Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel broody for a third child?

83 replies

Takeitinturns · 15/01/2024 00:00

I seem to come across quite a lot of threads from posters who are desperate for a third, or at least feel in their heart that they want another, don’t feel “done”, feel someone is missing etc. But are usually weighing these feelings up against financial reasons, a reluctant DH etc.

Am i uncommon in experiencing zero broodiness, which I felt strongly first and second time round? I’m trying to make sense the fact that I don’t feel broody, don’t want another, don’t feel it would make me or my family happier, but still have the thought crop up quite often.

Also wondering whether the broodiness returns late 30s, that’s what some seem to experience.

Anyway, anyone else feel this way?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Takeitinturns · 15/01/2024 23:03

Thanks everyone. Not really sure why if I don’t want another, the thought keeps coming up in my mind, I guess I’m feeling some kind of weird psychological pressure despite not feeling broody, not wanting to parent another, and knowing what is best for my current children. Anyone experience this too?

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 15/01/2024 20:51

Rudolphtherednoseddog · 15/01/2024 00:15

Really desperately wanted DC1 and DC2. I knew as soon as I was pregnant with DC2 that if all went well we were completely done after that, and fortunately DH felt the same way. Have never wavered from that position, even other people’s newborns that I used to fawn over I’m now very “meh” about. I occasionally wonder what a hypothetical DC3 would have been like (sex, personality etc) but I have absolutely no desire whatsoever to actually find out!

I’m like that. Really wanted my two DC, but then was completely done, and also never wavered.

Strawberrylacess · 15/01/2024 20:50

No, I didn't feel broody even for number 2 - that pregnancy was unexpected (wouldn't change them for the world now though).

Underestimated4 · 15/01/2024 20:41

I wanted DC 1 & DC 2 but have felt now desire for a 3rd, I knew after my first I wanted another but after my second I knew I was done. Both are girls so gender maybe plays a part in it for some but for me and my husband it doesn’t. My oldest isn’t biologically my husbands, had age been on our side we maybe would have had a 3rd but nearly 40 we know we are done.

Fourfurrymonsters · 15/01/2024 13:27

Not unusual at all. I have one of each sex, both young adults now, both much planned, wanted and loved but I knew 10000% that I was done after my second. I couldn’t think of anything worse than a third. The people I know who have more than two (and I know a lot) all seem to have really struggled in multiple ways.

Manthide · 15/01/2024 13:26

Isthatarealname · 15/01/2024 10:49

I always wanted 3 and then we had our second and I am so done. It actually annoys me how anti no 3 I am, I would like to be more supportive to friends who say they want to try for number 3 but I can feel myself making a face.

Don't get me wrong I love a baby and more than happy to have a cuddle but I don't want one permanently. We had a hard time with DS health wise when he was a baby so it probably stems from that. I know a lot of people have surprise number 3 and I honestly think I would terminate if that happened. That's awful isn't it.

When I told my mum I was pregnant with my third ( other 2 were 9 and 10) she said she'd have killed herself if she'd fallen pregnant at that age (I was 37)! Imagine how I felt telling her I was expecting number 4 at age 42.

AnonymousMusing · 15/01/2024 13:21

strawberryswizzler · 15/01/2024 13:09

that’s just not true though. you can have three kids and have an identity outside of parenthood and actual hobbies of your own.

I can't see how you can maintain outside interests with lots of kids, unless you can afford a nanny or have huge amounts of family help nearby.

DH and I both work full time, can only afford nursery not a nanny for our only DC, and have Zero family help. Even a second child would obliterate the very small amount of free time we each get to do something for ourselves.

blackpanth · 15/01/2024 13:20

When I had my son literally the day I had him I was broody. Had my daughter 3 weeks ago. Thank fully didn't feel broody at all. Happy to stick with 2.

Literallyoutofcontrol · 15/01/2024 13:14

Kit60 · 15/01/2024 13:07

I felt this physical broodiness before my first! I was astounded by how I felt.

I wish I could stop but I just can’t , I’ll be glad when I reach menopause

Manthide · 15/01/2024 13:10

Lots of people have 2 children with a small age gap and then 9 or 10 years later have a third. I've seen that pattern lots, maybe it's when you get to late 30s and suddenly all you can think of is having another one. I have 4dc with a large age gap between my first 2 and last 2. I did always want more - it just worked out that way. I had my youngest at age 42.

strawberryswizzler · 15/01/2024 13:09

AnonymousMusing · 15/01/2024 13:05

I think it is a hobby, in the sense that if you go for a 3rd child, you're making an active choice to devote all of your free time to parenting.
Unless you are exceedingly rich or the kids are massively spaced out, having three kids means that the only thing that you'll be doing outside of work is parenting.

that’s just not true though. you can have three kids and have an identity outside of parenthood and actual hobbies of your own.

Kit60 · 15/01/2024 13:07

Literallyoutofcontrol · 15/01/2024 12:20

I’m always broody it’s awful. A total obsession since I was 16 years old and had my first . I do feel a lot of it is down to being autistic and it became obsessive. I now just let nature decide for me as if I try to use contraception I get depressed so i have 8 now and who knows maybe I’ll have more maybe I’m too old (40) I literally can’t stop as soon as I leave hospital each time I’m planning the next

I felt this physical broodiness before my first! I was astounded by how I felt.

AnonymousMusing · 15/01/2024 13:05

strawberryswizzler · 15/01/2024 12:49

a hobby? what a weird comment. some people genuinely enjoy motherhood and want a big family. that doesn’t make it a hobby :S

I think it is a hobby, in the sense that if you go for a 3rd child, you're making an active choice to devote all of your free time to parenting.
Unless you are exceedingly rich or the kids are massively spaced out, having three kids means that the only thing that you'll be doing outside of work is parenting.

strawberryswizzler · 15/01/2024 12:49

Heather37231 · 15/01/2024 09:19

Christ no. When I was growing up I hardly knew anyone with more than one sibling. Very middle class town in the 80s. Few of my friends have more than one either.

I am constantly shocked at the number of people I meet at work and read about on here with 3 kids. I think you’ll get more people with 2+ kids on a parenting forum as clearly parenting is a bit of a hobby for them…

a hobby? what a weird comment. some people genuinely enjoy motherhood and want a big family. that doesn’t make it a hobby :S

MapelMoon · 15/01/2024 12:48

I think it is as normal to not want a third child as it is to want one.

Before I had our second, I thought I'd want to have more. I especially thought I'd want another if we ended up with two of the same sex, which we did. However, I couldn't be happier with the situation we have now. Two is perfect for us and to be honest the thought of going through it all again and having a third fills me with dread - so we are extra careful not to get pregnant.

When I had our second child, I felt an immense amount of guilt about not being able to give as much attention to both of them as I wanted to. We've found a balance now but the thought of splitting my attention three ways is something I know wouldn't work for me or my children.

My two close friends have had two, the same ages and sexes and they feel the same. In fact all of our DHs have either had the snip or are planning to.

I just absolutely know I'm done at two and never thought I'd feel like this but it's quite liberating really, nice to focus on what we have 💕.

AnonymousMusing · 15/01/2024 12:46

DecoratingDiva · 15/01/2024 11:55

I never felt broody and stopped at one.

I think this is my situation, too. I never had a yearning for a baby or toddler, but quite like older kids (8 and up) and decided if I only did it once, I could suck up the baby and toddler stage.

I didn't enjoy being pregnant (severe SPD, difficulty sleeping, frequent migraines) and in the newborn phase I just felt trapped and limited by breastfeeding. I don't really get why anyone would yearn for that phase again.

I am currently enduring the terrible 2s with a very physical, climbing, escape artist toddler and just looking forward to when he's older and less difficult to manage, rather than looking backwards and wishing for another dependent newborn.

kikisparks · 15/01/2024 12:26

PeloMom · 15/01/2024 00:55

Not alone. I always thought I’ll have 2 kids (guess societial expectations?). Once I had one I had zero desire for more… so that was it. I had my only at 38 and now almost mid 40s … so no, broodiness didn’t return.

Similar for me after my daughter have never had a desire for another.

Literallyoutofcontrol · 15/01/2024 12:20

I’m always broody it’s awful. A total obsession since I was 16 years old and had my first . I do feel a lot of it is down to being autistic and it became obsessive. I now just let nature decide for me as if I try to use contraception I get depressed so i have 8 now and who knows maybe I’ll have more maybe I’m too old (40) I literally can’t stop as soon as I leave hospital each time I’m planning the next

rosegoldivy · 15/01/2024 12:19

I was desperate for DC2,

Got a buy one get one free when i fell pregnant with twins so now have Dc3

I often wonder if I hadn't had the twins if I would have ever wanted more.

Definitely done, twins sucked the broodieness out my soul 🤣🤣🤣🤣

glittereyelash · 15/01/2024 12:16

I have one and no chance I'll be having another. Love the dynamic with just the three of us.

Kit60 · 15/01/2024 12:15

I wonder if the sex of the DC plays a role. I so often hear parents of two but same sex say they’d like one more but often hear parents one each sex say “Nope, we’ve got one of each.”

Wediblino7 · 15/01/2024 12:13

I’ve never been broody in my life, though ended up with 2 ☺️ I think with my first it was a case of see if it happens, my second was planned somewhat as I knew if I had one I didn’t want them to be an only child. I’m one of 7 and my mother would still say she was broody after we were all grown 😳

RebeccaCloud9 · 15/01/2024 12:07

I think lots of people know they are done after a certain number of babies. For most of my friends, that was 2 (some friends, one). For me, 3 was always a possibility but couldn't decide. At times, it was a yes-but-not-yet, at others it was oh-my-god-why-on-earth-do-we-think-we-could-cope-with-any-more but I never ever felt 'totally done'.

Now we have our 3rd, we are over the moon that she is here, and I have that knowing feeling myself of being done that I'd never had before.

Abbyant · 15/01/2024 11:58

My dp wants a third but I honestly don’t think I do we’ve got dd and ds and they still get 1on1 time with us with a 3rd I feel our dd would get pushed out as the eldest of four myself I had to become a third parent and I don’t want that for my dd.

celticprincess · 15/01/2024 11:58

Was always 2 that I wanted. Never more. In fact I swore I’d never give birth after watching a birth video as part of sex Ed at school. Had my eldest aged 32 and it took longer that expected to get pregnant. You spend all your younger years trying to not get pregnant then want to and can’t!! Eventually did. Very quick birth - too quick for pain relief. Decided we would go for number 2 after a year but took another so 3 year gap. Awful hyperemesis and another quick birth (even took myself to hospital earlier and they said I wasn’t in labour then suddenly I was pushing). The 2 kids have never got on really. Same sex. Was definitely done. DH wanted to keep going for the opposite sex. Then he decided to walk about when youngest was 18 months. 9 years later and I’m still single. He has a 3rd, same sex again. Didn’t stay with the mother (mother left him). I haven’t been in another relationship since. I’m late 40s now and that third baby urge has never happened.