Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby shower etiquette AIBU?

111 replies

babysharkx · 13/01/2024 19:05

So I just wanna get an outside opinion on this. One of my friends has a baby shower coming up and her best friend is organising it for her. She made a WhatsApp group for everyone invited.

She did a few polls in the chat to decide on the venue. Then told us the food options. The buffet is around £20 a head which everyone agreed to send their share of the money. Then she’d put in the chat something about wanting to order a cake and decorations and asked if people were happy to contribute. About 5 people said yes out of 20 and her mum even said she would pay for the cake.

Then a few weeks later the organiser has put in the chat she’s ordered the cake and decorations which has come to £150 so can everyone send her their share. Not sure what happened to her mum paying for the cake. I find it so cheeky as not everyone agreed to pay it! She’s shared her bank details in the chat about 4 times asking people to transfer it. More people have caved and paid than said they were originally going to but I think there’s still about 7 people that haven’t.

I know in the grand scheme it’s not a great deal of money but i don’t want to send it based on the principle. It’s a cost of living crisis. I’m already having to fund the buffet and buy a gift without paying for the cake and decorations too.

plus said friend turned up at my baby shower (which my mum hosted and provided the buffet) drank about 3 free bottles of wine, got a lift home from me and brought a book as a gift.. plus didn’t get my baby a present when she was born.

What would you do? Is it normal to be invited to a party and asked to pay for the decorations? I don’t know whether to send it just to keep the peace or just wait to see if she asks me directly to tell her what I think.

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 13/01/2024 20:29

I’ve paid to attend coworker wedding and baby showers. Those are really a different style of event than one for friends or family.

Someone has always hosted the friend or family showers. Sometimes they are simple affairs in someone’s home.

babysharkx · 13/01/2024 20:29

Outthedoor24 · 13/01/2024 20:22

Op I think it's very cheeky of the friend to be asking for more money.
I think £20 for the buffet is wild. Have you checked prices on the venues website? Is she expecting the friends to cover both the MtB, her and whoever else?

I'd probably cough up, for the sake of £7.50, but really I'd not be happy about it

Other options,
Just sit quiet say nothing don't send any more money. Ignore further money requests.

Or you could be braver and say 'sorry I didn't agree to paying for cake and decorations, I already think £20 for buffet is steep and I still have a gift to buy'

I agree I think it’s crazy but yeah I have checked and verified the cost. There was a canapés option that was slightly cheaper but they didn’t sound very nice!

the organiser even put in the chat the other day ‘think of it this way.. What I’m asking you all to contribute to the cost most people would spend without thinking on a trip to Starbucks anyway plus you will benefit from eating the cake and the decorations are a pretty central part of the shower’

OP posts:
PrimalOwl10 · 13/01/2024 20:26

Baby showers can be so grabby they want instragram pictures but the guests funding it. Buffets should not be 20 quid a head decorations can be obtained cheaply from poundland, ebay and home bargains. The host and family members usually fund this. I went to my good friends and only paid for drinks and a gift.

TenderChicken · 13/01/2024 20:23

Baby showers are typically held at home, not at a venue where each guest is paying £20+ a head 🤨

Definitely don't give her any more money! She is being so crass.

I also would spend very little on the gift. A teether or pack of muslins or such.

Outthedoor24 · 13/01/2024 20:22

Op I think it's very cheeky of the friend to be asking for more money.
I think £20 for the buffet is wild. Have you checked prices on the venues website? Is she expecting the friends to cover both the MtB, her and whoever else?

I'd probably cough up, for the sake of £7.50, but really I'd not be happy about it

Other options,
Just sit quiet say nothing don't send any more money. Ignore further money requests.

Or you could be braver and say 'sorry I didn't agree to paying for cake and decorations, I already think £20 for buffet is steep and I still have a gift to buy'

New2024 · 13/01/2024 20:01

The whole baby shower thing is out of hand by the sound of it. I don’t think I’ve ever been to an engagement party or a wedding I had to pay for. Drinks maybe, but not catering and not decorations or cake. I suppose people pay their own way at a hen night/weekend but they don’t bring a present with them. The purpose of a baby shower is to shower the expected baby with gifts.

Cherrysoup · 13/01/2024 19:56

Host pays. Very tacky to ask the guests to pay.

Motheranddaughter · 13/01/2024 19:51

You post ,you pay
End of
TBF I don’t go to baby showers

babysharkx · 13/01/2024 19:48

Theatrefan12 · 13/01/2024 19:42

I cross posted with you. Bit of crucial information you missed in your post. As pp said good bit of drip feeding there

Yeah reading it back I guess I do sound a bit entitled in the OG post 🙈 it clearly wasn’t worded in the best way but obviously there is more to the story I didn’t think to go into originally.

OP posts:
SnackQueen · 13/01/2024 19:48

Her bestie overspent but that's not on you. If she wanted the guests to increase their own contributions she should have checked with them first before blowing so much cash on. She'll also be taking the organisational glory anyway so she might as well take the financial hit and live in hope her friend reciprocates when it's her turn.

As a side point, asking guests to contribute anything towards baby showers and gender reveal parties is beyond uncouth.

mathanxiety · 13/01/2024 19:45

The scenario you have described is a far cry from what a baby shower should be.

You throw the party, you pay for it.

MrsMarzetti · 13/01/2024 19:44

When did people become so greedy and grabby? A present for the baby is more than enough. Why does the mother to be need a party and presents, before long the fathers to be will be having a party too.

ttcat37 · 13/01/2024 19:44

“plus said friend turned up at my baby shower (which my mum hosted and provided the buffet) drank about 3 free bottles of wine, got a lift home from me and brought a book as a gift.. plus didn’t get my baby a present when she was born.”

This is very grabby. What gift would have been acceptable for you?
And you wanted ANOTHER gift after the baby was born??

babysharkx · 13/01/2024 19:44

I love how the gift part is what everyone is focused on. I wouldn’t expect 2 gifts. I mentioned it in comparison of how things were when it was me. She didn’t have to contribute anything to the shower, had food/alcohol/transport provided, turned up with a book and explained she would get another gift but never did!

meanwhile the gift list for her shower are things like prep machine, baby carrier etc

OP posts:
hellojelly · 13/01/2024 19:43

babysharkx · 13/01/2024 19:27

Ahh maybe I should’ve said something like that but it’s just a bit awkward in a group chat. If I was the organiser and I’d asked who would be happy to contribute and only 5 people agreed I wouldn’t dream of going ahead and ordering it anyway and demanding the money. To me the silence from the other people is an indication of a no.

Just say it. Can almost guarantee other people are feeling the same.

"Sorry but I didn't agree to contribute to the cake because things are tight at the minute, and having sent money for the buffet plus needing to buy a gift too. Hopefully you can cancel the cake and I'm sure there'll be a lovely one at the supermarket instead."

Snowydaysfaraway · 13/01/2024 19:42

Just reply you don't like cake... And ignore...

mumsytoon · 13/01/2024 19:42

Mrgrinch · 13/01/2024 19:40

I just don't understand how in some social circles it's acceptable to invite people to an event but ask them to pay for it. This would never be done amongst my friends and family.

She took it upon herself to spend other people's money for them when they didn't offer it. She needs to pay for it herself.

Same here. You host, you pay. If it's a surprise then the dh pays. So crass and tacky to ask people to contribute. I wouldn't even bother going, given her behaviour at yours OP.

Theatrefan12 · 13/01/2024 19:42

babysharkx · 13/01/2024 19:31

see above. she literally said she was going to get a present when she was born as she brought a book cos she didn’t have time to get her a ‘proper present‘ so she was the one that set that expectation.

I cross posted with you. Bit of crucial information you missed in your post. As pp said good bit of drip feeding there

Mrgrinch · 13/01/2024 19:40

I just don't understand how in some social circles it's acceptable to invite people to an event but ask them to pay for it. This would never be done amongst my friends and family.

She took it upon herself to spend other people's money for them when they didn't offer it. She needs to pay for it herself.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/01/2024 19:39

YANBU for not wanting to contribute to the party and buy a gift as well. Unfortunately it’s been the norm with people I know/work with to have the grabbiest baby showers (including one woman who had 5 of them), so it doesn’t surprise me that she’s behaving like this, but it doesn’t mean you should pay up.

YABU for being cross with her for not buying you a baby shower gift and a newborn gift. I had a number of friends whinge about this when they had their babies and it really put me off the friendship frankly. Between that and their weddings it was like I was suddenly a cash cow for their family.

(But I’m someone who loathes the concept of baby showers so I may be biased.)

MiIz · 13/01/2024 19:32

but she literally said when she turned up at the shower ‘I’ve only brought a book because I would rather get her a proper gift when she’s born’

That changes the story, could be seen as a drip feed given that everyone is saying the same that you don't buy 2 gifts.

babysharkx · 13/01/2024 19:31

Theatrefan12 · 13/01/2024 19:24

brought a book as a gift.. plus didn’t get my baby a present when she was born

Nothing wrong with a book, better than yet another set of baby grows and bibs. And you are a CF to expect a second present when the baby is born

see above. she literally said she was going to get a present when she was born as she brought a book cos she didn’t have time to get her a ‘proper present‘ so she was the one that set that expectation.

OP posts:
Allinadayswork80 · 13/01/2024 19:29

Yeah I get that, but prob more awkward now tho! Hope you get it sorted x

babysharkx · 13/01/2024 19:27

Allinadayswork80 · 13/01/2024 19:23

All seems a bit OTT, I always thought a baby shower (albeit all a bit Americanised for me tbh) was usually hosted at someone’s house, a banner and some balloons, a few nibbles, some silly games and prezzies. £20 each for a buffet?! Bit extreme and I’d be reluctant to pay much more. But I’d have said that at the original message - something along the lines of “sorry, with the buffet cost and present I’m a bit stretched for much else”. It sucks to be the one organising stuff and no one replies or suggests anything then complains after the fact. If you hadn’t said anything before then I’d prob feel obliged to cough up now to save any ill feeling.

Ahh maybe I should’ve said something like that but it’s just a bit awkward in a group chat. If I was the organiser and I’d asked who would be happy to contribute and only 5 people agreed I wouldn’t dream of going ahead and ordering it anyway and demanding the money. To me the silence from the other people is an indication of a no.

OP posts:
Theatrefan12 · 13/01/2024 19:24

brought a book as a gift.. plus didn’t get my baby a present when she was born

Nothing wrong with a book, better than yet another set of baby grows and bibs. And you are a CF to expect a second present when the baby is born

Swipe left for the next trending thread