Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not tell in-laws “we” are pregnant?

115 replies

shutupjustine · 13/01/2024 16:58

DH is LC with his parents, essentially NC but will say thank you for gifts sent on his birthday etc. DH was treated differently to siblings and emotionally neglected, Mumsnet helped him go LC and DH was redirected to stately homes. MIL is a narcissist and FIL is so passive, he just allows it all to happen. We fell out for good after our wedding, Mumsnet said to not invite her as she will ruin it, we still did (I am close to my mum and so I always thought your mum should be there) and she did ruin it for DH by starting a fight. She also sent a lot of abuse about me and my family to family members and says nasty things about me.

Whilst I knew MIL would blame me for DH’s decision to go LC I didn’t expect the way she spoke about me, which I found out because she doesn’t know how to use Facebook properly and thought she was sending a message to her sister but instead wrote it on a status I can see. “Narcissist”, “psychopath” etc were used plenty.

Now I am pregnant, just coming up to 12 weeks. We are thrilled. This will be the third grandchild in his family, as his sister (golden child) has two. MIL is very involved in their lives and does a LOT of childcare which SIL needs as both of them are doctors. When first grandchild was born, MIL posted a picture of her, her name, sex, weight etc to Facebook within minutes of birth, whilst SIL was being cleaned up.

MIL already has 0 respect for me, is nasty behind my back, and has no boundaries even for her favourite child. To me it suggests she will be even worse with my child. DH and I want no pics of our child on social media, I know she will do it anyway; it’s who she is. She would also turn it and say we’re unreasonable if we ever got upset about it. So I don’t want her overly involved in our child’s life.

I suggested that we keep this pregnancy ours, those who deeply care for us will know. I’m not announcing on socials etc. it’s already such an anxious time as a FTM. When baby is born, we will tell MIL as well as rest of his family (he is also LC with SIL) and give them windows to visit and meet the child.

DH agrees but is also worried she will say how we have hidden the child / will tell everyone we’ve kept the child from her etc. my argument is that her behavioural patterns mean she will be angry with whichever decision we make.

Telling her before baby is born means she will make superficial attempts to reconcile with DH but also make our lives difficult. DH doesn’t want fake reconciliation, he needs her to admit she’s done wrong and make amends but it’s been 3 years of no attempts from her. When DH doesn’t allow her constant access to information / reconciliation, she will inevitably say it’s because of me and believe she has rights to my body and our baby.

SOOOO AIBU to suggest we wait until baby is born to tell in laws?
DH asked me to post and agrees with everything.

OP posts:
ChubbyMorticia · 13/01/2024 21:28

Here’s the thing: she’s going to insult you both no matter what you do. She enjoys it. He’s the scapegoat and you’re even lower as his wife. She will absolutely target your child. One, favouritism only works when there’s something to compare to. The GC grandkids need to see yours treated lesser than so they understand that Grandma’s love is conditional and if they don’t toe the line, they could be targeted next. Two, weaponizing your child against you. Sly comments, insults, undermining your parenting are SOP for toxic people.

Instead of asking yourselves WHEN to tell her about your pregnancy, you need to ask yourselves WHY you’d tell her. She abused her own child. Why would she treat yours better?

Snowydaysfaraway · 13/01/2024 21:13

I had a prem dc and dh told mil I didn't want visitors in hospital .. She ignored him and came anyway. I was fuming. Don't tell her unless you want her turning up...

Pacificisolated · 13/01/2024 20:50

Why would you invite her over to meet your child at all? She’s not going to respect your boundaries when she’s in your home and will use your baby as a means to abuse you. I wouldn’t entertain the idea of her having a relationship with my child. In fact, I think you would be failing your child by allowing them exposure to such dysfunction.

TheFormidableMrsC · 13/01/2024 20:30

Tell her after you've given birth and had a few weeks to yourself. I wouldn't blame you for not telling her at all. Also to add, instead od thinking she ruined your wedding, remind yourself that she publicly embarrassed herself and everybody will know. I wish you a happy and peaceful pregnancy Flowers

yeahbaby5 · 13/01/2024 20:12

I wouldn't tell her. I didn't tell my own mother until DC was born - she never visits nor does she live nearby so she wasn't going to find out by chance.

Enjoy your pregnancy and don't give her a second thought.

AuntHike · 13/01/2024 20:08

Congrats to you both, my upbringing by a narc mother has made me a better, more informed parent.

You can both lie to the problematic people, if anyone finds out before you feel ready.

Push your due date, due in September? Say end of October.

Claim the baby came early....

It's hard to sit on the headline information for these major events but they don't need the detailed truth, so stretch it to give yourself time or excuse yourself if they find out afterwards and it's not the time for a showdown.

Cherrysoup · 13/01/2024 20:06

Why are you telling her at all? You need to consider what you want here: do you want contact to increase and expose your child to her? Will she try to visit once she finds out? Why tell her?

Alittlebitwary · 13/01/2024 20:04

DisforDarkChocolate · 13/01/2024 17:46

Why are you planning any contact with a person who is abusive?

There is no reason she should meet your baby at all.

This. 100%. I would not be exposing any child of mine to any person who has behaved or treated their own children like they have - abusive and just downright awful. I would not tell them at all. I'd go NC to protect my baby and my family. You'll soon realise how precious your time is and you won't have the capacity to deal with toxic shit like that once you have a little person to care for. You are so much better off, you'll lose nothing by cutting them out and never seeing them again. Or, tell them and open yourselves and your child to more abuse and stress... Why would you do it? Surround yourselves with people that love and care for you how you want your child to see, feel and emulate. Surround yourselves with support. Don't let others, or fear of what they might think, stop you doing what's best for you.
Congratulations on your baby 😊 I hope you and DH do really work out what's best for you and only you xx

thedancingparrot · 13/01/2024 19:55

Alternatively you could be bold and just add the dc name to next year’s Christmas card… set the tone & make it clear if she wants any part of this she needs to wind in her behaviour.

5128gap · 13/01/2024 19:53

If you think she's going to use it to make things difficult for you, them personally I'd get that out of the way while you're still only pregnant. I'd have thought the last thing you'd want with a new baby is the drama of suddenly revealing the birth and any fall out from that. And personally if she's that bad I'd cut her off completely (up to your DH what he decides) rather than this half way house where you try to set rules and 'windows' which she will doubtless ignore or more drama will happen over it.

Allthingsdecember · 13/01/2024 19:23

Don’t tell her at all. Obviously she will probably find out eventually. But why would you let someone meet your baby when they treated their own son (and you!) so poorly that you went nc…let alone let them build a relationship them?

She has no automatic rights to your child. And more than that, you have a responsibility to protect your child from people that are likely to damage them emotionally. If she couldn’t be a good mother to your DH, even in adulthood, then she’s highly unlikely to be a positive addition to your child’s life.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 13/01/2024 19:13

She's going to be a cow whatever you do, so do what suits you.

Itiswhysofew · 13/01/2024 19:09

You predicted her behaviour at your wedding. There's a good chance she'll behave in the way you're anticipating re your DC. You & DH can do what you like. You could even have less contact, which'll mean you don't have to suffer her at all.

Congratulations!

AcrossthePond55 · 13/01/2024 19:08

@shutupjustine

Why tell her at all? I wouldn't. If she's too toxic for you and your DH to be around, she's 1000x too toxic to subject your child(ren) to.

I'd tell her nothing and if she finds out through the family grapevine, so be it. Hopefully she'll get the unspoken message. But if not, then you and DH can go from LC to real 'hardcore' NC. Which is probably the best thing to do anyway, baby or no baby.

Gymnopedie · 13/01/2024 19:06

OP you say the Stately Homes threads helped DH. Has he also read up on the FOG (fear, obligation, guilt)? It's about letting go of that feeling that however abusive someone was to you, you still can't stop letting them control your responses.
Fear, obligation, guilt

There's also a very good book which started off the whole concept:
Out of the Fog: Moving From Confusion to Clarity After Narcissistic Abuse

And another very helpful book:
Toxic Parents; Overcoming Their Hurtful Legacy and Reclaiming Your Life

Although he's gone LC your DH obviously still fears his mother's reactions, so he isn't completely at ease with it. These will help him to let go and not be affected by her in the future.

brandonflowersmushtash · 13/01/2024 18:59

Speaking from experience... Babies make people go a bit loopy and unreasonable.
She's already an unreasonable person.
She will cause you grief from the moment she hears about your news.
Tell her 2 weeks after- you won't ever get this time back with your baby.
I made this mistake with my first.

SunRainStorm · 13/01/2024 18:51

We had the same issue with my difficult in laws.

For our first child, I was still wanting 'happy families' so we treated them the same as my parents and tried to be incredibly equal and 'fair'. They were a fucking nightmare.

Second child- We decided to tell them once we were home from hospital and all was well.

They still kicked off, lashed out, had their tantrum- but just one big one rather than constant drama and threats and theatrics for months.

They take every opportunity for drama and conflict so we just try to limit the opportunities. Telling them earlier would have given them a larger window and more opportunities for tantrums and nonsense.

Narcissists hate when something isn't focused on them- so they struggle with other people's milestones and babies being born.

NamingConundrum · 13/01/2024 18:47

Why tell her at all? You're NC for a reason. She treats you both badly. You gave her a chance at your wedding and she ruined it. Why invite her back into your life to behave as awfully to your child? Protect your child and yourselves and dont invite her back in. Why tell her about a child she won't meet? She won't change, block from your life and enjoy your baby.

Genuineweddingone · 13/01/2024 18:36

Tell her nothing until the baby is here and safe. It is not her business. I am also in the stately homes threads so can say with certainty it will make no difference when she finds out she will lie and twist things anyway. They always do.

forrestgreen · 13/01/2024 18:32

I actually think you both can't win. No matter what you do there will be aggro in one form or another

So I'd do what will make the both of you happiest and healthiest. Which I think is the no info route.

Can you imagine if you told her and something happened with the pregnancy (sorry). She'd never stop bringing it up and you'd both never forgive her.

PlanningTowns · 13/01/2024 18:27

You haven’t considered the option that she won’t be interested which would bring with it other stresses linked to why you are LC and could be more damaging longer term.

of course they will find out at some point, but it’s entirely up to you when. Do beware that it may get back to them anyway in advance, but LC or NC it shouldn’t matter because that is the entire point of getting them out of your life.

to be honest if it’s that bad NC is probably something to consider because your boundaries are firmly set and expectations clearly managed.

Thisisnotmyid · 13/01/2024 18:22

I wouldn’t tell her at all OP. It sounds like she has not enriched your life at all or DH’s so why is she entitled to know? Being DH’s mother does not get her an automatic right to be involved in your child’s life. Do what is right for you and DH x

MaidOfSteel · 13/01/2024 18:19

Your husband isn't a bad person for wanting to protect himself, you and your little one. I hope he knows that.

I think your pregnancy and upcoming birth should be a happy and stress-free time. You both need to agree what is best for you and stay united in that. The 2 then 3 of you are what matters.

Dweetfidilove · 13/01/2024 18:18

Your husband is already labelled ‘bad’ and his children by extension will be ‘bad’ or have to listen to stories about their‘awful’ father, so she doesn’t need to be informed at all.

If she is so awful and unrepentant, you don’t need her in your space when you have just given birth and in a fragile state. People who do not like you and your husband have no right to your space / child.

LaghettiSpoops · 13/01/2024 18:17

Is her name Justine? 👀 🤣

Swipe left for the next trending thread