Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else see the BBC news report *MNHQ amending title to warn of graphic content*

134 replies

Ownedbykitties · 15/01/2024 22:35

BBC reported a trial of men who had cut off body parts of other men.

One gave consent to having his penis and testicles cut off. Another his nipple and yet another his leg.

AIBU to wonder who is standing next to you in a queue in the post office?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
APickUpFullOfPinkCarnations · 15/01/2024 23:49

I've seen this case come up in news reports over the last few weeks and just can't begin to comprehend it. Just... why?!

dapsnotplimsolls · 15/01/2024 23:48

Any cases of women doing this sort of thing to each other? No? Funny that ...

Chickenkeev · 15/01/2024 23:46

LemonLymanDotCom · 15/01/2024 23:42

“AIBU to wonder who is standing next to you in a queue in the post office?”
@Ownedbykitties I don’t live far away from where these men (no pun intended) operated, so I might literally have been stood next to one of them in a queue at the post office.

Ugh.

Love your username 😍

YabbaDabbaDooooo · 15/01/2024 23:42

All these people skipping from thread to thread demanding warnings here, there and everywhere...

Do you manage to get through life without ever seeing a news report, or hearing one on the radio?

Just how do you get through life, and what are you doing on the internet since it's not exactly something that's full of warnings for everything?

LemonLymanDotCom · 15/01/2024 23:42

“AIBU to wonder who is standing next to you in a queue in the post office?”
@Ownedbykitties I don’t live far away from where these men (no pun intended) operated, so I might literally have been stood next to one of them in a queue at the post office.

Ugh.

ConsuelaHammock · 15/01/2024 23:41

Nothing much surprises me anymore. The human race are deplorable!

blackpanth · 15/01/2024 23:40

Grim

Taxbreaks · 15/01/2024 23:39

There was a case twenty or thirty years ago where a group of men made their own videos. One of the videos appeared to show a man nailing another person's penis to a piece of wood.
In reality, the penis was already pierced and the nail did no damage but the person doing the nailing got charged as though he had. I think that's the origin o the 'consent is no excuse' view.

Flickersy · 15/01/2024 23:38

bombardelli · 15/01/2024 23:32

Yes it is a defence in those cases.

The campaign group, “We Can’t Consent to This”, with support from MPs from across the political spectrum, have lobbied the Government on what had been reported to be an increasingly successful use of a claim made by defendants that their victim had died or sustained serious injuries as a result of ‘rough sex gone wrong’. We Can’t Consent to This stated that 60 UK women have been killed by men who made such a claim which colloquially became known as the ‘rough sex defence’. In the last five years, the campaigners also claimed that this defence was successful in seven of the 17 killings of a woman which reached trial, with the man being found either not guilty or, much more frequently, being convicted of manslaughter.

That's what the campaigners say. It's not actually what's happening in court, which is being misrepresented a tad.

It is a basic principle of law in this country that one cannot consent to injury etc. That is cast iron and has not changed.

In the "rough sex gone wrong" cases, the defence is not that the victim consented, but that the accused didn't intend to cause them death or serious harm (because it was part of BDSM).

There is a trend of people trying to claim this defence, that is undeniable. However, the defence is being misrepresented as "the victim asked for it so it's OK" when that is not what is actually happening. Or indeed, legal.

This case is a very similar situation. Doesn't matter how much the victim consented. Doesn't matter if the accused claim in court they have signed affidavits and videos of them agreeing to it. If the accused intended to cause them death or serious enough injury that death was a realistic possibility, then they would be guilty of murder.

porridgeisbae · 15/01/2024 23:38

How does a person become a person who wants parts cut off

Maybe he thinks he's trans/ non-binary.

Bracksonsboss · 15/01/2024 23:38

CellarCaller · 15/01/2024 23:35

This thread should have a warning @mumsnet

Why?

SighedAndSmiled · 15/01/2024 23:36

CellarCaller · 15/01/2024 23:35

This thread should have a warning @mumsnet

All of this is reported in daily newspapers. It’s nothing other than that.
The topic is horrific, but there is nothing terrifying in these posts

CellarCaller · 15/01/2024 23:35

This thread should have a warning @mumsnet

Livelovebehappy · 15/01/2024 23:33

I’ve come to the conclusion that a lot of men are very sick and most of it is all about sex. On the news today about the perverted men in Rochdale still getting their kicks grooming and raping children. It’s a sick world we live in…

bombardelli · 15/01/2024 23:32

Flickersy · 15/01/2024 23:26

Consent isn't a defence in those cases either, although it's become a common catchphrase. In law it's about the intent of the accused, not the consent of the victim.

Yes it is a defence in those cases.

The campaign group, “We Can’t Consent to This”, with support from MPs from across the political spectrum, have lobbied the Government on what had been reported to be an increasingly successful use of a claim made by defendants that their victim had died or sustained serious injuries as a result of ‘rough sex gone wrong’. We Can’t Consent to This stated that 60 UK women have been killed by men who made such a claim which colloquially became known as the ‘rough sex defence’. In the last five years, the campaigners also claimed that this defence was successful in seven of the 17 killings of a woman which reached trial, with the man being found either not guilty or, much more frequently, being convicted of manslaughter.

Flickersy · 15/01/2024 23:26

AnImaginaryCat · 15/01/2024 23:24

Whose? The man who parts were removed? It's a pretty one off thrill if so.

How does a person become a person who wants parts cut off

Usually, mental illness.

Flickersy · 15/01/2024 23:26

bombardelli · 15/01/2024 22:59

'Consent is not a defence'

Kate Mulholland, the Crown Prosecution Service specialist prosecutor for London, said: "Consent is not a defence to the illegal surgical procedures the men willingly took part in to remove their ringleader's penis, leg and nipple, in non-sterile and on occasion life-threatening circumstances."

Shame judges don’t make ‘consent is not a defence’ their mantra when men kill women and claim it was ‘rough sex’.

Consent isn't a defence in those cases either, although it's become a common catchphrase. In law it's about the intent of the accused, not the consent of the victim.

AnImaginaryCat · 15/01/2024 23:24

TempleOfBloom · 15/01/2024 23:04

One of them was a nurse.

Working in a hospital.

They were doing this for sexual kicks.

Whose? The man who parts were removed? It's a pretty one off thrill if so.

How does a person become a person who wants parts cut off

HNY2024 · 15/01/2024 23:23

The ringleader has a Facebook profile still up. He seemed pretty normal a few years back!

Blueeyedmale · 15/01/2024 23:22

Nothing surprises me in this world just when you see someone and you think wow that's messed up,you see something on the news that's really worse.serious question will some men literally go to any lengths for a bit of gratification?

Northernsouloldies · 15/01/2024 23:20

brummyadele91 · 15/01/2024 23:18

You are joking 😬

The guy that did the cutting kept the bits in jars horrific.

Messyhair321 · 15/01/2024 23:18

Eh?

brummyadele91 · 15/01/2024 23:18

TempleOfBloom · 15/01/2024 23:04

One of them was a nurse.

Working in a hospital.

They were doing this for sexual kicks.

You are joking 😬

Northernsouloldies · 15/01/2024 23:17

It was a pay to view and I think you could watch in real time, why the fuck anyone would want to this or watch is beyond me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread