPhysics · 16/01/2024 12:09

I'd be really annoyed if a present I bought for a birthday child was just given to charity. If I knew in advance I wouldn't take anything - just a nice card.
Do many charities take random presents or worse, would this be a donation to a charity shop?
I like the idea of a present table for each child and you take yours home. You can offer to do a cash donation to a charity of your own choice to appease the other mums.

Agree · 16/01/2024 12:08

Is this idea all part of that virtue signalling 'worthiness' problem that young women have got going one these days?

It's so tedious. Not everything in life has to be fraught with martyrdom just to be good enough. Fun is still allowed.

Kit60 · 16/01/2024 12:07

letitialane · 16/01/2024 12:01

Agree with this too!

But surely they’ll have friends in common hence the decision of just one present for all kids? Otherwise, a family will be buying a gift for each child. Not saying I agree with any of this - the joint party sounds a headache.

pizzaHeart · 16/01/2024 12:05

rockwater · 16/01/2024 08:19

Absolutely not. I regularly give to charity so it's not as if I am against it at all but giving my kid's birthday presents away is just plain mean and it may backfire by making them resentful towards charity. Charity should be given freely and with the intention to help people, not confiscating gifts which will be seen by kids as some kind of punishment

This^
I think offering to donate one gift each to a charity is one thing but to donate all presents is too much.
I can understand people asking for donations to charity instead of presents in advance but not this.

All this sharing gifts was a recipe for disaster from the start tbh.

SweetBirdsong · 16/01/2024 12:01

Say 'LOL 😆 'That's a good one Jenny are you here all week?!'

Hmm

@EffingBirthdays Absolutely as other posters have said. NO WAY.

Saying 'I will get a little separate gift as a donation (like a jigsaw) but no WAY am I donating my boy's gifts,' (as a few people have suggested,) is what you should do. Good luck!

letitialane · 16/01/2024 12:01

NeedToChangeName · 16/01/2024 08:42

I would suggest a present table for each child, tell them your child will be taking their presents home and they can do what they like with theirs. I bet they will give their kids their gifts!

I like this idea from @Pineapplewaves

Agree with this too!

Needmorelego · 16/01/2024 12:00

@Growlybear83 exactly..The first thing I used to ask the parent when I got an invite was "what are they into"? I used to sometimes even like the child (usually more discreetly - as in "I know you like football. What's your team?")

letitialane · 16/01/2024 11:59

Mothership4two · 16/01/2024 07:39

"I think the boys are going to be upset if we do that and they have no presents at all"

OR "no actually I am not happy with that"

This.

Dinkyboots · 16/01/2024 11:58

But I would not want to be giving presents away, that's kind of insulting to the children and parents who may have carefully spent time and effort choosing a present specifically.

Dinkyboots · 16/01/2024 11:56

At a shared party my niece went to, the party invitees parents clubbed together and bought vouchers suitable for kids (books, gaming, whatever).

So the money was collected by one person who then divided it up between the birthday kids and bought separate vouchers for each one. Also they said a cap of £10 in total (contribution), not per birthday child, as with a lot of invitees coming, divided up between birthday kids it still made a generous voucher amount each.

Invitees could choose to go in with that or do their own thing so could still get present if they wanted, but it was nice and easy all round and made for less present wastage as birthday child could choose something they wanted with the voucher.

TinyTear · 16/01/2024 11:55

no no no no to ALL ideas!!!

I have a nearly 9 yo and the care and attention they put in gifts, even to kids they don't know so well... they would be SO disappointed to have the present they chose given to someone else or to charity. FFS

if you want charity donations open a justgiving and don't be surprised if people don't donate!

what a stupid idea!

kerstina · 16/01/2024 11:54

Just let people do what they want to do. Stop trying to control other people and certainly do not agree with taking children’s presents and giving them to charity. If people want to donate fine if people can’t afford a present fine but please don’t spoil your children’s fun by taking from them.

Agree · 16/01/2024 11:53

BusyMummyWrites01 · 16/01/2024 11:44

It’s never been an issue at any jointly held birthday my kids were a part of - as guests or the party child - you’re buying a £10 gift for a 9yo (usually books, lego or similar). Think people are being rather precious over this.

I can't imagine how this works and it sounds like a recipe for hurt feelings.

Also I'm guessing this is a 'privilege' thing because for some mums a £10 gift would put a dent in the budget.

So, how does it work? Take little boy X to buy a £10 present for his good friend Y at school. This involves an extra trip to the shops and a whole conversation, X spends copious time uhmming and ahhhing and finally decides on the perfect thing because he knows it's a subject his pal Y is interested in. He's anxious if what he's getting is 'good enough' or if other boys are spending more money. Wraps it, labels it, addresses it to Y, hands it over at party... only to be told... oh it's been given to child Z -or- worse, yeah we're giving these to charity. At this point, if I was mum I'd be aggrieved at the waste of time, effort, money, and emotional input, little boy X is going to be confused and disappointed and little boy Y is also.

How many people's feelings can a group of people hurt all in one day?

TheTigerWhoCameToEatMyHusband · 16/01/2024 11:52

I don't believe kid's birthdays should be turned into a charity fundraiser either it's their day. I'm all for giving to charity just not for my kid's birthday.

TheTigerWhoCameToEatMyHusband · 16/01/2024 11:51

I'd fuck this idea straight off and not care about people talking about me at the school gates. No way would I be sharing a party with 3 others anyway it's a recipe for trouble, complicated and stressful. I don't like birthday parties at the best of times. Should of just let people buy what they want for who they want and deal with the stuff you don't want after.