Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do people really change for new partners?

31 replies

somenotes · 13/01/2024 12:07

Months ago I was snooping on STBXH socials. He's in a relationship with a woman he values? and not the one he cheated with. When they first got together with new woman he changed his profile picture to theirs. Unfortunately, a few weeks later they broke up and he proceeded to post a ton of quotes indicating he's hurting. This is something he didn't do when our 6-year marriage ended.

They got back together after a 4-month break and he immediately deleted his SM. And 6 months in, he is still standing strong. I presume she asked him to get rid off the accounts.

I'm very surprised by his behaviour because we never had each other on SM. He was generally a bad husband (cheating, lying, ghosting etc. typical narcissist) and father. He chooses to have very minimal contact with DC and only visits about twice a year.

I don't think people can change in short months but maybe he has?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Over40Overdating · 13/01/2024 15:30

Whether he’s changed or not, a father of 2 ducking out of his children’s lives and dodging maintenance is still a shitty person with shitty values and likely his new partner is as awful as he is, so in that sense he may have changed as, as PPs have said, he’s found someone who shares his values and aims in life.

Why would a decent person choose to be with and condone an absent parent not paying for their kids?

NewNameNigel · 13/01/2024 15:22

Plsdiscuss · 13/01/2024 13:20

I don't think they do, definitely in not such a short time.

XH has just got engaged to the woman he cheated on me for. I certainly don't wish her well. I know he'll rain the shit on her that he rained on me for years when they get past the infatuation period. And I hope she gives him hell for it. Neither deserve happiness after the awful way they both behaved.

I think this post has illustrated why we like to think people can't change. It seems unfair that people who have wronged us can move on to have happy relationships / lives while we are still reeling from the pain of their actions so we tell ourselves that they won't change and history will repeat.

However in reality life isn't fair and many people are happier with people they cheat with and treat them better than their exes.
It sucks for the people left behind.

catelynjane · 13/01/2024 13:46

I absolutely think people can change, but that doesn't mean your ex has.

My last relationship was fairly dysfunctional all round and I don't really recognise how I behaved back then. Nowadays I'm more confident, have more self-esteem and am generally much happier which is reflected in my behaviour.

I think many people behave differently in different situations - it's normal to react to your environment and how people treat you, after all.

shieldmaiden7 · 13/01/2024 13:42

I was married for 14 years. He hated tea, a mad coffee drinker and allergic to cats that I was never allowed one and my mum had to shut hers in.

He now hates coffee, hasn't touched it since he's been with her and has a cat with his gf who is their baby.

Not sure where his allergies went 🤔

okthenwhat · 13/01/2024 13:33

One bloke I know who has a misogynist streak a mile wide really liked one woman. But she was seeing someone else and then not interested in dating.

So he had a couple of other relationships and treated them pretty poorly.

He's now the perfect partner to the first woman.

He hasn't changed, he just treated some women poorly because they weren't "the one". He could have treated every other woman like that but he didn't.

Plsdiscuss · 13/01/2024 13:20

I don't think they do, definitely in not such a short time.

XH has just got engaged to the woman he cheated on me for. I certainly don't wish her well. I know he'll rain the shit on her that he rained on me for years when they get past the infatuation period. And I hope she gives him hell for it. Neither deserve happiness after the awful way they both behaved.

sparkellie · 13/01/2024 13:17

He might have changed for her. In my experience that doesn't last though. He might have grown and changed for himself. But given the way he treats his kids I'd say that was unlikely. He might have deleted all his socials precisely because he hasn't changed. You'll never know. But it's not important. I hope you can get something through cms though, as a pp says his NI number might help if you have that..

NewNameNigel · 13/01/2024 13:01

Also he might have blocked the op rather than deleting his socials. Not everyone is comfortable with their ex seeing their social media.

Evaka · 13/01/2024 12:52

Ex might be on best behaviour which will slip, or has done a tonne of work and is nicer and more aware now. I'd imagine scenario 1 is more likely?

MsCactus · 13/01/2024 12:49

Yes, some people do change.

Has your XH changed? Definitely not.

somenotes · 13/01/2024 12:43

redastherose · 13/01/2024 12:29

Don't you have any paperwork from when your were together with his NI number on it? Presumably his employer can be traced through that via HMRC.

I do. He quit his job during divorce. Deleted LinkedIn. I presume he is probably working cash in hand somewhere until financial settlement is sorted. But, I could be wrong.

OP posts:
Zombiemum1946 · 13/01/2024 12:38

Of course people change. The rapid rate of change could be for any number of reasons. If your chasing him for cm that could be why he's off his socials it could also be his new partner has laid down the law.

somenotes · 13/01/2024 12:33

Thanks everyone. Very interesting comments.

OP posts:
vidflex · 13/01/2024 12:32

I definitely changed in the relationship I had after my first marriage. This time around I knew my worth, my boundaries and what I expected of the relationship. I was tougher. I wasn't the pushover I was before. So y was h I think we change to have the relationship we want

somenotes · 13/01/2024 12:31

AnneLovesGilbert · 13/01/2024 12:27

I think hoping people change and improve is better than hoping they haven’t. I was so scared of my ex I didn’t even tell him I was leaving, I said I was staying away for a few days and then phoned him to say I was filing for divorce and not going back. He’s remarried, they have a child, of course I hope he treats her better than he did me. Why would I wish fear or unhappiness on another woman?

Similar thought to you. I hope he treats this/next partner and future DC(s) (if any) better. And, I hope they don't experience any of the awful things he did to us.

OP posts:
redastherose · 13/01/2024 12:29

Don't you have any paperwork from when your were together with his NI number on it? Presumably his employer can be traced through that via HMRC.

gluggle · 13/01/2024 12:29

ManateeFair · 13/01/2024 12:24

I doubt he’s changed. He might be behaving differently on a surface level, but he’s still the same twat underneath.

This. Him deleting his socials is just him deleting his socials. Doesn't mean he's not still lying and cheating

AnneLovesGilbert · 13/01/2024 12:27

I think hoping people change and improve is better than hoping they haven’t. I was so scared of my ex I didn’t even tell him I was leaving, I said I was staying away for a few days and then phoned him to say I was filing for divorce and not going back. He’s remarried, they have a child, of course I hope he treats her better than he did me. Why would I wish fear or unhappiness on another woman?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 13/01/2024 12:27

I don't think once people are adults (eg mid 20s) they generally change, although of course its possible especially following significant life events (eg people often change their lifestyle and priorities, if not their fundamental personality, after having kids).

He may ne behaving differently in this relationship but that doesn't mean he is a different or a better person. And he is clearly still a crap father. If she 'made him a better person' he would be paying for and seeing his kids

ManateeFair · 13/01/2024 12:24

I doubt he’s changed. He might be behaving differently on a surface level, but he’s still the same twat underneath.

Skybluecoat · 13/01/2024 12:23

somenotes · 13/01/2024 12:22

I'm still quite traumatised by everything he did tbh.

Checking his socials in hopes to find any information of where he works so I could claim CM.

Ah well that’s different! I hope you get the info you need and he pays up!!

somenotes · 13/01/2024 12:22

Skybluecoat · 13/01/2024 12:14

Why do you care?

It sounds like you are still hurting OP so maybe you should protect yourself and not look at his SM. 💐

I'm still quite traumatised by everything he did tbh.

Checking his socials in hopes to find any information of where he works so I could claim CM.

OP posts:
SuperMarioMaker · 13/01/2024 12:22

Agree that some people bring out the worst in people and others bring out the best in people.

My ex brought out the worst in me with his behaviour. I have also done work on myself and behaviour. I believe I would be different in a new relationship. My ex and I weren't compatible. He's with someone new now. They seem to be a bit more compatible (from the outside ar least). I hope they make each other happy.

Reading between the lines, it sounds like OP is hurting because the ex behaved 'better' with the new partner than he did with OP. This is probably making OP feel like the new partner is somehow 'better' than OP because the ex was willing and able to change for them. The OP feels 'less' because they got the worse of the ex. But every relationship is different and not everyone goes on to repeat the patterns of their past for various reasons.

NewNameNigel · 13/01/2024 12:20

I think people grow and change throughout life. People learn from mistakes and mature. And people often leave relationships that don't work for them and find people they are more compatible with.

The result of this is that they can treat current partners better than they did exes. I'm definitely nicer to DH than I was to my ex because we get on better and have more similar values so there is therefore less tension between us.

I think you should focus on yourself and building your confidence so that you never accept cheating lying and ghosting in a relationship ever again.

headcheffer · 13/01/2024 12:19

Yes of course people can change. How depressing would it be if we went through life never being able to improve ourselves or change. I know I've hurt people in the past with my words or actions, and I've often reflected on those times and changed my actions in the future. Some of them I look back and am boggled because I would NEVER do some of that stuff now because I'm a totally different person.