Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby shower etiquette AIBU?

111 replies

babysharkx · 13/01/2024 19:05

So I just wanna get an outside opinion on this. One of my friends has a baby shower coming up and her best friend is organising it for her. She made a WhatsApp group for everyone invited.

She did a few polls in the chat to decide on the venue. Then told us the food options. The buffet is around £20 a head which everyone agreed to send their share of the money. Then she’d put in the chat something about wanting to order a cake and decorations and asked if people were happy to contribute. About 5 people said yes out of 20 and her mum even said she would pay for the cake.

Then a few weeks later the organiser has put in the chat she’s ordered the cake and decorations which has come to £150 so can everyone send her their share. Not sure what happened to her mum paying for the cake. I find it so cheeky as not everyone agreed to pay it! She’s shared her bank details in the chat about 4 times asking people to transfer it. More people have caved and paid than said they were originally going to but I think there’s still about 7 people that haven’t.

I know in the grand scheme it’s not a great deal of money but i don’t want to send it based on the principle. It’s a cost of living crisis. I’m already having to fund the buffet and buy a gift without paying for the cake and decorations too.

plus said friend turned up at my baby shower (which my mum hosted and provided the buffet) drank about 3 free bottles of wine, got a lift home from me and brought a book as a gift.. plus didn’t get my baby a present when she was born.

What would you do? Is it normal to be invited to a party and asked to pay for the decorations? I don’t know whether to send it just to keep the peace or just wait to see if she asks me directly to tell her what I think.

OP posts:
easylikeasundaymorn · 13/01/2024 22:47

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 13/01/2024 22:04

So now we have:

1.Engagement party
2.Massive Hen do, usually abroad, costs the same as a family holiday.
3.Wedding, needs outfit, gifts, night in hotel,
4.then couple get pregnant, needs a gender reveal
5.Then baby shower. Huge event. Cake, decorations, games, gifts
6.Then baby is born so needs another present.

  1. Baby Then has a sibling conceived, repeat steps 4-6

Modern day friendships are too expensive for me. I'm pleased I'm out of this stage.

The whole point of a baby shower is to give the presents then though. I've never heard of anyone giving presents both at the shower and again when the baby is born! Or for having baby showers for any child after the first one. I also don't know anyone who has had a party or anything for a gender reveal, and very few who had engagement parties (and none expected presents for them). So really it's 3 events max for most couples, which over 10-20 years of friendship doesn't seem excessive.

You also seem to be ignoring the fact that every single one of these things is optional.

There's this bizarre focus on MN that you're spending the money ON the friend, whereas the friend's occasion is just the REASON for the expenditure but you're paying for yourself just as you would for an other outlay for any other reason. e.g. if you stay in a hotel after the wedding you're paying for YOUR room, if you go on a hen do you're paying for YOUR drinks/activity, if a baby shower the majority of the cost is for YOUR food. People don't have this weird begrudging attitude for other stuff, if I went for a family meal for my dd's or DM's birthday I wouldn't count the cost of my steak as part of their birthday present as if I was doing them a massive favour, I'd think I am paying £30 for a meal that I am eating!

If I'm invited on, say, a hen, I think of it as a holiday for me - if it's somewhere I don't want to go I go or can't afford I politely refuse, if it's something I do fancy I enjoy myself doing something I want to do with people I like. Exactly if I was going on holiday with a partner/children/friends. I don't think of it as a begrudging obligation.

I don't understand people who apparently want friendships but don't want to actually spend any time or money socialising with said friends or celebrating key events in their life

ElevenSeven · 13/01/2024 22:42

Cheshiresun · 13/01/2024 22:37

Why are they having a baby shower when they can't afford it (or unwilling to pay to host it).

It's hardly an essential event.

For the glory (selfie reels on instagram and TikTok)

Groovy48592747 · 13/01/2024 22:42

I'd make my excuses and not go.

Grabbers.

Cheshiresun · 13/01/2024 22:37

Why are they having a baby shower when they can't afford it (or unwilling to pay to host it).

It's hardly an essential event.

easylikeasundaymorn · 13/01/2024 22:31

Elisabeth3468 · 13/01/2024 19:14

Tbh I've never heard of anyone paying towards anything of someone's baby shower! That sounds absolutely ridiculous.

really? I would say every single one I've been too I've paid something in addition to the cost of my individual share - for decorations or to cover the mother to be's plate. It's never a huge amount - if the buffet was £20 I would consider it to be the norm to pay £2-to an absolute max of £5 more. An extra £7.50 per person (£150/20) is a lot to expect though, and crucially, I've always been told the full amount and breakdown of costs at the start so could base my decision on whether to attend on that, rather than it being sprung on me as a done deal when it's hard to back out, so the organiser is being very cheeky.

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 13/01/2024 22:27

Oh yes. The cake smash. I luckily don't have to pay for my friend's carpet crawlers to nose dive a Victoria sponge.

I did realise I missed the christening off the list though. Do people do that as well still? I've never paid to attend one of those.

1990thatsme · 13/01/2024 22:23

YABU for even agreeing to attend this event.

Baby showers really are the pits.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 13/01/2024 22:18

A book is still a 'proper present' why are we being so entitled.

Just because your mum offered to host and pay for your party doesn't mean this girl has that on offer to her- the friend wants to organize a shower but clearly can't afford all the decorations herself. You can chip in and take that 7.50 off the cost of your gift. You can give a bundle of your baby's clothes or old books or toys as a gift you don't have to spent 1p more. Or, as you clearly don't like this mum to be very much, you can just not go.

It seems to be the norm that family hosting - decorations and food covered, a friend hosting - everyone is asked to chip in

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/01/2024 22:16

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 13/01/2024 22:04

So now we have:

1.Engagement party
2.Massive Hen do, usually abroad, costs the same as a family holiday.
3.Wedding, needs outfit, gifts, night in hotel,
4.then couple get pregnant, needs a gender reveal
5.Then baby shower. Huge event. Cake, decorations, games, gifts
6.Then baby is born so needs another present.

  1. Baby Then has a sibling conceived, repeat steps 4-6

Modern day friendships are too expensive for me. I'm pleased I'm out of this stage.

Don’t forget the latest thing - the “baby cake smash” party that takes place on the first birthday.

I must’ve spend thousands on my friends in the last 10-15 years.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/education-39656299

Cake smash

Would you cake smash?

Some parents spend £800 on their child's first birthday.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/education-39656299

bakewellbride · 13/01/2024 22:16

@Gruffallowhydidntyouknow you forgot the house warming party 🤣

VickyEadieofThigh · 13/01/2024 22:07

Who spends £27.50 on themselves on a visit to Starbucks?

tiktokontheclock · 13/01/2024 22:07

Had this at a friends hen a good few years back. Her sis was organising. Every other day there was a new cost over and above travel and accommodation. Spent 1k on a weekend away in Europe which back in 2015 was a lot.

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 13/01/2024 22:04

So now we have:

1.Engagement party
2.Massive Hen do, usually abroad, costs the same as a family holiday.
3.Wedding, needs outfit, gifts, night in hotel,
4.then couple get pregnant, needs a gender reveal
5.Then baby shower. Huge event. Cake, decorations, games, gifts
6.Then baby is born so needs another present.

  1. Baby Then has a sibling conceived, repeat steps 4-6

Modern day friendships are too expensive for me. I'm pleased I'm out of this stage.

bakewellbride · 13/01/2024 22:04

How crap of them! I've only been to one baby shower but didn't pay a penny and was never once expected to. I brought a gift and the host provided food, drink, everything. I'd be so pissed off in your shoes and tempted to not go.

Outthedoor24 · 13/01/2024 22:01

How to give the guilt trip.
It's January lots of people are fairly skint in January. Actually lots of people are skint until end of February (with Januarys wage going on credit card bill)

Sorry but it's January, no money for Starbucks, instand for me! Seriously I didn't agree to paying for cake just get a supermarket cake rather than a £££ bakers number.

ElevenSeven · 13/01/2024 21:42

Baby shower etiquette; don’t have one.

Don’t pay her, just stay silent

Mila2024 · 13/01/2024 21:31

YANBU. If you didn’t agree she shouldn’t be asking you for it… although for £7.50 I’d probably pay! I’d also just replicate the type of gift you got, so a book or equivalent.

I’ve arranged two baby showers recently - one for my sister and one for my SIL. Both in venues as nobody has a house that’s suitable for hosting (or that would have been my go to).

My Mum and I paid for my sisters but in my family the host tends to pay for the event (and we’ve been to several events this year that we haven’t paid a penny for).

For my SIL’s I made the cost clear at the outset so everybody accepted knowing what they’d pay. I bought cake, decorations, paid for SIL etc. but everyone paid for themselves. I just couldn’t afford to pay and whilst I earn ok I’m probably on the lowest wage out of the group.

I don’t agree that the host should pay, rather I think the host should make it clear what it will cost up front and keep it that way… so no surprise/additional costs.

Rachelff · 13/01/2024 20:57

This is the problem with baby showers. I think unless family hosts it at their house and gets all the decorations etc you really shouldn’t be expected to contribute towards food, decorations etc when you’re already taking a gift and then going to get them a second gift a month later when you see the actual baby. I didn’t have one as I felt like it was just asking for presents and I felt too uncomfortable with that 🙈 You wouldn’t arrange a wedding, invite people then send them a breakdown of the costs to transfer over their share! I went to one baby shower recently which was at a restaurant rather than in a hall or someone’s house and it was the first one I’d been to where you had to send money over in advance for food. I even found that a bit awkward 😬 Don’t know what I’d do in your situation, whether I’d just send it for an easy life but it is 100% cheeky!

MissersMercer · 13/01/2024 20:52

Never have I ever in nearly 40 years been invited to a party of any kind and then been asked to pay. Absolutely piss take that is.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/01/2024 20:38

Simple then - host just needs to avoid Starbucks for a while.

I don’t like Starbucks and think it’s a waste of money but nobody is going to value some random decorations and a professional (rather than supermarket) cake in the same way as they do their little guilty pleasure purchases.

Abbimae · 13/01/2024 20:36

If you buy a baby shower gift you don’t buy another one. Also no it’s not normal for guests to pay for these events!

momonpurpose · 13/01/2024 20:35

I think and mi d you I'm in the US where baby showers are a must and I ome from an ethnicity that makes huge baby showers I think it's really not right to ask for contributions. The host by chosing to host should not ask for donations. I think it's one thing to ask to bring a dish but this is too much.

Ilovethewild · 13/01/2024 20:31

Ask her whose keeping the decorations and left over cake…

very cheeky and not on.

don’t pay,

hellojelly · 13/01/2024 20:30

babysharkx · 13/01/2024 20:29

I agree I think it’s crazy but yeah I have checked and verified the cost. There was a canapés option that was slightly cheaper but they didn’t sound very nice!

the organiser even put in the chat the other day ‘think of it this way.. What I’m asking you all to contribute to the cost most people would spend without thinking on a trip to Starbucks anyway plus you will benefit from eating the cake and the decorations are a pretty central part of the shower’

I'd tell her she can pay for it herself then and just avoid Starbucks for a little longer to recoup the cost 😂

PrimalOwl10 · 13/01/2024 20:30

The mum to be sounds equally grabby with a bloody wish list with expensive items..I. wouldn't attend.

Swipe left for the next trending thread