Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please tell me this can't be true!

215 replies

JaffaCake70 · 15/01/2024 16:12

My Mum visited this afternoon, we were talking about wills and things that the departed have left in trust for their loved ones. During the course of the conversation Mum told me the following:

When my Grandmother passed away a few years ago at the age of 82, my Mum's older Sister wanted her wedding ring (for sentimental reasons).

When my Auntie went to collect the ring the undertakers gave it to her and told her that it had been stuck on my Nanna's finger so tight that they had cut her finger off in order to retrieve the ring.

I feel sick. Please please please tell me that this can't possibly be true? Has anyone else had experience of anything like this? I just can't believe it's true.. but if it's not true why would my Auntie, who isn't one for making things up, say it is?

OP posts:
MaggieNextDoor · 15/01/2024 17:03

I'm a nurse and have removed rings from deceased patients on lots of occasions. Soft paraffin oil works really well but in the case of enlarged knuckles due to arthritic changes, we would gain consent to cut the ring off - not cut the finger off. I'm pretty sure your Aunt misunderstood what the undertaker said. I've never heard of a finger being severed to remove a ring.

peakygold · 15/01/2024 17:02

To be fair, if that is what happened, she didn't need that finger anymore anyway.

Gowlett · 15/01/2024 17:01

Surely the ring was cut?
My Granny never once removed her wedding ring.
It was wedged onto her finger.
I think it’s better to be buried with it.

ALonelyRoad · 15/01/2024 16:59

I'm also in the 'not true' camp. Not that I'm suggesting your mum or aunt would lie, but as PP have suggested upthread, it sounds more likely that there's been a miscommunication about what exactly was cut off.

BingBunnyBlues · 15/01/2024 16:57

I would hate to think that this was true. There was justified outrage in the late 80s when the victims of a public disaster (the sinking of the Marchioness boat) had their hands cut off 'to save time' for the authorities conducting fingerprint identification. And then after the organ retention scandal in the late 90s/early 00s, surely those with a responsibility for the dead are far more aware of sensibilities around unnecessary actions on bodies?

LutonBeds · 15/01/2024 16:57

Used to work for an undertaker. They used the cotton method to remove rings.

easylikeasundaymorn · 15/01/2024 16:55

How long ago was it?
Just thinking pre 2000s it might have happened - that was when the inquest into the 1989 Marchioness disaster happened where there was huge public outcry about the decision to cut off the hands of the victims and send them for identification because they didn't have sufficient facilities to manage the full bodies.

To be honest having been to postmortems this wouldn't bother me as one finger is nothing compared to what they do to bodies there. Same with people who havent opted out of organ donation etc. Although I can absolutely understand its not nice to think about when it's your family member particularly for something without medical necessity like a ring.

TripleDaisySummer · 15/01/2024 16:54

stillplentyofjunkinthetrunk · 15/01/2024 16:48

As a jeweller rings can get stuck on fingers however having been in the situation of helping someone get a stuck ring off a finger many many times I think that there is a misunderstanding.

You wouldn't cut the finger OFF, but you might make a small incision that allowed some blood fluid to drain out causing the finger to shrink at which point it would be easy to remove the ring.

This sound most plausible - otherwise cutting the ring and then getting it fixed afterwards.

It sounds like someone mishearing and got upset or had a poor explanation and didn't ask for proper details and filled in blanks in most lurid way.

Supersimkin2 · 15/01/2024 16:53

My rings are lovely. I’d miles rather the girls demanded my cold dead hands were chopped off so they could wear them in good nick.

stillplentyofjunkinthetrunk · 15/01/2024 16:49

megletthesecond · 15/01/2024 16:48

They cut the ring. Not the finger off.

I don't think that'd be necessary but agree they'd do that before cutting the finger off.

megletthesecond · 15/01/2024 16:48

They cut the ring. Not the finger off.

stillplentyofjunkinthetrunk · 15/01/2024 16:48

cannaecookrisotto · 15/01/2024 16:16

We need a funeral director to pop along because I'm invested in the answer now as well. I can't believe a funeral director would cut a finger off for a ring so I'm going to sit in camp "untrue" until we learn otherwise.

As a jeweller rings can get stuck on fingers however having been in the situation of helping someone get a stuck ring off a finger many many times I think that there is a misunderstanding.

You wouldn't cut the finger OFF, but you might make a small incision that allowed some blood fluid to drain out causing the finger to shrink at which point it would be easy to remove the ring.

ButterBastardBeans · 15/01/2024 16:45

Could you call the undertakers and ask them?

spearthatbroc · 15/01/2024 16:40

is your aunt still alive? why not ask her?

JaffaCake70 · 15/01/2024 16:38

My Mum and Auntie get on very well, have never fallen out or anything like that.

Apparently my Auntie was very upset when she was told this by the funeral directors. It is my belief that the ring had not been cut and had no sign of damage.

I just can't believe it's true, I'm wondering now if my Mum has remembered the story wrong and they actually broke Nanna's knuckle. This is much more likely than them cutting her finger off isn't it?

OP posts:
NeptunaOfTheMermaidBattleSquadron · 15/01/2024 16:38

Graveyard humour that didn't land?
(not great if so but better than losing a finger)

LumpyPumpkin · 15/01/2024 16:37

Possibly being daft, but I don't understand how cutting a finger off would make removing the ring any easier at all. Even if it did, I still doubt it's true.

Xiaoxiong · 15/01/2024 16:28

Agree they cut the ring if they have to, not the finger!! My grandmother's rings were cut off and then repaired, my auntie wears them now.

spearthatbroc · 15/01/2024 16:26

maybe the aunt wanted to keep the ring for herself so told your mother a fib! Did your mum not want to have it?

ManateeFair · 15/01/2024 16:25

I suspect what your auntie actually said was 'The ring was so tight on her finger, they had to cut it off', meaning THE RING was cut, not the finger, and your mum just misunderstood.

There are loads of tricks for removing a stuck ring from a dead finger (most of which work on a living finger as well) that undertakers use. And on the rare occasion that they don't work, they simply cut through the ring and the deceased's loved one has to have it it repaired.

Apart from anything, cutting off someone's finger wouldn't actually help with removing the ring. The ring would just be stuck on a severed finger, instead of an attached one. Also, if they had cut it off, they certainly wouldn't have told your auntie like that. They'd have either said nothing about it or (if the deceased was in an open coffin) they would explain in a sensitive manner that they had placed one hand of the body over the other to conceal some damage to a finger. They wouldn't say 'Oh yeah, we cut her finger off, by the way.'

LadyPoison · 15/01/2024 16:25

I suspect it's got a bit garbled. I have cut plenty of rings off and never had to remove the finger yet!

I can well imagine the ring having to be cut off though. It's very common for knuckles to enlarge with arthritis and trap a wedding ring.

Heather37231 · 15/01/2024 16:25

hellojelly · 15/01/2024 16:21

I'd be very surprised too. A misunderstanding maybe? Something like "we couldn't get the ring off her finger so we had to cut it off" where they mean cutting the ring not the actual finger..

This is a list certainly what happened. Probably your Mum misunderstanding your Aunt rather than your Aunt misunderstanding the undertaker as your Aunt would have seen the cut ring.

Thehamsterthatcametotea · 15/01/2024 16:24

They would cut the ring, not the finger.

topgirlalways · 15/01/2024 16:24

They forgot to take my mums rings off when she died. We asked at the hospital next day, but her fingers were too swollen. We asked how and it was suggested a broken finger would likely to happen. But couldn’t do this until death certificate issued.

she then went to undertakers. Was told likely broken knuckle if we wanted ring attached. Said do what ever was easier as she was being cremated.

forgot to take them off and we got left we a pile of melted metal and exploded stones. Think would have preferred a chopped off finger than 50 year old rings melted.

Ifailed · 15/01/2024 16:23

I had a ring returned to me from the Undertakers. The ring had been cut.