Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why doesn’t the country support having children?

678 replies

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 15/01/2024 09:25

Just seen an article on The Guardian about the 15 free hours for childcare for under 2’s and how the whole system is a mess.

I’m just starting to lose hope that this country doesn’t support working families anymore?

AIBU and need to think more positively, or have we screwed up massively by not supporting families?

The Guardian article which I read.

UK government’s free childcare scheme in disarray, charities say

Thousands of concerned parents reportedly struggling to sign up for flagship offering that starts in April

https://www.theguardian.com/money/2024/jan/15/uk-governments-free-childcare-scheme-in-disarray-charities-say

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
LaurieStrode · 17/01/2024 11:00

Outthedoor24 · 17/01/2024 10:22

@LaurieStrode you took took took when you were a child too. It's what children do.

It shouldn't be seen as you are paying for other people's children it should be seen as you paying forward what other people paid for you.

And as someone without paying for your own children you should be able to seriously boost your own pension pot - children are expensive to keep and feed plus their activities

I'm old; my parents got nothing like what parents today take from the taxpayers.

Having children is an expensive lifestyle choice, and it's 100 percent a choice, so don't complain to me about the costs.

It costs the planet and other species a lot more.

LardyCakeAgain · 17/01/2024 10:53

What the planet is already struggling with, massively, is fresh, drinkable water and enough farmland for crops and meat/dairy production. Intensive farming on a massive scale is draining the land of nutrients and polluting water sources with the runoff. An ever-increasing world population is going to run out of resources sooner than you think - they've already had water riots in places like Bangalore in India, because their states were selling their drinking water to others that had run dry.

Babies in developed countries like ours take 3x their share of these resources compared to babies in developing countries. Personally I don't want to see our country become like Mumbai or Dhaka in Bangladesh - massively overpopulated, slum housing, and no healthy food or water for the poor.

Cetim · 17/01/2024 10:47

As a mother of twins, childcare has almost bankrupted me.

EasternStandard · 17/01/2024 10:47

MotherOfRatios · 17/01/2024 10:44

You're wrong, western states ARE struggling with low birth rates which is resulting in ageing populations.

https://time.com/5291439/west-population-problem-white-nationalists-policies/

https://www.niskanencenter.org/the-global-fertility-collapse/

The dc born today will be working in 20 ish years give or take a few.

What kind of workforce will that be like?

A lot will change in that amount of time

MotherOfRatios · 17/01/2024 10:44

ParanoidJo · 17/01/2024 10:18

Western states aren’t struggling with low birth rates, they’re struggling with supporting overpopulation - as is the planet. We have to take responsibility and not head into producing offspring mindlessly, we are taking more from the planet than we are giving back. Sounds dramatic, but it is really a problem.

You're wrong, western states ARE struggling with low birth rates which is resulting in ageing populations.

https://time.com/5291439/west-population-problem-white-nationalists-policies/

https://www.niskanencenter.org/the-global-fertility-collapse/

Can Better Policies Solve the West's Population Crisis?

The EU's average birth rate is well below what's needed to sustain a population

https://time.com/5291439/west-population-problem-white-nationalists-policies/

Drosera · 17/01/2024 10:35

LaurieStrode · 17/01/2024 10:04

@Stopthetankerimtryingtosleep

"more likely?"

That's just not true. Childfree people in my circle are actively and aggressively saving in order to pay for any necessary old-age care.

I think it's fair to say that most childfree people will find it easier to save. I'm on about £45k (fluctuates with overtime etc) and I seem to have way more disposable income than my friends with kids. My partner earns similarly and we share the rent/bills. Always have hundreds left over between us each month.

Outthedoor24 · 17/01/2024 10:22

@LaurieStrode you took took took when you were a child too. It's what children do.

It shouldn't be seen as you are paying for other people's children it should be seen as you paying forward what other people paid for you.

And as someone without paying for your own children you should be able to seriously boost your own pension pot - children are expensive to keep and feed plus their activities

ParanoidJo · 17/01/2024 10:18

MotherOfRatios · 15/01/2024 09:37

western states are struggling with low birth rates as someone in my mid 20s having affordable good quality housing and better wages would be a good place to start!

Western states aren’t struggling with low birth rates, they’re struggling with supporting overpopulation - as is the planet. We have to take responsibility and not head into producing offspring mindlessly, we are taking more from the planet than we are giving back. Sounds dramatic, but it is really a problem.

Stopthetankerimtryingtosleep · 17/01/2024 10:14

I wouldn't say your circle is representative of the whole population.

LaurieStrode · 17/01/2024 10:04

@Stopthetankerimtryingtosleep

"more likely?"

That's just not true. Childfree people in my circle are actively and aggressively saving in order to pay for any necessary old-age care.

WithACatLikeTread · 17/01/2024 10:04

LaurieStrode · 17/01/2024 10:02

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

And all the taxation to provide benefits to reproducers ISN'T discriminatory?

Those who don't take, take, take should enjoy nicer pensions than those who received financial benefits for years and years. It's only fair.

"Reproducers?" What a lovely term.

LaurieStrode · 17/01/2024 10:02

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

And all the taxation to provide benefits to reproducers ISN'T discriminatory?

Those who don't take, take, take should enjoy nicer pensions than those who received financial benefits for years and years. It's only fair.

Stopthetankerimtryingtosleep · 17/01/2024 09:55

LaurieStrode · 17/01/2024 09:32

I think childcare assistance should be docked from one's pension at the other end. Those who don't need it will get bigger pension payments. Or earlier pension eligibility.

Those who choose to have kids can plan on a more meagre income in old age. Let their own children augment it if need be.

That way childfree people aren't penalized. Everyone gets something.

But then on the other hand if you're childfree you're more likely to rely on the state for care in your later years, as you haven't created anyone to help care for you.

Outthedoor24 · 17/01/2024 09:54

@LaurieStrode
Aye that will work wonderfully.
What percentage of people end up stopping work and living off disability benefits long before they get their pension?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/01/2024 09:49

LaurieStrode · 17/01/2024 09:32

I think childcare assistance should be docked from one's pension at the other end. Those who don't need it will get bigger pension payments. Or earlier pension eligibility.

Those who choose to have kids can plan on a more meagre income in old age. Let their own children augment it if need be.

That way childfree people aren't penalized. Everyone gets something.

How nice. Not discriminatory in any way.

LaurieStrode · 17/01/2024 09:32

I think childcare assistance should be docked from one's pension at the other end. Those who don't need it will get bigger pension payments. Or earlier pension eligibility.

Those who choose to have kids can plan on a more meagre income in old age. Let their own children augment it if need be.

That way childfree people aren't penalized. Everyone gets something.

WithACatLikeTread · 17/01/2024 09:04

ChristmasTreeCookies · 17/01/2024 07:07

@ThinkingForward
That's a terrible idea.
According to that most people would be in their 30s-40s before having their first child..
Not to mention the increase risk of birth defects after 35.

Then they will moan about the extra IVF the NHS will need to fund.

ThinkingForward · 17/01/2024 08:50

@Drosera

Managed decline in population seems like the ideal here. But as much of the growth is in other regions with different cultures and no ambition to listen to our views I'm not sure that we have much vote on this. If we made better use of the ppl we had then the economic issue would be reduced.

Moving to a contribution driven access to the social security and health system, would reduce the attraction for unauthorised migration.

ThinkingForward · 17/01/2024 08:40

@bessytedsy

What are you thinking you need to pay ££k in NI to get childcare?

Years of employment based contributions would seem to be more likely acceptable to a larger proportion of the population.

You could always run a hybrid of the two. So many years and or so much contributed?

I would hope that the point of the policy is to improve the encouragement to work and the access to work rather than lock ppl out of employment totally.

Drosera · 17/01/2024 08:05

Probably an unpopular opinion lol but there's far too many humans on this planet already, and in this country alone. All the reasons people usually give for needing to maintain population growth are manmade issues that are inconsequential to the planet. Well, not inconsequential tbf as the consequences are pretty bad on the whole.

Needing more people to care for the overwhelming amount of people already existing is a manmade issue. Needing more workers to support the economy is also a manmade issue as the economy is a human creation. Current infrastructure (housing, roads, NHS, etc) is already struggling under the weight and arguably not fit for purpose.

I'm by no means one of those misanthropes who claims that humans are a scourge to the planet and would be happy to see mankind wiped from the earth for the benefit of the Tanzanian mole rat or whatever species is next on the extinction list, but it's quite clear that more humans all wanting more cars/houses/etc and all consuming and creating more waste is an exponentially growing problem. Each human creating several more humans, who create several more, etc etc.

There's no quick fix but I feel like society will increasingly feel the pinch generation on generation and we're going to be seeing ever increasing amounts of immigration due to worsening circumstances in less prosperous countries.

bessytedsy · 17/01/2024 07:46

May be this should be a bit like the state pension, support for childcare would depend on your employment NI record. Let's say you need 15years employment/first child and +10 yrs for each one after that between mother and father to access free childcare hrs? This would support those who have been in work but are either down on luck or don't have a great income but would still reinforce the need for personal responsibility.

Why base it of years instead of salary contributions?

ThinkingForward · 17/01/2024 07:18

@ChristmasTreeCookies did you read "between mother and father"

From my maths that lets say you are both the same age makes 18+7.5= 25.5 or uni 21+7.5=28.5 . Most ppl work and study so it would be between the two.

Average is around 28-29 these days. By sharing it between both parents then you don't discriminate against a couple with an age gap.

ChristmasTreeCookies · 17/01/2024 07:07

@ThinkingForward
That's a terrible idea.
According to that most people would be in their 30s-40s before having their first child..
Not to mention the increase risk of birth defects after 35.

ThinkingForward · 17/01/2024 04:11

@Daphnis156
@BlueGrey1

May be this should be a bit like the state pension, support for childcare would depend on your employment NI record. Let's say you need 15years employment/first child and +10 yrs for each one after that between mother and father to access free childcare hrs? This would support those who have been in work but are either down on luck or don't have a great income but would still reinforce the need for personal responsibility.

As 5 kids and never worked (as in a earlier post) shouldn't be a choice that everyone else has to pay for.

ThinkingForward · 17/01/2024 04:01

@Midwinter91
It really depends on which bit of USA. There are some bits where a house is cheaper than a normal family car. But the employment options are often grim.