Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

5 year old asked to wear cycling shorts by after school club

245 replies

LynseyR80 · 14/01/2024 23:04

My DD is 5 years old and tall for her age, wearing 7-8 clothes. When I picked her up from after school club last week the carer came out to have a word (in front of DD) and said that she’d had to point out to DD that she could see her pants whilst she was sitting down. DD doesn’t like tights and doesn’t want to wear trousers to school.
The carer said that she was under a moral obligation to point out to DD that she could see her pants and “why didn’t DD wear cycling shorts or tights like some of the other (older) girls?”

i don’t disagree that the carer could point out to my DD that she was “displaying” her pants (although she is 5) but AIBU to think that it’s not her place to say to my DD that she should be wearing gym shorts or tights under her skirt/pinafore?

OP posts:
Superduper02 · 15/01/2024 01:10

Shelby2010 · 15/01/2024 01:03

Little girls pants are definitely skimpy compared to how they used to be. Just get her some of the ‘boy short’ style, they are more comfortable (according to DD) and provide more adequate coverage.

They are weirdly skimpy. Even ones for toddlers barely cover bumcheeks. 🤨

Notthatcatagain · 15/01/2024 01:09

Hands up anyone who remembers navy blue school knickers,great big things with heavily elasticated legs. At my school, the posh girls had pockets in theirs. Maybe we should bring them back

Superduper02 · 15/01/2024 01:08

Annacondas · 14/01/2024 23:28

@Bagpuss2022 well yes

Frankly it’s concerning adults on here are surprised that children should be taught that their knickers are private!

Agree. It's not about sexualising kids. It's about accepting that sexual predators exist in every environment. If it were my DD, I'd be grateful to the lady for addressing this with me and either insist my DD wears tights, leggings or shorts.

Ponderingwindow · 15/01/2024 01:05

I bought my young dd cartwheel
shorts. I wanted her free to hang upside-down or to play however she wanted without worrying about if her pants were on display.

thin cotton ones that are cool and comfortable. Also nice from a hygiene perspective if your daughter tends to play pretty rough, but still wants to wear dresses. Pants aren’t great protection from sand and dirt.

Shelby2010 · 15/01/2024 01:03

Little girls pants are definitely skimpy compared to how they used to be. Just get her some of the ‘boy short’ style, they are more comfortable (according to DD) and provide more adequate coverage.

Labraradabrador · 15/01/2024 01:01

If a y6 is uncomfortable, then so be it - it has more to do with their evolving sense of bodily privacy than actually objectionable display. Young children have different expectations around nudity than adults - think about children foregoing a towel in changing rooms or on the beach, emergency change of clothing in the park, etc. yesterday I walked upon a mom using a portable potty in a parking lot - needs must when potty training.

we aren’t talking about children walking around in the nude - privates are covered by underwear and underwear mostly covered by clothing. The occasional glimpse of peppa pig pants on a 5 yo shouldn’t be shocking to anyone, and if someone is uncomfortable then the problem lies with them.

thirdfiddle · 15/01/2024 00:54

I wish they'd just put them all in joggers for primary school. It would be so much more practical and comfortable. They've started doing it on PE days, why not just do it on all days now? & Shorts in the summer.

JMSA · 15/01/2024 00:46

I have worked in a primary school. Many girls wore cycling shorts under their skirts, if they didn't have tights on.
They used to practice handstands and cartwheels in the playground at break, so I wouldn't see it as a negative thing. Yes, it's all very innocent at age 5. But the last thing you'd want is older kids making fun of her Peppa Pig pants! It's best just not to draw attention to these things.

LorlieS · 15/01/2024 00:41

@Labraradabrador I'm not saying they're seeing it as provocative, I'm saying a Yr 6 child may well feel uncomfortable seeing a 5 yo girl frequently showing her knickers.

Skodacool · 15/01/2024 00:38

Alloftheskies · 14/01/2024 23:20

I'd be livid if someone suggested my 5yo wear shorts tbh.. she's 5! And she's just wearing normal kids pants not some sort of raunchy underwear.. I mean what's the difference between that and shorts honestly? People are so odd out here sexualising 5yo in a school. So what if someone sees a bit of her knickers.
They'd rather make 5yo worry about how she is being looked at then just look away. How do they expect you to explain to her that she can't wear what she likes to wear because she's taller than the other girls so you can see a bit of her pants sometimes when she's sitting down, and people don't want to see that/think it's sexual. I mean wtf? She's 5 she shouldn't be having to worry about that.
I'm sorry it just makes me so sad. I was always very tall for my age and I vividly remember being taken aside once at the age of about 6 and being told as 'my body was more mature for my age' that the shorts I was wearing were to short and I should never wear them again. And I just remember the unsettling feeling that I was permanently being gawped at... like it hadn't registered on me before then that my body was some sort of contentious thing. I became incredibly self conscious..
I never want my daughters to feel like they are responsible for people sexualising them without their consent.
Pants can be sexual in some contexts and in others they are just an item of clothing which you might accidentally see sometimes and thats no big deal. Same with bra straps etc. People need to stop this nonsense

Absolutely agree with you. What on earth is the thinking behind making a 5 yo feel self conscious?

Labraradabrador · 15/01/2024 00:37

@LorlieS not really sure what your point is? I put mine in shorts regardless of group they are in because it helps them navigate changing privacy expectations. At he same time don’t think a 5 year old’s pants are provocative for anyone (even boys on the cusp of puberty) barring some ingrained sexual deviancy.

SleepingStandingUp · 15/01/2024 00:37

Largecatlover · 15/01/2024 00:15

Year 6 boys are age 10-11 and have had sex education at school.

Doesn't mean they're sexually interested in little girls they probably consider practically babies tho. It works new that as soon as my boys gets a whiff of puberty, they're already labelled by some as sex offenders in waiting

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 15/01/2024 00:34

I usually put my daughter in cycle shorts, they're not dissimilar in shape to 1950s children's underwear judging by the sewing patterns I've seen. Current girls pants have a crap fit and thickness for playing in.

Snowflakesonhisnose · 15/01/2024 00:34

Largecatlover · 14/01/2024 23:29

If this is in after school club then presumably it’s boys and girls of all ages mixed in together. I wouldn’t really want a year 6 boy ogling my reception/ year 1 daughter’s underwear. This might be what the carer is concerned about but doesn’t want to spell it out.

If a year 6 boy is 'ogling' a 5 year old's underwear, then he needs removing from that situation and to be referred to external services. The girl's pants wouldn't be the issue here.

LorlieS · 15/01/2024 00:29

@Labraradabrador I expect in after-school there will be children of all ages though, up to the age of 11 if it's primary.

Labraradabrador · 15/01/2024 00:24

At our school children in ks1 change in a coed setting (classroom) for forest school, so they all know what each others pants look like. At that age, there is nothing sexual about seeing pants, BUT they are starting to learn about privacy and at a transitional point where they are suddenly expected to be mindful of private vs public display. I put mine in bike shorts under their skirts to help make it easy for them - they don’t need to worry about showing their pants accidentally, and it allowed them to play without worry (cartwheels, hanging upside down, etc.). At the moment they mostly don’t really care who sees what, but in selective situations become sensitive about privacy, so I see shorts as a layer of protection that helps them maintain control.

AutumnNanny · 15/01/2024 00:23

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 00:03

When I was at primary school, we sat cross-legged on the floor in mandatory skirts in every assembly. No one told any of us to wear shorts or tights. We would cartwheel in the playground in our skirts too and people saw our knickers. They were normal full-coverage cotton briefs, not adult lingerie.

I wonder what the world is coming to when a five year old is having her school uniform policed.

I am with your DD on the hating tights and hating polyester trousers front. I'm autistic and the itching drives me crackers.

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia

thats the issue though, little girls pants are too skimpy these days. They don't adequately cover them like they used to!

AutumnNanny · 15/01/2024 00:21

Hols24 · 14/01/2024 23:49

I do not believe you saw her vagina 🙄

@Hols24 I don't think you really need to be that pedantic do you??

Not her vagina no, but definitely vulvas.

AutumnNanny · 15/01/2024 00:18

LynseyR80 · 14/01/2024 23:44

No, it was initially to my DD and then to me as well at pick up.
Privates are private - absolutely.
But how does my 5yo DD then reconcile that with wearing a swimsuit?

Edited

@LynseyR80 they don't think that deeply, they just follow what you tell them

BobbyBiscuits · 15/01/2024 00:16

It seems odd, but maybe if there are older kids (boys) in the group nearer to puberty there could be teasing and things that might be uncomfortable even if not outright inappropriate. I would buy her some of those knicker/ shorts hybrid things in black that cover a tiny bit more. Of course, it's your child and your choice.

SpidersAreShitheads · 15/01/2024 00:16

If it's an issue, then schools need to stop getting little kids to sit cross-legged on the floor. Girls wearing dresses and skirts are always going to be at risk of flashing their knickers when they're told to sit like this.

In a public environment I'd have some sympathy with putting shorts on to protect a young child from an unwanted gaze of someone potentially dangerous. But in a child-safe environment like a school, I don't see there's any need to truss a young child up in extra layers. My DC have just moved onto secondary school but when they were in primary - just a couple of years ago - the children were all still getting changed in the classrooms. Teachers, TAs, and other children - including the opposite sex - were all seeing the children's underwear. So that's OK but occasional flashing knickers while sat cross-legged on the carpet is shocking? That's just daft.

I'm also pretty sure that very young primary children would still do PE in their vest and knickers if they were indoors and didn't have a PE kit. It's perfectly decent and no different than wearing a swimming costume.

The NSPCC guidelines are about protecting privates, not pants. Pants is just a handy acronym that's easy to remember that's relevant for that part of the body.

Reigateforever · 15/01/2024 00:16

LynseyR80 · Yesterday 23:44

But how does my 5yo DD then reconcile that with wearing a swimsuit

Some manufacturers sexualize children clothes too much. It depends what style you want to see her wearing, there’s the choice from the itsy bitsy bikini through to ones that cover the tops of legs.

Largecatlover · 15/01/2024 00:15

Ffs22 · 14/01/2024 23:31

What! 6 year old boy “ogling” a 5 year old?? Is this a wind up- I sincerely hope so.

Year 6 boys are age 10-11 and have had sex education at school.

oneflewoverthe · 15/01/2024 00:12

Do her knickers come up small? Maybe she needs bigger ones with more coverage.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 00:10

If you can see a little girl's vulva when she's cross-legged in her school skirt, her knickers are the problem.

Fin.