Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

House-buying budget - how much did you keep in savings?

41 replies

MNUse · 14/01/2024 21:45

Not really an AIBU, and I’m really sorry if the title is annoying/offensive or to some given that house-buying at all let alone house-buying with savings reserved is so hard at the moment. But if you did buy a house and were in a position to reserve some savings as well, how much did you keep for savings vs spending on house budget? Basically looking to buy and wondering whether to try and spend at the top of my budget in order to try and get somewhere I love and could stay a long time in (with say about a fifth of my total money kept in savings) or buy something that’s ok and keep a more substantial amount in savings (about a third of my total money). How did you decide?

YABU - prioritise savings
YANBU - prioritise house budget (calling this YANBU since that’s what I’m inclined to do)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MNUse · 17/01/2024 23:03

Thank you so much to everyone who has posted - lots of important stuff to think about here

OP posts:
Toooldtoworry · 15/01/2024 19:18

Devilshands · 15/01/2024 16:48

I think you’d be insane to make a huge financial commitment like a house and NOT have savings (or at least something to fall back on like a good credit score etc) - we've all seen on here how much peoples circumstances suddenly change + unexpected costs.

It’s all relative though to deposit/house value and whether you can afford to.

My LTVR was 65% (i.e 65% upfront and only 35% mortgage on the value of the property). So I kept back a large amount of savings and just overpay on my mortgage instead of saving now…

On this for the love of God get income protection when buying.

NewName24 · 15/01/2024 18:29

Last time we moved, we threw everything at it, and then some, to be able to afford the house we've had the privilege of living in for the last 20 years. We even 'borrowed' from our dcs' savings accounts - they were too young to know.
We both had secure jobs. Nothing needed doing on the house. It was initially out of our budget but was just 'the one' after looking for some time at houses that all needed some compromise.

So, we had no savings. Zero. Zilch. Negative, in fact, in that we had to pay back our dc.

But, if you are buying somewhere uninhabitable, that won't apply.
If you are in less than secure jobs, then that won't apply.

All circumstances are different.

onthefence23 · 15/01/2024 17:58

First house at 25 took every single Penny and I lived in overdraft for two years doing it up.

Moving atm and this time hoping to keep about 10K in reserve

Devilshands · 15/01/2024 16:48

I think you’d be insane to make a huge financial commitment like a house and NOT have savings (or at least something to fall back on like a good credit score etc) - we've all seen on here how much peoples circumstances suddenly change + unexpected costs.

It’s all relative though to deposit/house value and whether you can afford to.

My LTVR was 65% (i.e 65% upfront and only 35% mortgage on the value of the property). So I kept back a large amount of savings and just overpay on my mortgage instead of saving now…

mealideas2024 · 15/01/2024 16:26

We took the maximum amount of mortgage that we could afford at that point in time, rather than invest the "cash" in the house if that makes sense? So we kept back about £50K from the house sale which we then used for emergency repairs to unforeseen circumstances and also was something to fall back on if one month we were struggling to pay the mortgage for whatever reason.

Now the rates have changed I'm not sure I'd do the same again and would argue that "cash is king".

Toooldtoworry · 15/01/2024 16:18

£10k which swiftly went on a kitchen and the back garden. We are mid 40s and I earn quite well. In the 4 years we have lived here we have done pretty much everything apart from loft insulation and boarding. Ironically just about to increase the mortgage to do an extension, but I'd rather die than move again.

mindutopia · 15/01/2024 16:13

We didn't consciously keep any in savings. We moved ourselves, literally with our and dh's friend's van, so no removals costs. We do have a business, so when in doubt, dh could always pay out extra in a given month if we needed more money (my income is more static as I'm salaried). But we didn't really 'need' any extra money above and beyond the costs of mortgage fee, conveyancing, the usual. We did eventually get a new bed/mattress and we did some decorating, but decorating was like a few tins of paint and we slept on our old mattress on the floor for a few months, so new bed wasn't urgent.

YYURYYUCICYYUR4ME · 15/01/2024 16:06

£0 - had to scrape anything and everything together to buy, cover costs and then worried about what next, with us renovating as and when we saved the money, generally doing most everything ourselves to save labour costs, which we repeated 4 times, including the removals! However, we also made sure that we had no other debts, credit cards etc., which helped with budgetting going forward.

llamadrama16 · 15/01/2024 16:04

Ah, should say as FTB we only kept about £10k in savings and only had a 15% deposit. Sorry, it's very different as a FTB.

llamadrama16 · 15/01/2024 15:56

Our current house we had a 30% deposit and kept £60k back for contingencies. Draining the savings wouldn't have got us a better interest rate as it wouldn't have got us to a 60% LTV vs the 70%, and as a result wouldn't have reduced our monthly payments a huge amount. We're a one income family so like to have 6 months of liquid living expenses in case of job loss.

Tryingtokeepcalmandcarryon · 15/01/2024 14:16

Also do some research into costs if you are looking at buying somewhere that needs work (eg you want to put in a new kitchen / diner, knock down walls, new bathroom) and think very carefully about whether you will realistically be able to afford this. Some of the quotes just for single storey extensions / new kitchens seem to be getting crazy at 100k plus. New windows / doors could be 20k / garden work 10k. Be very realistic, think about where you will
be in 5 years time.

If you see yourself with 2 children, part-time wages / nursery costs then don’t go for a house that needs 100k work you’ll never be able to afford (ahem, possibly speaking from experience here..)

HungryandIknowit · 15/01/2024 13:45

I think you should think about how long you would live there, the costs of moving again (very expensive), whether you have family and friends to fall back on if problems arise, and your ability to rebuild your savings after purchase. Good luck.

Wakeywake · 15/01/2024 10:22

We had nothing left in savings after we bought our first house and paid for moving. In fact, we slept on a duvet on the floor for the first month as we couldn't afford to buy a bed. It was worth it, though.

BMW6 · 15/01/2024 10:22

We decided to keep back a safety net of 10k.

deepsea9 · 15/01/2024 10:19

When we were FTBs and in our early 30s we threw everything we had at our first place, we did keep a bit back for furniture etc.

When we upsized last year we were older (and wiser) and have had 3 redundancies between us and one main earner. We've kept back six months post tax salary as I just wasn't comfortable not having accessible cash and will overpay the mortgage.

Housebuyer37 · 15/01/2024 10:14

Hardly anything but savings don't put a roof over your head. Totally depends on your situation, we needed to buy asap so all our money went into it.

Luckily we have secure jobs so could build up savings again.

gardenfoundry · 15/01/2024 09:42

IIRC we had about £5k in savings after purchasing the house to help pay for some much-wanted renovations.

NonSequentialRhubarb · 15/01/2024 09:37

We're looking to move at the moment. We have about £100k equity in the house and plan to only put £70k down for the deposit (15%). The rest we're keeping as cash to repay our existing savings that we spend during the moving process.

We're buying a new build so don't need a fund for repairs or renovating, but will probably pay for some upgrades and eventual decorating.

kelsaecobbles · 15/01/2024 09:06

2/3 of your cash will buy a reasonable house

Say 200k

Leaving you with 100k savings

Or 4/5 to buy another home - 240 leaving you with 60k

You may spend 20k on moving costs and new home stuff like curtains and dodgy boilers

Leaving you with at least 40k which would be a years salary or more - advice is usually 3 to 6 months

Since moving is say 20k expensive if you would move again from the cheaper home it's barely worth it is it?

Of course if the house prices you are considering are significantly more expensive it might feel different but you would still have tens of thousands saved

WonderingAboutBabies · 15/01/2024 08:58

It depends on your financial situation. Is your job secure? Do you have enough coming in each month to cover any emergency repairs i.e. broken boiler, faulty wiring etc? If not, I'd have a little emergency fund saved.

We bought a do-upper 2 bedroom flat with a 29% deposit. We held £15,000 back - £10,000 for new carpeting, electrics, bathroom, radiators, decorating, etc. and £5,000 for emergencies (which we haven't had to use yet phew!!).

ftmpleasebekind · 15/01/2024 08:54

MNUse · 14/01/2024 21:45

Not really an AIBU, and I’m really sorry if the title is annoying/offensive or to some given that house-buying at all let alone house-buying with savings reserved is so hard at the moment. But if you did buy a house and were in a position to reserve some savings as well, how much did you keep for savings vs spending on house budget? Basically looking to buy and wondering whether to try and spend at the top of my budget in order to try and get somewhere I love and could stay a long time in (with say about a fifth of my total money kept in savings) or buy something that’s ok and keep a more substantial amount in savings (about a third of my total money). How did you decide?

YABU - prioritise savings
YANBU - prioritise house budget (calling this YANBU since that’s what I’m inclined to do)

We had around 5k left in savings. Though we had rented before buying so had a lot of furniture, washing machine etc and the house we bought didn't need anything doing to it. So once we had paid the deposit and fees we didn't have anything major to then spend money on.
So it was just an emergency fund.

Startingagainandagain · 15/01/2024 08:48

Thankfully I had some savings left as the house needed a lot of stuffed done (rewiring, new boiler, fix a leak in the toilet, have some of the gutters replaced, kitchen drain repair). I did the painting, remove the carpets and restore the flooring myself but again needed some money to buy supplies.

I still have a little bit saved which is making me nervous so I am saving everything I can to have money if the roof needs work next...

I would say unless you buy a complete new built you need to keep some savings to cover repairs.

It is likely you will find stuff that the survey won't have picked up once you have bought your new home...

TreeStone · 15/01/2024 08:28

FTB? We absolutely emptied out our savings, we were scraping around to buy tins of paint.
If we'd needed anything urgent like a new boiler it would have had to go on a credit card. It did need new kitchen and bathroom but we saved up for them once we'd moved.

Our parents really encouraged us to get the biggest house we could stretch to. Also our previous rent had been more than the mortgage so we had more disposable income after we'd moved.

Kazzyhoward · 15/01/2024 08:19

We did half and half. It was a long time ago, but we'd saved £50k. £25k went as the deposit and the other £25k was held back as we knew we wanted to do work on the house - nothing major like extensions nor roof, but new kitchen/bathroom, redecoration, and a bit of electrical work. Glad we saved back so much as we soon burned through the £25k as everything is more expensive than you imagine and so much "extra" work needed doing that we hadn't realised. We'd never have spent it all on the deposit which would have left us with nothing for the work that needed doing. At the time we pondered a more expensive house and using more of the savings for the deposit (and higher mortgage), but glad we didn't.