Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

12 year olds being stopped and bags searched.

115 replies

Howdoidoit100 · 13/01/2024 18:28

My daughter and her friend were today stopped in a large store and told (not asked) to hand over their bags. They were absolutely terrified so just did as they were told. They hadn't put anything in their bags but one child had something in her hand that she planned to buy. The security officer then told another member of staff to take them to the tills to ensure they paid for the item in the girls hand.

At the time they were searched they were in the middle of the store still browsing (not trying to leave)

No apology or explanation was offered and one of the girls disolved in to tears after leaving. They were absolutely humiliated with everyone in this large store staring at them whilst they were searched.

Am I unreasonable to feel they were treated unfairly? At the very least I would like the security to have called me before searching them and provided an explanation of why they were being searched. I would have been able to guide the girls on what to do and perhaps made it less frightening for them.

I do understand kids do steal....I just don't like how this was handled. Not sure if I'm being over protective.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Westernesse · 16/01/2024 07:45

DdraigGoch · 16/01/2024 03:24

Guess who ends up paying for the shrinkage?

Yes, the mugs that we honest customers are.

Tough.

and yes, I’m sure retailers really would lower prices is shoplifting didn’t exist. 😆

GeckoEcho · 16/01/2024 04:34

The customers doing most of the theft where I work currently are women with strollers and/or loose clothing, especially burkas, and men brazenly grabbing stuff and hightailing it past security. Yet security ARE far more likely to stop schoolkids or little old ladies to check their bags/ receipts. Low hanging fruit.

DdraigGoch · 16/01/2024 03:24

Westernesse · 15/01/2024 18:30

Shoplifting is part of the price of doing business in retail. Security staff have no powers to search or touch anyone. They cannot detain.

ive intervened on behalf of kids being hassled by security guards in big shopping malls. I remember one was holding onto a kid’s bike and his arm. I told the fat little prick to let go and that I would report him to the police for attempting to detain a child. I reminded him that he has no power over anyone and nobody is accountable to him.

the idea that these random shop security guards should be allowed to detail, search or harass people is preposterous.

yes, shoplifting occurs. But it is the price of doing business and is written off as shrinkage and largely covered by insurance.

Guess who ends up paying for the shrinkage?

Yes, the mugs that we honest customers are.

Westernesse · 15/01/2024 18:37

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 18:34

I am saying there is absolutely no need to hover in the background watching their interaction as an unnecessary hero in waiting to create a drama when it is not needed. Do you wear a cape?

If the teens want support, they have their friends with them and they can call their parents on the mobile phones they all carry. I know my ds would be more "humiliated" with a busy body stranger hanging about watching and wading in to "help".

I’ll do more than help personally. I’m happy to roll about on the ground with these mall cop wannabes if they are being aggressive or acting illegally towards kids.

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 18:37

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 18:34

I am saying there is absolutely no need to hover in the background watching their interaction as an unnecessary hero in waiting to create a drama when it is not needed. Do you wear a cape?

If the teens want support, they have their friends with them and they can call their parents on the mobile phones they all carry. I know my ds would be more "humiliated" with a busy body stranger hanging about watching and wading in to "help".

You must have a lot of faith in these jumped up security guards. If we can't always trust the police, I certainly won't be blindly trusting security guards.

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 18:34

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 18:25

I wasn't talking about the ops specific situation. I'm explaining what I do. You just said they are not alone as they're on a shop floor... ergo other customers are around as witnesses. Yet you seem to object to my witnessing any encounters

I am saying there is absolutely no need to hover in the background watching their interaction as an unnecessary hero in waiting to create a drama when it is not needed. Do you wear a cape?

If the teens want support, they have their friends with them and they can call their parents on the mobile phones they all carry. I know my ds would be more "humiliated" with a busy body stranger hanging about watching and wading in to "help".

Westernesse · 15/01/2024 18:32

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 18:22

They were not "alone" they were in the middle of a supermarket with their friends and the security guard asked to check her bag. It is not as if he took her into an interrogation room and waterboarded her!

If a teen cannot cope with that they shouldn't be out alone.

The security guard has no right to check anyone’s bag and should certainly not be trying that shit with children.

they have no statutory powers or authority whatsoever.

Westernesse · 15/01/2024 18:30

Shoplifting is part of the price of doing business in retail. Security staff have no powers to search or touch anyone. They cannot detain.

ive intervened on behalf of kids being hassled by security guards in big shopping malls. I remember one was holding onto a kid’s bike and his arm. I told the fat little prick to let go and that I would report him to the police for attempting to detain a child. I reminded him that he has no power over anyone and nobody is accountable to him.

the idea that these random shop security guards should be allowed to detail, search or harass people is preposterous.

yes, shoplifting occurs. But it is the price of doing business and is written off as shrinkage and largely covered by insurance.

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 18:25

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 18:22

They were not "alone" they were in the middle of a supermarket with their friends and the security guard asked to check her bag. It is not as if he took her into an interrogation room and waterboarded her!

If a teen cannot cope with that they shouldn't be out alone.

I wasn't talking about the ops specific situation. I'm explaining what I do. You just said they are not alone as they're on a shop floor... ergo other customers are around as witnesses. Yet you seem to object to my witnessing any encounters

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 18:22

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 18:14

No that's not profiling. That's making sure a person in a position of power is treating a vulnerable child who is alone without an appropriate adult properly.

They were not "alone" they were in the middle of a supermarket with their friends and the security guard asked to check her bag. It is not as if he took her into an interrogation room and waterboarded her!

If a teen cannot cope with that they shouldn't be out alone.

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 18:14

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 18:12

ok, you now agree you are profiling security guards.

Why is that any different to profiling teens, who are also less than perfect and sometimes make bad decisions due to immaturity, that were acting a bit suspiciously and taking reasonable actions (checking a bag is reasonable) to protect your business?

No that's not profiling. That's making sure a person in a position of power is treating a vulnerable child who is alone without an appropriate adult properly.

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 18:12

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 18:02

Yes I can quite imagine many are incompetent or arseholes. I mean look at all the times police get called out.....child Q for example....that's with all their training. So yes, I can well imagine your bog standard security guard being less than perfect.

ok, you now agree you are profiling security guards.

Why is that any different to profiling teens, who are also less than perfect and sometimes make bad decisions due to immaturity, that were acting a bit suspiciously and taking reasonable actions (checking a bag is reasonable) to protect your business?

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 18:04

Have you never heard about adults who hand out cards to kids being stopped and searched which gives them information about their rights.

Good on them

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 18:02

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 17:58

I've seen security guards stop school kids ...I will always stand there and watch to make sure the child is ok and being treated fairly and if I see them being treated in a way I wouldn't want my child treated, I'm more than happy to stand up for them.

Your words not mine, you always stand there and watch security guards do their jobs even if there is no issue, just in case. So you are profiling the security guards as either being incompetent or arseholes that prey on children to treat them unfairly?

Yes I can quite imagine many are incompetent or arseholes. I mean look at all the times police get called out.....child Q for example....that's with all their training. So yes, I can well imagine your bog standard security guard being less than perfect.

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 17:58

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 17:51

I'm not profiling anyone... don't be daft

I once saw a few kids buy something at the self checkout. They didn't get a receipt. I saw them pay though . The woman monitoring the self checkout got on her walkie talkie literally screaming they haven't got a receipt. 100% I'd stand up for them. No I wouldn't stand up for an adult unless they were disabled or particularly vulnerable looking. I once saw a chugger stop an incredibly elderly confused looking gentleman. Luckily he wandered off and ignored him. But yes, I'm happy to stand up for people who are vulnerable. We all should be.

I've seen security guards stop school kids ...I will always stand there and watch to make sure the child is ok and being treated fairly and if I see them being treated in a way I wouldn't want my child treated, I'm more than happy to stand up for them.

Your words not mine, you always stand there and watch security guards do their jobs even if there is no issue, just in case. So you are profiling the security guards as either being incompetent or arseholes that prey on children to treat them unfairly?

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 17:57

I would have been positively incandescent with rage if something like that had ever happened to my dd. Intimidation of 12-year-old girls by an adult male

Well exactly.

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 17:51

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 17:45

I've seen security guards stop school kids ...I will always stand there and watch

So you "profile" too? Or do you stand and watch adults that have been stopped? It is assuming all teens are trustworthy and all security guards are arseholes which is simply not the case.

Your previous posts are all about shielding children from any minor challenge from an adult while out and about. If a teen is not ready for someone to ask to check their bag, keep them in or go with them until they are.

It is not good for their development, or learning how to navigate in the real world if they are taught they are untouchable and never experience any challenge. No wonder kids have such poor resilience nowadays if a security guard who clearly works for the shop, in an open area where there is no threat if they have done nothing wrong asking to check their bags is traumatising/humiliating.

I'm not profiling anyone... don't be daft

I once saw a few kids buy something at the self checkout. They didn't get a receipt. I saw them pay though . The woman monitoring the self checkout got on her walkie talkie literally screaming they haven't got a receipt. 100% I'd stand up for them. No I wouldn't stand up for an adult unless they were disabled or particularly vulnerable looking. I once saw a chugger stop an incredibly elderly confused looking gentleman. Luckily he wandered off and ignored him. But yes, I'm happy to stand up for people who are vulnerable. We all should be.

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 17:45

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 17:00

Yes it is absolutely profiling, and I don't have a problem with that

Well you really should...we all should

I've seen security guards stop school kids ...I will always stand there and watch

So you "profile" too? Or do you stand and watch adults that have been stopped? It is assuming all teens are trustworthy and all security guards are arseholes which is simply not the case.

Your previous posts are all about shielding children from any minor challenge from an adult while out and about. If a teen is not ready for someone to ask to check their bag, keep them in or go with them until they are.

It is not good for their development, or learning how to navigate in the real world if they are taught they are untouchable and never experience any challenge. No wonder kids have such poor resilience nowadays if a security guard who clearly works for the shop, in an open area where there is no threat if they have done nothing wrong asking to check their bags is traumatising/humiliating.

FruitBowlCrazy · 15/01/2024 17:29

I would have been positively incandescent with rage if something like that had ever happened to my dd. Intimidation of 12-year-old girls by an adult male, and total humiliation in the middle of the shop, with no proof whatsoever that they had tried to conceal anything in their bags?

No way would I put up with that, I'm afraid. I would have marched straight down there and insisted on speaking to the store manager. And if that wasn't enough to sort it out, I would have put in a formal complaint to their head office by email, and printed it out and sent a copy to every single one of the directors. I suspect I would also name the store on here, and on social media.

Comedycook · 15/01/2024 17:00

Yes it is absolutely profiling, and I don't have a problem with that

Well you really should...we all should

Anansisu · 15/01/2024 16:24

We aren’t talking about that though. We are talking about on the shop floor in a retail setting with other people and cctv present. The child has the right to say no; however the consequence will then be that they are placed in an interview room with a member of store staff present and held until the police arrive.

I don't understand this comment really - are you saying that a shop has the right to detain a child?

Westernesse · 15/01/2024 16:13

I would go to the shop, find the security guard and challenge him/threaten him to his face if he did anything like that to my kids.

shop security guards have no powers of search. In fact they have no powers at all of any kind and have zero right to touch never mind search another person’s property.

they are there as deterrent only. Nothing else.

NewName24 · 15/01/2024 16:00

Excellent post @SeemsSoUnfair

SeemsSoUnfair · 15/01/2024 15:59

Goldenbear · 15/01/2024 12:40

But the OP's daughter and friends had not done anything wrong, they had not attempted to exit, why is acceptable to humiliate teenagers who have some nothing wrong except be teenagers, that is profiling and completely unacceptable in other walks of life.

I am not going to raise my teen to pick on every little minor thing in life that is not fair and stamp his feet. Live is to short to sweat the small stuff. It is not ideal having your bag searched if you have done nothing wrong, but if they are old enough to go shopping without an adult then they are also are capable of understanding why it was done.

Yes it is absolutely profiling, and I don't have a problem with that. Teens commonly make bad choices. That is why they get watched in shops, why they get stopped by police at night for welfare checks, why their insurance costs are higher, why some holiday destinations will not accept them, etc etc. It is also why (hopefully) if someone saw them looking vulnerable or if they needed help they would offer support.

A security guard thought they were acting suspiciously for whatever reason and asked to check inside their bags. If a teen finds that so humiliating they are left traumatised or in tears they are probably better waiting until an adult can accompany them to the shops.

Perhaps the security guards could have handled it better, but we are hearing the story 3rd hand via a teenager so who knows if he was a bit OTT or if the girls just got a fright because they had other intentions, or it their parents had not prepared them for what happens in shops. Surely anyone who lets their 12 year old go shopping with friends gives them some words of advice first about temptation, consequences, peer pressure and the possibility of being challenged by security staff.

Ponoka7 · 15/01/2024 14:48

ilovebreadsauce · 15/01/2024 14:04

I don't "have to" do anything!

You would if you shopped at Costco. It's in the T&C's though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread