Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I really need to some advice here

82 replies

Dearymee · 14/01/2024 21:14

I’m going to try and make this as unidentifiable as possible for what will become obvious reasons. Salaries are adjusted to be not identifying but are not base rate tax payer salaries.

im in tech and I I started a new role 4 months ago, got a pay rise to 60k. How ever they’ve jut put me at risk, and it looks like it’s rapid turn around for compulsory redundancies. As of yet I don’t know if I’ll be selected BUT last In first out tends to be the way BUT tbh I would say I’m the best and most qualified person for the job. BUT I’ve no indication either way and the entire department was advised to look for other roles outside the business and to use our connections and even to go back to our old employer if we can. 50% of us will be going. However, the whole thing has been handled very very poorly (I won’t go into it but it’s jaw dropping) As a result there will be a settlement (over 10k)

so I’ve been looking

I’ve got an interview (65-80k)and then a final informal chat on another (55k) realistically the former is probably out of my reach

i pulled in a connection and got a wink wink nudge nudge tenative we’ll Mickey Mouse the interview at my old employer. Different role but same salary range. BUT the max salary is 5k less than my current salary and they won’t pay me the max. So I’d be looking at 7 maybe even 10 less, but the job isn’t live yet so I don’t know. BUT the benefit package is a lot better. I sort of feel indebted to them now.

BUT I still don’t know if I’m going to be laid off.

leaving only makes sense IF I’m being laid off and will get a settlement. I can probably make that happen if I put myself forward for it but I have to do it very very soon.

ultimately my views on my current work place have changed and the culture has taken a massive shift and it’s become very unpleasant. That being said I could make it work, if I wanted (if not laid off) but I don’t want to.

so my options as I see it;

do nothing - get laid off, my old employer don’t shaft me and offer 7k pay cut to 53k. Fine. Settlement and benefits work to not put me at a financial disadvantage.

do nothing but NOT laid off - and quit. No settlement and pay cut in other job= financial disadvantage.

put myself forward for redundancy- get settlement go to old employer, fine

put myself forward for redundancy- settlement but old employer shafts me pay wise and don’t get to other jobs and I’m stuffed. unlikely but still in the realm of possibility

do I put myself forward for being laid off as I think leaving is the best bet for me but it only makes financial sense if I get a payout.

do I do it?

OP posts:
Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:48

Menomeno · 14/01/2024 22:37

I wouldn’t count on any settlement. A company on the verge of collapse isn’t going to go throwing £10Ks round like confetti to people that they don’t need to pay a penny to by law.

Could you manage on the lower salary at your old employer? Were you happy there, but just tempted by the higher salary of the new place?

We’ll get it combined with an NDA.

i was happy, bored but well respected. I can manage on the lower salary. That’s exactly it, I was approached and tempted away by the sudden increase in salary

OP posts:
DNLove · 14/01/2024 22:46

Sounds to me like your current employer is being specifically vague so that people are in the position you are in now. They are hoping that people will jump ship to secure a role and won't hang around for redundancy. This cuts down on their redundancy costs. Do you want to work for a company that will treat it's staff in this way? Likely after this round if redundancies there will an awful atmosphere, increased workload on people, lack of clarity about real ownership. Most likely won't be an enjoyable place to work.
Your aim here is to not miss out on the £10k if you are one of the people on the chopping block.
If your previous employer has created a role for you they clearly want you back. There's likely no urgency in getting you into the role.
I would be honest with your old employer, tell them that you don't want to prematurely quit your existing role until you know if you are eligible for the payout. You are 100% taking their offer but you are unable to confirm the start date until things are sorted with existing employer. I'm sure you're current employer has some rough time line they can provide to give old employer an idea of start date.

Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:46

Mumof2teens79 · 14/01/2024 22:34

No you can offer VR to the same group/roles. Doesn't need to be business wide (early retirement does) and always company discretion. People can also volunteer from any department but obviously less likely to be accepted if their department is not at risk.

The distinction here is that they are probably not offering enhanced redundancy pay for VR.

Is the "settlement" over and above statutory redundancy pay? The whole settlement issue is confusing me.
Also why they would officially advise everyone to look for alternatives if they are only losing 50%....unless they are hoping you all quit.

You just be honest with old employer.....really want to come back but its too early for me to accept any offer....can you hold that thought while we wait and see if I am made redundant? As obviously I don't want to lose the payout especially as you offer is less than I get now.

Yeah it’s way above it, statutory for me would be nothing. Now it is related to seniority so in truth the lower paid individuals it will be significantly less. I wish I could give more detail but it would be outing.

re looking for jobs, I think the rapid nature of the process would mean it would be hard to most to secure a role. It s a consistent message from my peers that we’ve been told ‘ to see the process through but explore all options’

OP posts:
Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:38

Thank you @laclochette it’s about 3 months pay roughly (after tax) but it will be tax free. What makes it appealing is If I was walking into another job, my car died on its arse so I need another one and that would be a weight off

i don’t owe them? I really feel like I do? Esp if they created a job for Me? I’m worried about burning bridges

OP posts:
Menomeno · 14/01/2024 22:37

I wouldn’t count on any settlement. A company on the verge of collapse isn’t going to go throwing £10Ks round like confetti to people that they don’t need to pay a penny to by law.

Could you manage on the lower salary at your old employer? Were you happy there, but just tempted by the higher salary of the new place?

Mumof2teens79 · 14/01/2024 22:34

No you can offer VR to the same group/roles. Doesn't need to be business wide (early retirement does) and always company discretion. People can also volunteer from any department but obviously less likely to be accepted if their department is not at risk.

The distinction here is that they are probably not offering enhanced redundancy pay for VR.

Is the "settlement" over and above statutory redundancy pay? The whole settlement issue is confusing me.
Also why they would officially advise everyone to look for alternatives if they are only losing 50%....unless they are hoping you all quit.

You just be honest with old employer.....really want to come back but its too early for me to accept any offer....can you hold that thought while we wait and see if I am made redundant? As obviously I don't want to lose the payout especially as you offer is less than I get now.

Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:33

CrapBucket · 14/01/2024 22:28

This is not how businesses work. You say to them, thanks for the offer, I need to finalise arrangements at my current company, I will come back to you in the next 48 hours or so.

I am baffled how you can be juggling so many well paid opportunities and yet unable to deal with a simple situation?

Why be mean? But I’ll tell you why I’m not my best self. 2 weeks before being out at risk, my dad died. My dad was my best friend, who I’d talk to about this, he was so proud I got a job at a salary that I deserved. I lost him suddenly and the rug got pulled out from underneath me, and I feel like I’m drowning at the best of times. This on top, I can’t see.

OP posts:
laclochette · 14/01/2024 22:31

Oh and don't feel indebted to your old employer. You're making a "distressed purchase" going there. Find the best role out there for you.

Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:29

Tel12 · 14/01/2024 22:27

With 50 percent of the workforce going I would say that you have a very high chance if being among them. Personally I would try to secure the post with your old employer. You can always look elsewhere when the dust settles. A bird in the hand and all that.

I think I’d need to stay at least a year, at least or that bridge would be burned

OP posts:
laclochette · 14/01/2024 22:29

I wouldn't let yourself get too distracted by the settlement. I know £10k is a lot of money in some senses, but it's a one off payment. In a few years you won't remember it, and it's your salary, not anything like this that affects eg your lending power for a mortgage, your position from which to negotiate your NEXT role and salary, and so on. It is hard to say as you haven't given actual figures, but I'm going to hazard a guess that £10k is only equivalent to few months' take home pay.

I would also see your current job as a place to get away from. Even if you're kept on it'll be a horrible atmosphere, and there may be further cuts etc if they are in a bad way. You say leaving only makes sense if you get a settlement, but based on your other comments, I don't agree - it sounds like you don't respect the organisation much any more, and so the best thing is absolutely to move on.

So my approach would be - time to move on to the best possible role. It's better not to be made redundant, in case you don't have a job lined up immediately, so don't take redundancy for ultimately a pretty small settlement, but focus on finding the best possible job and getting out of there ASAP on your own time, without the stress of wondering if you can get a new role before you've spent your way through the £10k settlement.

In a year's time you can be comfortable in a whole new role and all this will be behind you.

CrapBucket · 14/01/2024 22:28

Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:23

They’ll want an immediate answer when they issue a job offer because they’ve literally created a position out of thin air but it’s my current place, if I’m going to be selected for redundancy it’s fine but if not then I pretty much ‘have to’ quit ( I mean I don’t have a gun to my head but my old employer created a job out of nothing for me so I do feel indebted)

This is not how businesses work. You say to them, thanks for the offer, I need to finalise arrangements at my current company, I will come back to you in the next 48 hours or so.

I am baffled how you can be juggling so many well paid opportunities and yet unable to deal with a simple situation?

Tel12 · 14/01/2024 22:27

With 50 percent of the workforce going I would say that you have a very high chance if being among them. Personally I would try to secure the post with your old employer. You can always look elsewhere when the dust settles. A bird in the hand and all that.

Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:24

Mumof2teens79 · 14/01/2024 22:22

Isn't that the definition of voluntary redundancy?

Apparently not, because I think that might be business wide, I’ve not got a clue. You can put yourself forward for redundancy (if you’re at risk) but the business ultimately can say no, so i think that’s the distinction

OP posts:
Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:23

Curlewwoohoo · 14/01/2024 22:19

When do you need to let your old employer know by?

They’ll want an immediate answer when they issue a job offer because they’ve literally created a position out of thin air but it’s my current place, if I’m going to be selected for redundancy it’s fine but if not then I pretty much ‘have to’ quit ( I mean I don’t have a gun to my head but my old employer created a job out of nothing for me so I do feel indebted)

OP posts:
Mumof2teens79 · 14/01/2024 22:22

Dearymee · 14/01/2024 21:31

Yes I will. The nature of the settlement has been provided in writing as has what it would mean to me has been provided in writing to each potentially impacted individual. Voluntary redundancy is not being offered but if you are at risk you can put yourself forward for redundancy at the businesses discretion

Isn't that the definition of voluntary redundancy?

Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:20

Annacondas · 14/01/2024 22:16

@Dearymee you seem to be the type of person who mentally struggles with a lot

Since common sense and practicality aren’t what you want to hear enjoy making this decision. Pointless for anyone to post since you’ve decided to make this into a drama

And you sound like a nasty piece of work

but that is precisely want i want to hear and need to hear. My old employer is pretty much guaranteed but the salary not so much. Other offer 75% of the way and salary has been discussed. I want to leave my current job but it’s only worth while if I’m actually made redundant. If I quit, not so much

OP posts:
Curlewwoohoo · 14/01/2024 22:19

When do you need to let your old employer know by?

Charlie2121 · 14/01/2024 22:17

MadeOfAllWork · 14/01/2024 21:33

Almost certainly last in first out. You are the cheapest to get rid of. Also, this sounds like a shoddy company that you are best out of.

Last in first out is illegal.

Annacondas · 14/01/2024 22:16

@Dearymee you seem to be the type of person who mentally struggles with a lot

Since common sense and practicality aren’t what you want to hear enjoy making this decision. Pointless for anyone to post since you’ve decided to make this into a drama

Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:14

Annacondas · 14/01/2024 22:10

@Dearymee but you’re not obligated to return

Jesus wept.

no need for snarky comments thanks, im already mentally struggling with this.

i feel as though I am as they have created a position for me and whilst yeah no gun is to my head, it would be a bridge forever burned

OP posts:
Annacondas · 14/01/2024 22:10

@Dearymee but you’re not obligated to return

Jesus wept.

Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:09

Annacondas · 14/01/2024 22:06

Why are you panicking.

Calm down and take a step back

Currently you have no offers on the table. So don’t put yourself forwards for redundancy.

It’s quite a simple choice

Because it’s a huge decision and I feel obligated now to return to my old employer

OP posts:
Annacondas · 14/01/2024 22:06

Why are you panicking.

Calm down and take a step back

Currently you have no offers on the table. So don’t put yourself forwards for redundancy.

It’s quite a simple choice

Dearymee · 14/01/2024 22:05

Anyone? I’m like frozen and panicking

OP posts:
Dearymee · 14/01/2024 21:44

Annacondas · 14/01/2024 21:40

Why can’t you just wait a little bit and see if you get an actual offer from the interview mentioned in your post or your old employer offers a contract.

Tell both you need to move the process along, get an actual offer in writing then put yourself forward for redundancy.

There is a deadline of when you can put yourself forward that’s most likely going to be before all of that as it is very very soon

ive said to my current employer need to know as have many, and nothing, it’s part of why it’s been done so poorly. Can’t get into the ins and outs but it’s definitely intentional to keep people guessing

OP posts: