Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

12 year olds being stopped and bags searched.

115 replies

Howdoidoit100 · 13/01/2024 18:28

My daughter and her friend were today stopped in a large store and told (not asked) to hand over their bags. They were absolutely terrified so just did as they were told. They hadn't put anything in their bags but one child had something in her hand that she planned to buy. The security officer then told another member of staff to take them to the tills to ensure they paid for the item in the girls hand.

At the time they were searched they were in the middle of the store still browsing (not trying to leave)

No apology or explanation was offered and one of the girls disolved in to tears after leaving. They were absolutely humiliated with everyone in this large store staring at them whilst they were searched.

Am I unreasonable to feel they were treated unfairly? At the very least I would like the security to have called me before searching them and provided an explanation of why they were being searched. I would have been able to guide the girls on what to do and perhaps made it less frightening for them.

I do understand kids do steal....I just don't like how this was handled. Not sure if I'm being over protective.

OP posts:
Comedycook · 14/01/2024 10:12

gamerchick · 14/01/2024 10:03

You're a shoplifters dream you Grin

Yeah hilarious

I don't know what the answer is necessarily but I dislike the power imbalance...and despite what some posters seem to think, very few 12 year old girls would have the confidence and ability to explain their rights and actions to an adult (I presume) man. Like I said, I'd very much like to see what their training consists of in relation to vulnerable people.

ilovebreadsauce · 14/01/2024 10:09

I would just say no. I think that would force to make a citizens arrest which I could in the future bring an action dor wrongful arrest

gamerchick · 14/01/2024 10:03

Comedycook · 13/01/2024 22:50

I do not think security staff should be allowed to approach children who don't have an adult with them in order to search bags.

You're a shoplifters dream you Grin

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 14/01/2024 01:48

Were you there? Did you actually witness this?

To a scared 12 year old "could I check your bags?" And "you must show me your bags" can come across as the same, especially when being emotionally relayed to a parent.

Is this a local shop they use often? So that if her friend is actually a local, well known, shoplifter they'd be well aware of her by face and therefore confronted her before she could steal anything and that was why they also insisted she was observed paying there and then?

Or is it even possible your DD actually WAS stealing? And she's telling you a story to cover for this?

Knowing locally that security guards have been told to not even try and stop shoplifters for their own safety least they get stabbed ... I don't think the same about the guards as others here

Sparklybutold · 14/01/2024 01:35

@Howdoidoit100 was all this information from the 2 children? I'd be asking to speak to the store to try and get a full picture.

MCOut · 14/01/2024 01:29

If the security guard had asked to see inside their bags as they were leaving, it would not have been an unreasonable request. However, there is no reason to bother someone while they’re still on the shop floor and he shouldn’t have marched them to the till.

TurquoiseSeasAndSilverSand · 14/01/2024 01:17

Bag searching aside, being forced to buy the item was not OK. They hadn't finished their shopping, the child may have decided not to buy it, or change her mind and swap it for something else, she was well within her rights to do that. As an adult I wouldn't expect to be frog marched to the checkouts and forced to pay for something when I was in the middle of the shop.

DdraigGoch · 14/01/2024 01:15

Kids don’t want their parents called.

These days I wouldn't be so sure. I think that you mentioned that you were a teacher. You must therefore have come across "my darling child didn't do whatever it was you said they did and I don't care if you've got thirty witnesses and CCTV of him beating Johnny Smith to a pulp and anyway he's a grass..."

One 14 year old girl around here certainly uses "I'll get my dad to see to you" as a threat and given his criminal history I could well believe it.

DdraigGoch · 14/01/2024 01:06

Comedycook · 13/01/2024 23:37

You must be in cloud cuckoo land if you think a 12 year old girl would feel able to explain their rights or behave in a confrontational way with an adult (I presume male) security guard. Most would be feel quite nervous.

The comparison was with an 8 year old. Yes, 12 year olds will be more streetwise than 8 year olds.

CeeCeeBloom · 14/01/2024 01:05

SisterHyster · 13/01/2024 23:33

They do change.
Typically, they get more aware of their rights, they get better at expressing themselves, and also more confrontational.

They also become more self-conscious, hate attention, and become more emotional. My daughters would have reacted the same way if this had happened to them at 12. I just hope you're more empathetic with your daughter if she doesn't grow up specifically the exact way you want her to.

IReallyStillCantBeBothered · 14/01/2024 00:35

Comedycook · 13/01/2024 22:50

I do not think security staff should be allowed to approach children who don't have an adult with them in order to search bags.

The children should not be allowed to go into store without an adult. Fact is teenagers are the largest demographic that shoplift so you just can’t say don’t stop any teenager.

Spomsored · 14/01/2024 00:25

It's not fair on law-abiding teenagers/children but equally it's not fair that people steal from shops and those who do pay for their shopping have to cover the losses. The options are that shops implement some security measures or that young people are not allowed into shops without an adult. I think preparing your children how to cope with various scenarios they may meet in life is only sensible.

SighedAndSmiled · 14/01/2024 00:14

Marblessolveeverything · 13/01/2024 22:10

I'm torn having done my stent in retail it predominantly was secondary aged children who shop lifted.

But I would be curious of the rules around searching as I understand it has to be voluntary only the police can search without permission and even then there are strict rules.

While at sixth form, ( non uniform) a few friends and I went to a local supermarket in town, we were chatting, not loud, about four of us, and we had a basket.
it was our lunch break so we couldn’t dawdle.

We all noticed this woman following us and glaring at us, had no idea who she was at the time, and just carried on.

She must have been security and trying to get us out.

She wasn’t in luck, none of us were thieves, just walking around the store to buy some things, but I do remember us looking at her and wondering what the matter with her was.

🤣🤣

SisterHyster · 14/01/2024 00:05

Comedycook · 13/01/2024 23:56

Correct.

But I was challenging your point of view which states 12 years olds should know their legal rights and be able to express them. Clearly that's not always the case and clearly the fact that rules exist in order to protect children in these circumstances, shows you are quite wrong

It’s part of the curriculum here.

The law exists to protect children against having legal proceedings taken against them when they may not understand the questions; or are at risk of sexual harm (to use the strip search example)

There is no risk of a security guard asking to see inside a shopping bag in a public place. All that happens in low-value theft is they take the items back and escort the person out the shop. The only issue is when they refuse to show the contents of the bag willingly; because then the police are called. The initial discussion with police happens without their parents present too.

Frangipanyoul8r · 14/01/2024 00:04

The big wide world of independence can be intimidating for a child. It doesn’t mean they should be sheltered from it.

If you teach your child to feel hard done by every time they experience something that makes them feel uncomfortable, you aren’t helping them to grow up.

Mumtime2 · 14/01/2024 00:03

Is there a sign on the door of the shop to say searches will be a possibility?
I feel if you are entering into a shop, and they target you just like anyone else, it is all part of this may possibly happen.
Teens are likely not necessarily yours, but this is a fact of life they need to know will happen.
A bit of discretion from security would be more civilised.
Kids have to be savvy nowadays thanks to those who ruin it for the honest ones.
I was chased out of a supermarket once and yelled to get back inside did I not purchase something, It was horrible, in my uniform.
I accidentally rescanned my item as I packed it.
She told me to find the thrown in the bin receipt for her. I refused so she did.
Discretion is lacking for some power trips I guess.

Comedycook · 14/01/2024 00:01

Tempnamechng · 14/01/2024 00:00

Over reaction. I went to supermarket before Christmas and was spot checked. The guard just asked me to open my shopping bag and then emptied it, at a desk at the front of the store, checking against my receipt. It was annoying but hardly traumatic and not in the least be embarrassing. My only argument was that they either trust me to self check out or provide staff to do it.

I presume you're an adult?

Tempnamechng · 14/01/2024 00:00

Over reaction. I went to supermarket before Christmas and was spot checked. The guard just asked me to open my shopping bag and then emptied it, at a desk at the front of the store, checking against my receipt. It was annoying but hardly traumatic and not in the least be embarrassing. My only argument was that they either trust me to self check out or provide staff to do it.

Comedycook · 13/01/2024 23:56

SisterHyster · 13/01/2024 23:52

I think you are getting a little bit confused. We are talking about a child being asked to show inside a shopping bag, not inside their underwear.

Correct.

But I was challenging your point of view which states 12 years olds should know their legal rights and be able to express them. Clearly that's not always the case and clearly the fact that rules exist in order to protect children in these circumstances, shows you are quite wrong

ThomasinaLivesHere · 13/01/2024 23:54

I think adults seems to find it much easier to confront teenagers and do so when they wouldn’t with an adult or at least nothing to the same degree. I noticed a change when I grew up. I had a few experiences like this as a teenager and haven’t as an adult. I remember one time simply being asked to leave the shop when I was with one other friend shopping for another friend’s birthday. We were just browsing and weren’t messing around or anything. We were then escorted out by security.

SisterHyster · 13/01/2024 23:52

Comedycook · 13/01/2024 23:45

@SisterHyster ever heard about child Q who was strip searched by police without her parents being informed? Should she have just known her rights and spoken up for herself?

I think you are getting a little bit confused. We are talking about a child being asked to show inside a shopping bag, not inside their underwear.

SisterHyster · 13/01/2024 23:50

Comedycook · 13/01/2024 23:43

So when children are being questioned by police...do you believe they should be left to it without an appropriate adult? Seeing as they are so sure of themselves....

Obviously a child should be able to have an appointed adult present at questioning, just like adults with a lawyer and employees may take union reps with them for work issues.

We aren’t talking about that though. We are talking about on the shop floor in a retail setting with other people and cctv present. The child has the right to say no; however the consequence will then be that they are placed in an interview room with a member of store staff present and held until the police arrive.

From my time working in retail; the only ones who refused were the shoplifters. They would act bold until the police/security asked for their parents phone numbers; then they’d panic. Then they’d be mighty sheepish as they were escorted out by their parents or the police.

Kids don’t want their parents called.

Comedycook · 13/01/2024 23:46

SisterHyster · 13/01/2024 23:44

I’m not the one scared of the world and causing arguments wherever I go but go on, whatever boosts your fragile ego.

And your the one who thinks 12 year olds should be perfectly able to argue their legal rights with random security guards

Comedycook · 13/01/2024 23:45

@SisterHyster ever heard about child Q who was strip searched by police without her parents being informed? Should she have just known her rights and spoken up for herself?

SisterHyster · 13/01/2024 23:44

Comedycook · 13/01/2024 23:42

Pathetic

I’m not the one scared of the world and causing arguments wherever I go but go on, whatever boosts your fragile ego.

Swipe left for the next trending thread