Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

12 year olds being stopped and bags searched.

115 replies

Howdoidoit100 · 13/01/2024 18:28

My daughter and her friend were today stopped in a large store and told (not asked) to hand over their bags. They were absolutely terrified so just did as they were told. They hadn't put anything in their bags but one child had something in her hand that she planned to buy. The security officer then told another member of staff to take them to the tills to ensure they paid for the item in the girls hand.

At the time they were searched they were in the middle of the store still browsing (not trying to leave)

No apology or explanation was offered and one of the girls disolved in to tears after leaving. They were absolutely humiliated with everyone in this large store staring at them whilst they were searched.

Am I unreasonable to feel they were treated unfairly? At the very least I would like the security to have called me before searching them and provided an explanation of why they were being searched. I would have been able to guide the girls on what to do and perhaps made it less frightening for them.

I do understand kids do steal....I just don't like how this was handled. Not sure if I'm being over protective.

OP posts:
ilovebreadsauce · 15/01/2024 14:04

Ponoka7 · 15/01/2024 12:24

Might have come from Costco. You have to show your receipt before leaving.

I'd want the manager to have a look at the CCTV to see if the security guard had reasonable cause to search. There's many male security guards who like the power over young women.

I don't "have to" do anything!

Marblessolveeverything · 15/01/2024 13:41

@Goldenbear where did I suggest they were scapegoats ? T

he reality is stats on lifting will show higher level per age group in youths 🤷 Add in a big bag, possibly acting nervous and you literally have the 101 of when security guards are meant to notice.

As I said what are the policies and rules on requesting a search ?

As I said I am torn I hate paying more because shop lifting is rife. But what is your alternative suggestion?

Goldenbear · 15/01/2024 12:40

SeemsSoUnfair · 13/01/2024 22:43

Reality is shoplifting is commonly commited by teens and I remember hearing lots of stories from ds of kids at his school getting searched or caught so i can't blame shops for putting in rules such as only 2 kids in the shop at a time or asking to check bags / pockets.

Ds was told shops are not playgrounds and he understood why teens might be eyed with suspicion and that he can thank his school peers for that. Told him if you are asked you have nothing to worry about if you have done nothing wrong and the quickest thing to do is just be calm, show your bag and be respectful to those doing their job.

Obviously a body search of children is unacceptable but I don't see a problem with checking bags, asking them to empty pockets.

Your Dds and/or her friends reaction was overly dramatic.

But the OP's daughter and friends had not done anything wrong, they had not attempted to exit, why is acceptable to humiliate teenagers who have some nothing wrong except be teenagers, that is profiling and completely unacceptable in other walks of life.

Goldenbear · 15/01/2024 12:36

Marblessolveeverything · 13/01/2024 22:10

I'm torn having done my stent in retail it predominantly was secondary aged children who shop lifted.

But I would be curious of the rules around searching as I understand it has to be voluntary only the police can search without permission and even then there are strict rules.

So you think it is acceptable to scapegoat youth because of your previous position in retail?

Ponoka7 · 15/01/2024 12:24

ilovebreadsauce · 15/01/2024 12:17

I thought about this thread when I was leaving Decathlon yesterday and a security guard by the door was asking everyone to see their receipt as they left.
I said no and walked off.what fucking right do they think they have?

Might have come from Costco. You have to show your receipt before leaving.

I'd want the manager to have a look at the CCTV to see if the security guard had reasonable cause to search. There's many male security guards who like the power over young women.

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 12:18

ilovebreadsauce · 15/01/2024 12:17

I thought about this thread when I was leaving Decathlon yesterday and a security guard by the door was asking everyone to see their receipt as they left.
I said no and walked off.what fucking right do they think they have?

Good for you

ilovebreadsauce · 15/01/2024 12:17

I thought about this thread when I was leaving Decathlon yesterday and a security guard by the door was asking everyone to see their receipt as they left.
I said no and walked off.what fucking right do they think they have?

SisterHyster · 15/01/2024 09:56

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 15/01/2024 09:39

No to mention that for some children, even being wrongly accused would be enough to get them in serious trouble with their parents if they get a call from the shop.

I know when I was a teen, I’d be out shopping (not shoplifting!) and my parents would be at work. They would be absolutely mortified to have to leave their jobs to come and collect me from the shop because I was behaving sufficiently suspicious to be accused of theft.

Many parents may even have lost out on pay in this type of scenarios.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 15/01/2024 09:39

SisterHyster · 14/01/2024 18:59

From my experience, being put in the interview room and having to give their parents phone number is way more scary for teens than simply having their bag peeked in. And often, no parent is available, therefore it becomes a police matter.

No to mention that for some children, even being wrongly accused would be enough to get them in serious trouble with their parents if they get a call from the shop.

Cherry8809 · 15/01/2024 03:44

Comedycook · 14/01/2024 10:12

Yeah hilarious

I don't know what the answer is necessarily but I dislike the power imbalance...and despite what some posters seem to think, very few 12 year old girls would have the confidence and ability to explain their rights and actions to an adult (I presume) man. Like I said, I'd very much like to see what their training consists of in relation to vulnerable people.

SIA Training Factsheet - Vulnerable Individuals

Security Guarding is a licensable activity, and there’s actually a large amount of course content that needs to be covered and signed off on.

SIA licence-linked qualifications

https://qualifications.pearson.com/content/dam/pdf/btec-specialist/SIA-Training-factsheet-September-2013.pdf

DdraigGoch · 15/01/2024 01:33

and you STILL think shops can do what they want and we should just accept authority.

"Could I take a look in your bag?" is not comparable to prosecuting someone on trumped-up charges. It's really not a big ask if you've done nothing wrong.

SisterHyster · 14/01/2024 18:59

bobomomo · 14/01/2024 14:39

In an ideal world children suspected of shop lifting will be taken to a room where they can wait for an appropriate adult to come, then bags can be searched - however if they haven't stolen anything it's far quicker to let the security guard check their bag. I've seen teens steal loads of stuff here, the manager told me (when I reported a certain group) that they don't bother going after them unless they have £10+ of goods (mostly it's lads stealing pastries from Lidl worth 69p!) Lidl don't have security guards here.

How about we all taught teens not steal then adults wouldn't be suspicious of them alas this is not going to happen

From my experience, being put in the interview room and having to give their parents phone number is way more scary for teens than simply having their bag peeked in. And often, no parent is available, therefore it becomes a police matter.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 14/01/2024 16:50

IReallyStillCantBeBothered · 14/01/2024 00:35

The children should not be allowed to go into store without an adult. Fact is teenagers are the largest demographic that shoplift so you just can’t say don’t stop any teenager.

It’s been a very long time since I worked in retail but in those days we received extensive training on stock management and teenagers were not the largest demographic of shoplifters. The main demographic was drug addicts, followed by career shoplifters, usually smartly dressed middle aged people - the ones than no one would look twice at.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 14/01/2024 16:11

They can approach them if and when they have a reasonable suspicion that they are stealing something. Which is not when you are in the middle of the store with an item in your hand.

As for the idea of leaving your rucksack at customer services. Really? So I go in with a rucksack which I often do because it's easier to carry stuff home, I can expect to be stopped and searched in the middle of the shop? Yeah right.

Deal with the actual shoplifters and stop treating the rest of us as if we are idiots.

The responses on this thread beggar belief really. You've got all the fall out from the Horizon scandal playing out around us, and you STILL think shops can do what they want and we should just accept authority.

And as if any of you have "trained" your young children about security guards etc. The sanctimonious smugness on MN is something to be believed at times.

MaybeSmaller · 14/01/2024 16:02

Comedycook · 13/01/2024 22:50

I do not think security staff should be allowed to approach children who don't have an adult with them in order to search bags.

In that case, children won't be allowed into the shop at all unless they're accompanied by an adult.

You don't seriously think shops will just let children in to steal with impunity, do you?

gamerchick · 14/01/2024 15:45

Comedycook · 14/01/2024 10:12

Yeah hilarious

I don't know what the answer is necessarily but I dislike the power imbalance...and despite what some posters seem to think, very few 12 year old girls would have the confidence and ability to explain their rights and actions to an adult (I presume) man. Like I said, I'd very much like to see what their training consists of in relation to vulnerable people.

Evidently. Organised shoplifters would latch onto your idea immediately. Not all 12 yr olds are little shy things.

The only way to make that work would be to ban kids shopping alone completely.

LenaLamont · 14/01/2024 14:44

@HellsToilet - my apologies, I'm having a Hard Of Thinking day.

bobomomo · 14/01/2024 14:39

In an ideal world children suspected of shop lifting will be taken to a room where they can wait for an appropriate adult to come, then bags can be searched - however if they haven't stolen anything it's far quicker to let the security guard check their bag. I've seen teens steal loads of stuff here, the manager told me (when I reported a certain group) that they don't bother going after them unless they have £10+ of goods (mostly it's lads stealing pastries from Lidl worth 69p!) Lidl don't have security guards here.

How about we all taught teens not steal then adults wouldn't be suspicious of them alas this is not going to happen

HellsToilet · 14/01/2024 14:35

LenaLamont · 14/01/2024 14:31

Why not just let them carry guns and shoot people they think may commit a crime, eh?

Um, @HellsToilet , you do realise this is just looking in a bag, right?

Spot check for shoplifters. Shops do that. The other girl had put an item in her bag already, which may well have been what flagged them on CCTV.

It's very common, it's nothing to get upset about.

I was parodying the comment I was quoting.

LenaLamont · 14/01/2024 14:31

Why not just let them carry guns and shoot people they think may commit a crime, eh?

Um, @HellsToilet , you do realise this is just looking in a bag, right?

Spot check for shoplifters. Shops do that. The other girl had put an item in her bag already, which may well have been what flagged them on CCTV.

It's very common, it's nothing to get upset about.

Allthecatseverywhereallatonce · 14/01/2024 14:25

My dd & her friend both 15 continually get stopped in the same shop by the same security guard 🤨. Every time they have their bags searched. Even the cashiers notice the security guard circling them and pass comments on it. I am wondering whether to contact the store. The girls keep going back so I assume they are not too bothered. They do however say it is embarrassing as the guard just searches their bags in the middle of the store.

I have never been stopped and had my bag searched, I don't know if my dd just looks guilty, she is very shy and hates confrontation so they just agree
I understand that teens are more likely to shoplift it just feels a bit over the top every time.

HellsToilet · 14/01/2024 14:19

SisterHyster · 13/01/2024 23:12

Okay, then let’s just do away with security completely and let everyone leave without paying, in case they get “scared”

In fact, just close the checkouts and make the whole thing a free for all eh? Sack the staff and just let the customers steal stuff straight from the storeroom eh? Don’t want to scare people.

Let's just allow people to ignore the law, slander and intimidate members of the public without evidence, cause or authority just so they can feel important and powerful.

Why not just let them carry guns and shoot people they think may commit a crime, eh? Don't want to protect people's legal rights at the expense of mini-Hitler's egos and the all important profits of large corporations.

NewName24 · 14/01/2024 13:59

Spomsored · 14/01/2024 00:25

It's not fair on law-abiding teenagers/children but equally it's not fair that people steal from shops and those who do pay for their shopping have to cover the losses. The options are that shops implement some security measures or that young people are not allowed into shops without an adult. I think preparing your children how to cope with various scenarios they may meet in life is only sensible.

Exactly.
As a pp said early on in this thread, my teens understood that some people steal, and that some people are employed to both try to prevent it and catch people who do. As such, they would happily show the security team what was in their bags and then be on their way. No need for confrontation at all.

Same as every time I go in to a stadium or arena or the theatre, I show the security team what is in my bag and go on my merry way. There is no confrontation. I've never accidently had any bombs or machetes or anything in there, so it isn't a problem, but I'm glad they check, so that it isn't a problem for anyone inside that venue.
Same with being checked on the way out of a shop. I've never stolen anything in my life, but the more people that do, the more costs rise for those of us that don't, so I' am happy to be checked as I realise that is looking after all of us and it isn't personal at all.

NewName24 · 14/01/2024 13:54

Frangipanyoul8r · 14/01/2024 00:04

The big wide world of independence can be intimidating for a child. It doesn’t mean they should be sheltered from it.

If you teach your child to feel hard done by every time they experience something that makes them feel uncomfortable, you aren’t helping them to grow up.

This, 100%

PuttingDownRoots · 14/01/2024 10:13

Unaccompanied children aren't even allowed in a shopping centre near my parents house at certain times.