Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say No to this charity BS

343 replies

EffingBirthdays · 16/01/2024 07:34

DS9 and 3 school mates are sharing a birthday party in few days .
I ve made a point to the other mums that we should add a note to what’s app group to kindly bring one present max , absolutely no need for anything more as kids will share

Thats when one of the other mums had the bright idea to donate ALL gifts to kids related charity - apparently her friend did it with her kid and it was massive success all parents were very happy etc

WTAF! Party is not cheap, and how the fuck do I say this to ds?

I don’t mind donating the odd gift but we have more than 40 kids invited, wtaf?

all other 3 mums agreed, wtf do I do? AIBU?

OP posts:
MzHz · 16/01/2024 09:16

Good god, these kids are 9, they’re gonna know this is dumb.

how thick are these other mums? They sound ridiculous!

unless there is an agreement to allow the boys to choose a couple of gifts each and donate the rest, this is going to be a disaster of a birthday

@EffingBirthdays divide and conquer, call them up individually and express your concerns and hope that someone’s only brain cells actually meet together in their head.

Brefugee · 16/01/2024 09:13

EarringsandLipstick · 16/01/2024 08:39

But what's the alternative to '1 gift each'? You can't expect parents to get 4 presents for a shared party!

The other way shared parties work is each person invites a small number. And only those invitees buy for that person. Same idea.

presumably the 4 boys have either joint friends, or single friends. So in that case when my DC have been to such parties, we have either bought a present for the actual friend, and a card for the others the DC don't really know.

and for parties where they were friends with all the birthday kids we usually got joint presents with the other friends who were invited.

It's not rocket science.

As for all the "who wants tat" comments. Do you buy tat for other kids? i never have. That's just mean/daft/weird.

Petrine · 16/01/2024 09:10

Giving a child’s birthday gifts away is just awful. How would those parents feel if they themselves had a celebration involving gift giving, say an engagement, and someone arbitrarily announced all gifts were to be given away - how would they feel?

Virtue signalling at the children’s expense… dreadful behaviour.

VisionsOfSplendour · 16/01/2024 09:04

The whole thing is totally bonkers, firstly the suggestion to take a random gift and secondly to give the random gifts awayShock

as a parent of an invited child I'd have no clue what to buy and then would be pretty pissed off that having taken the time to think of something it was given away

Stupidity at its finest

When my children were that age if the party was for more than 2 children the invitation had wording along the lines of not buying three presents and you child had been invited by X,Y ior Z and to buy for that child - equally shared on the invitations

Greengagesnfennel · 16/01/2024 08:53

If it's only a few days away how can you do sharing either! Lots of people will have already bought the presents they planned to give.

It's too late to be sending out new instructions to people. And you will all piss people off if you say this late on that you are gifting them to charity or want money etc.

If you wanted to do anything different you should have told people ages ago when invites went out.

SandyWaves · 16/01/2024 08:53

When i see a please no gift, I feel sad for the bday kid. Of course, kids want to open presents on their birthday.

Donations to charity instead...seriously, I cannot stand this. They can give to charity themselves, I donate to the charities I want. Again, makes me feel sorry for the bday kid

Sharing a party with 4 kids is madness in my opinion. Too many chiefs and all that.

Many parents would have already bought a gift, i certainly would have. To ask just to bring one present was considerate IMO considering there are 4 kids.

Next time, have your own party!

determinedtomakethiswork · 16/01/2024 08:50

I would say to her "but your children have never seen you give all your presents away so why would they expect you to give their presents away?"

LittleMonks11 · 16/01/2024 08:49

No, no and thrice no.

That's uncool for 9 year olds. A wedding, or 70th birthday or 50th wedding anniversary celebration maybe. Also people like giving gifts and some parents might be put out.

Suggest instead a spend limit to send the invitee mums. Like a fiver.

Or have they already ploughed ahead?

NeedToChangeName · 16/01/2024 08:48

Could you agree to contact all the parents to suggest they buy one gift only, and tell them who it's for. And then each family decides what to do with their own child's gifts?

Jaigh · 16/01/2024 08:48

I'd have rather threw £20 in a pot and the pot shared between the 4 kids. This is the problem with sharing their party I suppose, I get why you tried to make it better on the guests, but absolutely no way should it all go to charity.

Needmorelego · 16/01/2024 08:47

I'd drop out of the party and personally invite 3 or 4 of your childs closest friends round for a birthday tea.
Those big parties are horrible anyway.

AllEars112232 · 16/01/2024 08:44

TheLogicalSong · 16/01/2024 07:43

I don't get the sharing idea - who would be taking presents home? I think you started muddying the water by suggesting this and the others have now taken it a step further. You should have left it to sort itself out.

Totally agree with this!

Needmorelego · 16/01/2024 08:44

So does the "one gift only" mean "pick some random toy - anything it doesn't matter - it's going straight to charity anyway" or "you just buy for Bob and not the other 3 - Bob loves cars. But it doesn't matter - it's going to charity anyway" ?
Just baffling.

Astonetogo · 16/01/2024 08:43

EarringsandLipstick · 16/01/2024 08:36

@Astonetogo

No, you were clear!

It's still a terrible idea (nearly as bad as taking them all to charity).

There will be a big pile of gifts. All but 4 will be donated. The child has to randomly select one, knowing there are loads of other gifts, any of which might be preferable - and they want more than one of course!

And on top of that, play nice don't make a fuss (about your birthday being messed up!) and you'll, er, get to go to the cinema.

I mean. Stop.

Well fair enough if you disagree. Although I think most 9 / 10 year old are capable of understanding ‘only one is for you’, just like picking a lucky bag from a shop of a gift from a bran tub! They’ll never know what’s in the other gifts, so no disappointment on what they’ve missed out on.

I don’t think there’s any harm in teaching children that giving to charity is a nice thing to do, especially when so many are struggling at this time. The joy of giving is greater than receiving! At 9 I think they can handle that, although as they are still young and it’s the first time doing it this way it’s reasonable to also sweeten the pill with a treat of a different nature. My opinion.

CoffeeCantata · 16/01/2024 08:42

I'm all for charitable giving but...

I wish people would just give to charities themselves, and not on behalf of others, unless someone has specifically requested it!

And youngsters are certainly not going to either understand or appreciate it. It's a mild form of control and abuse.😀 There are other ways to teach them to be caring and charitable.

NeedToChangeName · 16/01/2024 08:42

I would suggest a present table for each child, tell them your child will be taking their presents home and they can do what they like with theirs. I bet they will give their kids their gifts!

I like this idea from @Pineapplewaves

Uokhon · 16/01/2024 08:42

How would three kids living at different addresses share one gift anyway?

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 16/01/2024 08:39

Thats when one of the other mums had the bright idea to donate ALL gifts to kids related charity - apparently her friend did it with her kid and it was massive success all parents were very happy etc

Call me cynical but unless I actually see the presents being donated, I assume it has not been done and it was a way to dodge gift giving.

Needmorelego · 16/01/2024 08:39

@Astonetogo but that's very unfair to the gift buyer.
I always tried to get something the child was into - so child A might get some Pokémon cards and stickers because they were Pokémon obsessed and Child B gets a Ninjago set because that's their obsession.
I would be annoyed if Child B ended up with the Pokémon stuff because they had no interest in it. I didn't buy it for them. I bought it for child A.

EarringsandLipstick · 16/01/2024 08:39

Brefugee · 16/01/2024 08:37

the "1 gift max" was a stupid idea, OP, so go back in the group and say that. And then say, very clearly, that the other boys can do what they like, but your DS would actually like to have the presents that people have thoughtfully picked out for him to have.

As for not having the gumption to say that in the group? You have children. You have to have the gumption to advocate for them.

But what's the alternative to '1 gift each'? You can't expect parents to get 4 presents for a shared party!

The other way shared parties work is each person invites a small number. And only those invitees buy for that person. Same idea.

kelsaecobbles · 16/01/2024 08:39

I guess this is symptomatic of a problem

A lot of people today don't want piles of presents for themselves or their kids

They don't want the tat, the plastic, the duplications , the lack of storage space. The hassle of getting rid of stuff they never wanted

They don't want children growing up focussed on stuff not people and relationships and experiences

They don't want to help destroy the planet their kids will inherit

It's a culture clash

Brefugee · 16/01/2024 08:37

the "1 gift max" was a stupid idea, OP, so go back in the group and say that. And then say, very clearly, that the other boys can do what they like, but your DS would actually like to have the presents that people have thoughtfully picked out for him to have.

As for not having the gumption to say that in the group? You have children. You have to have the gumption to advocate for them.

EarringsandLipstick · 16/01/2024 08:37

@Lochroy

Which is why OP suggested that party-goers only bring one present each, not 4, and these would be shared out.

Astonetogo · 16/01/2024 08:36

The reason I suggest going with it is that these mums sound gossipy and setting them against you would make life uncomfortable for a very long time.

Is there any chance they are calling your bluff on this? Are they definitely serious?!

EarringsandLipstick · 16/01/2024 08:36

@Astonetogo

No, you were clear!

It's still a terrible idea (nearly as bad as taking them all to charity).

There will be a big pile of gifts. All but 4 will be donated. The child has to randomly select one, knowing there are loads of other gifts, any of which might be preferable - and they want more than one of course!

And on top of that, play nice don't make a fuss (about your birthday being messed up!) and you'll, er, get to go to the cinema.

I mean. Stop.