Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel broody for a third child?

83 replies

Takeitinturns · 15/01/2024 00:00

I seem to come across quite a lot of threads from posters who are desperate for a third, or at least feel in their heart that they want another, don’t feel “done”, feel someone is missing etc. But are usually weighing these feelings up against financial reasons, a reluctant DH etc.

Am i uncommon in experiencing zero broodiness, which I felt strongly first and second time round? I’m trying to make sense the fact that I don’t feel broody, don’t want another, don’t feel it would make me or my family happier, but still have the thought crop up quite often.

Also wondering whether the broodiness returns late 30s, that’s what some seem to experience.

Anyway, anyone else feel this way?

OP posts:
Himawarigirl · 15/01/2024 11:58

I think it’s just the threads you see on here. I have three and read threads like those a lot. But the vast majority of my friends have one or two children, absolutely know they’re done and thought we were mad for having another. Own the feeling of knowing you’re done. I didn’t have it after two but it was the strongest feeling after number three was here and I was so grateful for the clarity of it.

DecoratingDiva · 15/01/2024 11:55

I never felt broody and stopped at one.

Whatstheword21 · 15/01/2024 11:54

I feel like this! Early-mid 30’s and have no desire for a third, but it randomly pops into my head at least once a week! I’m worried I’ll get the intense broodiness in a few years as well.

Jellycats4life · 15/01/2024 11:49

Three kids was never, ever on my radar. As soon as I had my second baby I was 100% done and did not feel remotely sad that my pregnancy days were over.

I never felt wistful about the end of each developmental stage either. No more weaning - great. No more potty training - great. No more preschool - great. And so on!

Anetaaa · 15/01/2024 11:45

Yeah I had 2 under 2 and my partner got vasectomy like 3 months after 2nd was born 😂 no way Jose

bookworm14 · 15/01/2024 11:21

I stopped feeling broody after one, and some people never feel broody at all! Clearly plenty of people aren’t desperate for a third or there would be many more families with three or more children.

Tryingtokeepcalmandcarryon · 15/01/2024 11:15

Nice to see lots of people in a similar boat to me here, very happy with my x2 but no way would we go for x3. Had a short period during the toddler / baby phase of seriously considering it. I definitely mourned the loss of never being pregnant again, never giving birth etc. It was a weird time and hormones felt so strong. Possibly impacted by miscarriage trauma too.

Now though, I really can’t begin to imagine how we would cope with a 3rd, it really would break us. Mentally, financially.. Just about to get my life back when youngest goes to school and get back to work. Also, I do think it depends on the nature of the child. My eldest is incredibly challenging and life is a rollercoaster. Possibly could cope with x3 calmer children without additional needs.

Ladyj84 · 15/01/2024 10:58

If I could have more I would but financially we are good and any more would strain it. I had first 13 years ago and last 3 in the last 2 years. Adore the kids,love every day and came from big families both sides and we all support each other and have fun still as adults. So 4 it is but almost 39 I would still have loved more

Dracarys1 · 15/01/2024 10:56

I'm in my early 40s so now would be the time I'd get that 'last chance' broodiness but I really don't. I used to feel sad and envious when someone announced a pregnancy but now I just feel relieved. I've got 2 young DC and I'm starting to look forward to them being old enough to do more with and actually start enjoying our family unit rather than feeling exhausted all the time. Definitely couldn't go back to square one now with a newborn. I think you just know when you're done xx

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 15/01/2024 10:53

I had two and the thought of having more has never crossed my mind. I only ever wanted one, tbh.
There was a poll here on MN a while back and a huge majority (84% IIRC) said that although they loved their 3rd child, given what they now know they'd stick with two.

DonnaBanana · 15/01/2024 10:52

Also three is a very inconvenient number. If you add 3 children to 2 parents it is a nightmare to stay in hotels, cruise ships, or frankly even just going to a restaurant and either having to have two rooms, two tables, etc. with one extra hanger on. Four is a good round number.

Isthatarealname · 15/01/2024 10:49

I always wanted 3 and then we had our second and I am so done. It actually annoys me how anti no 3 I am, I would like to be more supportive to friends who say they want to try for number 3 but I can feel myself making a face.

Don't get me wrong I love a baby and more than happy to have a cuddle but I don't want one permanently. We had a hard time with DS health wise when he was a baby so it probably stems from that. I know a lot of people have surprise number 3 and I honestly think I would terminate if that happened. That's awful isn't it.

PermanentTemporary · 15/01/2024 10:46

Unreasonable? Why would it be?

100% broody for years before ds. I never wanted another in a visceral way after ds was born, though I badly wanted another for him. But given dh's poor health, we didn't do it. He's dead now and I'm glad we only had one, though I have no doubt ds would have preferred a sibling.

You're allowed to make a rational decision about your own life and thank goodness we can control our fertility.

DonnaBanana · 15/01/2024 10:42

Daisies12 · 15/01/2024 10:36

Maybe your rationale brain is taking over. No one (and the planet) needs more than 2 kids.

Well rationally no one needs any. There are more than enough people on the planet.

StinkyWizzleteets · 15/01/2024 10:42

I hadn’t ever wanted any and ended up with 2. I couldn’t think of anything worse than a third or more.

LollyPopLouie · 15/01/2024 10:40

I became a single parent when ds was 1.5 and did everything until my lazy ex found a partner and started doing a bit. That has killed my desire for more kids!

FrancisSeaton · 15/01/2024 10:39

I didn't feel broody for a third until my second was about 8. Then wham. But a year or so after having my third I entered peri menopause with a bang so wonder if my body was telling me something

Daisies12 · 15/01/2024 10:36

Maybe your rationale brain is taking over. No one (and the planet) needs more than 2 kids.

Makeupalley · 15/01/2024 10:31

I had a little wobble for a third when my youngest went to school. Said to myself if I still feel like this in 6 months, then maybe we should go for it. As it happens, by the Christmas holidays I was fine, realised it was just the end of that stage of being a mum making me question things. She's 10 now and I'm 39. Two was the right number for us.

keylemon · 15/01/2024 10:24

Every person is different. There are no rules. I frankly feel so disconnected with these feelings of having a certain number of kids. I had what was suitable for my situation financially but also realistic about how things would work for us. Do not feel odd about it.

Stickthatupyourdojo · 15/01/2024 10:17

I wasn't overly broody for baby #2 as the birth was a shit show for number 1 but knew we wanted two children if we could. #2 then took 4 years to happen despite falling pregnant quickly with our eldest plus an ectopic and miscarriage along the way. We were just about to officially stop trying when I found out I was pregnant again. As a result there's a 6.5 age gap between our children.

I was really happy when I found out I was pregnant but also really scared, right up until baby was here (very difficult pregnancy and the threat of a difficult delivery from our eldest). Since our second child arrived (delivery went smoothly, no sign of the issue experienced with our first child) though I've felt broody for a third, it's really taken me by surprise, I was expecting lots of relief (which I've had) but also a feeling of "phew, don't need to do that ever again" but it's not happened! I'm not going to roll the dice again but I'd like to.

Fridaysgirl17 · 15/01/2024 10:15

I'm 2 & done without a doubt, I knew when I was pregnant with my 2nd I was never doing it again (complicated pregnancies) & then my partner left when our youngest was 8 months old & I was a single mother, he had been cheating on me & OW was pregnant so he moved in with her, they've had 2 babies in the 2 years since he left. I know even if I meet someone (which is nowhere near my mind) I'll never have another I'm 40 now & honestly feel not an ounce of broodiness

Namechangedagain20 · 15/01/2024 10:07

TruJay · 15/01/2024 00:07

I really wanted a third and didn’t think it could ever happen, we had to have a big gap due to genetic testing and it was a difficult journey. I would still have a fourth…and a fifth so I am of absolutely no help to your question. I don’t think I’d ever feel ‘done’. I know lots of people who have stopped at two though and haven’t expressed wishes for number 3, they could have them though I suppose and just haven’t shared that.

This is how I feel. I’ve got 3 and find it really strange that I’ll never be pregnant or have a newborn again, I don’t know when I’d ever really feel ‘done’ in that sense. I won’t have another though, my youngest is 2 now and I know it wouldn’t be sensible to have another, and in reality I don’t want to do sleepless nights again. The strange thing is I don’t look at other peoples babies and think they’re cute or anything, I assume it’s a biological urge type thing that’ll stop as I age.

hazandduck · 15/01/2024 10:01

I definitely madly wanted my two. I was desperate for my first, slightly more relaxed with my second but we both knew we wanted two definitely. They’re 2 years apart. Now the little one will start school in September and I am quite upset about it, and everyone keeps saying “Oh you’ll have another baby,” but I don’t want another baby…I want my two babies back, the ones which are all grown up now. These have honestly been the happiest, most defining years of my life with my girls. I feel so sad that this stage is over, despite being excited for what her school days will bring. It just goes too fast :(

I don’t think having a third will cure this weird feeling of loss. I know I am incredibly lucky and haven’t really lost anything…it’s just weird how the baby and toddler years just go and suddenly you have to share them with everyone else!

Blughbablugh · 15/01/2024 09:59

I have 2 and was broody for both of them. The thought of having a 3rd makes me recoil in horror! I absolutely adore both my children and wouldn't be without them but both I and my husband are 100% sure we are done. It just doesn't make sense to us to have a third for so many reasons and we just don't have the urge. So no it's not unusual not to feel broody. Don't get me wrong, I love seeing little newborn babies but the thought of me having another newborn, no way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread