Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say No to this charity BS

343 replies

EffingBirthdays · 16/01/2024 07:34

DS9 and 3 school mates are sharing a birthday party in few days .
I ve made a point to the other mums that we should add a note to what’s app group to kindly bring one present max , absolutely no need for anything more as kids will share

Thats when one of the other mums had the bright idea to donate ALL gifts to kids related charity - apparently her friend did it with her kid and it was massive success all parents were very happy etc

WTAF! Party is not cheap, and how the fuck do I say this to ds?

I don’t mind donating the odd gift but we have more than 40 kids invited, wtaf?

all other 3 mums agreed, wtf do I do? AIBU?

OP posts:
Mikimoto · 16/01/2024 10:09

The weirdest part is the original idea of one gift between all 4 kids: how on earth would that work?!

We went to a party recently where they asked for only second-hand/re-gifted presents: I thought that was a nice option.

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 16/01/2024 10:07

Sounds a bit like this mum is trying to trump you by being even more 'thoughtful' but her idea doesn't really make much sense. I think it's great to teach kids about giving and chatity but i don't think their birthday is the right time to do it. If people want to donate a present to charity they can do this off their own back.

A 4 way split part is tricky and i agree withthe setiment behind your suggestion however I'm not sure how you would execute this plan in the most appropriate way. Ideally each party invitee is given only 1 specified child to buy for (however this could cause issues with friendship dynamics), a cash present where final amout is split 4 ways and the boys go shopping after (could be awkward/cheeky to suggest), sending a message to say 'please don't feel you have to but all 4 boys presents' (problem is 1 or 2 may recieve noticeably more but some will buy for all 4).

I think I'd be inclined to say nothing about presents in the invite and let invitees parents do what they feel most appropriate. 4 in one go is a lot to buy. I think I'd maybe just buy 4 x£5ish gifts instead of one at £15ish.

ManchesterLu · 16/01/2024 10:04

Just tell her it's fine if her son wants to donate his share of the gifts, but it's up to the other lads what they do with theirs. End of. She's bloody cheeky for suggesting that they should donate their gifts.

Jk8 · 16/01/2024 10:01

Honestly you all sound unreasonable (1 gift each ? If it's a party for 4 children then each child brings 4 regardless of the cost or doesn't bother tbh)

& no I wouldn't donate all my childs gifts to charity with no prior discussion with them & probably only being supported by other parents because the reality of a joint birthday pretty much means there will be uneven gifts/things going missing/debates about who's who's...ect

It sounds like a massive pain in the arse to be honest & id imagine donating the lot to charity is probably the easiest solution

Codlingmoths · 16/01/2024 10:00

How about ‘I’m worried the kids will be upset if we tell them their presenrs are all going to charity, and also that their friends will be pissed off if they find out their presents were just given away immediately. I know my son won’t keep secrets! Thoughts?’

pontipinemum · 16/01/2024 09:59

@EarringsandLipstick that sounds fantastic! The €5 in a card is something I've heard a lot of online but not seen in person, my nieces birthday was recently enough and she got lots of actual presents. When my DS starts primary school should I be the one to try instigate this? His birthday is July so will not be the 1st in the year, or just when it does get to his birthday do it? Also maybe €10 as there will prob only be about 8 kids in his class, but there are a few classes per room so more might be invited? (I'm in Ireland too I recognise your name)

No way would I have been happy at that age to give all my birthday gifts to charity. I can't imagine any child being remotely happy with it

Needmorelego · 16/01/2024 09:58

@Brefugee I find one persons idea of "tat" is another persons idea of a perfectly normal present.
I hate the word "tat".
Does my head in.

Sandtownnel · 16/01/2024 09:58

This isn't ok. I honestly don't know which child wouldn't want a present. I know a few mums did that at my dc previous school, the kids were not happy. Even worse they were only 5. I'm all for donating but not in this way.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 16/01/2024 09:55

Well, firstly I think the "1 gift each and we'll share them out" is dumb. I'd either stick a fiver in all 4 cards or buy each kid a bar of chocolate/felt pen set/other small item that can be used.

I'd also ASK the DC what they wanted to do.

And, interesting how many people here are expressing annoyance at the idea of a present being donated to charity yet on another thread this is exactly what people are saying should be done as its rude to say you won't use/wear a gift

Folklore9074 · 16/01/2024 09:53

If you’re not bothered about presents tell the parents and say they don’t need to bring presents or to make a charity donation. Getting presents and then donating is a faff for everyone.

DogLover24 · 16/01/2024 09:50

@EffingBirthdays OP, you MUST stick up for your DC and say something. He/she comes first!!!

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 16/01/2024 09:49

“My son is always very excited and grateful to receive birthday gifts from his friends, and we know that other parents put time and effort into choosing them. I don’t think it’s fair for me to tell him that we adults have decided we will give all of his 10th birthday presents away so I’m not going to join in with that.”

I honestly can’t think of any honest way to say it other than that! It’s such an awkward mess and the charity angle now makes it all about pitting the selfish v the virtuous.

Dorriethelittlewitch · 16/01/2024 09:42

capable of understanding ‘only one is for you’, just like picking a lucky bag from a shop of a gift from a bran tub! They’ll never know what’s in the other gifts, so no disappointment on what they’ve missed out on.

Depends on the child surely. My almost 9 year old would struggle at A. Having to make an unseen choice and B. Imagining what he hadn't picked. I also don't believe his birthday party would be the place to work on his resilience around those areas. I would have been the same. Hate still hate surprises.

As a parent I'd be annoyed too. I like to pick thoughtful presents for my dcs friends and classmates. Something relevant and personal. If party throwers want a charity donation instead or a book or indeed cash because the birthday child is saving up, that should be communicated at the point of invitation.

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 16/01/2024 09:41

I think taking 40 presents away from children on their birthday is absolutely ridiculous. Talk about virtue-signalling. The others have probably said yes out of guilt and are thinking the same as you!

Dibilnik · 16/01/2024 09:41

Just say "Don't be daft!"

Ionlylikedityesterday · 16/01/2024 09:39

As a parent I would be pissed off if I went to the trouble of choosing and buying a gift then having it donated to charity. I prefer to be in control of my own charity giving and not have it snuck upon me.

LookItsMeAgain · 16/01/2024 09:39

Come on OP - grab your gumption by the whoohaas and reply that donating the gifts to charity would be a terrible idea.
If the kids want to donate a gift from their split of the collection at the end of the day, you would be up to doing that but the idea that they would not have any birthday presents just doesn't sit right and is missing the point of only asking the guests to bring one gift.

Send the message. Go on. You know you want to!

Growlybear83 · 16/01/2024 09:38

The present sharing sounds bizarre! I realise that 40 children can't each bring a present for all four of the party children, but how do the presents get divided up? I always found that my daughter was given some birthday presents, like makeup, which went straight in the charity bag, but most parents tried to buy something for her that they thought she would like. But if children are only bringing one present, what happens if most of the parents decide to buy for one particular child and bring presents that the other three won't be interested in? Will the children open all the presents together after the party and argue about who has what, or will they be divided up at random to be opened at home?

Isometimeswonder · 16/01/2024 09:38

If I bought a present for someone, child or adult, I'd be pissed off if it was given away immediately.
I prefer to make my own charitable contribution.

AuntHike · 16/01/2024 09:38

Charity bullshit indeed
Where are these magical charities that are awaiting wrapped birthday presents suitable for 9 year old boys. Which parent is going to load, unload, store, reload, deliver during working hours these gifts?
Unless Father Christmas has a drop off point locally, the charity angle is bullshit, you might as well say you'll be donating all gifts directly to Council Landfill.

Mrgrinch · 16/01/2024 09:34

To be honest the whole thing has disaster written all over it. You expect 4 young boys to be able to share out the gifts amongst them with no arguments? What about the one super amazing gift that they all love, who gets that? Who gets left with the regifted crap that's not even age appropriate?

It's highly likely the parents have suggested donating them because of your stupid one gift rule to begin with.

forrestgreen · 16/01/2024 09:34

"That's a lovely idea in principle, however on my birthday I still enjoy the thrill of presents. I've asked ds and he'd prefer presents and to be able to donate some to charity afterwards. Let me know what your dc would like to do and I'll draft a text to parents'

Merryhobnobs · 16/01/2024 09:28

If the party is only a few days away then many people will already have planned and bought a present, so it is really unfair to change this now. It should have been stated on the invite.

TempName247 · 16/01/2024 09:28

say ‘having thought more about the 1 present idea and gifting to charity, I’m thinking it’s not going to work - we’ve left it too late as people will have spent time picking out gifts for a specific child and we would risk annoying/offending them’

Berthatydfil · 16/01/2024 09:27

Has anyone asked the children?
(sorry I have skimmed so might have missed this)
I can only imagine how disappointed they will be to see their presents being bundled up and taken from them. They are entitled to a choice in this.

What if family member turn up are you going to confiscate their gifts too?
You have to give the attendees the heads up too.
If the mothers want to generate charity donations let them do it in their birthdays.
I suggest this is being driven by the parent of the charity friend who would like to be seen as virtuous at little cost to herself.

If you have to go along with it I would say no presents please but we will be requesting a donation to X charity. Promise your child a trip out/sleepover etc with a few special friends to make up for ut.
And NO MORE shared parties ever again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread