Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please tell me this can't be true!

215 replies

JaffaCake70 · 15/01/2024 16:12

My Mum visited this afternoon, we were talking about wills and things that the departed have left in trust for their loved ones. During the course of the conversation Mum told me the following:

When my Grandmother passed away a few years ago at the age of 82, my Mum's older Sister wanted her wedding ring (for sentimental reasons).

When my Auntie went to collect the ring the undertakers gave it to her and told her that it had been stuck on my Nanna's finger so tight that they had cut her finger off in order to retrieve the ring.

I feel sick. Please please please tell me that this can't possibly be true? Has anyone else had experience of anything like this? I just can't believe it's true.. but if it's not true why would my Auntie, who isn't one for making things up, say it is?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ProtectMotherNature · 17/01/2024 19:02

Post mortems are not in my experience the awful scenario that one would imagine; the one I attended was in every aspect very respectful to the deceased gentleman.

spearthatbroc · 17/01/2024 15:31

topgirlalways · 17/01/2024 14:42

That is exactly what happened. No stones as they melted. The metal was sifted through and collected. Given to us in a bag. I think the undertaker remembered during cremation.

I did take it to be shaped into a new ring. It had to be cleaned, melted and polished.

please don’t doubt a true but horrible story.

whilst i certainly believe you! I do think that doubting or at least being skeptical of some stories you read in the internet from anonymous posters is no bad thing

ShennyInfinity · 17/01/2024 15:04

My husband used to be a Funeral Director and in all the time he worked there fingers were never cut off, they used to put string around the finger and pull the ring off, I'm so sorry you were told this, that's outrageous and I hope he was joking, bad joke all the same.

ShennyInfinity · 17/01/2024 14:46

My husband used to be a Funeral Director so I've just asked the question, I'll get back to you.

topgirlalways · 17/01/2024 14:42

That is exactly what happened. No stones as they melted. The metal was sifted through and collected. Given to us in a bag. I think the undertaker remembered during cremation.

I did take it to be shaped into a new ring. It had to be cleaned, melted and polished.

please don’t doubt a true but horrible story.

spearthatbroc · 17/01/2024 14:38

Poodles23 · 17/01/2024 10:20

It sounds to me like the funeral director was joking, surely?!

He is in the wrong profession if he was

more likely he never said it and it’s been misinterpreted

RosaMoline · 17/01/2024 13:16

T1Dmama · 17/01/2024 13:01

Unfortunately not all undertakers are respectful.
we lived next door to a gentleman who worked for our local undertaker, when it swapped companies and new management came in he left and went to work for a different one… he never disclosed details but did say he never felt they were very respectful with the bodies… Needless to say that when my grandad died and the hospital said he’d be moved to our nearest funeral directors we were very quick to call them and say NO! We had his body moved to where our neighbour worked and he was very kind and came along and spoke to us for ages.
So I would say that if your aunt wanted the ring and had expressed this wish then if cutting the finger off was the only way of retrieving the ring then yes they might have just done it… quite why they told the aunt though is another matter..
Please remember this was just her body, when we die we often require an autopsy and we are cut open, ribs cracked apart, skull possibly opened to study brain, organs removed and studied etc… so in the grand scheme of things a finger removal is nothing…. And we are only going to either be cremated or decay anyway.

Cutting the ring damages it and maybe they’ve had complaints before, cutting it is only ok if it’s just going to be melted down and made into something else.

Again, a digit would NOT be cut off under ANY circumstances!
I don’t entirely disagree with the part of your post about some funeral directors being disrespectful…(in the minority it has the be said..very strict codes of practice in my industry)
However, the hospital where your grandad passed away - it didn’t have a mortuary?if that’s the case, you let them know your preferred FD and arrangements are made to collect the deceased.
You do have instances where a person passed away in the community unexpectedly and sometimes they will be transferred to a FD who has the local coroner contract temporarily before being picked up?

T1Dmama · 17/01/2024 13:01

Unfortunately not all undertakers are respectful.
we lived next door to a gentleman who worked for our local undertaker, when it swapped companies and new management came in he left and went to work for a different one… he never disclosed details but did say he never felt they were very respectful with the bodies… Needless to say that when my grandad died and the hospital said he’d be moved to our nearest funeral directors we were very quick to call them and say NO! We had his body moved to where our neighbour worked and he was very kind and came along and spoke to us for ages.
So I would say that if your aunt wanted the ring and had expressed this wish then if cutting the finger off was the only way of retrieving the ring then yes they might have just done it… quite why they told the aunt though is another matter..
Please remember this was just her body, when we die we often require an autopsy and we are cut open, ribs cracked apart, skull possibly opened to study brain, organs removed and studied etc… so in the grand scheme of things a finger removal is nothing…. And we are only going to either be cremated or decay anyway.

Cutting the ring damages it and maybe they’ve had complaints before, cutting it is only ok if it’s just going to be melted down and made into something else.

ProtectMotherNature · 17/01/2024 11:32

Information directly from a funeral director, "Firstly try good old washing up liquid. Or then try wrapping some cotton around the finger, then slide the ring over the cotton and unravel it from the other side and the cotton pushes it off."

Poodles23 · 17/01/2024 10:20

It sounds to me like the funeral director was joking, surely?!

TheWorldisGoingMad · 17/01/2024 10:07

Perhaps this was said, to stop you from wanting the ring. It's cruel, but it is possible.

bustybetty · 17/01/2024 07:49

I wouldn't have thought a ring would be stuck because a dead person is kept cold. If you want to get a ring off you make sure your hand is cold. I think this is just made up by the aunt!

vodkacat · 16/01/2024 23:40

My dad passed this weekend, the ring was stuck. The FD managed to get it off but he said if he couldn’t the ring would be cut off not the finger at the funeral home.

Isinglass20 · 16/01/2024 23:05

It was cut off ie the ring not the finger

ProtectMotherNature · 16/01/2024 22:52

I've sent a message to my daughter-in-law asking how they get them off (she is a funeral director) I'll add a message when she replies.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 16/01/2024 22:31

The thing that I find somewhat concerning is that your Aunt would tell your Mum this. Even more that your Mum would then tell you.

Missingpop · 16/01/2024 20:51

I think your aunt has a very active imagination; there are rules as to what acts can be performed on a deceased person’s body & lopping a finger off would almost certainly fall into the category of desiccation of human remains; so I very much doubt there’s an ounce of truth in what she’s said, they might have cut the ring off for her & then given her the cut ring.

Reigateforever · 16/01/2024 20:06

My mother had her ring cut off her swollen finger by a jeweler, using a ring cutter, while she was alive. I don’t see why the same cannot be done after the person has died.
Ring cut off finger not finger cut off.

Bellaboo01 · 16/01/2024 19:44

topgirlalways · 15/01/2024 16:24

They forgot to take my mums rings off when she died. We asked at the hospital next day, but her fingers were too swollen. We asked how and it was suggested a broken finger would likely to happen. But couldn’t do this until death certificate issued.

she then went to undertakers. Was told likely broken knuckle if we wanted ring attached. Said do what ever was easier as she was being cremated.

forgot to take them off and we got left we a pile of melted metal and exploded stones. Think would have preferred a chopped off finger than 50 year old rings melted.

Are you suggesting that after cremation you were given melted gold and burst tones (whatever that means)!? This isn't even slightly possible after a cremation.

Sillyname63 · 16/01/2024 19:34

The undertaker may have said , I had the cut it off meaning the ring not her finger, think there have been cross wires somewhere along the line.

Timeforanotheraliasnow · 16/01/2024 19:20

I doubt this is true. When my nana died they cut the ring to get it off her finger, maybe there’s a misunderstanding here?

Sennelier1 · 16/01/2024 18:33

Undertakers have this special cutter that they can slide únder a ring to cut through it. I've never neard they cut of a finger to retrieve a ring.

NeptuneOrion · 16/01/2024 18:03

Cutting the ring would be much easier. It must be a weird family legend.

Wildyone · 16/01/2024 17:59

Rest assured. Having dealt with many dead bodies and difficult to remove rings, this is highly unlikely. They use a string threaded thro the ring and pull it off that way. If that wasn't possible the ring would be cut..not the finger! These days anyway. As it was the 60s and given the size change they probably did. Its no biggie. Its 60 years ago

Swipe left for the next trending thread