Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why doesn’t the country support having children?

678 replies

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 15/01/2024 09:25

Just seen an article on The Guardian about the 15 free hours for childcare for under 2’s and how the whole system is a mess.

I’m just starting to lose hope that this country doesn’t support working families anymore?

AIBU and need to think more positively, or have we screwed up massively by not supporting families?

The Guardian article which I read.

UK government’s free childcare scheme in disarray, charities say

Thousands of concerned parents reportedly struggling to sign up for flagship offering that starts in April

https://www.theguardian.com/money/2024/jan/15/uk-governments-free-childcare-scheme-in-disarray-charities-say

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
ruby1957 · 15/01/2024 18:09

The stats for the elderly burden are 50 years in the future.,
**
The baby boomers are not the problem for the children being born now - your generations - Xs and Millenials - will be the costly generation. Be careful of blaming everyone else but yourselves.

TripleDaisySummer · 15/01/2024 18:07

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/01/2024 17:46

@TripleDaisySummer If falling birthrates are that widespread then it suggests that differences between how various govts are subsidising parents/families don’t actually matter that much. Or in other words that increasing subsidies in the UK wouldn’t have an overall effect.

A global trend towards having fewer or no children has to be on the basis of global trends - such as climate change and/or this being one of the first generations in human history where there is ready access to birth control and societies that recognise that it’s perfectly normal to choose not to have kids.

I really do think this is an area where research is fundamental - just throwing money at people so they’ll have kids may not mean they actually do.

Some countries have manged very slight increases in fertility rates with very generous polices- but most are either under replacement level of 2.1 or heading there very soon.

Most of the increase in population is people not dying and past fertility ie people born 20-30 -40 years ago hitting peak fertile ages.

Problem is at one stage it was thought once we hit 2.1 replacement fertility it would establish what seems to be happen is it gets lower and lower - as we get fewer in fertile years there's less and less penitential for babies. At some point I'd personally expect it to rise again and population go up but lack of evidence is making some people get excited it won't stablish or rise again.

Unfortunately there are other factors like young people leaving land for cities and better life and aging farming population left - sparking concerns in future about food production in world as that young population leaves and doesn't return.

Then aging population put ever increasing pressures on working age population and health care systems.

I think some people hear less people and think oh good less carbon impact - because they don't think though the ramifications .

Personally I think it's already perfectly normal not to have children but people who do have them and face sudden cost increases or circumstances change and end up with their children growing up in poverty which has long term social there I do think we should help the children to mitigate negative affects.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 15/01/2024 18:06

Mia45 · 15/01/2024 17:26

Child benefit was universal until 2013 and then some stupid super rich twats complained about how they were getting all this money they didn’t need, instead of modestly just giving it away to charity. (A bit like rich OAPS twats who complain about getting the heating allowance despite evidence showing that such a universal system was the most efficient way get the money to those in need. So now we have single parents that are ironically entitled to UC but not child benefit and lots of skilled people in the economy who are put off doing overtime or taking a promotion due to the 70% + marginal tax rate this has created for those on 50-60k

Thank you! MNetters always sound surprised when I say we applied for child benefit and we're eligible for £0 a month. It's not universally given out anymore. We aren't "well off" we are just over the threshold I believe.

Frankley · 15/01/2024 18:00

I'm older, when l had my children there was no 'maternity leave '. Mothers to be just collected the E45 form( think it was that) and had to leave their job. I was lucky, because there was no guarantee or thought that you could return to the job,but l was asked if l could return to my job due to staff shortage when my child was about one year old.
I found a child minder, later a private nursery. Same again with my second child. I really enjoyed both doing a part time job and being a mother
When l later told this to expectant Mothers going off on maternity leave they had difficulty believing it.
I believe maternity leave started in about 1975 in the UK. So some things have improved for working Mothers.

bessytedsy · 15/01/2024 17:50

@mia45 it doesn’t help that wages have stagnated & the band hasn’t changed. 55k in 2013 is approx 73k today & 55k today is like 30k in the yr 2000.

OutsideLookingOut · 15/01/2024 17:47

TripleDaisySummer · 15/01/2024 17:36

Japan and Italy further along with aging society curve and would be better indicators to watch on economy and wages than black death where people died rather than lived longer and became economic dependents in old age.

It seems to be more stagnation in economy and in Japan and prolonged stagnation in average wage as well. Older people tend to buy less but also have higher medical needs and costs - so there's a shift in jobs and where money get spent.

American is behind us in aging but many of their baby boomers haven't saved enough and some that did had those saving wiped out by medical bills - I read somewhere they are fastest growing age group of homeless people

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-06-20/homeless-crisis-housing-californians-older-seniors-study#:~:text=Kushel%20and%20her%20team%20found,in%20families%2C%20are%20over%2065.

People will always have children and find ways to do so - with compromises that may well force on them - but the replacement level round the world has dropped only exceptions are sub saharan Africa. It's a societal shift that brings challenges.

I thinkt he comparison with the black death would be post the boomers. The period in between will be awful for adults/older people now but do we want to perpetuate a broken system?

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/01/2024 17:46

@TripleDaisySummer If falling birthrates are that widespread then it suggests that differences between how various govts are subsidising parents/families don’t actually matter that much. Or in other words that increasing subsidies in the UK wouldn’t have an overall effect.

A global trend towards having fewer or no children has to be on the basis of global trends - such as climate change and/or this being one of the first generations in human history where there is ready access to birth control and societies that recognise that it’s perfectly normal to choose not to have kids.

I really do think this is an area where research is fundamental - just throwing money at people so they’ll have kids may not mean they actually do.

bessytedsy · 15/01/2024 17:46

Japan and Italy further along with aging society curve and would be better indicators to watch on economy and wages than black death where people died rather than lived longer and became economic dependents in old age.

Japan has actually tried to mitigate some of the impact & introduced policies years ago but doesn’t seem to be helping.

bessytedsy · 15/01/2024 17:40

It’s a major economical issue particularly since our productivity has been so shit since the crash.

“The demographic changes means government spending on the elderly is expected to quadruple from £225bn to £950bn by 2072, according to CPS estimates.
More crucially, this expenditure is set to double as a share of GDP to 21pc over the period.
That means more tax will be needed to pay for it, or other spending will have to fall – threatening a vicious cycle where a shrinking, younger workforce has to fork out ever-larger sums to support the elderly.
To offset the impact of the ageing population, the UK economy would need to grow by 2.9pc every year, for the next 50 years.
But on present trends, growth for the next five years will average an annual rate of just 1.4pc, according to the Office for Budget Responsibility”

And I bet growth will be lower!

Ageing population means taxes must rise even further, warns OBR

Britain’s debt pile on course to surpass 300pc of GDP within 50 years

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2023/07/13/ageing-population-taxes-rise-even-further-warns-obr/

TripleDaisySummer · 15/01/2024 17:36

Japan and Italy further along with aging society curve and would be better indicators to watch on economy and wages than black death where people died rather than lived longer and became economic dependents in old age.

It seems to be more stagnation in economy and in Japan and prolonged stagnation in average wage as well. Older people tend to buy less but also have higher medical needs and costs - so there's a shift in jobs and where money get spent.

American is behind us in aging but many of their baby boomers haven't saved enough and some that did had those saving wiped out by medical bills - I read somewhere they are fastest growing age group of homeless people

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-06-20/homeless-crisis-housing-californians-older-seniors-study#:~:text=Kushel%20and%20her%20team%20found,in%20families%2C%20are%20over%2065.

People will always have children and find ways to do so - with compromises that may well force on them - but the replacement level round the world has dropped only exceptions are sub saharan Africa. It's a societal shift that brings challenges.

Gregory Gibson, who is unhoused, on skid row.

The truth about our homeless crisis: As Californians age, they are priced out

The largest study in decades of California's homelessness crisis finds that older seniors priced out of housing are now a substantive share of those living on the streets.

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-06-20/homeless-crisis-housing-californians-older-seniors-study#:~:text=Kushel%20and%20her%20team%20found,in%20families%2C%20are%20over%2065.

OutsideLookingOut · 15/01/2024 17:26

LardyCakeAgain · 15/01/2024 16:56

Realistically, even if they removed all government benefits tomorrow, the world isn't going to stop having children. It would be a less equal society, possibly, and migraton patterns might change, but the primal urge to reproduce will still be there for some women. So your scenario is a bit silly. Look at what happened in Europe after the Black Death - a shortage of workers actually improved the wages & lives of poor serfs and labourers as it inflated their value.

On this point it is not suprising that ultra capitalists want an increase in birthrate like Elon Musk for example. Fewer children, fewer workers may have more power than they would like.

Mia45 · 15/01/2024 17:26

bessytedsy · 15/01/2024 17:11

It's partly a demographic vicious cycle - we have an ageing population, that costs more of state wealth and puts more pressure on people of working age, they're less likely to have children - also these issues get less coverage in press and by politicians - you end up with a society that's pretty hostile to young families.

yep & it suits many to ignore the issue.

Why isn’t child benefit universal, my parents got something, maybe family allowance that was universal.

Child benefit was universal until 2013 and then some stupid super rich twats complained about how they were getting all this money they didn’t need, instead of modestly just giving it away to charity. (A bit like rich OAPS twats who complain about getting the heating allowance despite evidence showing that such a universal system was the most efficient way get the money to those in need. So now we have single parents that are ironically entitled to UC but not child benefit and lots of skilled people in the economy who are put off doing overtime or taking a promotion due to the 70% + marginal tax rate this has created for those on 50-60k

AyeRightYeAre · 15/01/2024 17:25

Maternity leave, statutory maternity pay, maternity allowance, free prescriptions, free and subsidised childcare, UC for low paid working parents, flexible working legislation - just a few things.

You also need to contribute yourself and having children can mean sacrifices.

SerendipityJane · 15/01/2024 17:22

FruitBowlCrazy · 15/01/2024 17:14

There is only so much money available, and all of it comes directly from the taxpayer one way or another.

In an ideal world, money would grow on trees.

and therefore be worthless.

bessytedsy · 15/01/2024 17:22

There is only so much money available, and all of it comes directly from the taxpayer one way or another.

which is why a shrinking pool of taxpayers needs to be planned for plus there should be perhaps discussions around what taxpayers want their money to be spent on.

bessytedsy · 15/01/2024 17:20

I’d also question if a falling birth rate is a bad thing anymore

Reduced birth rates are ok it’s the fact there is so many old people vs young. It’s not particularly economically advantageous or progressive to have those demographics.

Mia45 · 15/01/2024 17:18

MrsMurphyIWish · 15/01/2024 16:23

We were discussing this at work today as one of my colleague wants a child but as a teacher on M3 can’t afford it currently.

My parents (no qualifications, no job) had my brother and I with no concerns about our future. They got a council house and we lived off benefits (not a great life tbh). Conversely, DH and I saved for both maternity leaves. Waited to have kids in our mid 30s when we were both UPS teachers. DS is in Yr 5 so we’re still paying for childcare - looking forward to Yr 7!

We mused at work whether our society in the future will just consist of children born to the economically inactive or the very rich feeding ever more into an unequal society.

Edited

It is essentially the middle classes that choose to have a lifestyle that needs planning accordingly. I say that as someone who had kids as poor and middle class. We did take a dip in our lifestyle when we had kids and had to consider that if we want to stay in our nice house in our nice area and maintain a certain standard of living then having more children and the timing would affect that. Maybe background I came from but never expected we could have it all.

FruitBowlCrazy · 15/01/2024 17:14

There is only so much money available, and all of it comes directly from the taxpayer one way or another.

In an ideal world, money would grow on trees.

bessytedsy · 15/01/2024 17:12

If you can't afford children, don't have them

Education standards are dreadful too.

SerendipityJane · 15/01/2024 17:12

Kpo58 · 15/01/2024 16:27

A slow global population decline is a good thing. A population crash is not. What would happen in that scenario is that the country's infrastructure will crumble and they would eventually be invaded by a country which is having a population boom, but not the resources to look after them. The native population will then get replaced, loosing the heritage and history of the country.

all Empires fall.

EasternStandard · 15/01/2024 17:12

Kpo58 · 15/01/2024 16:27

A slow global population decline is a good thing. A population crash is not. What would happen in that scenario is that the country's infrastructure will crumble and they would eventually be invaded by a country which is having a population boom, but not the resources to look after them. The native population will then get replaced, loosing the heritage and history of the country.

I think this is more likely generally if it were not for tech replacing jobs at an increasing rate

bessytedsy · 15/01/2024 17:11

It's partly a demographic vicious cycle - we have an ageing population, that costs more of state wealth and puts more pressure on people of working age, they're less likely to have children - also these issues get less coverage in press and by politicians - you end up with a society that's pretty hostile to young families.

yep & it suits many to ignore the issue.

Why isn’t child benefit universal, my parents got something, maybe family allowance that was universal.

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 15/01/2024 17:09

Daphnis156 · 15/01/2024 16:59

If you can't afford children, don't have them.

So soon only the super rich can have children as the price of everything you need in life increases?

OP posts:
OutsideLookingOut · 15/01/2024 17:07

Many reasons:

  1. They want to see how much they can get away with the status quo. Doing more will cost money
  2. They can get new workers with immigration. Not popular but they can speak against it and still increase immigration see Brexit for an example
  3. AI is going to reduce the need for many many jobs
  4. I don't think the government really cares about climate change but

But to parents, do you really just want to make another drone worker? Do you want your children to work in elderly care or the caring professions in general? Fewer people and children in particular might give your child more options and freedom. Someone mentioned how workers got improved conditions after the black death. Positives can come from being a rarer resource.

ISSTIUTNG · 15/01/2024 17:06

Daphnis156 · 15/01/2024 16:59

If you can't afford children, don't have them.

Utterly pointless, illogical and tone deaf statement when 90% of the population can't really afford to have children...

Swipe left for the next trending thread