Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say No to this charity BS

343 replies

EffingBirthdays · 16/01/2024 07:34

DS9 and 3 school mates are sharing a birthday party in few days .
I ve made a point to the other mums that we should add a note to what’s app group to kindly bring one present max , absolutely no need for anything more as kids will share

Thats when one of the other mums had the bright idea to donate ALL gifts to kids related charity - apparently her friend did it with her kid and it was massive success all parents were very happy etc

WTAF! Party is not cheap, and how the fuck do I say this to ds?

I don’t mind donating the odd gift but we have more than 40 kids invited, wtaf?

all other 3 mums agreed, wtf do I do? AIBU?

OP posts:
00100001 · 17/01/2024 18:19

Jaydexx1 · 17/01/2024 18:15

Yup never herd of other kids sharing party's i personally wouldn't have it wouldnt care how much I had to pay kids birthdays are once a year that's their time, would rather them feel special over saving money. Everyone is different though

Well good for you being able to afford £300 or whatever for a party. Others can't.

It also doesn't stop them feeling special....

SharonEllis · 17/01/2024 18:17

Mention charity & people's brains fall out (not yours, the woman whose daft idea this was). No you are not unreasonable. At the very least you have to tell the guests & give them the option to just give the money to a charity. There are loads of charities I dont support & I would bject to my present being given to them. People who really understand charities give them cash. Not stuff.

Jaydexx1 · 17/01/2024 18:15

Yup never herd of other kids sharing party's i personally wouldn't have it wouldnt care how much I had to pay kids birthdays are once a year that's their time, would rather them feel special over saving money. Everyone is different though

00100001 · 17/01/2024 17:57

Jaydexx1 · 17/01/2024 12:37

Why are they sharing a party ? Or sharing gifts ? No way would I donate my child's birthday presents personally I would be removing my child from the party and doing their own one ..... Unless twins I dont understand why you would want your child to share their party with friends from school

It's fairly normal.

3 kids in one class with birthdays within 2 weeks of each other and they all want a party. Makes sense to share it, seeing as the guests will be pretty much the same kids each time - no clashes, ⅓ price of hire etc... I'm surprised you've never experienced it before.

Oriunda · 17/01/2024 15:15

No one is on the hook for 40 gifts. Not every child in a class has a party. Plus, not every child will be from the school, surely?

We’ve held joint parties in the past; we’ve invited the children (or boys) from class and then our own DS’ individual friends. It makes total sense given you’re mostly inviting the same pool of kids. Avoids clashing dates. Means parents aren’t continually having to drop off at birthday parties each week. Means we could run to a more expensive event like paintballing.

Each invited friend usually bought a birthday card (usually with cash inside) for the child/ren that invited them. So classmates would bring two envelopes; the outside school friends just one for the child that invited them.

OP, by giving in to the other parents you are possibly setting a precedent for next year’s party or birthday. I’d make it clear to your son’s closest friends’ parents that your son will gratefully receive any gifts. Message separately if you have to.

AliceMcK · 17/01/2024 15:08

Needmorelego · 17/01/2024 09:04

@hanschristmassolo that's the thing - these big parties are just ridiculous. I'm not convinced children actually enjoy them that much.
I never invited more than about 7 children to my daughter's parties and we had them at home (which is a small flat btw).

Not true, my DDs have always had big parties, whole class, plus siblings. I’ve always thrown parties that can accommodate siblings. My older 2 DDs are 2 years apart and birthdays are days apart, it’s always been a joint party, last year we threw a 3rd child in the mix. The 3rd little girl had never had a party and her parents couldn’t afford one so she went thirds with us, we had over 50kids and they all had an amazing time. We hired a function room at a local con club, got a dj and let the venue do food.

i know not everyone is able to throw big parties, my DH and I save and budget each year to make sure we can.

As far as presents were concerned each child handed out individual invites so they got presents from their friends only. I’ve never expected parents to give presents to both my daughters, just the one their child is friends with.

Also to whoever was saying that no one thinks about presents there will be lots of generic colouring books etc… also disagree, I’ve very rarely bought a generic present I buy for the birthday child, fine in reception when your getting to know people, but as they get older I usually let my children pick and they choose what their friend likes. It’s the same with my DDs presents, last year turning 9 & 11 all their gifts were very specific to them from their friends.

Not sure the OPs going to come back to the thread now. Also waiting to see if the DM picks this up lol

GasPanic · 17/01/2024 13:08

How does that work ?

I mean 40 people invited. So does each of the 4 kids get 40 presents each ?

I mean giving all the presents to charity seems a bit harsh on the kids. OTOH 40 presents seems like an enormous amount, especially after Xmas.

Not only that, but surely you are on the hook for 40x presents in return. At £10 a present that is £400. Not to mention the pita of having to choose a present every week.

Or am I missing something.

SwingTheMonkey · 17/01/2024 13:02

Jaydexx1 · 17/01/2024 12:42

It's not common where I'm from unless it's siblings. Party's don't need to be expensive if you have an imagination but sharing I would never make my child share because it's expensive save more or do something cheaper poor kids ... I have 3 btw before someone jumps in saying obviously you don't know what it's like having children.

Not sure where you are from but it’s very common in England. And I’d far rather my child had the party they want, rather than one I could afford. One of my children shared a party with his best friend - I don’t think he considered himself a ‘poor child’. He had a whale of a time.

Jaydexx1 · 17/01/2024 12:42

It's not common where I'm from unless it's siblings. Party's don't need to be expensive if you have an imagination but sharing I would never make my child share because it's expensive save more or do something cheaper poor kids ... I have 3 btw before someone jumps in saying obviously you don't know what it's like having children.

SwingTheMonkey · 17/01/2024 12:40

Jaydexx1 · 17/01/2024 12:37

Why are they sharing a party ? Or sharing gifts ? No way would I donate my child's birthday presents personally I would be removing my child from the party and doing their own one ..... Unless twins I dont understand why you would want your child to share their party with friends from school

Sharing a party with another child is very common, my kids have been to loads of shared parties. It often means a party that is too expensive for each set of parents to afford on their own, becomes affordable.

Sharing a party with 3 other kids isn’t so common.

Jaydexx1 · 17/01/2024 12:37

Why are they sharing a party ? Or sharing gifts ? No way would I donate my child's birthday presents personally I would be removing my child from the party and doing their own one ..... Unless twins I dont understand why you would want your child to share their party with friends from school

Needmorelego · 17/01/2024 12:14

@Sodndashitall in the early days of parties when it was the whole class type (ie age 4 or 5) I tended to go generic and buy notebooks and pencils/pen and some stickers - which always seemed well recieved.
Once the children were older and I knew them (and the parents) better I would always ask what type of things they were in to.
This is another reason why I don't understand the "I don't want to talk to people at the school gate" threads. Perfect place for a quick conversation about possible pressies.

LookItsMeAgain · 17/01/2024 12:05

Kit60 · 16/01/2024 14:02

That’s all well and good but in that case if this mum insists on being so virtuous, she should tell everyone to donate to a charity of their choice or just keep the cash they’d have spent on a gift in a CoL/climate crisis.

On the day of the party @EffingBirthdays , make sure that Virtuous Mum knows (hereafter known as VM) that you will look after collecting any presents that are brought to the party and you will ensure that they get brought to the local Children's Hospice or Hospital and the kids there will be ever so grateful for them.

I have a sneaky suspicion that VM would try to pull a stunt on or after the day but I can't work out what that stunt might look like.

At least if you get to take charge, you can go through the gifts and work out what would and wouldn't be acceptable to pass along (in case there are some really unsuitable/unusable gifts) and then you can pass everything else along.

I agree with others though - if I had to go to the effort of getting a present in the first place, knowing that it wasn't going to be used by any of the respective birthday kids, I would probably either not get a gift and pass on the money directly to the charity or they might even get a re-gifted present.

Sodndashitall · 17/01/2024 11:56

Needmorelego · 17/01/2024 08:47

@Sodndashitall so you would rather your child gets some random gift that they may not have any interest in - but the gift his best mate purposely chose because best mate knows exactly what he loves and is obsessed with goes to charity?
The whole idea shows how bad gift buying with so many people just buying random stuff (we see this with all the Christmas threads).
Ask the parent (or child) what type of things they like or give a voucher/money. Stop with all this random "I hope they like this" gifts.

Clearly you spend far more time choosing party gifts than I did! Typically I just have a stash of gifts and pluck one out for the party. Yes there's the odd best friend choice but at that age usually the parents choose and buy.
I think it's totally unreasonable to expect people to bring 4 gifts to a party sothey have to be divided up somehow. I find unseen is best and saves arguments over one "cool" toy. Each to their town

Widower2014 · 17/01/2024 11:34

Maybe point out that you already give your child/children unwanted toys and clothes to charity. The idea of birthday is to replace items no longer used so why not say instead ask people to bring a clean and working Preloved toy to be donated and the boys have their new gifts

SD1978 · 17/01/2024 11:15

4 boys sharing a party, and suggesting each invitee only bring one gift was a daft idea, how the hell would you decide which kid gets what present? As I, sure you're realising now, sharing a party with that many others is always going to be a tad fraught with how it should go. The giving all the gifts to charity is just another silly idea on top of a joint party that big, your suggestion (sorry) and this finishes it off. I'd go along with it, because you would have had no idea who, if anyone was bringing a gift for your son anyway. Is he old enough to understand what's been suggested? Personally, as an adult I'd still be gutted not to get any presents though. Can you suggest that a percentage is donated, so they still maybe get some gifts?

Grantanow · 17/01/2024 11:10

You don't have to agree to a proposal. It's not even a decision. And you were not consulted.

LittleOwl153 · 17/01/2024 11:02

As a guest at this party I would be very pissed off. Assuming the party is this coming weekend I would have likely bought and wrapped presents for each of the kids by now - potentally stretching my budget to do so. I'd expect some backlash here tbh.

Crazycatlady79 · 17/01/2024 10:52

This is an overly complicated situation and that's why shared parties are a nightmare.

The decision should not have been made without you and I'm not sure why the other Mums discussed this without you.

If you do decide to go along with this, then the parents of the children coming definitely need an heads up, as they may not want to pay out for a gift that's just going to be donated elsewhere.

If you do all decide, instead, to go with a one present (or whatever) request, how is that going to work in terms of sharing amongst the DC?!

Would it just be easier to arrange a PayPal collection over WatsApp for parents to then either split and get each child something they would like, or to donate to a charity you can (hopefully) all agree on.

Good luck, as I think you might need it!

Laura0076 · 17/01/2024 10:33

I understand that. I mainly stick to small local charities where I can take the donation personally... such a shame its condition to checking donations go to a charity ... this world 🤯

pontipinemum · 17/01/2024 10:27

@EarringsandLipstick DS will not be going to a private south side school. It'll be a rural county school where most of the kids are from farms! The party venue thing I don't see working here, there just isn't anywhere close enough so it probably will be parties at peoples houses, but I like the though of him getting money towards buying one decent present. Hopefully it is already the 'thing' in the school. If not I'll wait until his birthday and request it, ppl might do the same for their kids then

SwingTheMonkey · 17/01/2024 10:25

This could have been avoided if you’d addressed the situation with the group yesterday morning, instead of posting here.

If I were you, I’d send a message to the party mums saying your child would like to donate his presents to a charity of his own choice so could presents be divided into piles on the day to enable this to happen. You then decide what you want to do with them when he gets home and opens them. Nobody else needs to know what you’ve done with them - I personally would be removing myself from the party WhatsApp and not commenting on it further. If other mums want to take photos of their darlings delivering toys to the needy to share on social media, let them. Keep out of it.

Thecatmaster · 17/01/2024 09:54

I think that the better idea would have been for parents to contribute to a fund for a joint present to be bought for each child or a link provided to a charity instead.

Needmorelego · 17/01/2024 09:37

@Laura0076 that's the thing - I regularly give to charity but obviously I choose who I donate too.
I refused to do a "shoebox" once because I don't think Samaritans Purse (who they were intended for) is a good charity.

Laura0076 · 17/01/2024 09:33

That's very true. I usually bulk buy a load when the works does 3 for £12 I think £4 a gift is pretty reasonable. I always try to get something that the invites hinted the child might like lol.
I'm not against spending money for the parties. Me and my lil one do alot of charity work as I've had a rough past and I need to use things such as food banks, emergency housing etc. And I like her to see the value of that also x

Swipe left for the next trending thread