Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you handle living in a rougher, tougher society?

193 replies

fuckingcoldshowers · 15/01/2024 20:30

Thinking about this as it's freezing where I am, and thanking my lucky stars we can stick the heating on.

I would be 100% shit in a tougher world. Anything from the grinding hardship of WW2 to dystopias like The Walking Dead. I'd be so shit Grin I mean, actually I wouldn't survive in the first place but if the universe was having a laugh and I did make it past the initial event, I'd be rubbish. I mean, obviously it would be very scary and devastating, but the sheer MISERY of it all would sap my motivation to survive, I reckon.

I can't think straight when I'm really hungry. Also, hanger would lead to some sort of stupid spat with the wrong person.

I'm also terrible without decent sleep. After enough sleep deprivation I'd give up.

Finally - even if fed and sleeping I cannot deal with no nice, clean shower or bathing facilities. I'd be SO CRANKY feeling grubby and dishevelled all the time, traipsing around trying to survive.

Could you adapt well and cope cheerfully without these basics after the apocalypse?

OP posts:
stayathomer · 15/01/2024 21:37

We were poor poor years ago, couldn’t afford heating for weeks bar electric heater which we’d move to the kids’ room (aunt and mum used to help with the electricity bill but we’d try not to use too much), hungry a bit (not all the time) so kids had food, no luxuries. We managed and tried to keep happy, and I don’t think the kids noticed, but the phrase ‘weighs on your heart’ comes to mind. It was difficult to be properly happy but we still had good times

TotHappy · 15/01/2024 21:36

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 15/01/2024 20:53

Part of me thinks I'd quite like to not have to confirm to societal norms anymore. No need to make polite small talk, or go to work, or pay bills.

Just hole up somewhere remote and try to avoid other humans.

In reality I'd probably be dead within the first week - probably from tripping over or losing my glasses.

Or I'd find myself somehow responsible for admin crap in a larger group where I'd have to be pleasant to everyone whilst finding the end of the world boring as fuck.

In my fantasies I'm very capable and strong, and discover my frequently suppressed irritation with people in general becomes a superpower where I take no shit and headbutt people in the face if they try to threaten me.

Yes, this this! I bet I'd find myself taking the fucking minutes of the apocalypse

Skinnydoublecrochet · 15/01/2024 21:35

I watched a documentary years ago called ‘Tudor Farm’ with Ruth Goodman. And she washed etc like a Tudor would and said linen against the skin soaked up the sweat.
In the Walking dead, I would find a supermarket and eat and eat crisps and sweets.
I’m far too lazy for farm work so would have starved in medieval world.

fuckingcoldshowers · 15/01/2024 21:33

coldcallerbaiter · 15/01/2024 21:23

I wonder if men would capture women and let them live, but kill the rival men….

I know I would fight tooth and nail to protect my dc and I would do anything I had to.

It scares me if I think how much more vulnerable women and children are in any breakdown of law and order. So much male aggression let loose.

OP posts:
TeachesOfPeaches · 15/01/2024 21:33

I wonder how people survived the 1970s without central heating. That's traumatising enough

TheKeatingFive · 15/01/2024 21:32

I think you'd surprise yourself if it came to it

ISeeTheLight · 15/01/2024 21:30

Another one here who'd serious struggle without her glasses.

That said I am quite fat, but also tall. And I have a ridiculously slow metabolism thanks to an underactive thyroid. At least I wouldn't starve to death immediately.

I do also have a herniated disc in my spine (waiting for operation) so I'd struggle with anything physical, or at least I'd be in pain.

All in all I might survive - I have some basic survival skills - but I'd be miserable.

deveronvalley · 15/01/2024 21:29

I grew up in an unusual rural home that was not really fit for human habitation (by late 20th century standards), I also had to do physical work to contribute to the running of this place. As an adult I run my own business and do lots of solo hillwalking. I don’t have survivalist skills but I think I’d be ok, I wouldn’t shrivel up and die at the first sign of discomfort. My husband is tough as old boots and would be fine.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 15/01/2024 21:28

coldcallerbaiter · 15/01/2024 21:25

So the reason you will all give for getting laser eye surgery is zombie apocalypse - I guess it’s as good a reason as any…

I have thought if apocalypse/alien invasion/zombies happen I will very much regret not getting lazer eye surgery. I can barley see without my glasses. Having said that I know someone who got lazer eye surgery at 26 and her short-sightedness is coming back 20 years later so it's not necessarily a permanent solution.

m00ngirl · 15/01/2024 21:28

ChaToilLeam · 15/01/2024 20:56

I’d probably survive for a while. Short, fat and robust - I come from a long line of peasants. Wouldn’t be much fun though.

LOL. Tinder profile? 😉

5128gap · 15/01/2024 21:28

I doubt I'd be bothered to survive the event itself. All the running and hiding and jumping over ravines carrying an orphan, while a random man I had frissons of chemistry with barked orders at me and made me steer his truck while he shot people...I'd have no interest in it tbh.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 15/01/2024 21:28

Nobody enjoys surviving in these situations. Just look at some of the social media posts coming out of Gaza right now. It’s hell. But what’s the alternative? People hope for a better future, if not for themselves then for their children or other younger family members, and so they push through. Nobody living in a tougher situation is born more hardy or less wanting of basics and comforts, it’s just down to luck that they don’t have it. If you were in a situation like the ones billions of people living in the developing world and war zones are in currently you would survive as best you can because you’d have to, just like the many people living through awful times in Gaza and Ukraine and Yemen and Somalia and Afghanistan and Malawi etc.

Nobody likes being hungry or sleep deprived but you’re no better or different to the many real, ordinary people for whom that is life and just because you are fortunate enough to never have been in that situation doesn’t mean you would react any differently to them. To think that’s the case almost makes out that the kinds of people who find themselves in war zones or famine etc are somehow extraordinary or unusual or superhuman when the reality is they are just ordinary people and they are suffering just as much as you would be, don’t imagine it’s any easier for them right now than it would be for you, it others people and suggests that it’s okay for some groups of people to be in that situation because they’re more suited to it. No human is suited to the conditions in many areas of the world right now, you’re no more precious than any of the people in those awful situations and I think it’s distasteful to suggest that somehow you are.

itadak · 15/01/2024 21:27

It's surprising what you can do if you had to. I'd probably be ok but the thing that would be most difficult would be the violence. If resources are scarce people fight. As society breaks down it's a question of take what you can - aggression and fighting would be distressing and anyway I'm bad at that.

There'd be some relief in the rule of survival though. Anyone who said "I can't be on fishing duty because my anxiety is through the roof" or "You can't make me weed the vegetable patch because it's bullying" Would soon find out that if you didn't do it you wouldn't eat.

I hope we don't lose all the comfort, civilization and prosperity we have now though. I like it!

SirWalterElliot · 15/01/2024 21:27

I don't think I have the will to survive either. DH would though, so I guess he'd probably drag me along.

m00ngirl · 15/01/2024 21:26

I'd be fine 👀

AGreenKaren · 15/01/2024 21:26

You're lucky I can barely afford to use heating at all since COL it's 12c in my place and Im using heated throws.

You being unreasonable as there are people in the UK living like this today who cannot afford things.

We should think ourselves we are lucky we are not in a war place like ukraine and we at least safe

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 15/01/2024 21:25

Id say i have a lot of resilience, I've survived a lot. But I'm sick and my body would literally seize up and stop working. My apocalypse plan is to get my DC to their Dad/my Ex then bunker down somewhere and wait to die, hopefully not by being eaten alive. .
My EX.is an arsehole but he loves his kids and I'm sure he'd do whatever necessary to keep them alive and unlike me who can barley walk and can't carry any weight at all he's physically able and can fight.

coldcallerbaiter · 15/01/2024 21:25

So the reason you will all give for getting laser eye surgery is zombie apocalypse - I guess it’s as good a reason as any…

Seagrassbasket · 15/01/2024 21:23

I’ve thought about this probably more than is healthy or reasonable, and I actually think I’d be alright. Unless, as others have said, I lost my specs. Then I’d be fooked.

Might be time to book that laser surgery!

coldcallerbaiter · 15/01/2024 21:23

I wonder if men would capture women and let them live, but kill the rival men….

I know I would fight tooth and nail to protect my dc and I would do anything I had to.

KohlaParasaurus · 15/01/2024 21:23

I have some skills that mean a feral community might find it more useful to keep me alive and fed than to eat me.

mdinbc · 15/01/2024 21:18

We have very cold temperatures currently in Canada, especially out west. I often thought of those prairie pioneer mums and how they ever managed when a baby woke up with poop all up their backs in the middle of the night.

Thank goodness for modern conveniences.

mathanxiety · 15/01/2024 21:18

I'd do great with the make do and mend stuff.

Otoh, I'd be the last one to know about someone doing a black market trade in anything, so there would be more than the average amount of making do for me. Also the mending.

CaramelMac · 15/01/2024 21:17

I grew up in the North East in the 1980’s, so I think I’d probably be fine 🤣

Don’t forget that WW2 actually improved a lot of people’s health and access to quality food.

Errols · 15/01/2024 21:14

I'd be fine. I'm from sturdy peasant stock and would happily revert. I'd fight anyone for a mangel wurzel.

Swipe left for the next trending thread