Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child’s birthday money/savings

93 replies

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 16:53

Hi,
please tell me if I’m being unreasonable or not.

my DC turned 1 at the beginning of last year. We had a birthday party with family & friends and the majority of them gave money for us to put into her account. Me & DP aren’t married so my DC has my DP’s surname. I asked him for months and months once she was born to open up a savings account for her. This was never done so I made an appointment with the bank & got 1 opened for them.

since I’ve opened the savings account for DC I have never taken any money from it, I see it as their money to spend on what they see fit when they are older. I have a standing order that transfers money from my account to their account every month. He has never put any money in there.

for what it’s worth I only work 2 days a week, my wage goes mostly on nursery fees, phone bill & im left with about £100 at the end of the month. He pays all the bills for the house & our lifestyle. We’re lucky that he earns very well and I have the opportunity to only work 2 days a week.

every now and then I will mention to him about the £250 from DC birthday, he always says he’ll do it when he gets round to it however today he’s now said that ‘DC will never go without so therefore doesn’t need the £250, he pays for everything for her so she won’t miss the money’

my argument is that money was given to her by family and friends so it should go to her.
Ive said to him he can have access to her savings account, he can open his own savings account but he’s not interested.

my mum is very funny with money so he has now made a few comments that I’m being funny and making him feel guilty for taking the money.

i never had any savings as a child so I’m only doing what I think is best for my DC. Am I wrong for that? Open to being told I am unreasonable

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Charlie2121 · 17/01/2024 21:15

RitaConnors · 15/01/2024 10:08

I suspect the trend of using the mother's name is more prevalent in younger less stable relationships where they think there is a realistic chance the father won’t hang around.

I think it's the opposite. I think those women are just the ones who give the baby their partners name as a way of securing him.

An independent woman thinks differently.

Well in most of the cases I know of it is the woman who is the higher earner, significantly so in many cases, so your theory certainly isn’t true in my experience.

Victoriaspongecake1 · 15/01/2024 17:08

Mel2023 · 15/01/2024 15:55

We have a savings account for our son. All his birthday money, Christmas money etc goes in it and there is no exception. Your partner absolutely needs to pay it into your DC account. It’s DC money not your DH. If it was me I’d pay it out the joint account and let him have his hissy fit over that.

Gosh, our DS got £50 cash for Christmas which I hadn’t yet paid into his account. I never have any cash in the house and DH went to my MIL with DS for a few days and accidentally took my purse with my cash and cards in the changing bag. I had to get some shopping in and literally had no money except the £50 of DS Xmas money. I of course had to use it and felt soooo guilty until I got my purse back with my ££ in it which I then used to reimburse DS. I don’t know how your DH isn’t feeling bad about it all tbh.

This would be me! I see it as their money and not mine. I’ve not been great with money in the past but I don’t want my daughter to be like that. I want to teach her about money and making good decisions. I never had that hence the bad financial decisions. but I’m so strict with her money, I’d never touch it as I see it as ‘not mine’ and not something I can dip into every now and then.

OP posts:
Victoriaspongecake1 · 15/01/2024 17:05

GabriellaMontez · 15/01/2024 14:49

I wonder how he'd feel if you announced at her next birthday celebration in front of friends and family "please don't give dd cash, her dad takes it for himself ".

Would he be OK with that?

Or would he be totally ashamed?

He would be mortified, maybe not because of what he’s done but more I’ve made a scene about it.

OP posts:
Mel2023 · 15/01/2024 15:55

We have a savings account for our son. All his birthday money, Christmas money etc goes in it and there is no exception. Your partner absolutely needs to pay it into your DC account. It’s DC money not your DH. If it was me I’d pay it out the joint account and let him have his hissy fit over that.

Gosh, our DS got £50 cash for Christmas which I hadn’t yet paid into his account. I never have any cash in the house and DH went to my MIL with DS for a few days and accidentally took my purse with my cash and cards in the changing bag. I had to get some shopping in and literally had no money except the £50 of DS Xmas money. I of course had to use it and felt soooo guilty until I got my purse back with my ££ in it which I then used to reimburse DS. I don’t know how your DH isn’t feeling bad about it all tbh.

GabriellaMontez · 15/01/2024 14:49

I wonder how he'd feel if you announced at her next birthday celebration in front of friends and family "please don't give dd cash, her dad takes it for himself ".

Would he be OK with that?

Or would he be totally ashamed?

Victoriaspongecake1 · 15/01/2024 11:44

RitaConnors · 15/01/2024 11:03

Sorry, the name thing has become a bot of a derail of your thread. Flowers

I think what's happened to you with this money issue has been a bit of a wake up call and it's a opportunity for you to keep a closer eye on your partner's attitude to money and how he speaks to you/treats you.

100%

going forward I’ll going to make changes such as transferring the nursery fees from my account to the joint account. Contributing to the joint account & whenever friends or family would like to gift money to my DC then I’ll pass along their bank details rather than accept cash.

its all well and good when things are rosey and you don’t think about what could happen to you if things do go belly up so I need to protect myself and my DC especially as we aren’t married yet.

Sometimes you need a different perspective on things from an outside POV to open your eyes and make you realise you are doing the right thing however you need to wise up at the same time

OP posts:
GabriellaMontez · 15/01/2024 11:05

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 17:24

It’s a credit card that gets cleared at the end of the month. If I was to withdraw money from it, there would be a charge.

i did mention about taking the money from the joint account but he said I was being funny about money & it’s not a nice trait to have

Stealing from your child isn't a nice trait.

RitaConnors · 15/01/2024 11:03

Sorry, the name thing has become a bot of a derail of your thread. Flowers

I think what's happened to you with this money issue has been a bit of a wake up call and it's a opportunity for you to keep a closer eye on your partner's attitude to money and how he speaks to you/treats you.

Victoriaspongecake1 · 15/01/2024 10:29

weve been together a long time, DC was always going to have DP’s surname. We’re engaged to be married however fell pregnant first and put the wedding on hold. I know many parents who aren’t married yet the children have the father’s name.

OP posts:
RitaConnors · 15/01/2024 10:08

I suspect the trend of using the mother's name is more prevalent in younger less stable relationships where they think there is a realistic chance the father won’t hang around.

I think it's the opposite. I think those women are just the ones who give the baby their partners name as a way of securing him.

An independent woman thinks differently.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 15/01/2024 08:59

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 17:24

It’s a credit card that gets cleared at the end of the month. If I was to withdraw money from it, there would be a charge.

i did mention about taking the money from the joint account but he said I was being funny about money & it’s not a nice trait to have

Over a month or two you could use the credit card to pay £250 of things you'd normally pay yourself and then transfer £250 from your account to DC account.

Charlie2121 · 15/01/2024 08:44

ArnieLinson · 14/01/2024 17:06

firstly, Me & DP aren’t married so my DC has my DP’s surname
this makes absolutely no sense. If you are not married the child should have the mother’s name.

secondly, he has stolen money from your child. That was her money, not family money. He needs to out it in the bank account. Do not give him access. He has proven he cannot be trusted. And change it to a junior isa. He will try to take it i will bet my last rolo on that.

why are you so very part time with a man you arent married to who steals from his own daughter? Is he paying into a private pension for you, or topping up your very part time one? Are you still claiming child benefit for your state pension contributions?

why, if you are working so very part time, are you paying all the nursery fees? Why are you left with less than £25 a week if he earns so well?

Edited

I know around 10 couples who are not married and every single child they have has the fathers surname.

They are all older first time parents in extremely stable relationships, many 15/20 years so no concerns about splitting up.

I suspect the trend of using the mother's name is more prevalent in younger less stable relationships where they think there is a realistic chance the father won’t hang around.

Wheresthefibre · 15/01/2024 08:36

He has all this money but doesn’t want to give the child their own £250?

SecondHandFurniture · 15/01/2024 08:33

Ah, someone has hit the nail on the head. He wanted her to have to ask for it because he likes being the big man with the wallet. Bet he loves that the "deal" with having children was that you either work PT or not at all.

skippy67 · 15/01/2024 08:29

Still sulking?? Are you sure you want to marry this Prince?!

Victoriaspongecake1 · 15/01/2024 08:23

Justbecause19 · 15/01/2024 04:20

Op in future can you get family members to transfer money directly into DC account for birthday/Christmas? This is what we do, much easier than sorting cash and DC will be able to see who has contributed in future.

going forward this is what I will be doing. It will be so much easier and there isn’t a risk of the money resting in someone else’s account.

im grateful and thankful for all of the responses as it’s given me a head wobble to see things from a different view that I wouldn’t have originally. I’ve also applied for the tax credits but not to be paid for them.

as it stands he is still sulking, Slept on the sofa last night & took himself off to work this morning before we woke up (normally I’ll drive him to the station) oh well. I know I’ve done the right thing for my child & that’s all that matters

OP posts:
Nonewclothes2024 · 15/01/2024 04:24

You are absolutely right. People have given money to your child and it should be in their account.

Justbecause19 · 15/01/2024 04:20

Op in future can you get family members to transfer money directly into DC account for birthday/Christmas? This is what we do, much easier than sorting cash and DC will be able to see who has contributed in future.

Singleandproud · 15/01/2024 00:29

It's great you've sorted out Child Benefit.

I would arrange a trip to a registry office to get married whether you have a ceremony and party or not, you've had a child and bought a house this is just another legal process to go through it doesn't have to cost much.

I'd be looking into a Junior SIPP opposed to a savings account, 18 year olds getting access to £X amount is always a gamble. When I was on my gap year one of my friends would use the savings her parents had given her to pay for her night out and treat everyone and wasted the lot. A SIPP means that when your child retires at 60 they'll still have you providing for them even if you are no longer around.

As for the £250 I would put in an extra £25 from my account for the next 10 months but use his credit card to pay for whatever I would have originally used that £25 for.

Have a little read up on financial abuse, he may not be at that level yet but it doesn't sound like he is far from it and could easily head down that avenue

laclochette · 15/01/2024 00:11

I'm afraid there's a clear pattern here. He wants his daughter's access to money to be dependent on him - "she can ask for it when she's older if she needs it", just as he seems to like you having to go to him for money.

God knows what's going on here - maybe he likes to be the big man who gets to have people coming to him in need and get to dole it out.

Money is a form of power, and it isn't your power if you have to constantly ask someone to grant it to you. It's theirs.

TheSmallAssassin · 14/01/2024 23:20

@SleepingBeautySnores we didn't get married until our kids were several years into school and even then I kept my name, so we've always had different surnames - I've never encountered any problems at school, the doctors or anywhere else and they are adults now.

TheSmallAssassin · 14/01/2024 23:14

Glad he has transferred it over.

he said he hasn’t spent it, it’s always available to her if she wants it

She shouldn't (when she's old enough) have to ask for her own money, and over the years it would be easy for it to get lost in everything else.

SleepingBeautySnores · 14/01/2024 23:04

OP I'm really pleased to read, that unlike so many women on here, you're actually taking notice of the good advice being given to you, and have managed, albeit with him sulking like a child, to get your own DC's money into their account where it should be.

I'm afraid I also agree with one or two other posters, that unless you're married your child should have your surname. I know when it's all exciting and the father wants the kudos of being the big man, having impregnated you, that some women feel obliged to give the child their father's surname, but in my opinion, if the father wants their child to have their name, then they should marry the mother, to give her and their child, the financial security that being married offers. Otherwise, when the children start nursery or school, the name of the mother not matching up with the name of the child can cause all sorts of confusion. I actually know a young woman with 2 kids who ended up changing her name by Deed Poll to that of her partner, so that at school her children were easily recognised as being hers. Much better for children to have the same surname as their mother, married or otherwise in my opinion.

RitzyMcFee · 14/01/2024 22:46

Thats nonsense.

It isn't nonsense. If you aren't married,traditionally the child has the mother's name.

Otherwise scullery maids would be giving their children the name of the lord of the manor and causing a scandal.

Victoriaspongecake1 · 14/01/2024 20:55

ColourByNumbers88 · 14/01/2024 20:43

@Victoriaspongecake1 I think you are doing a really clever thing to save the gift money, but get it into a kids isa to take the tax advantage. That will pay Uni fees/a house deposit/whatever they need as a young adult and it will build up to thousands.

I think you need to change your mindset from "working more to contribute more to the daily finances" though. You are already saving him nursery fees by not working on those days, think if it that way. You need to get that child benefit sorted to get your national insurance contribution. The nursery fees should be coming from the joint account (which should be in both names) so it's clear what the household finances are.

As an unmarried partner you need to get back to work and ensure you are contributing to a pension or you are going to be totally screwed at retirement age. You said you are paying money by standing order into savings for your child but you should be paying this into a pension for yourself or an isa for yourself. Plan for the future.

As a part time worker I'd be getting married asap. I was in a long term relationship with a high earner and when we split up I wasn't entitled to any of his pension. Don't be me.

Thank you so much. I have applied for the child tax credits to help with my pension but not receive any payment. Work did pass in conversation if I wanted to pick up any extra days at work and I will go back to them next week and see what we could agree to.

I want to be around for my DC but also want her to see a working mother and not having to rely on a man. Everything is all well and good when you’re getting on but if we do split then things can get nasty and like you said I wouldn’t be entitled to anything. I would leave myself high and dry and I do not want that to happen.

It’s funny how something so silly and ridiculous can make you second guess and question things.

OP posts: