Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The taboo of disliking your Mother

105 replies

Daughternotdaughter · 14/01/2024 16:57

Name changed for this as I don't want it linked to previous posts.

I've spent a wonderful afternoon visiting with my aunt who I treat as my honorary Mom. She fulfilled the nurturing element of my childhood and continues to fulfill that role into my adult life.

I always had a difficult relationship with my Mother, she is hyper critical of me; I'm never quite good enough, thin enough, responsible enough. I hold a very senior position in a professional, registered role, I'm married, have a child and we're mortgage free. I have a normal BMI but I'm very strict with my diet.

I dislike my Mother and have little respect for her, she is self-absorbed and has tantrums if she doesn't get her own way. Growing up we always pandered to her moods with our Father frequently telling us, "don't upset your mother". I lived in fear of her moods, outbursts and silent treatment.

There's a societal tendency to idealise the mother-daughter relationship, and those facing difficulties in this dynamic may feel societal judgment. It's crucial for society to acknowledge the complexity of such relationships and provide support rather than judgment for those navigating challenging familial dynamics. Comments such as "you can't dislike your mother" and "you only have one Mom, you'll miss her when she's gone" perpetuate the belief of the idealised relationship and essentially gaslight the child.

It would be interesting to hear from those in a similar situation and how you navigate the above responses.

OP posts:
SusieSussex · 14/01/2024 17:07

I'm in the same boat. I don't like, let alone love my mother. There is no bond there. This isn't because I'm a heartless person, it's because my mother bullied me senseless as a child. She was also burdening me with her mental health and marriage problems and crying over her crush on her pottery teacher when I was 6 years old. I could certainly never turn to her for support and she was such a bully that it killed any bond i may have had. She hit me a lot and it would sometimes be more like laying in to me than hitting. It used to upset me how she treated my dad, but as I grew older I realised that there was not much I could do about it.

I just explain to people that she bullied me and that if they met her they'd think she was sweet, but that some people are different behind closed doors. If pressed I would probably point out that people thought Harold Shipman was a lovely man.

I refuse to be gaslit about it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/01/2024 17:05

I didn’t exactly dislike my mother but I didn’t feel any real warmth towards her or identity with her and didn’t much respect her.

I don’t think it’s as uncommon as you suggest. Blood ties are no guarantee of closeness.

Testina · 14/01/2024 17:03

I was the only child of 6 not to attend mother’s funeral. Since I turned 18 until she died when I was 50, I saw her maybe 10 times? With two 10 year periods of not seeing her. Suffice to say that’s a tricky relationship.

In all that time, my relationship with my mother has come up in some detail with friends, and more in passing with others. I don’t go on about it, but for example if asked by a colleague how often I visit, I might say, “Ah - we’re not close actually” and move on.

I can remember the one and only time I had a negative reaction - and I remember that the other person present shut down that person instantly, not me.

So I don’t recognise your experience at all. Quite the opposite - specific to my own case and in general conversation, I hear, “mother daughter relationship - they can be difficult things”.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 14/01/2024 17:02

At best: Good for them that they've been so fortunate as to not have any comprehension of how abusive a parent can be.

When I'm actively being harangued because 'but it's your mother/blood's thicker than water/you'll miss her when she's gone/I wish mine was here?

Fucking morons want to piss right off/that is literally the exact opposite of what the full quote means/I might, but I've missed having a loving, nurturing parent all my fucking life, so I'd only be missing what I should have had from the outset/I'm sorry for your loss now fuck off imposing your experiences over mine.

Dacadactyl · 14/01/2024 17:00

I just joke about it with otherz tbh. I just say "you've not had to put up with her!"

My mum is a funny case because she was a fantastic mum growing up, but now she provides practical support, but she cannot empathise or provide emotional support at all. This is difficult and she is also very critical.