Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else see the BBC news report *MNHQ amending title to warn of graphic content*

134 replies

Ownedbykitties · 15/01/2024 22:35

BBC reported a trial of men who had cut off body parts of other men.

One gave consent to having his penis and testicles cut off. Another his nipple and yet another his leg.

AIBU to wonder who is standing next to you in a queue in the post office?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
8
chaosmaker · 17/01/2024 14:43

I saw a video by someone that worked in a clinic in the states that could no longer work there as it went straight to surgery without counselling with the 'affirmation' model. She said the last straw was after a young woman had a double mastectomy (she called it top surgery but we know what it really is) and came back a few months later saying she wanted them back. The child has no understanding of long term consequences.
I used to read Bizarre and there was a whole community of people that had a fetish of limb removal and one cover had a woman with a wooden leg on who'd had a voluntary leg amputation. This was about the 90's

Ownedbykitties · 16/01/2024 17:01

I can absolutely relate to this

OP posts:
porridgeisbae · 16/01/2024 16:47

APickUpFullOfPinkCarnations · 16/01/2024 15:56

Fucking hell. This is chilling.

Yes. Surgeons etc here are doing it obliquely too. The aim is usually to relieve the person of their 'gender dysphoria,' so if the person's dysphoria is relieved to the person's satisfaction by just having their boobs removed then the system is happy to leave them like that. I suppose doctors aren't in control of whether someone goes further or not, and anyway if the person supposedly no longer has an issue, the doctors' job is done. Sometimes it's where the person planned to stop all along. I think it's unnerving though. Which probably shows I'm not a right on millenial/zoomer.

People are also choosing to have their nipples removed sometimes, because they're 'dysphoric' about them, when both sexes have nipples.

Which type of life changing decisions? And what age were the children making the decisions?

Primarily if children go on puberty blockers maybe. Those aren't without side/long term effects. Also once a child's on that, they are effectively on course for later body-changing hormones. That path rarely changes. So they're effectively making the decision to transition when they're quite young.

Krabappel · 16/01/2024 16:04

bombardelli · 15/01/2024 22:59

'Consent is not a defence'

Kate Mulholland, the Crown Prosecution Service specialist prosecutor for London, said: "Consent is not a defence to the illegal surgical procedures the men willingly took part in to remove their ringleader's penis, leg and nipple, in non-sterile and on occasion life-threatening circumstances."

Shame judges don’t make ‘consent is not a defence’ their mantra when men kill women and claim it was ‘rough sex’.

It's illegal to strangle someone to the point of death even if they agreed to be 'choked' in sex.

Rangelife · 16/01/2024 16:02

Decisions around education providers (going to a single sex school when the pupil is the opposite sex and nobody questioning what happens when the Year 7 female child inevitably gets a period and how the hell are they meant to change their sanitary products in a school full of boys toilets), medications to stop the onset of puberty and periods being given to 12 year olds, keeping the actual sex of a child private and not telling the parents of the teenage girls who are friends with their child that the said child actually still has a penis and allowing sleepovers without this information being disclosed), allowing Year 7 males to happily get their first girlfriend and these boys having no clue that their first girlfriend still has a penis, ignoring offers of neurodiversity assessment as 'we know our child has gender dysphoria so it isn't needed', asking children as young as 6 to re gender their classmate and repeatedly telling them off if they accidentally revert to the old gender. Don't even get me started on the bonkers uniform decisions and how there was always, always a mother in the background of this with (in my non psychiatry trained opinion) with significant mental health issues.

I would bring up my concerns about the long term impacts of this on not only the individual children, but on the often whole year groups of children who were interacting with these children who had made a massive life changing decision and were expected to go along with it all and deal with it. I (stupidly) though that it might be a good idea to suggest the adults to lead on this and make the big decisions instead of leaving it in the hands of kids who are going through the hormonal and cognitive firestorm that is childhood and puberty. I was firmly told to be quiet. So I left that line of work as I thought I have either got this wrong and I am letting my unconscious bias come to the table or I am going to be part of a system that enables something that will be seen as a scandal in a couple of decades.

APickUpFullOfPinkCarnations · 16/01/2024 15:56

NotBadConsidering · 16/01/2024 10:21

In addition to the above information about this guy being a trans activist, there is more about castration.

The World Professional Association of Transgender Health, (WPATH) is a lobby group for trans health. It produces “standards of care” every few years or so which is often held up as the standard for treatment.

In December 2022 it released its Standards of Care version 8, which is commonly referred to by children’s gender clinics as being the “go to” document to guide the treatment of children. This new version has a chapter titled “Eunuch Identity” in which being a eunuch, someone who wishes to be castrated, is deemed a valid gender identity and describes how to best treat this group with “affirmative medical care”: castration, in other words.

This chapter was written in conjunction with a man who hosts a private forum on a website called the Eunuch Archives. In the private forum men discuss their child sex abuse fantasies 😡.

So whenever you read that “gender affirming care” for children is “evidenced based” (it isn’t) and people quote WPATH as their reliable source, remember that WPATH is an organisation that colluded with child sex abuse fetishists to produce their so called “Standards of Care” with people like the man described in the OP’s news article.

https://reduxx.info/top-trans-medical-association-collaborated-with-castration-child-abuse-fetishists/

Fucking hell. This is chilling.

Cailin66 · 16/01/2024 15:29

Rangelife · 16/01/2024 10:04

@TempleOfBloom I am really glad that there is a cohort of Mumsnetters tracking this stuff. These escalatory situations is exactly why I got a worried gut feeling when I was working in Local Authority children and family services. When I raised the concerns about how these life changing decisions by children on my case load, facilitated by adults were potentially going to have awful impacts upstream in the life course and making these already vulnerable children (they all had underlying vulnerabilities, mostly to do with parenting capacity, it was a pattern) my colleagues thought I wasn't 'being kind or supportive'.

Which type of life changing decisions? And what age were the children making the decisions?

Winnading · 16/01/2024 14:01

Moonmelodies · 16/01/2024 10:01

Lots of people pee without a penis.

Vanishingly few men lose their penis in accidents/in wars or explosions. Some obviously lose their penis on purpose. But generally they need reconstruction or catheter.

Unless you mean lots of women who do not have a penis to lose therefore yes, lots of "people" pee without a penis?

porridgeisbae · 16/01/2024 13:13

I know it's not 'woke,' but I don't agree with surgeries to make someone neither a man or a woman. Some people 'identify' that way and so for instance they just want their breasts removed or whatever. I know doctors aren't 100% in control of how patients use the service, and if someone has some surgery rather than all, it's probably better in some ways, but still, it feels like making monsters.

ArabellaScott · 16/01/2024 12:15

Leg removal. This Scottish doctor carried it out in an NHS hospital (patients were private).

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/625680.stm

BBC News | SCOTLAND | Surgeon defends amputations

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/625680.stm

ArabellaScott · 16/01/2024 12:12

NettleTea · 16/01/2024 12:09

OK, young men. And maybe not young boys here. But young boys elsewhere, where their governements have not pushed back on transitioning and medical pathways for children. Plenty of 'young girls' getting their breasts lopped off in the USA.
Certainly before the age that their brain is fully developed though. And certainly not without thorough investigations as to WHY they are presenting to the clinics, due to psychological assessment and therapy being classed as conversion therapy.
Lots of young men with children's genitals too, due to the hormones. Even ONE guy having the castration / paedophile crossover is one to many - but it seems plenty approved his activism, and plenty paid to watch.

Scottish girls, under 18 years old, are sent to England for mastectomies.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/scottish-doctors-approved-breast-removal-for-51-trans-teenagers-qvkmz8r2c

Scottish doctors approved breast removal for 51 trans teenagers

More than 50 transgender boys under the age of 18 have been approved for double mastectomies in Scotland, it has been revealed.The figures, released under freed

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/scottish-doctors-approved-breast-removal-for-51-trans-teenagers-qvkmz8r2c

NettleTea · 16/01/2024 12:09

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 10:17

No one is performing "affirmation surgery" on young boys, stop scaremongering.

OK, young men. And maybe not young boys here. But young boys elsewhere, where their governements have not pushed back on transitioning and medical pathways for children. Plenty of 'young girls' getting their breasts lopped off in the USA.
Certainly before the age that their brain is fully developed though. And certainly not without thorough investigations as to WHY they are presenting to the clinics, due to psychological assessment and therapy being classed as conversion therapy.
Lots of young men with children's genitals too, due to the hormones. Even ONE guy having the castration / paedophile crossover is one to many - but it seems plenty approved his activism, and plenty paid to watch.

NettleTea · 16/01/2024 12:03

Floofydawg · 16/01/2024 10:15

So now, according to the WHO this is not a mental health disorder, it is just all part of lifes rich tapestry, and if you don't accept that you are a big smelly bigot.

Fucking hell. What do we have to accept next?

pretty much anything that pervy men want us to, it would seem

givemushypeasachance · 16/01/2024 11:53

I have paid several hundreds of pounds to a woman to painfully inject ink into my leg and leave a permanent "scar", in effect. And I posted about it online and got compliments!

Up to a point I wonder if part of the issue is with the more extreme modifications is it's okay if you pay a licenced medical professional to do it, and it's not if you get some rando doing it. Doctors have to follow professional standards, and shouldn't carry out "unnecessary" invasive medical procedures. But how do you explain breast augmentation for someone who wants to go up a few cup sizes or get more modelling work? Or a 5'6'' bloke paying to have his legs broken and be stretched out to 5'9''? That's not a medical short stature, that's just wanting to be a bit taller.

What if I just want to have someone cut my little finger off. It's not a big deal. If someone's willing to do it, in safe sanitary conditions, why not.

porridgeisbae · 16/01/2024 11:50

Why is it socially acceptable to pay ££££ for someone to re-shape your face, to break and re-set bones to stretch out your limbs and become taller, to put silicone implants in your breasts. But it's not acceptable to pay someone to cut your nipple off?

Anything that's about sex (or at least, non-vanilla sex) is still a bit taboo when it comes to extreme kinks like cutting parts of the body for immediate sexual gratification etc. And so it should be.

I mean, people have labiaplasties or attempts at penile enlargement etc but that doesn't seem the same. They are a means to an end rather than for an immediate sexual thrill.

Flickersy · 16/01/2024 11:46

NaughtyBoyGeorgeMichaelJacksonBrown · 16/01/2024 11:36

Very interesting points. I feel it's very clear in my mind where the line is, but of course that is just my opinion and hard to get a consensus. I'd hate to be the one wording the legislation and guidance on this.

It is an interesting topic, or at least I think it is.

To reduce it to it's simplest, the law constantly has to balance the rights of people to do what they want with the rights of said people and others not to be harmed unduly by those actions. To take two extremes at either end of the spectrum of this: you can play music loudly on a bus and it'll annoy others and legally that's ok, but you can't kill people you don't like, for hopefully obvious reasons. You can legally agree to go skydiving but you can't consent to being killed.

As you say, I wouldn't want to be the one having to draft the legislation.

MeinKraft · 16/01/2024 11:45

'The guy that did the cutting kept the bits in jars horrific.'

You'd need a massive jar for the leg

itsmylife7 · 16/01/2024 11:43

The pay to view made £200,000 . What does that tell you !

NaughtyBoyGeorgeMichaelJacksonBrown · 16/01/2024 11:36

givemushypeasachance · 16/01/2024 11:31

It's where you draw a line on what is acceptable to do to yourself as "body modification", and that varies between different societies and cultural norms.

What about circumcision. Considered perfectly normal and routine in some cultures, and abusive in others.

What about tattoos - it's a painful process of permanently altering your body. Without consent, tattooing is GBH or wounding, as the skin is pierced and you bleed.

What about more "extreme" modifications such as tongue-splitting, or implanting objects under your skin to look like horns or ridges.

What about cosmetic surgery. Why is it socially acceptable to pay ££££ for someone to re-shape your face, to break and re-set bones to stretch out your limbs and become taller, to put silicone implants in your breasts. But it's not acceptable to pay someone to cut your nipple off?

Very interesting points. I feel it's very clear in my mind where the line is, but of course that is just my opinion and hard to get a consensus. I'd hate to be the one wording the legislation and guidance on this.

givemushypeasachance · 16/01/2024 11:31

It's where you draw a line on what is acceptable to do to yourself as "body modification", and that varies between different societies and cultural norms.

What about circumcision. Considered perfectly normal and routine in some cultures, and abusive in others.

What about tattoos - it's a painful process of permanently altering your body. Without consent, tattooing is GBH or wounding, as the skin is pierced and you bleed.

What about more "extreme" modifications such as tongue-splitting, or implanting objects under your skin to look like horns or ridges.

What about cosmetic surgery. Why is it socially acceptable to pay ££££ for someone to re-shape your face, to break and re-set bones to stretch out your limbs and become taller, to put silicone implants in your breasts. But it's not acceptable to pay someone to cut your nipple off?

porridgeisbae · 16/01/2024 11:29

Both men and women pay a LOT to see real time streamed 'snuff' movies.

@JanglingJack These are mostly a myth/moral panic. Don't think they've ever found one. There's not a market for it.

Bracksonsboss · 16/01/2024 11:27

This has become a man bashing thread based on the outlandish behaviour of a couple of outliers. Weird…..

lesdeluges · 16/01/2024 11:10

Sadly nothing in the behaviour of men surprises me at all.

There is an undercurrent of violence in all of them, yes that's what I said, the vast majority however are able to contain it and live very good lives.

Think of road rage, street violence, sexual violence, wars, you name it. Most of it is male orientated.

TempleOfBloom · 16/01/2024 11:08

PrawnLiberationFront · 16/01/2024 10:17

No one is performing "affirmation surgery" on young boys, stop scaremongering.

Susie Green, founder of Mermaids, took her child to Thailand for such surgery for their 16th birthday.

OK, not legal to do now, and 15 / 16 isn’t a ‘young child’ but laws are made against things that actually happen.

Swipe left for the next trending thread