Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we cannot accept rent via DC's bank account!?

244 replies

coucoululu · 13/01/2024 21:53

DH and I have a flat that we would like to rent out. We understand rent will be a second income and so will get taxed as such.

DH is saying if we were to open a bank account for our 10 month old, it would be his income and will only get taxed after £12,500.

I highly doubt this is ok. I have had a Google and am sure it's not allowed.

The money ultimately would be for DC and maintenance of the property but even so.

Advice greatly appreciated. X

OP posts:
Brandyginger · 13/01/2024 23:05

We have an accountant (and the tax partners at work) handle our tax affairs as my Cambridge qualified lawyer husband isn’t to be trusted with finding “loopholes”!

Flatulence · 13/01/2024 23:05

That's tax fraud.
If you like the idea of jail time, go ahead and commit it.
Otherwise, pay your tax and stop trying to find ways to avoid it.
I hope you have a more ethical approach to how you treat your tenants than you do to paying for public services via taxation.

friendlycat · 13/01/2024 23:02

You don’t need an Oxford qualified lawyer. Just a regular accountant who will tell you this is illegal.

AllEars112232 · 13/01/2024 23:02

Scrantonicity2 · 13/01/2024 22:44

I'm an Oxford qualified lawyer and you can tell DH he's stumbled upon a tax loophole only geniuses ever notice.

Definitely go ahead and do it; HMRC's view is basically that if you're clever enough to think of this ingenious scheme then you deserve to keep the money, so no issues there.

I'd be pouring him a cold beer for being such a smart boy!!

Please don't hurt his feelings by pointing out very easily Google-able points of law, it's not kind.

🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂

Toastcrumbsinsofa · 13/01/2024 23:00

Being a qualified Oxford lawyer doesn’t exempt him from paying tax (or being convicted for fraud). Don’t do it!

Tinkerbyebye · 13/01/2024 23:00

It’s tax evasion

just pay it

Spomsored · 13/01/2024 22:59

Although it is sometimes possible to find loopholes and evade tax, that is usually the prerogative of the very wealthy. This idea is so obvious every landlord in the country would be doing it (advised by every accountant) if it was possible.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/01/2024 22:59

I scraped a Diploma of Higher Education from the Open University and even I can tell that your oh, so very smart husband is clearly suffering from a serious condition.

It's called being an absolute fucking imbecile.

Changedforthisthread1 · 13/01/2024 22:57

whatkatydid2014 · 13/01/2024 22:42

This made me laugh. OH & I are both accountants with his specialty being tax and he says pretty much word for word the same. Some of his clients drive him to distraction with the refusal to believe/follow the advice they are paying him for. His other favourite is when they say I’ve done “x” so how’s best to manage that for tax. Answer is invariably ask the question before you do anything.
OP - just tell your OH it doesn’t matter if it’s a clever idea or a stupid one as regardless it’s not allowed and will just lead to you ending up with a fine.

😁

I'm on the "other side" to your OH, if you see what mean, but I will we all share similar experiences.

The worst is when it's family or friends. This is normally the conversation:
Them: I'm going to do a, b, c, so I don't have to pay tax
Me: That's not a good idea, and it wont work because tax law x, y, z
Them: You're wrong! My mate Paul told me he does it and it's fine
Me: Fine. Do it then. But when you and your mate Paul have to deal with HMRC and pay interest and penalties, do not come crying to me.^

It's always a bloody "mate" or" someone down the pub" who is giving out stupid tax advice. 😂

TeaGinandFags · 13/01/2024 22:54

Something else your DH is obviously unaware of:

If you use a letting agent they automatically inform HMRC of who their clients are and which properties are being let.

Talk to an accountant who will be able to advise on how to (legally) minimise your tax liability. Landlords are also subject to some very specific laws so a letting agent would be able to advise and supply contracts and tenant vetting. HMRC will also help as most of their investigations deal with idiots making mistakes rather than out and out crooks.

If DH won't listen make the appointments yourself. Or is he worth going to court for?

CheesecakeandCrackers · 13/01/2024 22:50

Sunnydays0101 · 13/01/2024 22:13

If your DS does not own the flat then it’s tax evasion getting the rent paid into an account in his name. It will be your name and your DH’s names on the lease, it will be you both paying management company bills, etc.

Yep, this

ireallycantthinkofaname · 13/01/2024 22:49

First thought reading this thread was 'Ewww'; as PP have said, stop trying to worm your way out of paying what you owe. It's a crime, and when it's rental income it's bloody worse, and if you're going to break the law don't also be stupid enough to ask to advice on mumsnet (of all places!) for how to do it.

Your DP's attitude stinks and would give me huge ick quite frankly!

ReadingSoManyThreads · 13/01/2024 22:46

coucoululu · 13/01/2024 22:25

Thank you everyone.

DH has also gotten really offended and called Mumsnet stupid and asked if any of you are an Oxford qualified lawyer and he isn't stupid, he had a good idea.

Just totally fed up now.

I'm not surprised you're totally fed up now. Your husband sounds like a total twat. Whilst it was "an idea", it certainly wasn't a "good idea". And "Oxford qualified lawyer", oh my goodness, I think he means a tax specialist. He may think Mumsnet is stupid, but it seems he is more stupid than this internet forum.

Be careful with this prick, he clearly can't deal with being wrong, not the sort of thing you need to deal with in a partner.

katmarie · 13/01/2024 22:46

I had a landlord that did exactly this. He was dodgy as fuck in many other ways too. He was prosecuted for tax evasion and I was interviewed by HMRC when they investigated it. They went after him for every penny they could and made his life miserable. So no, it's not a good idea, your DH is very wrong.

Scrantonicity2 · 13/01/2024 22:44

I'm an Oxford qualified lawyer and you can tell DH he's stumbled upon a tax loophole only geniuses ever notice.

Definitely go ahead and do it; HMRC's view is basically that if you're clever enough to think of this ingenious scheme then you deserve to keep the money, so no issues there.

I'd be pouring him a cold beer for being such a smart boy!!

Please don't hurt his feelings by pointing out very easily Google-able points of law, it's not kind.

XmaswasbadNYisworse · 13/01/2024 22:43

You might be able to legally save some tax by putting the property in a company, and running it that way rather than as your personal asset, particularly if you're higher rate tax payers. But whether that's a sensible option will depend on your particular circumstances, and your intentions for the property (length of time to hold, mortgage status, likely increase in value)

What your DH is proposing is illegal on several counts.

Talk to a tax specialist for permitted ways to reduce/offset what you owe.

whatkatydid2014 · 13/01/2024 22:42

Changedforthisthread1 · 13/01/2024 22:37

Oxford qualified lawyer? No
Tax Specialist? Yes.

I always say to people who come up with these stupid ideas, refuse to listen and think they are cleverer than everyone else - you know what, do it.

If he is nor going to listen to sensible advice, then he's going to do it anyway.

But, he he better not cry and whinge when HMRC open up enquiries into his tax.
He'll end up spending more money and time dealing with HMRC, than had he just paid the correct tax in the first place.

If he does go ahead, I suggest he put some savings together when he inevitably has to pay the correct tax, interest and penalties.

This made me laugh. OH & I are both accountants with his specialty being tax and he says pretty much word for word the same. Some of his clients drive him to distraction with the refusal to believe/follow the advice they are paying him for. His other favourite is when they say I’ve done “x” so how’s best to manage that for tax. Answer is invariably ask the question before you do anything.
OP - just tell your OH it doesn’t matter if it’s a clever idea or a stupid one as regardless it’s not allowed and will just lead to you ending up with a fine.

Maray1967 · 13/01/2024 22:41

Testina · 13/01/2024 22:27

Oh gosh, “Oxford qualified” isn’t making him sound any less stupid 😭

Hilarious! Does he think Oxford University teaches law on tax that other university law courses do t? Some special insights only provided at Oxford?

You’ve got an idiot DH who can’t admit he’s wrong.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 13/01/2024 22:41

It's tax evasion. Just pay FFS.

ClimbingHydrangea · 13/01/2024 22:39

@Fanlover1122 - OP and her husband would still have to pay the tax as they gave their minor child the benefit of the income producing asset. HMRC aren’t daft.

TeaGinandFags · 13/01/2024 22:39

It's legally impossible for a minor to own property so it wpuld still be treated as yours.

Them income is the money earned rather than money taken. You will be able to vlaim for expenses and wear and tear.

Get thee to an accountants (also tax deductable) and play it straight. It's the best advice.

AnneValentine · 13/01/2024 22:38

coucoululu · 13/01/2024 22:25

Thank you everyone.

DH has also gotten really offended and called Mumsnet stupid and asked if any of you are an Oxford qualified lawyer and he isn't stupid, he had a good idea.

Just totally fed up now.

It’s fraud.

10 month olds cannot open bank accounts in their name. It would be linked to yours. They also cannot receive an income.

Tell your OH he is a dickhead.

Fanlover1122 · 13/01/2024 22:38

The beneficial interest can be assigned to him....you need to go to a solicitor and have them draft a deed of transfer.....

once the above has been actioned
it can, as far as I am aware (although it’s been a while since I did this) then it can be his rent.....

worth checking in with the lawyer as it will save a lot of tax

Changedforthisthread1 · 13/01/2024 22:37

coucoululu · 13/01/2024 22:25

Thank you everyone.

DH has also gotten really offended and called Mumsnet stupid and asked if any of you are an Oxford qualified lawyer and he isn't stupid, he had a good idea.

Just totally fed up now.

Oxford qualified lawyer? No
Tax Specialist? Yes.

I always say to people who come up with these stupid ideas, refuse to listen and think they are cleverer than everyone else - you know what, do it.

If he is nor going to listen to sensible advice, then he's going to do it anyway.

But, he he better not cry and whinge when HMRC open up enquiries into his tax.
He'll end up spending more money and time dealing with HMRC, than had he just paid the correct tax in the first place.

If he does go ahead, I suggest he put some savings together when he inevitably has to pay the correct tax, interest and penalties.

betterangels · 13/01/2024 22:34

coucoululu · 13/01/2024 22:25

Thank you everyone.

DH has also gotten really offended and called Mumsnet stupid and asked if any of you are an Oxford qualified lawyer and he isn't stupid, he had a good idea.

Just totally fed up now.

Is he always this touchy when people poke holes in his harebrained ideas? Imagine such a fragile ego. I'd be cringing for him.