Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child’s birthday money/savings

93 replies

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 16:53

Hi,
please tell me if I’m being unreasonable or not.

my DC turned 1 at the beginning of last year. We had a birthday party with family & friends and the majority of them gave money for us to put into her account. Me & DP aren’t married so my DC has my DP’s surname. I asked him for months and months once she was born to open up a savings account for her. This was never done so I made an appointment with the bank & got 1 opened for them.

since I’ve opened the savings account for DC I have never taken any money from it, I see it as their money to spend on what they see fit when they are older. I have a standing order that transfers money from my account to their account every month. He has never put any money in there.

for what it’s worth I only work 2 days a week, my wage goes mostly on nursery fees, phone bill & im left with about £100 at the end of the month. He pays all the bills for the house & our lifestyle. We’re lucky that he earns very well and I have the opportunity to only work 2 days a week.

every now and then I will mention to him about the £250 from DC birthday, he always says he’ll do it when he gets round to it however today he’s now said that ‘DC will never go without so therefore doesn’t need the £250, he pays for everything for her so she won’t miss the money’

my argument is that money was given to her by family and friends so it should go to her.
Ive said to him he can have access to her savings account, he can open his own savings account but he’s not interested.

my mum is very funny with money so he has now made a few comments that I’m being funny and making him feel guilty for taking the money.

i never had any savings as a child so I’m only doing what I think is best for my DC. Am I wrong for that? Open to being told I am unreasonable

OP posts:
ColourByNumbers88 · 14/01/2024 20:43

@Victoriaspongecake1 I think you are doing a really clever thing to save the gift money, but get it into a kids isa to take the tax advantage. That will pay Uni fees/a house deposit/whatever they need as a young adult and it will build up to thousands.

I think you need to change your mindset from "working more to contribute more to the daily finances" though. You are already saving him nursery fees by not working on those days, think if it that way. You need to get that child benefit sorted to get your national insurance contribution. The nursery fees should be coming from the joint account (which should be in both names) so it's clear what the household finances are.

As an unmarried partner you need to get back to work and ensure you are contributing to a pension or you are going to be totally screwed at retirement age. You said you are paying money by standing order into savings for your child but you should be paying this into a pension for yourself or an isa for yourself. Plan for the future.

As a part time worker I'd be getting married asap. I was in a long term relationship with a high earner and when we split up I wasn't entitled to any of his pension. Don't be me.

Moonshine5 · 14/01/2024 20:32

ArnieLinson · 14/01/2024 17:06

firstly, Me & DP aren’t married so my DC has my DP’s surname
this makes absolutely no sense. If you are not married the child should have the mother’s name.

secondly, he has stolen money from your child. That was her money, not family money. He needs to out it in the bank account. Do not give him access. He has proven he cannot be trusted. And change it to a junior isa. He will try to take it i will bet my last rolo on that.

why are you so very part time with a man you arent married to who steals from his own daughter? Is he paying into a private pension for you, or topping up your very part time one? Are you still claiming child benefit for your state pension contributions?

why, if you are working so very part time, are you paying all the nursery fees? Why are you left with less than £25 a week if he earns so well?

Edited

The surname explanation makes no sense, you could have given your name. Still be your DP child

PeloMom · 14/01/2024 20:29

Now you know on go forward basis you collect any money gifted to your child and put them in the account otherwise she won’t ever see them.

Thatladdo · 14/01/2024 20:27

"firstly, Me & DP aren’t married so my DC has my DP’s surname
this makes absolutely no sense. If you are not married the child should have the mother’s name."

Thats nonsense.

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 20:24

PonyPatter44 · 14/01/2024 20:10

Copied from the Gov.uk website;
You’ll get National Insurance credits automatically if you claim Child Benefit and your child is under 12.

These credits count towards your State Pension, so you do not have gaps in your National Insurance record if either:
you’re not working
you do not earn enough to pay National Insurance contributions

You can make a claim and opt out of getting payments if you do not want to pay the charge. You can still get the other advantages provided by Child Benefit, like National Insurance credits

The bit in bold is possibly more important for you. Also, child benefit would be a bit of money for you that's out of his direct control. That's always a worthwhile thing to consider.

Thank you, that’s very helpful. I didn’t know about this. I thought he would have to pay it back in his tax. I’ll get onto this now

OP posts:
Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 20:24

Weallnamechangesometimes · 14/01/2024 20:22

Please claim child benefit but asked not to be paid it. That way your national insurance contribution is covered and your child will get their ni number without any fuss when they are 16

Thank you, I will do. I didn’t realise I could do this. That’s very helpful

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 14/01/2024 20:22

Absolutely unfair to not put it into their account or bought something so specific with it. People don’t give money for it to sit in a parents account

Weallnamechangesometimes · 14/01/2024 20:22

Please claim child benefit but asked not to be paid it. That way your national insurance contribution is covered and your child will get their ni number without any fuss when they are 16

SecondHandFurniture · 14/01/2024 20:17

I can't believe how weird he's being about this when he earns what he earns. It's like he begrudges paying a larger proportion of the bills due to child/you working PT due to child, and saw this as some kind of refund.

Doyouwantmejusttogo · 14/01/2024 20:17

He stole £250 from a baby? He sounds like a catch.

TeaKitten · 14/01/2024 20:13

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 20:07

Having tried to have a serious conversation with him about this is like banging my head against a brick wall.

he said he hasn’t spent it, it’s always available to her if she wants it. He says he realises it should have gone to her but he never got round to it which I believe to be bull.

i just wanted the money in her account, apparently it was the way I went about it but I don’t know how else I could approach the subject.

the joke of it all is he is a very good earner, he’s very good with money - he saves hard, rarely spends any money on himself etc so this situation really threw me. I hate the fact that I will now have to be on top of the cash from her bday/xmas cards. It was only when I realise the cash had gone from on top of the microwave that I mentioned where did it go

Can you actually see all his accounts and how much he spends? You can see he’s controlling with money right?

PonyPatter44 · 14/01/2024 20:10

Copied from the Gov.uk website;
You’ll get National Insurance credits automatically if you claim Child Benefit and your child is under 12.

These credits count towards your State Pension, so you do not have gaps in your National Insurance record if either:
you’re not working
you do not earn enough to pay National Insurance contributions

You can make a claim and opt out of getting payments if you do not want to pay the charge. You can still get the other advantages provided by Child Benefit, like National Insurance credits

The bit in bold is possibly more important for you. Also, child benefit would be a bit of money for you that's out of his direct control. That's always a worthwhile thing to consider.

lieselotte · 14/01/2024 20:07

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 17:22

I always thought by putting any money received for them to go into an account. I never had a savings account as a child so thought I was doing the right thing.

I see what you mean with putting the money towards things they may need such as clothes or trips out etc

No, it's their birthday money and should go into an account for them. As they get older it's for them to spend or save as they see fit.

It's not for parents to spend, even on things for the child.

CaramelMac · 14/01/2024 20:07

Aww bless him, he’s obviously in such dire straights he’s had to use his child’s birthday money to pay his bills. 🙄

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 20:07

Lavender14 · 14/01/2024 19:47

I totally agree with pps. We have a savings account for ds (1) and any money that we get for him goes into that as well as the child benefit every 4 weeks. Sometimes if he needs something and there's enough there we will use his account to buy things for him but it's always topped up again and money from it is only ever spent on him directly eg. car seat or clothes.

I think it's super unethical that your dp has just taken all of your dds birthday presents and kept it for himself to be spent on ???. I'd sit down with your dp and say you need to agree some boundaries around finances. I'd agree that everything given to dd is to be put in an account and held for her to use as she gets older for whatever she wants. I'd ask specifically what your dp has spent the £250 on or if he's just keeping it for himself.

I'd set up a joint account for all bills and both of you pay into that according to the %difference in your earnings. I'd also handle all money for dd from now on so dp doesn't get it first.

Truthfully his cageyness around this would worry me and I think I'd be doing some digging into his statements etc. If he's as well off as he sounds then why wouldn't he happily put £250 in an account for dd and be paying into it regularly... that doesn't add up to me and suggests there's mismanagement of money happening. I'm not sure why it's all left to you. He's also sounding a bit gaslighty with him saying you're being strange with money like your mum when what you're asking is just common sense and securing your child's future... I'd make sure you have your own savings building up op just incase for future.

Having tried to have a serious conversation with him about this is like banging my head against a brick wall.

he said he hasn’t spent it, it’s always available to her if she wants it. He says he realises it should have gone to her but he never got round to it which I believe to be bull.

i just wanted the money in her account, apparently it was the way I went about it but I don’t know how else I could approach the subject.

the joke of it all is he is a very good earner, he’s very good with money - he saves hard, rarely spends any money on himself etc so this situation really threw me. I hate the fact that I will now have to be on top of the cash from her bday/xmas cards. It was only when I realise the cash had gone from on top of the microwave that I mentioned where did it go

OP posts:
WhereIsMyLight · 14/01/2024 20:05

TeaKitten · 14/01/2024 19:38

If you plan on teaching them how to deal with money then they should be fine with savings, just because you no people who’ve been stupid at 18 doesn’t mean everyone will be. I think it’s a pretty shitty way to do things really, punishing them for mistakes you are teaching them not to make anyway. Risky as well because you might save nothing with the intension to pay for things, and then you could end up broke, ill or dead and theyl just have nothing because you chose that for them. Each to their own though.

DH’s parents are accountants, they taught him and his sibling how to deal with money. His sibling is shit with money. You can teach as much as you want, personality sometimes still wins out. DH’s sibling went into debt for their wedding. They received £6,000 from relatives at their wedding (they told us this), still had debt. Then when the marriage lasted a year, they needed money from his parents to pay for the divorce. As I said, my parent’s sibling displayed similar behaviour, although it was designer clothes.

It’s not a punishment. They are currently a toddler but as I said, we plan to teach saving and we expect them to make mistakes. We certainly have. They just won’t make those mistakes with any significant sums of money. There’s a finite pot of money and so that money isn’t going to come back if they make a mistake with it. Why is it a punishment to put steps in place to stop them wasting big chunks of money? Especially when there’s irresponsible genes on both sides?

If we end up broke, then I’d be even more pissed off if they piss the money away. If we end up dead, then life insurance will kick in, clear the mortgage and leave some after that. Obviously we would have no control over what they do with a very large sum of money then but we’ll be dead so won’t care and there is no backup if they blow it all. We are saving now, we plan to continue saving. Again, as I said in my first post, we top up that savings account each month and have done since they were born. It’s just not in their name. It is spent on things for them, money comes out but it is growing slightly each year.

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 20:02

PonyPatter44 · 14/01/2024 19:31

Why do you keep talking about child maintenance? Is your DP not DDs father? Or do you mean child benefit? I would STRONGLY advise you to claim it, as it ensures your National Insurance entitlement. Your DP will be taxed on it but its important for you.

I mean child benefit rather than maintenance sorry. He is DC’s dad but he earns over the threshold so if I was to claim it he would have to pay it back in his self assessment. What’s the point in claiming something that he would have to pay? He may as well just give me free rein on the credit card than doing that?

OP posts:
Lavender14 · 14/01/2024 19:47

I totally agree with pps. We have a savings account for ds (1) and any money that we get for him goes into that as well as the child benefit every 4 weeks. Sometimes if he needs something and there's enough there we will use his account to buy things for him but it's always topped up again and money from it is only ever spent on him directly eg. car seat or clothes.

I think it's super unethical that your dp has just taken all of your dds birthday presents and kept it for himself to be spent on ???. I'd sit down with your dp and say you need to agree some boundaries around finances. I'd agree that everything given to dd is to be put in an account and held for her to use as she gets older for whatever she wants. I'd ask specifically what your dp has spent the £250 on or if he's just keeping it for himself.

I'd set up a joint account for all bills and both of you pay into that according to the %difference in your earnings. I'd also handle all money for dd from now on so dp doesn't get it first.

Truthfully his cageyness around this would worry me and I think I'd be doing some digging into his statements etc. If he's as well off as he sounds then why wouldn't he happily put £250 in an account for dd and be paying into it regularly... that doesn't add up to me and suggests there's mismanagement of money happening. I'm not sure why it's all left to you. He's also sounding a bit gaslighty with him saying you're being strange with money like your mum when what you're asking is just common sense and securing your child's future... I'd make sure you have your own savings building up op just incase for future.

SisterMichaelsHabit · 14/01/2024 19:40

Oh if you're concerned about them getting it at 18, maybe look at a Junior SIPP instead of a Junior ISA, it's also tax-efficient and they can't get it until they're close to retirement so it has ages to grow. Really I think you both need proper financial advice that you can both action together as a united couple in a way that best benefits your child.

TeaKitten · 14/01/2024 19:38

WhereIsMyLight · 14/01/2024 19:06

To address the questions:

Our DC is a toddler. As they get older, they can have more of a day in what they spend their Christmas and birthday money on. I said we plan on teaching financial literacy as they get older and about saving for things they want.

We have chosen not to open a savings account as I explained in my original post because you can teach financial literacy but it doesn’t always translate to actual financial literacy. We have seen this in both sides of our families. One is my parent and their sibling. One is DH and his sibling. Both siblings are financially irresponsible and would (and have) piss away a sum of money. I’m off the opinion that some money on experiences is fine, it’s why people save for holidays, but I don’t see the value in pissing away that money on endless pointless shit, drinking and shopping. At 18 that money is theirs and I can’t stop them pissing that away, even if it’s been really bloody hard to put that money away for them at the time.

Again, as I said in my original post, we plan on paying for driving lessons. I’m not sure if we will purchase a car or pay for the insurance on ours, that’ll be something we work out when it happens and will depend on insurance rates, how expensive cars are, whether they can get a decent run around. Yes, we plan to pay for university (if they choose to go), we might not be able to cover tuition fees but they won’t save enough to cover that anyway. One of the main reasons we will likely only have one DC is so that we can help them with driving lessons, university, a house deposit.

No, we are not loaded. But we have seen sums of money given at 18 go to shit and have chosen a different route.

If you plan on teaching them how to deal with money then they should be fine with savings, just because you no people who’ve been stupid at 18 doesn’t mean everyone will be. I think it’s a pretty shitty way to do things really, punishing them for mistakes you are teaching them not to make anyway. Risky as well because you might save nothing with the intension to pay for things, and then you could end up broke, ill or dead and theyl just have nothing because you chose that for them. Each to their own though.

SisterMichaelsHabit · 14/01/2024 19:37

OP you need to explain compound interest (and tax efficient savings for DC) to him! That money should all go from DC's account into a Junior ISA no one can touch until DC is 18, because the earlier the money goes in, the more compound interest it earns!
When DC is 18, that £250 will be worth more than £250.

I would approach this with your DP by not making it about who did what with the £250, but making it about whether it's been put in the best place for it to benefit your DC. That's the best way to get through to him that this money should be invested for future success and that you are with him not against him.

If he's a high earner and doesn't have any investments (especially tax efficient ones like pensions and ISAs) he's doing all of you a disservice as that money isn't working best for you all.

You could do with getting him to speak to an IFA about what money he's got and how it's being invested both for him and DC so he understands where you're coming from!

PonyPatter44 · 14/01/2024 19:31

Why do you keep talking about child maintenance? Is your DP not DDs father? Or do you mean child benefit? I would STRONGLY advise you to claim it, as it ensures your National Insurance entitlement. Your DP will be taxed on it but its important for you.

MamaMode · 14/01/2024 19:29

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 17:24

It’s a credit card that gets cleared at the end of the month. If I was to withdraw money from it, there would be a charge.

i did mention about taking the money from the joint account but he said I was being funny about money & it’s not a nice trait to have

Buy £250 of vouchers (Toy store /child clothing store) from the credit card then 🤷🏽‍♀️

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 19:26

No we have clear wills. I was adamant about that as I loss a parent at a very young age & have experienced what can happen to a family when a parent dies unexpectedly and very young.

I don’t think we will see eye to eye on this matter, the most important thing is the money is rightfully in her account.

I will look at going back to work more days & moving the nursery fees to the joint account. Working more days means I’ll have more money & financially contribute to the household.

OP posts:
ArnieLinson · 14/01/2024 19:16

he has begrudgingly transferred the money over to DC account however is now sulking upstairs as I’ve made him feel weird about it.
you have much bigger issues, op.