Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

5 year old asked to wear cycling shorts by after school club

245 replies

LynseyR80 · 14/01/2024 23:04

My DD is 5 years old and tall for her age, wearing 7-8 clothes. When I picked her up from after school club last week the carer came out to have a word (in front of DD) and said that she’d had to point out to DD that she could see her pants whilst she was sitting down. DD doesn’t like tights and doesn’t want to wear trousers to school.
The carer said that she was under a moral obligation to point out to DD that she could see her pants and “why didn’t DD wear cycling shorts or tights like some of the other (older) girls?”

i don’t disagree that the carer could point out to my DD that she was “displaying” her pants (although she is 5) but AIBU to think that it’s not her place to say to my DD that she should be wearing gym shorts or tights under her skirt/pinafore?

OP posts:
Hols24 · 15/01/2024 08:23

applewood87 · 15/01/2024 07:15

Have you taught your daughter the pants rule?

@applewood87 But the pants rule has nothing to do with covering up your pants Confused

MirrorBack · 15/01/2024 08:12

Firstly, having taught the age group it’s REALLY common for girls to sit and expose knickers without thinking. They aren’t aware to pull sorts down or forward yet and just plonk down.
I used to try to quietly address it to simply remind them to give their skirt a little pull forward as they sat (without others hearing). It resolves that. Can you teach her? Doesn’t need to be sexualised or even mention underwear. Just show her to smooth her skirt to the floor.
I don’t personally like cycling shorts, it’s a sweaty extra layer and later can contribute to thrush as a habit if they are synthetic. I however got my girls cotton boxer type underwear rather than tiny knickers for school. Very comfy, breathable and doesn’t pull aside

NotQuiteNorma · 15/01/2024 08:09

On what planet is it wrong to have concerns for the privacy of a child's intimate parts? Seriously stop trying to be offended at nothing, refocus your outrage and be grateful someone had the sense to point out what you seem oblivious to. She's trying to protect your child.

TTCquestion · 15/01/2024 07:56

Sunday12 · 15/01/2024 07:31

But why would seeing the knickers make the difference? An otherwise normal person turns into a pedo ar the sight of a 5 year olds underwear? Or that a pedo only strikes if knickers are not covered? What exactly are we protecting against with the shorts?

They are two obviously extreme examples. Of course it could still happen with shorts or many layers, as I’m sure was the case in the high profiles cases I mentioned, in which I believe photos were taken of the children in the nursery. But my point was that these cases highlighted how we really don’t know about the private lives of the adults who work in schools etc, in reply to the comment which went something along the lines of (paraphrasing) “Surely staff can vouch that there are no offenders on site.” (I’ve just remembered about the school caretaker, as well as the nursery staff cases.) I wouldn’t be offended if a staff member approached me as a parent for the reasons of pants = private which we teach our DC, the concept of dignity from a young age and in the unlikely event knickers were a little saggy.

Simonjt · 15/01/2024 07:51

My sons primary when we were in the UK stressed that underwear should only be visible when changing for PE, they had shorts in the uniform policy as they followed the pants rule.

Sunday12 · 15/01/2024 07:31

TTCquestion · 15/01/2024 07:05

Honestly my only concern would be I would worry an adult found it so morally wrong to see a kids knickers ! This deflection is unfair. As someone who works with children and is trained in child protection and safeguarding, we are constantly told to have to mindset of “It could happen here” - and yes, even in settings which should be safe, depressingly. Surely you have heard of very high profiles in nurseries over recent years, despite them obviously having the relevant checks before starting the job?

But why would seeing the knickers make the difference? An otherwise normal person turns into a pedo ar the sight of a 5 year olds underwear? Or that a pedo only strikes if knickers are not covered? What exactly are we protecting against with the shorts?

BayCityCoaster · 15/01/2024 07:31

Adhdeeedout · 15/01/2024 06:56

What do we do when the shorts are being asked to get covered up because they’re meant to be private to protect the girls dignity? Do we put our girls in clothes that hide their ankles and go up to their chins?

The private parts are the genitals, the underwear is to cover the genitals and now we need another layer to cover the underwear covering the genitals ?

How about instead of policing a young female child’s clothing we police those who seek to make a pair of knickers on a five year old something other than a pair of knickers on a five year old? There is nothing sexual about a pair of knickers on a five year old and if someone thinks there is, a pair of shorts over the knickers isn’t going to stop their perverse predilections.

The private parts are the genitals, the underwear is to cover the genitals and now we need another layer to cover the underwear covering the genitals ?

But this argument is just bizarre.

Yes, of course we need another layer to cover the underwear!

Literally everyone, except young girls wearing skirts.dresses - women, boys and men! - all have another layer covering their underwear?!

It’s not socially acceptable to go out with your underwear on display! Again - the clue is in the name: underwear.

This isn’t some demonisation of young girls.

The woman absolutely should not have said anything in front of the OP’s daughter. And if I were her, I wouldn’t have said anything at all.

But yes, of course we need another layer to cover the underwear….!

Insertdeadcatsnamehere · 15/01/2024 07:19

Where on earth are you all buying your daughters' pants? I'm 42 and my 5 year old's pants look exactly the same as mine did at that age. I've just asked my 70 year old mum and she says the same.

applewood87 · 15/01/2024 07:15

Have you taught your daughter the pants rule?

Soontobe60 · 15/01/2024 07:13

It could be that when the child is sitting down cross legged, her pants shift and don’t cover her genitals fully. It’s actually very common! Maybe the staff member was alluding to that happening?

Sunday12 · 15/01/2024 07:10

If anyone is interested in seeing a 5 year olds knickers they have something wrong with them.

this is a cultural thing though in my experience. I was raised without being sexualised at all and it wouldn’t be a problem for small children to wear whatever they liked. No inhibitions. (In fact school we had to wear vest and knickers for PE)

I have had people ask that my daughter wear cycling shorts under her skirts since she was tiny. I feel that cultural differences play a big part. And have had mentioned from carers if my daughter is in the park and hasn’t got shorts on under skirts. I find it uncomfortable because of the sexualisation. Why would anyone be looking up my children’s skirts? Really discomforting.

TTCquestion · 15/01/2024 07:05

Tryingmybestadhd · 15/01/2024 02:02

It’s ridiculous imo , she is 5 . I would have replied “ I’m assuming you can vouch none of your staff are pedophiles , so why is this a issue at 5 “
Honestly my only concern would be I would worry an adult found it so morally wrong to see a kids knickers !

why should girls have to wear shorts ffs so boys or worse men don’t look ? the misogyny in this thread 🤦🏻‍♀️

Honestly my only concern would be I would worry an adult found it so morally wrong to see a kids knickers ! This deflection is unfair. As someone who works with children and is trained in child protection and safeguarding, we are constantly told to have to mindset of “It could happen here” - and yes, even in settings which should be safe, depressingly. Surely you have heard of very high profiles in nurseries over recent years, despite them obviously having the relevant checks before starting the job?

Neurodiversitydoctor · 15/01/2024 07:01

I think the short type knickers linked above are a good compromise. Tights on little girls are a bit of a pain.

Mystro202 · 15/01/2024 07:00

Absolutely ridiculous of the carer to point this out. And for the posters saying she's correct. Wtaf! Her skirt is knee length and I presume that shorts are not part of the uniform policy. So op has done nothing wrong!! I doubt any of us wore shorts under our skirts at 5!!! The only time my dd7 has worn shorts under her skirt is when she wanted to do cartwheels in the summer.
I remember working in a creche on work experience whilenat school and a 4 yo child had a summer dress with NOTHING underneath. No underwear at all. Now that is an issue...not least for germs etc.

Shadowsindarkplaces · 15/01/2024 06:59

The issue then, is poor quality underwear, that goes baggy, is too skimpy etc. Parents need to use parental pressure and refuse to buy substandard clothing.
Again, I'm of the generation that did Infant school PE in pants and vest!
DH is of the generation when half the class didn't have pants, let alone wear 2 layers.

Adhdeeedout · 15/01/2024 06:56

What do we do when the shorts are being asked to get covered up because they’re meant to be private to protect the girls dignity? Do we put our girls in clothes that hide their ankles and go up to their chins?

The private parts are the genitals, the underwear is to cover the genitals and now we need another layer to cover the underwear covering the genitals ?

How about instead of policing a young female child’s clothing we police those who seek to make a pair of knickers on a five year old something other than a pair of knickers on a five year old? There is nothing sexual about a pair of knickers on a five year old and if someone thinks there is, a pair of shorts over the knickers isn’t going to stop their perverse predilections.

TTCquestion · 15/01/2024 06:53

TempleOfBloom · 14/01/2024 23:21

Oh, FFS, she did not ‘have to’ point out to a 5 yo child that she could see her pants.

IF It had to be pointed out at all, she could talk to you,

But why on earth does a 5 year old have to hide their pants in a protected child- friendly environment??

Pants cover the body.

Do we now have to cover clothing that covers the body?

Edited

Because we teach our little ones that pants and knickers are private - for reasons I would have thought were obvious.

Mikimoto · 15/01/2024 06:49

The "light" thermal tights/undertrousers in Uniqlo are sort of "furry" inside and very comfortable - maybe try them?

Lovetoshop365 · 15/01/2024 06:37

This has happened to me too, working in a school environment.

Itsbeginingtolookalotlikexmas · 15/01/2024 06:36

In British culture it is seen as rude, by most, to show your underwear. Unless you are on the beach or at home, just get her some little black shorts. It’s not a feminist issue.

Devilshands · 15/01/2024 06:36

mumsytoon · 14/01/2024 23:21

So what if someone sees a bit of her knickers.

So you're all fine with anyone seeing her underwear then? You're assuming it is just kids.

I mean…kids are hardly all innocent are they?
There are constantly stories in press about kids as young as 6-8 doing unspeakable things. There was a report about 8 year olds watching porn a few years ago!!

But, I agree you with!

This is about protecting OPs little girl. If it was me, I’d be pleased someone was looking out for my child.

brummyadele91 · 15/01/2024 06:32

Hols24 · 14/01/2024 23:13

For goodness sake, if girls sit cross-legged wearing a school skirt, you may well see their pants. Not a big deal and not something to raise with parents 🙄🙄 Blimey, in my day we did indoor PE wearing pants and vest at that age!

Yes we wore gum
Knickers for PE at high school in the 90's

Neurodiversitydoctor · 15/01/2024 06:31

VenhamousSnake · 14/01/2024 23:09

Bloody hell how short is the dress?

Isn't she cold with no tights? At age 5 even if she doesn't like them surely you just tell her she has to wear them or have trousers.

This either the skirt or dress needs to be knee length or she needs to wear tights surely? It January FGS.

Copperoliverbear · 15/01/2024 06:29

@Alloftheskies I'm afraid the world we live in today a little girls underwear can be sexual to some people, it's awful to think, but there are a lot of weird people around. You just don't know who works there and how old the older kids are. None of I like to think these things but things happen in this world today that is beyond or comprehension.