Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you handle living in a rougher, tougher society?

193 replies

fuckingcoldshowers · 15/01/2024 20:30

Thinking about this as it's freezing where I am, and thanking my lucky stars we can stick the heating on.

I would be 100% shit in a tougher world. Anything from the grinding hardship of WW2 to dystopias like The Walking Dead. I'd be so shit Grin I mean, actually I wouldn't survive in the first place but if the universe was having a laugh and I did make it past the initial event, I'd be rubbish. I mean, obviously it would be very scary and devastating, but the sheer MISERY of it all would sap my motivation to survive, I reckon.

I can't think straight when I'm really hungry. Also, hanger would lead to some sort of stupid spat with the wrong person.

I'm also terrible without decent sleep. After enough sleep deprivation I'd give up.

Finally - even if fed and sleeping I cannot deal with no nice, clean shower or bathing facilities. I'd be SO CRANKY feeling grubby and dishevelled all the time, traipsing around trying to survive.

Could you adapt well and cope cheerfully without these basics after the apocalypse?

OP posts:
Fooshufflewickjbannanapants · 16/01/2024 07:34

Ginmonkeyagain · 15/01/2024 21:10

@Togomalone A Time Travellers Guide to Medieval England is good on this.

People did indeed wash. They would often use pieces of wet linen to rub their bodies clean.

Edited

I love that series! Also listen to Dr Eleanor Janega podcasts and books. She's brilliant.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 16/01/2024 07:27

saltinesandcoffeecups · 16/01/2024 00:17

It’s amazing how things become less important when the level of effort ramps up

I still have serious doubts about how some people would cope with no electricity or water going by some of the comments I read on MN. Most people would rise to the challenge, but there are also some who won't.

rockwater · 16/01/2024 07:06

I would hate it, absolutely despise it as I love my comforts like being warm, nice food and high quality toiletries and cosmetics.

But, that said, I am quite determined and have a strong survival instinct so I feel like I'd throw myself into it like Xena and become this amazon warrior to protect my family. I'd certainly complain about it though. A lot. My peri menopausal rage without my HRT would assist me greatly with fighting off attackers 😂

EarringsandLipstick · 16/01/2024 07:00

Christmasbird · 16/01/2024 01:09

I'm glad someone asked this because I was thinking about it recently. I could do most of the things listed.
It's so cold in my house I can see my breath in the air, I am more isolated, geographicaly and socially than anyone else i have encountered and wouldn't crumble without companionship or a 'D'H. I'm fairly happy to eat the same boring meal of vegetables every day and have almost nothing in a material sense so wouldn't miss anything in particular.

What's strange is that I make an effort to look put together so no one would ever know my true circumstances.
Also none of the above is by choice, I just genuinely have next to nothing. When I was with my ex partner I had an easy life and didn't have to work btw, the tables have just turned massively in my life

That sounds very tough 💐

I hope things improve for you.

EarringsandLipstick · 16/01/2024 06:58

HighQueenOfTheFarRealm · 16/01/2024 06:55

The human spirit is strong and I'm sure many of you will be surprised at what you'd do when your basic instinct to survive kicks in. It'll be shit and depressing but most people will fight to survive.

This.

You would adapt. You would have to. As evidenced by the utter suffering endured by so many currently.

It's not comparable to war or apocalypse obviously, but remember Covid? If any of us were told in advance of the restrictions we'd face then, we'd have said we couldn't do it. Many of us said that during Covid too, and did.

HighQueenOfTheFarRealm · 16/01/2024 06:55

The human spirit is strong and I'm sure many of you will be surprised at what you'd do when your basic instinct to survive kicks in. It'll be shit and depressing but most people will fight to survive.

jeaux90 · 16/01/2024 06:48

Yeah I'd be grand, I'm a good shot and resilient and haul up somewhere remote.

I think I'd miss a pint the most Grin

RunningAwayToJoinTheCircus · 16/01/2024 06:46

I would be ok initially - we never put the heating on, I can cook over an open fire, I own a Cobb oven and a Kelly Kettle, we have lots of blankets, jumpers, hot water bottles etc and other camping gear.
I am pretty knowledgeable about first aid, natural remedies, water purification, infection prevention and suchlike.
We have enough food to keep us going for maybe a month (one meal a day and weird combos, but would have calories) and know how to "grey man" and stealth cook to stop other people knowing we had food when they didn't.
I think I could also be utterly ruthless, if it came down to it, I would kill someone trying to take what my family needed to survive.
Having said all that, long term, I would be fucked! I'm old and ill and wouldn't be much use other than as an information source. I would die quite soon without access to my medication anyway.
I would pass on as much as I could to help my loved ones though.
During a "collapse" I would just concentrate on keeping my family safe, and I think we'd be ok. The aftermath and " rebuilding " wouldn't be my problem.

Minesril · 16/01/2024 06:41

AyeRightYeAre · 15/01/2024 22:05

I'm a scout leader. I've camped in the snow. Gone days without washing. Cooked over open fires. I've got skills and knowledge.

I wouldn't enjoy living like that but could cope.

I always say that in the apocalypse i want Bear Grylls and Caroline Girvan on my side, but my son's cubs leader will be a start Grin

Sometimes I wonder how my sons would survive in a 'Gone' situation where all the grownups disappear. Or 'the Enemy' where they all turn into zombies! In both scenarios the older kids are really good at looking after the younger ones but who knows.

sawnotseen · 16/01/2024 05:54

I think I would.im tiny - 5ft and 7stone but fierce! As Shakespeare said....
I'd want a gun though - a super sonic gun like Linda Hamilton in The Terminator

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/01/2024 04:53

coxesorangepippin · 16/01/2024 02:14

After two days without washing my hair looks like I've dunked it in chip fat.

Imagine after six months of not washing, living in some godforsaken cave somewhere or something

Ugh God no

Mine too. But a few weeks in East Africa with no water to waste and I just got used to it. Weirdly the combination of being a bit yuk and the red dust, I thought, "THAT'S why the local people do their hair the way they do, with the red paste". Looks good, keeps the sun off, no need to wash. And also weirdly, we didn't smell as bad as you'd think.

It is interesting when you get a case of the fuck-its. You just adapt.

Also the plot of every Hallmark film Grin

JanglingJack · 16/01/2024 02:31

My will to survive would come from trying to protect my children and grandchild.

Actually that's pretty much all I'm surviving for now.

If I didn't have them.... Oh blimey, and my cats 🙄 ...

Nah. I wouldn't be living through this current shit let alone some sort of apocalypse.
I'd happily run a bubble bath with some razor blades.

coxesorangepippin · 16/01/2024 02:14

After two days without washing my hair looks like I've dunked it in chip fat.

Imagine after six months of not washing, living in some godforsaken cave somewhere or something

Ugh God no

RobertaFirmino · 16/01/2024 02:06

Well you'd have to cope, wouldn't you? The only alternative would be to top yourself. Your best bet would be to make friends with Ruth Goodman and Bear Grylls. Ruth knows how people lived before electricity and Bear knows what to eat, how to get clean water etc.

Christmasbird · 16/01/2024 01:09

I'm glad someone asked this because I was thinking about it recently. I could do most of the things listed.
It's so cold in my house I can see my breath in the air, I am more isolated, geographicaly and socially than anyone else i have encountered and wouldn't crumble without companionship or a 'D'H. I'm fairly happy to eat the same boring meal of vegetables every day and have almost nothing in a material sense so wouldn't miss anything in particular.

What's strange is that I make an effort to look put together so no one would ever know my true circumstances.
Also none of the above is by choice, I just genuinely have next to nothing. When I was with my ex partner I had an easy life and didn't have to work btw, the tables have just turned massively in my life

aurynne · 16/01/2024 01:09

Our brains are made to adapt. If you're thrown into a survival-mode or a very uncomfortable situation, for the first 2-3 days you will feel despair, like you cannot survive for much longer. Then you will start adapting. Every little thing you've managed to do to survive will give you so much fulfillment that the feeling of it, and the adrenaline, will keep you going. And then in about a week, you will notice things do not feel so bad anymore, even if you're still very far from having adapted to it.

I've been there. It is an amazing process. I am glad I'm back to "my normal", but it has given me a very valuable insight. Sometimes I miss the feeling of achievement, the "yes, this is what I was meant to do in life" when I found food, water, or got myself out of being lost in the wilderness.

Panastasia · 16/01/2024 01:00

Years ago, there was a show in the US on PBS, which reenacted the colonial period, approx 1600s settlers in New England.

Oprah and Gayle did a short stint on the show, where everyone lived a typical day from that period. The PBS show ran for a few months, but I think Oprah and Gayle were there a few days.

I remember Oprah feeling shocked, and she said something like “now I know why it took so long for white women to get the vote. They had no time to organize, and were too exhausted”. She mentioned she’d never thought of there point of view before.

It looked grim. I’d never survive, I’ve got autoimmune diseases and I’d be in agony without my meds.

www.oprah.com/relationships/oprah-goes-colonial/all

RantyAnty · 16/01/2024 00:58

Possibly, but I'd move myself to a somewhat warmer place but not sweltering. I can fish, make a fire.

LuluBlakey1 · 16/01/2024 00:54

I grew up in a working class family in Gateshead so I think I'd cope if I had to. I sort of see myself in a Michonne role if it was zombies- I'm terrified of them but would rather deal with them than hide away from them. Unless they are the type that run fast- I'd be stuffed then.

AllIsWellish · 16/01/2024 00:51

HamBone · 16/01/2024 00:31

Ah, I’d forgotten about my poor eyesight. If my glasses got broken, I’d probably walk into a tree, knock myself out and get eaten by a pack of wolves. 😂

Edited

It would more likely to be a pack of rampaging XL bullies than wolves round here, maybe the bullies would kill all the zombies

I'm a bit obsessed with a zombie apocalypse but if they are like the wwz ones or 28 days later I'd probably be dead pretty fast

ConsuelaHammock · 16/01/2024 00:50

I’d be ok. I’d hate it but I’d survive.
I grew up in an old cold farmhouse with a coal fired stove which we used for cooking, heating and hot water. We did have an electric cooker too but the stove was the heart of the house. I can grow stuff and work with animals, drive a tractor, shoot a gun.
We have solar panels and a well( so many people have filled theirs in but we kept ours. We used it a few years ago when we had a big freeze and all water pipes were frozen. We have open fires and a back boiler so would always have hot water. We have a wind turbine too on the farm so could possibly power an electric car. Husband and son are both good with guns. Husband and both kids are good at archery too. Both my daughter and I can ride well. Husband can too but not since childhood. He’s a fast leaner. Son would be a disaster and probably fall off and break bones. He can drive a tractor, digger and manitou though so he’s not completely useless. Both husband and son can use a chainsaw.
I can shoot but I’m not very accurate. We have chickens and a good vegetable garden and fruit trees. And a farm? I would worry about people trying to take what we have more than any zombies tbh. The living are more dangerous than any zombie. Except the ones in maze runner. Those feckers can run!!
Not thought about it much at all 😂

saltinesandcoffeecups · 16/01/2024 00:45

Ok… so on the glasses thing . One of the places on my list to loot is the eyeglass shop first for contacts then for glasses. Bonus points if it’s a grind on site place.

I figure I’ll learn enough to be the the glasses ‘hookup’ and that will be my schtick in the PA hellscape. Seriously… the optometrist is going to be the last place targeted by the ne’er-do-wells

AffIt · 16/01/2024 00:45

Technically, yes: I'm quite hardy, fairly robust and an uncannily accurate aim.

Would I enjoy it? Probably not: I like central heating and easy access to a good Chinese takeaway.

Giggorata · 16/01/2024 00:42

I have good survival and primitive living skills and I would be OK if it weren't for the lack of essential meds. Bugger.

Nonimai · 16/01/2024 00:41

I watched Threads recently - that was sobering.
and the Julia Roberts Film ˋLeave the world behind´ has made me quite fearful - the idea that you don’t realise there has been an attack or even what the attack is. It was the son losing his teeth,presumably through radiation poisoning, even though there hadn’t been a bomb. That really got to me.
Sorry to be frightening but I often feel we were really lucky that covid wasn’t significantly nastier. Had it been like Ebola or haemorrhagic fever life would look quite different now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread