Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To prioritise distance above all other factors in primary choice?

68 replies

CalmerChameleons · 13/01/2024 16:37

For context, my area is low birth rate so I've been told I will get into whichever school I put first, neither have been full for reception in the last couple of years.

I have twins who will start primary school in September.

School A: five minutes walk from my house. Generally seems good, one form entry so no scope to separate DTs if we wanted to at some point, and fewer children there for them both to develop their own friendship groups. If this was my only option I'd be happy with it, BUT

School B: faith school (why I would definitely get in despite greater distance).
I'd always wanted my children to go to a faith school, I know it's wrong/meaningless to some and don't want to get into that debate here but just to note it's important for me.
Absolutely loved the head and the whole ethos of the school, everything that was said on the tour made me think it was perfect for us. Two form entry and they are happy to be flexible about DTs moving between classes depending on their needs for each year (eg maybe start off in same class and move apart when older). It's also a lot more diverse than school A which is a big positive for me. If everything was equal I'd choose this one BUT

It's a 10 minute drive across town if there was no traffic. Realistically, it would mean going through loads of traffic so probably more like 30 mins plus, plus all the faff of two children into a car, parking up near the school etc. It's beyond where I work so would mean if I did drop off/collection it would add extra to my journey and mean it was a bit of a race to get to work on time (and I prefer to cycle or bus and walk rather than drive, neither of these would work with kids). DH works from home a lot so if he did it it would be over an hour round trip Vs ten mins.

I feel mean not sending my kids to the school I think would be perfect, and instead the nearest one which is just fine. But the further one will mean they have to spend less time with us and more time in before/after school care, it means they could never walk themselves when they're in Y5/6. Mornings will involve leaving a lot earlier and more stress, Vs just walking them a few mins up the road.

AIBU to think that it'll be more positive for our lives for them to attend a nearby school rather than a school which might suit them a bit better?

OP posts:
NameChange30 · 13/01/2024 19:29

CalmerChameleons · 13/01/2024 18:13

Thanks for all the responses, given me some great points to consider.

DTs wouldn't contemplate separate classes at the moment but their opinion may change later!

There's a local secondary within walking distance, everyone from school A goes there but school B most go to a different secondary (not a faith one) which is also an awkward drive away. Secondary schools are very similar so I'd definitely prefer the walkable one so they can get there themselves!

It's really hilly here and it's over three miles each way so I don't think I could cycle with them in a trailer and I don't think they'd be able to cycle alone until secondary age. They'd also have to go along the busy road I'd be driving down.

Moving isn't an option unfortunately for a lot of reasons.

As moving isn't an option and school A feeds into the local secondary, which is good and walkable, I'd go with school A.

I think the only way to cycle the school run with that distance would be to get an electric longtail (eg Tern GSD) but even with that I'm not convinced it's worth it.

We cycle to school, nursery and work, and electric bikes are a game changer (we have an electric cargo bike and an electric regular bike) but even so, school is less than a mile away.

CurlyWurly1991 · 13/01/2024 19:23

Mumteedum · 13/01/2024 18:47

The thing I wish I'd thought more about is the secondary school. Everyone talks about catchment but the thing where I live that guarantees where you get in at secondary, is which primary school you went to. Check out which secondary is the school they're a feeder school for, for another factor to think about.

Edited

This is a very important consideration !

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 19:21

The two situations are not comparable though. A 20 minute walk is still pretty close and even more so somewhere like London with great public transport. A 30 minute drive even if it should only take 10 minutes with no traffic is not comparable to still being able to actually walk to school.

The drive is 25 mins which I often do as it’s on the way to work. Traffic & railway lines make it longer than walking. Public transport is longer still & as I said plenty have a longer journey. Funding & resources would be me important to me than journey length.

Mumteedum · 13/01/2024 18:47

The thing I wish I'd thought more about is the secondary school. Everyone talks about catchment but the thing where I live that guarantees where you get in at secondary, is which primary school you went to. Check out which secondary is the school they're a feeder school for, for another factor to think about.

musicforthesoul · 13/01/2024 18:39

Normally I'd say go for the local school but I think with twins you need to give serious consideration to the other school.

It may not be an issue but depending on personalities you may find twins relying on each other to the exclusion of everyone else, or possibly one twin dominating everything. In a one form entry it will be far harder for both twins to come out of their shell and develop their own friendships etc without relying on their sibling. The friendship pool will be too small.

OP you're the best person to judge this, if you think it's likely they may need to be separated later for the benefit of one or both, better to go with school B from the start. If you think it'll be OK with them in the same class until high school go with the local school and deal with the issue if it comes up.

redastherose · 13/01/2024 18:34

Despite the issue of not being able to separate the twins I still think A is the best option. The advantage of being able to walk to school (especially the freedom to do that alone once old enough) and the fact that it feeds into the local secondary school will be a huge benefit over the many years in school.

Moonshine5 · 13/01/2024 18:25

There is no right or wrong

Moonshine5 · 13/01/2024 18:24

That's an hour. Your children your choice.
From what you described to me School B offers the best but it comes at a cost to you and your DH. Your children obviously will be in the car on the journey but they are benefitting from the school.

CalmerChameleons · 13/01/2024 18:15

Moonshine5 · 13/01/2024 17:50

Not necessarily negative.
And on balance it could be worth it. My opinion is that school B would offer a superior experience for their children and therefore worth the journey. Remember OP said it's 10 minutes and 30 minutes worst case traffic

It's ten minutes if you did it at 8pm or similar, school time it'd be at least 30 mins (have tested it a few times recently).

OP posts:
CalmerChameleons · 13/01/2024 18:13

Thanks for all the responses, given me some great points to consider.

DTs wouldn't contemplate separate classes at the moment but their opinion may change later!

There's a local secondary within walking distance, everyone from school A goes there but school B most go to a different secondary (not a faith one) which is also an awkward drive away. Secondary schools are very similar so I'd definitely prefer the walkable one so they can get there themselves!

It's really hilly here and it's over three miles each way so I don't think I could cycle with them in a trailer and I don't think they'd be able to cycle alone until secondary age. They'd also have to go along the busy road I'd be driving down.

Moving isn't an option unfortunately for a lot of reasons.

OP posts:
Whinge · 13/01/2024 17:57

Remember OP said it's 10 minutes and 30 minutes worst case traffic

Op said it was 10 minutes with no traffic. Which isn't ever going to apply to the times she needs to make the journey. Even the Op herself admits it's more likely to be 30 minutes.

I agree with those saying go for the local school. You really don't want to commit to this journey for the next 7+ years.

Moonshine5 · 13/01/2024 17:50

Doppelgangers · 13/01/2024 17:22

It won't just be the OP and her husband who suffer though. A 30 minute journey twice a day every day will undoubtedly have an impact on the children.

Not necessarily negative.
And on balance it could be worth it. My opinion is that school B would offer a superior experience for their children and therefore worth the journey. Remember OP said it's 10 minutes and 30 minutes worst case traffic

Doppelgangers · 13/01/2024 17:40

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 17:36

Maybe it’s different in London but we are a 20 min walk to the primary & lots live a bit further away. Doesn’t impact clubs, play dates etc. And kids at prep travel much further.

You’ll be shocked at some of the London secondary journey times!

The two situations are not comparable though. A 20 minute walk is still pretty close and even more so somewhere like London with great public transport. A 30 minute drive even if it should only take 10 minutes with no traffic is not comparable to still being able to actually walk to school.

NameChange30 · 13/01/2024 17:39

What are the secondary schools like, are they in different catchments for different secondaries?

From what you've said about school B, I would seriously consider moving house, but only if the new area was in the catchment of a good secondary.

School A will be fine and logistics win so I do think if you can't or don't want to move, just stick with A.

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 17:36

Maybe it’s different in London but we are a 20 min walk to the primary & lots live a bit further away. Doesn’t impact clubs, play dates etc. And kids at prep travel much further.

You’ll be shocked at some of the London secondary journey times!

Ericaequites · 13/01/2024 17:35

The walkable school with better logistics wins hands down.

spriots · 13/01/2024 17:27

If you love the faith school that much, would you consider moving?

Of course if it would involve vast stamp duty then that's a no go but if it wouldn't it might be worth thinking about

Doppelgangers · 13/01/2024 17:27

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 17:23

A 30 minute journey twice a day every day will undoubtedly have an impact on the children.

why?

They will need to leave to get to school 30 minutes earlier.

They will get home much later having less down time at home after school and potentially not being able to attend clubs due to the time it takes.

They won't be able to play out after school with their peers.

They won't be able to walk home.

Any events at school will mean either waiting around nearby or driving home and back again.

Anytime they leave something behind either at home or at school the chances of a parent being able to drop it off or quickly nip to collect it is much less than at the school a short walk away.

Primrose28 · 13/01/2024 17:26

We went for the faith school in similar circumstances but not twins, 3 each a couple of years apart and have been completely happy. Yes there are definitely times that I have thought closer would be easier but the school is brilliant, the kids are doing amazingly and are very happy. The pastoral care and general ethos is particularly strong and this is well worth the extra time to me.

Friends that have gone for the closer school have mixed views - particularly when the weather is awful!

IKnowYouBetterThanThat · 13/01/2024 17:26

I was never within walking distance of my DC primary schools (just how it worked out location wise) and it was a pita!

I would go for the one within walking distance.

decisionssmecisions · 13/01/2024 17:23

A 30 minute journey twice a day every day will undoubtedly have an impact on the children.

why?

Pops1985 · 13/01/2024 17:22

We moved our year one child from the 5 minute walkable school to a 10 minute drive faith school. For us it was absolutely the best choice. Local school has a falling roll, no resources or wraparound care and is not heading in a great direction. It also had no secondary school options whereas now we are in the faith system they are much more likely to get into a good secondary school alongside primary school friends. Yes the logistics aren’t great but we are nearly 18 months in and have found our groove. They are in more wraparound care but they love it, they actually complain on days I pick them up at 3.30.

Doppelgangers · 13/01/2024 17:22

Moonshine5 · 13/01/2024 17:13

It will be a sacrifice but pastorally School B wins no contest. I think it will be best for your children, obviously there will be a cost to you and your husband.

It won't just be the OP and her husband who suffer though. A 30 minute journey twice a day every day will undoubtedly have an impact on the children.

JaniceBattersby · 13/01/2024 17:19

I’ve sent all four of mine to the fairly average closest school which is a three minute walk. There’s a fancier school a ten min drive away that they would have got into but I just could not bear driving there and back every day up to three times (after school clubs) and fighting to park. So we chose the closest school and I don’t regret it for one second. It’s been brilliant. They’ve been able to walk home from after school clubs since they were in Y4 and all of their friends live very close by.

GrassWillBeGreener · 13/01/2024 17:15

I think you're right to stay with the close school. The one thing I'd be rechecking is whether there were any viable cycle routes to school B, and if so what bicycle equipment could make that possible. My youngest was cycled to school on a tag-along till about 7 or so then supervised and eventually in year 6 could cycle himself. But our 10 minutes if no traffic drive was paralleled by a 10 minute cycle route (a footpath/cycle path that was much more direct). You won't be surprised to hear that I've seen multiple types of bikes, not just tag alongs and trailers but cargo bikes, specialist family bikes, and triple bikes (ie tandem+1).