Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

5 year old asked to wear cycling shorts by after school club

245 replies

LynseyR80 · 14/01/2024 23:04

My DD is 5 years old and tall for her age, wearing 7-8 clothes. When I picked her up from after school club last week the carer came out to have a word (in front of DD) and said that she’d had to point out to DD that she could see her pants whilst she was sitting down. DD doesn’t like tights and doesn’t want to wear trousers to school.
The carer said that she was under a moral obligation to point out to DD that she could see her pants and “why didn’t DD wear cycling shorts or tights like some of the other (older) girls?”

i don’t disagree that the carer could point out to my DD that she was “displaying” her pants (although she is 5) but AIBU to think that it’s not her place to say to my DD that she should be wearing gym shorts or tights under her skirt/pinafore?

OP posts:
bluechicky · 15/01/2024 06:24

AnneValentine · 15/01/2024 06:20

When does showing off underwear become an issue?

Yes when? Because it definitely does.

Copperoliverbear · 15/01/2024 06:24

I think it's more for safety reasons, there could be older children there too and men working there too.
I know it's not nice but this is the world we live in today, carers have to cover all bases, not nice but you just don't know nowadays.

AnneValentine · 15/01/2024 06:20

LynseyR80 · 14/01/2024 23:13

I’m objecting to the fact that she’s five years old and showing her underwear is an issue.

When does showing off underwear become an issue?

Zanatdy · 15/01/2024 06:18

If you’re ok with her underwear showing then don’t do anything about it. I don’t see an issue with it being pointed out. I can’t remember what age my DD started wearing cycling shorts but probably wasn’t primary. But then her pinafores were not that short and she had no choice but to wear tights in winter. You probably just need to buy lower pinafores, guess the carer felt bad suggesting that

bluechicky · 15/01/2024 06:07

user1492757084 · 15/01/2024 04:38

Your daughter is five and she will get better at not showing her knickers.

Teach her how to sit cross legged with her hands in her lap. Show her how that saves her knickers being on show.

Check that her knickers are in good order - large enough, fit well, clean and in school colour.

DD is five and I agree that five year olds are bound to show their knickers in normal play and that knickers are similar to any other covering when worn on a five year old.
She will soon develop a need for modesty.

When she starts to like climbing and doing hand stands and cartwheels provide her with some cotton bike shorts for her modesty and to prevent her displaying her knickers.

This sounds a good approach

bluechicky · 15/01/2024 06:05

If you want your daughter to carry on accidently show her knickers then that's up to you.

Personally id find her a pair of trousers she likes so her movement isn't restricted and she can focus on playing and learning without having to worry about her knickers

Redcar78 · 15/01/2024 05:54

You're being precious, she didn't tell your DD what to wear, she made a suggestion you could try as your DD doesn't like tights or skirts FFS 🤷‍♀️

Bellavida99 · 15/01/2024 05:49

My daughter and her friends all wore shorts under their skirts or dresses at primary school. I can’t remember how it came about but it’s really common, handy when they’re sitting cross legged or doing cartwheels etc, and a bit of a no brainer. Get her some navy / black cotton cycling shorts - sorted. Don’t make a lady doing her job a big issue

Rosebud21 · 15/01/2024 05:39

Parentofeanda · 14/01/2024 23:47

Actually yabu. I have once had the unfortunate view of a little girls vagina before as she was sat cross legged and her pants had gone to the side a bit, it was just my eyes moving left to right that saw it before you jump on and say I was deliberately looking!! But I had to quickly avert my eyes and I just distracted her to move to a different position.
I DONT want to see peoples underwear! Whether children or adults.

My 4 year old wears tights, if she cant wear tights then yes shorts.

I think you saw the labia, which are part of the vulva, terminology is important

Lwrenagain · 15/01/2024 05:33

I'm so interested in people's opinions on this one.
I've friends with daughters with polar opposite views - some won't let their dd wear shorts under skirts, others won't not let them wear shorts under skirts.
It was a completely none issue when I was a boy mum but now I've a DD I'm really wondering whats for the best here.

Girls don't ever get a fucking day off do they? 😡

5twomany · 15/01/2024 05:22

I buy my daughter these style of knickers as i also find the other shaped knickers are not so great at covering everything and feel really thin
Buy Black with Bright Elastic Shorts 5 Pack (2-16yrs) from the Next UK online shop
That being said i think unless her knickers were not covering everything or she is running around with her skirt over her head i don't know why she felt the need to say anything to a 5 year old who doesn't understand what the problem is
she should have waited to speak to you as her parent

Buy Black with Bright Elastic Shorts 5 Pack (2-16yrs) from the Next UK online shop

Shop for Black with Bright Elastic Shorts 5 Pack (2-16yrs) at Next.co.uk. Next day delivery and free returns to store. 1000s of products online. Buy Black with Bright Elastic Shorts 5 Pack (2-16yrs) now!

https://www.next.co.uk/style/st766509/c91327#c91327

Stopsnowing · 15/01/2024 04:52

Alloftheskies · 14/01/2024 23:34

Little girls should not be made to worry whether someone can briefly see their pants due to the way they are sitting. That's just horrible. Can you not see how that's wrong? It's not about dignity or privacy.. it would be if you could actually see their naked body... but all that's going on here is you are sexualising a piece of cotton and teaching a 5yo child that they are a potential sexual object to observers and moreover that they are responsible for worrying about that.

Totally agree

Stopsnowing · 15/01/2024 04:49

Totally agree. If anything she just needs to push her skirt down over her crossed legs after she has sat down.

user1492757084 · 15/01/2024 04:38

Your daughter is five and she will get better at not showing her knickers.

Teach her how to sit cross legged with her hands in her lap. Show her how that saves her knickers being on show.

Check that her knickers are in good order - large enough, fit well, clean and in school colour.

DD is five and I agree that five year olds are bound to show their knickers in normal play and that knickers are similar to any other covering when worn on a five year old.
She will soon develop a need for modesty.

When she starts to like climbing and doing hand stands and cartwheels provide her with some cotton bike shorts for her modesty and to prevent her displaying her knickers.

VashtaNerada · 15/01/2024 04:11

I used to teach Year One and the idea of telling a parent to put shorts on their child would never have crossed my mind! It can’t be healthy to have all those layers on.
I wonder if there is an age divide here? When I was at school (1980s) you sometimes wore a petticoat under your skirt but never shorts. I think the whole thing is peculiar and sexualising. It really doesn’t matter if you can see the underwear of a small child. In many countries, children that age will go naked at the beach and nobody will think anything of it. At least the child is dressed!

Anna8089 · 15/01/2024 04:02

Then don't put a short skirt or pinafore on her . Buy the shorts , you're being weird.

Midnightgrey · 15/01/2024 03:55

I am in my late 50s. I grew up where people were in the closet, pregnant girls got thrown out by their families, shotgun weddings were not uncommon and divorce was frowned on. We girls wore dresses mostly at primary school. There was not a single girl that I knew of there who was trussed up in a pair of shorts. Even when one of my friends went to a convent school, the nuns just suggested more generously covering knickers but there were no inspections and nobody was wearing modesty shorts under their shorts. My mother once did suggest I learn to sit down with my legs tucked together but I have a sneaking suspicion that not being a very girly girl I was sitting akimbo in one of the aforementioned dresses at the time. I am a bit appalled at the message we are sending here. I have sons and certainly in year 6 (or in any other year for that matter) I can't imagine them ogling a 5 year old's underwear.

SpidersAreShitheads · 15/01/2024 03:51

Rather than putting the onus on girls to add more layers of clothing - which is potentially uncomfortable and hot, plus less practical - why don't the schools change their uniform policies? And their rules around sitting cross-legged, and getting changed?

If skirts and dresses are such a safeguarding issue, then bring in shorts, skorts, and trousers only.

Schools should also stop children changing for PE in the same classroom together because everyone sees knickers and underwear there.

And schools should also stop forcing the children to sit cross-legged on the floor - because that's another reason that girls end up flashing their knickers. Children are forced to sit cross-legged, any other sitting position is typically not allowed. This puts girls at obvious risk of showing their knickers.

If this is such an issue for little 5 year old girls, the solution is not to force more layers onto little children but to change the uniform and school practices.

Females of any age shouldn't be the ones to have to adapt their behaviour because of the predatory behaviour of others.

If little girls occasionally flashing knickers is an issue, then change school policies - don't put the onus on the little girls to have to adopt potentially uncomfortable solutions to accommodate others. If your daughter is happy to wear additional shorts under a skirt then great - but it shouldn't be compulsory. The behaviour of little girls isn't the issue here.

BayCityCoaster · 15/01/2024 03:48

Well, the only other cohort of people who expose their underwear are male youths who wear their pants half way down their arse. And they’re widely mocked…

BayCityCoaster · 15/01/2024 03:46

I really don’t get what the big drama is about keeping underwear hidden.

It’s socially acceptable to keep underwear hidden…? Everyone does. The only people who don’t, are girls who wear skirts/dresses, and who run, jump, play and sit on the floor cross-legged in them.

Everyone else keeps their underwear under wraps.

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 15/01/2024 03:41

I don’t disagree with you. I find it ridiculous tbh. Dd is a bit older now and wears skorts which seems like the go to compromise in these situations

BayCityCoaster · 15/01/2024 03:37

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 03:32

I didn't wear shorts at secondary school either. I'm surprised that she goes outside at break, none of the girls in my entire school did. The teachers used the "playground" as a car park because it was ignored by all the girls.

Well, whatever.

It’s entirely the norm for girls to wear bike pants under skirts these days.

I don’t, but I’m not a girl, so…..

OP - it was merely a suggestion. Take it or leave it.

NaughtybutNice77 · 15/01/2024 03:35

I don't think she was giving instructions, just making reasonable suggestions. Maybe you're on the defensive and feel attacked and awkward because you hadn't noticed?
If neither of these solutions are agreeable how about lo ger dresses or even the gingham dress style uniform playsuit you can buy 🤔

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 03:32

BayCityCoaster · 15/01/2024 03:27

You’re probably not going to be playing as much tag, or hanging upside down from bars, as my 13YO.

I didn't wear shorts at secondary school either. I'm surprised that she goes outside at break, none of the girls in my entire school did. The teachers used the "playground" as a car park because it was ignored by all the girls.

BayCityCoaster · 15/01/2024 03:27

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 03:25

I don't and I'm in my forties. That's just absurd.

You’re probably not going to be playing as much tag, or hanging upside down from bars, as my 13YO.