Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you handle living in a rougher, tougher society?

193 replies

fuckingcoldshowers · 15/01/2024 20:30

Thinking about this as it's freezing where I am, and thanking my lucky stars we can stick the heating on.

I would be 100% shit in a tougher world. Anything from the grinding hardship of WW2 to dystopias like The Walking Dead. I'd be so shit Grin I mean, actually I wouldn't survive in the first place but if the universe was having a laugh and I did make it past the initial event, I'd be rubbish. I mean, obviously it would be very scary and devastating, but the sheer MISERY of it all would sap my motivation to survive, I reckon.

I can't think straight when I'm really hungry. Also, hanger would lead to some sort of stupid spat with the wrong person.

I'm also terrible without decent sleep. After enough sleep deprivation I'd give up.

Finally - even if fed and sleeping I cannot deal with no nice, clean shower or bathing facilities. I'd be SO CRANKY feeling grubby and dishevelled all the time, traipsing around trying to survive.

Could you adapt well and cope cheerfully without these basics after the apocalypse?

OP posts:
HamBone · 16/01/2024 00:31

Ah, I’d forgotten about my poor eyesight. If my glasses got broken, I’d probably walk into a tree, knock myself out and get eaten by a pack of wolves. 😂

Aroundthewaygirl · 16/01/2024 00:22

The thought of no air conditioning in the summer and a daily shower would kill me dead. I hate the heat, I’m irritable when I feel dirty and I would suck at hunting for my food. I prob wouldn’t make it 😂

saltinesandcoffeecups · 16/01/2024 00:17

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 16/01/2024 00:11

Those of us who live in countries which don't have central heating seem to manage!

I agree with pps who have said you really don't know how you would cope until you had to, and most would just get on with it. We have earthquakes here, and are about due for "the big one". If it happens in my lifetime I will just have to deal with it - there's no running away!

I do however wonder how the ultra hygiene freaks, wash everything after an hour's wear, can't possibly eat anything unhealthy etc. type MNers would cope 🤔😂I suspect they would soon fall to pieces.

It’s amazing how things become less important when the level of effort ramps up

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 16/01/2024 00:11

TeachesOfPeaches · 15/01/2024 21:33

I wonder how people survived the 1970s without central heating. That's traumatising enough

Those of us who live in countries which don't have central heating seem to manage!

I agree with pps who have said you really don't know how you would cope until you had to, and most would just get on with it. We have earthquakes here, and are about due for "the big one". If it happens in my lifetime I will just have to deal with it - there's no running away!

I do however wonder how the ultra hygiene freaks, wash everything after an hour's wear, can't possibly eat anything unhealthy etc. type MNers would cope 🤔😂I suspect they would soon fall to pieces.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 16/01/2024 00:07

I think I’d be ok realistically.

Have some outdoors skills, in reasonable shape, have guns and practiced in shooting (+ a decent ammo supply to start with), have decent weather gear, am not fussed too much with cold, currently no maintenance meds, some ‘living off the land’ skills, a lot of time playing the ‘what of’ game, a lot of hours sunk in my guilty pleasure of Post Apocalyptic fiction

glasses/contacts, not in the greatest of shape at the moment, getting older, somewhat sentimental, starting to experience niggling 45+ health issues, a fair amount of cushy life syndrome

All in all I think I’d be ok for a bit. Do I envision myself in a rocking chair watching the world end… no but I feel like I’d give it a decent go.

Doormatnomore · 15/01/2024 23:54

Adrenaline would see me through the initial event. A couple of “oh shit” situations where people just start doing what I say and I can stomp faster than most people can run, but once the adrenaline wears off I’m back to off the charts anxiety. I had to hide from the Evri man because I thought he thought I scowled at him when I was getting my last parcel - no way I’m seeing the dawn of a new civilisation.

newstart24 · 15/01/2024 23:39

I live in a house with single glazing throughout and we currently have the heating off as it’s night time. We had a coal fire downstairs that kept us very warm in the lounge during the evening. I’m now in bed (heating off) and am fine as I have a thick duvet and blanket. The cold isn’t that bad. Or maybe I’m just used to it.

squashedalmondcroissant · 15/01/2024 23:34

Hmm interesting question! My friend and I have pondered this before...

I think I'd survive for a time (luck being on my side obviously) - I'm quite strong and have plenty of survival skills and knowledge. I forage wild food and have lived in the past on very little, food and comforts wise. I like to think I have a pretty strong will to live that would see me at least attempt to survive most situations but who can ever really know until you are in them!

I do hate being cold with a passion. And I'd absolutely die immediately if survival involved running away from anything (fat & slow 😂)

Ultimately though I think it would be the other people that would do me in. I'm not ruthless enough and would probably take another survivor in to my hobbit hole to help them out only for them to kill me in my sleep and take my stuff 😞

MissMelanieH · 15/01/2024 23:20

Nope, I'd be the one ditched by the roadside gasping "go on without me" in the first chapter.
But I'm 51, I've had a good innings so far so I'm comfortable with that.

MintyCedric · 15/01/2024 23:09

I’m good in a crisis, creative and able to amuse myself without tech. I can make fires and cook decent meals from random odds and sods and have a fair bit of first aid training and decent DIY skills.

I’m also a middle aged fat bird so…yay!

Just as long as I have my glasses, thyroxine,
ADs and HRT, plus coffee and wine I’ll be just grand 😂

wildlifeWalker · 15/01/2024 22:49

Togomalone · 15/01/2024 21:05

@uhtredsonofuhtred1 people in the Middle Ages in Northern Europe washed regularly- most people washed everyday. It’s apparently a myth that people were smelly and unclean. They had soap, water and kept their clothing as clean as they could as cleanliness was next to godliness. There’s an episode about this on the Betwixt the sheets podcast.

However they probably did smell of smoke. I spent time with an indigenous community and the smell of smoke was pervasive due to open fires- but I’m sure they were used to it.

Better teeth too due to no/little sugar!

NotSienna · 15/01/2024 22:46

I’ve just finished reading The drift by CJ Tudor- I really recommend it! It’s fiction but almost believable as it’s about a virus / apocalypse… I can’t say more without ruining the plot, but I found it fascinating and horrifying in equal measures. Some of you would really enjoy reading this, I think!!

Tumbleweed101 · 15/01/2024 22:44

I think there is a reason most movies based around such scenarios show the majority of the population dead. Most people couldn’t handle such circumstances whether it’s health reasons - physical or mental. Age. Commitments to others. Lack of reasources or knowledge etc.

I could probably survive some scenarios - for example I have some bush craft type survival knowledge but I would manage in a situation where others were being aggressive and I needed to have physical fitness to defend myself. I’m also alone so no back up people to help.

Nevermind31 · 15/01/2024 22:43

I cannot see without my contact lenses and get a migraine if I am stressed, have low blood sugar, have high blood sugar, a dehydrated, I have poor first aid skills, cannot see blood without fainting. I wouldn’t last two minutes.
having said that… I bet most people in Ukraine and Gaza are also not built for this…

SisterHyster · 15/01/2024 22:42

I think I’d be mostly okay.

Im generally pretty healthy - I think I’ve had antibiotics once in the last decade.

Im not the fittest but I am pretty good at problem solving and thinking outside the box. I’m generally pretty good in a crisis and working out a plan.

As a student I had £20/week to life off (this was in the 2010s so not when £20 was reasonable) and from that I managed to buy all my food and a bottle of wine, so I’m used to making do with very little.

I really, really don’t like the cold. I think the cold might get me tbh.

therealcookiemonster · 15/01/2024 22:39

I live in Birmingham, so already surviving in a rougher, tougher world. the walking dead as nothing on the city centre of a Saturday night.

BitOutOfPractice · 15/01/2024 22:35

Me? Survive? With these knees? Not a chance.

fuckingcoldshowers · 15/01/2024 22:34

Why do you think you are any more likely not to survive than anybody else? What makes you so special that you’re any more guaranteed a death than any other person? Whether you live or die would be a roll of the dice, just as it is for the majority of ordinary people

@MolkosTeenageAngst Because I have type 1 diabetes. So in a lot of situations there will be no insulin after my prescription runs out and I die in a few days. In a world war situation the supply chain will most likely be affected.

So yes, I'm guaranteed a death. I did say I'd be most likely to die - which you refused to accept at face value - but I was purposefully vague in my OP because this was intended as a light hearted thread and didn't want it to become a serious discussion about the grimness of societal breakdown and the collapse of medical infrastructure 🙄

Anyway. It struck me as kinda funny that even if I did find a big stash of diabetes supplies so I could technically live, I'd be a whiny bitch anyway due to the lack of creature comforts.

It's just dark humour. It's not that deep.

OP posts:
Icannoteven · 15/01/2024 22:31

MrsCarson · 15/01/2024 22:19

I'd be lost without glasses too.
But booking Lazer just incase of the apocalypse made me laugh. Can you imagine the small talk, So Seagrassbasket, what made you want Lazer? Oh just in case of the Zombie apocalypse, I'd like to stand a chance at surviving.

😂

SisterHyster · 15/01/2024 22:30

theduchessofspork · 15/01/2024 20:37

Decently well when younger but far too fat and unfit and CBA now

which I guess is why everyone was dead by 50 a few hundred years ago (if they were lucky)

Interestingly this is actually not true. The average life expectancy was low; but it was just skewed because of high infant and child mortality. If you made it through childhood; you had a pretty good chance of living a relatively long life.

Itsnotallaboutyoulikeyouthink · 15/01/2024 22:29

Topically there are a lot of
people that are experiencing this right now. The survival instinct would kick in, you think you can’t do it because you’ve never been exposed to
anything like it but your body and mentally would switch pretty quickly.

Icannoteven · 15/01/2024 22:29

Yes, as long as there were still books and I didn’t get any more dental infections. The lack of antibiotics would be my main concern, I think.

I fantasise about living through the breakdown of society a lot and I think it would suit me. There is so much about modern life that I hate. Work for instance. The routine of it. How it steals our time and energy. The pointlessness of most jobs and how distant the goals and objectives of our working lives are from our primal needs and motivations. I would trade in the daily comforts we get from maintaining such a rigid and lifeless existence. I know I would be happier and more satisfied with a life where I had to hunt, gather or grow my own food. I like the accomplishment of completing small tasks and learning new things - learning how to build something, or grow something. Things that are tangible and real. I think people would be more interesting in such times too - I suspect there would be a lot less boring small talk required (‘what are you doing on the weekend’, ‘how was your Christmas’).

All in all, I’m not sure what we have built as a civilisation has been worth it. I mean, I appreciate the medical advances we have made (particularly contraception) but other than that I am not sure there is much from modern life I would like to keep.

Nellieinthebarn · 15/01/2024 22:26

Well without my heart medication I would probably not last a week anyway, but without my HRT I'd be so full of rage within a couple of days I'd be picking fights I had no hope of winning and would be probably be murdered before the heart attack got me.

Clarebelle878 · 15/01/2024 22:20

Not a chance I’d make it. I think I’d take some tablets and have a hot bath, and slip away if I saw the writing on the wall (assuming the zombies/ virus/ insert apocalyptic event didn’t carry me off first!)

Ponderingwindow · 15/01/2024 22:19

i got really nervous during the supply chain shortages during covid. I had trouble getting things like toothpaste and shampoo that are safe to use. I worried about getting allergen safe version of meds that I need to stay alive. sometimes my supplies of those dwindled far too low.

without that supply chain, I can’t survive.